Honey Bee Larvae Research Articles

Molecular Impact of Sublethal Spinetoram Exposure on Honeybee (Apis mellifera) Larval and Adult Transcriptomes

Pesticide toxicity is a global concern for honeybee populations, and understanding these effects at the molecular level is critical. This study analyzed the transcriptome of honeybees at larval and adult stages after chronic exposure to a sublethal dose (0.0017 µg a.i./larva) of spinetoram (SPI) during the larval phase. Four groups were used: acetone-treated honeybee larvae (ATL), acetone-treated honeybee adults (ATAs), SPI-treated honeybee larvae (STL), and SPI-treated honeybee adults (STAs). In total, 5719 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified for ATL vs. ATAs, 5754 for STL vs. STAs, 273 for ATL vs. STL, and 203 for ATAs vs. STAs (FC ≤ 1.5, p < 0.05). In response to SPI, 29 unique DEGs were identified in larvae and 42 in adults, with 23 overlapping between comparisons, suggesting genes linked to SPI toxicity. Gene ontology analysis showed that SPI affected metabolism-related genes in larvae and lipid-transport-associated genes in adults. KEGG pathway analysis revealed an enrichment of pathways predominantly associated with metabolism, hormone biosynthesis, and motor proteins in STL. The transcriptomic data were validated by qPCR. These findings demonstrated that SPI disrupts essential molecular processes, potentially harming honeybee development and behavior, underscoring the need for safer agricultural practices.

Azoxystrobin Exposure Impacts on Development Status and Physiological Responses of Worker Bees (Apis mellifera L.) from Larval to Pupal Stages.

Honeybee larvae and pupae form the cornerstone of colony survival, development, and reproduction. Azoxystrobin is an effective strobilurin fungicide that is applied during the flowering stage for controlling plant pathogens. The contaminated nectar and pollen resulting from its application are collected by forager bees and impact the health of honeybee larvae and pupae. The current study evaluated the survival, development, and physiological effects of azoxystrobin exposure on the larvae and pupae of Apis mellifera worker bees. The field-recommended concentrations of azoxystrobin were found to suppress the survival indices and lifespan in the larval as well as pupal stages; moreover, the rates of the survival and pupation of larvae as well as the body weights of the pupae and newly-emerged adult bees were significantly reduced upon long-term exposure to azoxystrobin. In addition, azoxystrobin ingestion induced changes in the expression of genes critical for the development, immunity, and nutrient metabolism of larvae and pupae, although the expression profile of these genes differed between the larval and pupal stages. Results indicated the chronic toxicity of azoxystrobin on the growth and development of honeybee larvae and pupae, which would affect their sensitivity to pathogens and other external stresses during the development stage and the study will provide vital information regarding the pollination safety and rational use of pesticides.

In vivo and Laboratory Studies of Tetracycline Prevention of Foulbrood disease of Apis cerana indica Fab. and its Effects on Honey

Laboratory and field studies were carried out to assess the efficacy of the antibiotic tetracycline in preventing and managing American foulbrood (AFB) and European foulbrood (EFB) diseases in honey bees. Experiments with immature worker bees in the laboratory demonstrated that honey bee larvae could endure a broad range of antibiotic doses in their diet. The recommended dose of tetracycline (100 μg/ml) effectively protected young larvae from infection. However, once the dose exceeded this recommended level, it reached a point where it became lethal.

Why is pollen in Camellia oleifera inedible to honeybees?

This Commentary examines a recent study that addressed a long-standing controversy: Is the lethal effect of Tea-oil Camellia on honeybee larvae due to nectar or pollen toxicity? Flowers of Camellia oleifera are adapting to bird pollination, evolving 'anti-bee' traits such as theasaponin-containing pollen, which is toxic to bee larvae.

