The Tates, Ford, and The House of Fiction Robert Buffington (bio) Allen Tate plunged into his novel, turning the history of his family into fiction, as soon as Caroline and he returned to Monteagle from Washington, on January 5, 1937. Instead of writing about both sides of his family as he had been trying to do in the history—also entitled The Fathers—he was basing the novel on his mother's side only and confining it to the time of the Civil War. He used his great-grandfather Major Benjamin Lewis Bogan as the prototype of the novel's Major Lewis Buchan, substituting the Scottish Buchan for the Irish Bogan. It was Dorothea Brande's strange vision at a party in Washington of Major Bogan and his home, Pleasant Hill, that had enabled him to start the novel. It was from Ford Madox Ford, who had taught Caroline Gordon, when she was first married to Allen, how to put a novel together, that he got his point of view, adapting the method of The Good Soldier. "I've involved myself," he wrote Mark Van Doren, "in the most elementary of the difficulties besetting the amateur novelist—the personal narrator. Omniscience would compel me to know more about the past than I do know. The personal narrator is a monster that nobody can believe in. So there we are. Or rather there I am. I've got about five characters that are slowly getting all snarled up together, and I fear the putative reader will never know where he is." The main character "might have been handled more broadly in a contemporary setting, but I am deluding myself that I am showing how the modern American rose in unfavorable surroundings, the conservative background of Virginia at that time." After a month he had produced fifty pages, writing about four hours a day and stewing "in the juice the other hours." Caroline was impressed by his doing at least two pages every day, since she herself had days working on a novel when she couldn't get a word down. "I must say he doesn't seem to suffer half as much as I do. I suppose it is just naturally easier for him." Caroline's Civil War novel None Shall Look Back was published [End Page 73] on February 19, 1937. It got good reviews from Clifton Fadiman in the New Yorker, Carl Van Doren in the Boston Herald, and Katherine Anne Porter in the New Republic—though the Tates were distressed by Porter's slighting reference to the fiction of another friend, Stark Young. Ford reviewed it for Scribner's Bookbuyer, comparing Gordon to Tolstoy and calling her "the most mysterious of writers": in person "vivid, brilliant, clamorous," she writes calmly, endowing a tragic novel of war with "a peculiar quality of tranquility." Allen thought the review by Allan Nevins in the Saturday Review of Literature was unfair and noted that of the nine books he and Caroline had published between them, None Shall Look Back was the first one even mentioned in the Saturday Review: "I had no idea ten years ago it was so dangerous to find the divine Elinor tiresome and vulgar." (The late Elinor Wylie, he had said back then, was "the dullest talker" he had ever met; her third husband, William Rose Benét, was one of the founders of the Saturday Review.) He also thought unfair the review in Books by Stephen Vincent Benét. Caroline recalled that Allen was the only reviewer of Stephen Benét's John Brown's Body who had withheld his praise. ("Its sole title to poetry," he had written in the Nation, "is the fact that it is written in verse.") Early sales of Caroline's novel, for which Scribner's was running large advertisements decorated with a drawing of Nathan Bedford Forrest, were encouraging: four thousand copies the first three weeks. With the departure of Andrew Lytle and his sister, Polly—Andrew on a trip to Hollywood—the Tates were alone in Lytle's Log Cabin, and Caroline was forced to cook. Rather than use the kitchen, which was in the cellar and had a dirt...