Cyclic nucleotides have defined signal transduction roles in animals, fungi, and other diverse eukaryote kingdoms. However, the situation in plants is still not clear after more than 3 decades of investigations reporting evidence for and against a regulatory role for cyclic nucleotides in higher plants. No sequenced higher plant genome contains homologs of the nucleotidyl cyclase genes that are recognizable in diverse eukaryotic kingdoms, including, curiously, the Chlorophyta phylum of the Viridiplantae kingdom. The report of Qi et al. (1) is a recent example of claims that recombinant plant proteins (or their fragments) from diverse protein families have guanylyl cyclase (GC) activity in vitro—claims that have led to the hope that the cyclic nucleotide regulatory system in plants is not a molecular house of cards. However, the GC activity reported was ≈150 fmol cGMP per μg of 14-kDa protein fragment (AtPepR1-GC) per 30 min. This activity is extraordinarily low. Each molecule of this putative recombinant GC synthesizes one cGMP molecule every 10 d. By contrast, recombinant and native human GC molecules synthesize 103–104 cGMP molecules per second, 109- to 1010-fold faster (2). This very low activity is typical of the other putative noncanonical GCs reported in plants, including fragments of other plant receptor kinases cited by Qi et al. (1) and Ludidi and Gehring (AtGC1, ref. 3). GC comprises 0.005–0.1% of bovine lung protein (2), but even if AtPepR1 was 99% of total Arabidopsis protein the GC activity of the plant would be <10−6 of the activity in some animal tissues.
Read full abstract