Flumethrin exposure perturbs gut microbiota structure and intestinal metabolism in honeybees (Apis mellifera)

Flumethrin mitigates Varroa’s harm to honeybee colonies; however, its residues in colonies threaten the fitness of honeybee hosts and gut microbiota. Our previous research has shown that flumethrin induces significant physiological effects on honeybee larvae; but the effects of flumethrin on the gut microbiota and metabolism of adult honeybees are still unknown. In this study, 1-day-old honeybees were exposed to 0, 0.01, 0.1, and 1 mg/L flumethrin for 14 days and the impacts of flumethrin on the intestinal system were evaluated. The results showed that exposure to 1 mg/L flumethrin significantly reduced honeybee survival and the activities of antioxidative enzymes (superoxide dismutase and catalase) and detoxification enzymes (glutathione S-transferase) in honeybee heads. Moreover, exposure to 0.01, 0.1, and 1 mg/L flumethrin significantly decreased the diversity of the honeybee gut microbiota. Results from untargeted metabolomics showed that long-term exposure to 0.01, 0.1, and 1 mg/L flumethrin caused changes in the metabolic pathways of honeybee gut microbes. Furthermore, increased metabolism of phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan derivatives was observed in honeybee gut microbes. These findings underscore the importance of careful consideration in using pesticides in apiculture and provide a basis for safeguarding honeybees from pollutants, considering the effects on gut microbes.

Synergistic effects between microplastics and glyphosate on honey bee larvae

Microplastic (MPs) pollution has emerged as a global ecological concern, however, the impact of MPs exposure, particularly in conjunction with other pollutants such as glyphosate (GLY) on honey bee remains unknown. This study investigated the effects of exposure to different concentrations of MPs and their combination with GLY on honey bee larvae development, or during the larvae period, regulation of major detoxification, antioxidant and immune genes, and oxidative stress biomarkers. Results revealed that combined exposure to MPs and GLY decreased larvae survivorship and weight, while exposure to MPs alone showed no significant differences. Both MPs and GLY alone downregulated the defensin-1 gene, but only combined exposure with GLY downregulated the hymenoptaecin gene and increased catalase enzyme activity. The data suggest a synergistic effect of MPs and GLY, leading to immunosuppression and reduced larvae survival and weight. These findings highlight potential risks of two prevalent environmental pollutants on honey bee health.

Chalkbrood Disease Caused by Ascosphaera apis in Honey Bees (Apis mellifera)-Morphological and Histological Changes in Infected Larvae.

Chalkbrood is a mycological brood disease of the Western honey bee (Apis mellifera), caused by the fungus Ascosphaera apis. The aim of this study was the investigation of the pathology of artificially reared Apis mellifera larvae, experimentally infected with A. apis spores (1.0 × 103 spores/larva). Non-infected larvae served as control. Five living larvae and every dead larva were collected daily (day 1-7 p.i.). All larvae were macroscopically measured, photographed, formalin-fixed, and histologically processed (hematoxylin-eosin stain, Grocott silvering). Histological sections were digitized, and the size of the larvae was measured (mouth-after length, area) and statistically analyzed. Twenty-six larvae from the collected larvae (n = 64; 23 dead, 3 alive) showed histological signs of infection from 3 d p.i. onwards. The dead larvae showed macroscopically white/brown deposits, indistinct segmentation, and a lack of body elongation. Infected larvae were significantly smaller than the controls on days 3 p.i. (p < 0.05), 4 p.i. (p < 0.001), and 6 p.i. (p < 0.05). The early time of death, the low number of transitional stages, and the strong penetration of the larval carcass with fungal mycelium indicate a rapid and fulminant infection process, which is probably relevant for spreading the disease within the colony.

Long-term monitoring of Paenibacillus larvae, causative agent of American Foulbrood, in Uruguay

Paenibacillus larvae is the causative agent of American Foulbrood (AFB), the most severe bacterial disease affecting honey bee (Apis mellifera) larvae. It was first reported in Uruguay in 1999. Here, we summarize the monitoring strategy carried out from 2001 to date, based on nationwide surveys sampling honey from colonies (2001/2002, 2011, 2021) or from honey storage tanks (2014–2019). We also discuss the actions carried out for the prevention of AFB outbreaks. Uruguay’s experience in managing AFB for nearly 25 years without antibiotic use, might provide some helpful ideas for other countries working on AFB control programs.

