Despite guidelines advising passive rewarming for mild accidental hypothermia (AH), patients are frequently admitted to intensive care unit (ICU) for active rewarming using a forced-air warming device. We implemented a new policy at our institution aimed at safely reducing ICU admissions for AH. We analyzed our practice pre- and post-policy intervention and compared our experiences with acute care hospitals in Connecticut. A retrospective chart review was performed on 203 participants with AH identified by primary and secondary discharge codes. Our new policy recommended passive rewarming on the medical floors for mild hypothermia (>32°C) and ICU admission for moderate hypothermia (<32°C). Practices of other Connecticut hospitals were obtained by surveying ICU nurse managers and medical directors. Over a 3-year period, prior to rewarming policy change, 64% (n = 92) of patients with AH were admitted to ICU, with a mean ICU length of stay (LOS [SD]) of 2.75 (2.2) days. After the policy change, over a 3-year period, 15% (n = 9) were admitted to ICU (P < .001), with an ICU LOS of 2.11 (0.9) days (P = 0.005). In both groups with AH, altered mental status, infection, and acute alcohol intoxication were the most common diagnoses at presentation. Alcohol intoxication was more prevalent in the post-policy intervention group, pre 17% versus post 46% (P < .001). No complications such as dermal burns or cardiac arrhythmias were noted with forced-air warming device use during either time period. Among the 29 hospitals surveyed, 20 used active rewarming in ICU or intermediate care units and 9 cared for patients on telemetry units. Most hospitals used active external rewarming for core body temperature of <35°C; however, 37% of hospitals performed active rewarming at temperatures >35°Cor lacked a policy. Reserving forced-air warming devices for the treatment of moderate-to-severe hypothermia (<32°C) significantly reduced ICU admissions for AH.