Previous studies have suggested that electromagnetic fields (EMF), such as those found in several common pieces of equipment in the assisted reproductive laboratory (ART), have detrimental effects on gametes and embryos, yet little controlled data exists. Last year at this meeting we presented what appears to be one of the first controlled studies of EMFs in an ART setting, using a porcine sperm model. In that study, high-frequency EMF (roughly three times that of the top shelf of a culture incubator; ∼80 mGuass) disrupted sperm cellular function. The objective of the present study was to determine if EMFs had similar affects on human semen samples. An in vitro based study of EMF affects on sperm cell function using a human model. Semen samples were collected from proven donors and prepared with a modified human tubal media using standard techniques. Ejaculates were then split between four EMF fields based upon levels consistent with the selves of a standard culture incubator (2, 30 and 90 mGuass), or a a high-frequency (HF) EMF (>250 mGuass) control. The samples were cultured under conditions of 37°C and room air. To assess the effects of EMF, standard semen parameters were assessed by CASA at times 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180 minutes and 24 hours. Resulting data were compared using ANOVA with repeated measures. Additional samples were collected and fixed with gluteraldehyde for later biochemical analysis. As expected, motility and forward progression (FP) decreased with time (P<.001). However, ejaculates exposed to the HF-EMF suffered a much more rapid decrease in both motility (P<.001) and FP (P<.04). While samples exposed to low EMF lost ∼20% of their motility in the first 24 hrs, HF-EMF exposed cells lost over 70% of their initial motility. Further, cells exposed to the HF-EMF demonstrated first a rapid increase then decline in FP. Biochemical assays remain pending at this time. As in the earlier animal study, exposure to extremely high EMF appears to have a negative impact on the functional viability of human sperm by decreasing motility and forward progression. However, at this point, it is unclear if the lower levels of EMF, consistent with the levels seen in an assisted reproductive laboratory (ART), also have deleterious effects. Given the ubiquitous nature of EMF in the ART laboratory, further research is warranted to determine if EMF in this environment does decrease cell function, and therefore pregnancy rates.
Read full abstract