Bioefficacy and molecular characterization of Bacillus thuringiensis strain NBAIR BtGa against greater wax moth, Galleria mellonella L.

Galleria mellonella, the greater wax moth has always been an important pest against honeybees and has remained a nightmare for beekeeping farmers. Management of G. mellonella in live honeybee colonies is very difficult because most current management practices can destroy whole honeybee colonies. In the present study, experiments were conducted to isolate and characterize Bacillus thuringiensis from infected greater wax moth cadavers and to evaluate their biocontrol ability against G. mellonella. The bioefficacy of these isolates has been evaluated against greater wax moth along with the standard strain HD-1. Among all the strains tested, NBAIR BtGa demonstrated higher efficacy compared to other strains, with an LC50 value of 125.17µg/ml, whereas HD-1 exhibited a significantly higher LC50 value of 946.61µg/ml. Considering the economic importance of NBAIR BtGa we performed whole genome sequencing of this strain resulting in the identification of a genome size of 5.96Mb consisting of 6888 protein-coding genes. Gene ontology analysis categorized these genes into three groups based on their roles, i.e., biological functions (2169 genes), cellular components (1900 genes), and molecular functions (2774 genes). Through insecticidal toxicity-related genes (ITRG) profiling of our strain across the genome by Bt toxin scanner and cry processor resulted in the identification of several Cry proteins namely Cry1Ab11, Cry1Ia44, Cry1Aa2, Cry2Af1, Cry1Da2, Cry1Eb1, Cry1Ab5, Cry1Cb2, Cry1Ac2. Besides Cry proteins, other ITRG genes, viz. Vip3Bb2, Zwittermicin A resistance proteins, Chitinase C, Mpp46Ab1, immune inhibitor A, Bmp1, Vpb4Ca1, and Spp1Aa1 were also reported, which show toxicity against lepidopteran pests. The studies were also conducted to test the biosafety of Bt toxins against honeybee larvae and adults, which showed strain NBAIR BtGa was more than 99% safer for honeybee larvae as well as adults. Thus, the data generated ascertains its effectiveness as a biocontrol agent and it can be used further for the development of bio formulation for the management of G. mellonella in honeybee colonies.

The neonicotinoid acetamiprid reduces larval and adult survival in honeybees (Apis mellifera) and interacts with a fungicide mixture

Plant protection products (PPPs), which are frequently used in agriculture, can be major stressors for honeybees. They have been found abundantly in the beehive, particularly in pollen. Few studies have analysed effects on honeybee larvae, and little is known about effects of insecticide-fungicide-mixtures, although this is a highly realistic exposure scenario. We asked whether the combination of a frequently used insecticide and fungicides would affect developing bees. Honeybee larvae (Apis mellifera carnica) were reared in vitro on larval diets containing different PPPs at two concentrations, derived from residues found in pollen. We used the neonicotinoid acetamiprid, the combined fungicides boscalid/dimoxystrobin and the mixture of all three substances. Mortality was assessed at larval, pupal, and adult stages, and the size and weight of newly emerged bees were measured. The insecticide treatment in higher concentrations significantly reduced larval and adult survival. Interestingly, survival was not affected by the high concentrated insecticide-fungicides-mixture. However, negative synergistic effects on adult survival were caused by the low concentrated insecticide-fungicides-mixture, which had no effect when applied alone. The lower concentrated combined fungicides led to significantly lighter adult bees, although the survival was unaffected. Our results suggest that environmental relevant concentrations can be harmful to honeybees. To fully understand the interaction of different PPPs, more combinations and concentrations should be studied in social and solitary bees with possibly different sensitivities.

