Over the last 3 decades the National Cancer Institute has evaluated a variety of models for anticancer drug screening. Predominant among these have been the in vivo murine leukemias L1210 and P388. Currently, the NCI principal screening experiment incorporates the P388 model as a high capacity (10,000 compounds/year) prescreen; second tier testing is performed on a relatively limited number (200 compounds/year) of P388 “actives” against a “tumor panel” which presently consists of 4 in vivo tumor models including the L1210 murine leukemia, the B16 mouse melanoma, the M5076 murine sarcoma and the human MX-1 mammary xenograft. The tumor panel experiment was initiated in 1976 to explore whether the P388 + tumor panel would detect new agents that would have been missed by L1210 alone, and whether ultimately such an approach might facilitate the discovery of new agents effective against tumor types which have thus far proved highly refractory to chemotherapy. Current analyses of the tumor panel experiment indicate that, thus far, this predominantly “compound-oriented” approach has identified some new agents with apparent clinical activity, however mostly within the leukemia/lymphoma family. Unfortunately, none of the current models employed has identified new drug candidates with particularly promising activity in any of the major human solid tumors including lung cancer, colorectal cancer, breast cancer, prostatic cancer and others. 1 Venditti JM Wesley RA Plowman J Current NCI pre-clinical antitumor screening in vivo. Results of tumor panel screening, 1976-1982, and future directions. in: Garattini S Goldin A Hawking F Advances in pharmacology and chemotherapy, 20. Academic Press, Orlando, Florida1984: 1-20 Google Scholar , 2 Boyd MR. NCI drug discovery and development. Proceedings of the General Motors Cancer Research Foundation Conference on “Cancer Therapy: where Do We Go From Here,” Jackson Hole, Wyoming: September 14-15, 1984 Google Scholar , 3 Proceedings of the Workshop on Disease-Oriented Antitumor Drug Discovery and Development. National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MarylandJanuary 9-10, 1985: 1-273 Google Scholar , 4 NCI planning to switch drug development emphasis from compound to human cancer-oriented stratgegy. The Cancer Letter. 1984; 10 (October 26): 1-3 Google Scholar , 5 DCT board approves new screening program, natural product concepts. The Cancer Letter. 1985; 11 (March 1): 4-8 Google Scholar Presently, therefore, the NCI is developing an alternative “disease-oriented” screening experiment. 2 Boyd MR. NCI drug discovery and development. Proceedings of the General Motors Cancer Research Foundation Conference on “Cancer Therapy: where Do We Go From Here,” Jackson Hole, Wyoming: September 14-15, 1984 Google Scholar , 3 Proceedings of the Workshop on Disease-Oriented Antitumor Drug Discovery and Development. National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MarylandJanuary 9-10, 1985: 1-273 Google Scholar , 4 NCI planning to switch drug development emphasis from compound to human cancer-oriented stratgegy. The Cancer Letter. 1984; 10 (October 26): 1-3 Google Scholar , 5 DCT board approves new screening program, natural product concepts. The Cancer Letter. 1985; 11 (March 1): 4-8 Google Scholar The new screening approach will incorporate a variety of representative in vitro and in vivo models representing specific target disease types. The first phase of the new screening experiment is designated as the NCI Lung Cancer Drug Discovery Project (LCDDP). For the LCDDP, the “prescreen” will consist of a well-defined, diverse and representative human lung cancer cell line panel (20-30 lines) against which substances will be tested initially using in vitro assays. Non-cancer cell lines as well as selected murine tumor cell lines (P388, L1210) and other human tumor cell lines will be included in the prescreening panel to provide comparative data and to facilitate the assessment of tumor type selectivity.
Read full abstract