Assessment of Lambda-Cyhalothrin and Spinetoram Toxicity and Their Effects on the Activities of Antioxidant Enzymes and Acetylcholinesterase in Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) Larvae.

Honeybees play a crucial role as agricultural pollinators and are frequently exposed to various pollutants, including pesticides. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the toxicity of lambda-cyhalothrin (LCY) and spinetoram (SPI) in honey bee larvae reared in vitro through single (acute) and repeated (chronic) exposure. The acute LD50 values for LCY and SPI were 0.058 (0.051-0.066) and 0.026 (0.01-0.045) μg a.i./larva, respectively. In chronic exposure, the LD50 values of LCY and SPI were 0.040 (0.033-0.046) and 0.017 (0.014-0.019) μg a.i./larva, respectively. The chronic no-observed-effect dose of LCY and SPI was 0.0125 μg a.i./larva. Adult deformation rates exceeded 30% in all LCY treatment groups, showing statistically significant differences compared to the solvent control group (SCG). Similarly, SPI-treated bees exhibited significantly more deformities than SCG. Furthermore, we examined the activities of several enzymes, namely, acetylcholinesterase (AChE), glutathione-S-transferase (GST), catalase (CAT), and superoxide dismutase (SOD), in larvae, pupae, and newly emerged bees after chronic exposure at the larval stage (honey bee larval chronic LD50, LD50/10 (1/10th of LD50), and LD50/20 (1/20th of LD50)). LCY and SPI induced significant changes in detoxification (GST), antioxidative (SOD and CAT), and signaling enzymes (AChE) during the developmental stages (larvae, pupae, and adults) of honey bees at sublethal and residue levels. Our results indicate that LCY and SPI may affect the development of honey bees and alter the activity of enzymes associated with oxidative stress, detoxification, and neurotransmission. These results highlight the potential risks that LCY and SPI may pose to the health and normal development of honey bees.

Bacteriophage resistance evolution in a honey bee pathogen.

Honey bee (Apis mellifera) larvae are susceptible to the bacterial pathogen Paenibacillus larvae, which causes severe damage to bee colonies. Antibiotic treatment requires veterinary supervision in the United States, is not used in many parts of the world, perpetuates problems associated with antibiotic resistance, and can necessitate residual testing in bee products. There is interest in using bacteriophages to treat infected colonies (bacteriophage therapy) and several trials are promising. Nevertheless, the safety of using biological agents in the environment must be scrutinized. In this study we analyzed the ability of P. larvae to evolve resistance to several different bacteriophages. We found that bacteriophage resistance is rapidly developed in culture but often results in growth defects. Mutations in the bacteriophage-resistant isolates are concentrated in genes encoding potential surface receptors. Testing one of these isolates in bee larvae, we found it to have reduced virulence compared to the parental P. larvae strain. We also found that bacteriophages are likely able to counteract resistance evolution. This work suggests that while bacteriophage-resistance may arise, its impact will likely be mitigated by reduced pathogenicity and secondary bacteriophage mutations that overcome resistance.

Lethal effects of tea-oil Camellia on honeybee larvae due to pollen toxicity.

Lethal effects of tea-oil Camellia on honeybee larvae due to pollen toxicity.

Cyclobutrifluram (TYMIRIUM® technology): Low risks of a soil applied nematicide and fungicide to non-target soil invertebrates and bees

Cyclobutrifluram (TYMIRIUM® technology) is a seed- and soil-applied nematicide and fungicide which protects the plant root mass. Cyclobutrifluram acts by inhibiting mitochondrial complex II electron transport and succinate dehydrogenase inhibition (SDHI). Concerns over the potential adverse effects on non-target species were addressed by assessing whether recommended field application rates of cyclobutrifluram would result in adverse impacts on soil invertebrates or honeybees. Studies conducted under laboratory conditions with the active ingredient and two formulations provided No Observed Effect Concentrations for earthworm (Eisenia andreii) reproduction of 71–171 mg a.i./kg dry soil with no effects on soil mite (Hypoaspis aculifier) reproduction. There were no effects on honeybee (Apis mellifera) adults or larvae following chronic exposure to doses up to 400 and 160 mg/kg diet respectively. Using Brazil as a target market (soybean seed treatment and in-furrow application in fruiting vegetables), our laboratory studies indicate that the risk to two species of soil invertebrates and honeybees of the use of cyclobutrifluram either in-furrow or as a seed treatment was orders of magnitude below any levels of concern.

Profile of the gut microbial composition in Apis mellifera larvae collected in Ha Noi

Profile of the gut microbial composition in Apis mellifera larvae collected in Ha Noi

Enantioselective toxicity of the neonicotinoid dinotefuran on honeybee (Apis mellifera) larvae

The threat of neonicotinoids to insect pollinators, particularly honeybees (Apis mellifera), is a global concern, but the risk of chiral neonicotinoids to insect larvae remains poorly understood. In the current study, we evaluated the acute and chronic toxicity of dinotefuran enantiomers to honeybee larvae in vitro and explored the mechanism of toxicity. The results showed that the acute median lethal dose (LD50) of S-dinotefuran to honeybee larvae was 30.0 μg/larva after oral exposure for 72 h, which was more toxic than rac-dinotefuran (92.7 μg/larva) and R-dinotefuran (183.6 μg/larva). Although the acute toxicity of the three forms of dinotefuran to larvae was lower than that to adults, chronic exposure significantly reduced larval survival, larval weight, and weight of newly emerged adults. Analysis of gene expression and hormone titer indicated that dinotefuran affects larval growth and development by interfering with nutrient digestion and absorption and the molting system. Analysis of hemolymph metabolome further revealed that disturbances in the neuroactive ligand-receptor interaction pathway and energy metabolism are the key mechanisms of dinotefuran toxicity to bee larvae. In addition, melatonin and vitellogenin are used by larvae to cope with dinotefuran-induced oxidative stress. Our results contribute to a comprehensive understanding of dinotefuran damage to bees and provide new insights into the mechanism of enantioselective toxicity of insecticides to insect larvae.

Does consuming irradiated royal jelly affect Apis mellifera larvae development and survival to adulthood in vitro?

The purpose of this study was to determine if Apis mellifera could be reared in vitro on a diet containing royal jelly (RJ) irradiated at 25 kGy. Twelve-hour-old larvae were collected from fourteen colonies and fed a diet containing unirradiated RJ (refrigerated until use), irradiated RJ, or an irradiation control (RJ stored next to the irradiator for the time it takes to irradiate RJ). Statistically fewer larvae survived to adulthood when fed a diet containing irradiated RJ (70.6%) than when fed a diet containing unirradiated RJ (82.9%) or the irradiation control RJ (78.4%; F2,39 = 4.34; p < 0.001). Nevertheless, larval survival at day 8 and eclosion exceeded the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s requirements for controls in tier one toxicological studies. Feeding on irradiated RJ did not affect bee developmental time or weight at emergence. The data demonstrate that A. mellifera workers can be reared on a diet that includes irradiated RJ, but that additional diet refinements may be necessary to improve the survival of these individuals to levels experienced by larvae feeding on a diet containing unirradiated RJ.

Potential of Bioactive Protein and Protein Hydrolysate from Apis mellifera Larvae as Cosmeceutical Active Ingredients for Anti-Skin Aging.

This study aimed to extract bioactive proteins and protein hydrolysates from Apis mellifera larvae and assess their potential application in cosmetics as well as their irritation properties. The larvae were defatted and extracted using various mediums, including DI water, along with 0.5 M aqueous solutions of sodium hydroxide, ascorbic acid, citric acid, and hydrochloric acid. Subsequently, the crude proteins were hydrolyzed using the Alcalase® enzyme. All extracts underwent testing for antioxidant activities via the 2,2'-azino-bis (3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) and Griess assays. Anti-aging properties were evaluated in terms of anti-collagenase and anti-hyaluronidase effects. Irritation potential was assessed using the hen's egg chorioallantoic membrane (HET-CAM) test. The results revealed that the sodium hydroxide extraction showed promising outcomes in terms of yield, protein content, and effectiveness in inhibiting hyaluronidase, with the highest inhibition at 78.1 ± 1.5%, comparable to that of oleanolic acid. Conversely, crude protein extracted with ascorbic acid and its hydrolysate showed notable antioxidant and collagenase-inhibitory activities. Remarkably, their anti-collagenase effects were comparable to those of ascorbic acid and lysine. Additionally, it demonstrated safety upon testing with the CAM. In conclusion, the findings provided valuable insights into the utilization of A. mellifera larval proteins as active ingredients with a wide range of cosmeceutical applications, particularly due to their antioxidant, anti-aging, and low irritation properties, which hold significant promise for anti-skin wrinkles.

Oxidative Stress Response of Honey Bee Colonies (Apis mellifera L.) during Long-Term Exposure at a Frequency of 900 MHz under Field Conditions.

In this study, oxidative stress and lipid peroxidation in honey bee larvae, pupae and the midguts of adult bees were investigated during a one-year exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields (RF-EMFs) at a frequency of 900 MHz under field conditions. The experiment was carried out on honey bee colonies at three locations with electric field levels of 30 mV m-1, 70 mV m-1 and 1000 mV m-1. Antioxidant enzymes, glutathione-S-transferase (GST), catalase (CAT) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) as indicators of lipid peroxidation were measured spectrophotometrically. The GST activity within the same developmental stage showed no significant differences regardless of electric field level or sampling time. The highest GST activity was found in the pupae, followed by activity in the larvae and midguts. Both CAT activity and TBARS concentration were the highest in the midguts, regardless of field level and sampling time. The larvae showed a significantly higher TBARS concentration at the location with an electric field level of 1000 mV m-1 compared to the locations with lower levels. Our results show that RF-EMFs at a frequency of 900 MHz can cause oxidative stress in honey bees, with the larval stage being more sensitive than the pupal stage, but there was no linear relationship between electric field level and effect in any of the developmental stages.

Toxic effects of acaricide fenazaquin on development, hemolymph metabolome, and gut microbiome of honeybee (Apis mellifera) larvae

Fenazaquin, a potent insecticide widely used to control phytophagous mites, has recently emerged as a potential solution for managing Varroa destructor mites in honeybees. However, the comprehensive impact of fenazaquin on honeybee health remains insufficiently understood. Our current study investigated the acute and chronic toxicity of fenazaquin to honeybee larvae, along with its influence on larval hemolymph metabolism and gut microbiota. Results showed that the acute median lethal dose (LD50) of fenazaquin for honeybee larvae was 1.786 μg/larva, and the chronic LD50 was 1.213 μg/larva. Although chronic exposure to low doses of fenazaquin exhibited no significant effect on larval development, increasing doses of fenazaquin resulted in significant increases in larval mortality, developmental time, and deformity rates. At the metabolic level, high doses of fenazaquin inhibited nucleotide, purine, and lipid metabolism pathways in the larval hemolymph, leading to energy metabolism disorders and physiological dysfunction. Furthermore, high doses of fenazaquin reduced gut microbial diversity and abundance, characterized by decreased relative abundance of functional gut bacterium Lactobacillus kunkeei and increased pathogenic bacterium Melissococcus plutonius. The disrupted gut microbiota, combined with the observed gut tissue damage, could potentially impair food digestion and nutrient absorption in the larvae. Our results provide valuable insights into the complex and diverse effects of fenazaquin on honeybee larvae, establishing an important theoretical basis for applying fenazaquin in beekeeping.