We study the mod-$\ell$ homotopy type of classifying spaces for commutativity, $B(\mathbb{Z}, G)$, at a prime $\ell$. We show that the mod-$\ell$ homology of $B(\mathbb{Z}, G)$ depends on the mod-$\ell$ homotopy type of $BG$ when $G$ is a compact connected Lie group, in the sense that a mod-$\ell$ homology isomorphism $BG \to BH$ for such groups induces a mod-$\ell$ homology isomorphism $B(\mathbb{Z}, G) \to B(\mathbb{Z}, H)$. In order to prove this result, we study a presentation of $B(\mathbb{Z}, G)$ as a homotopy colimit over a topological poset of closed abelian subgroups, expanding on an idea of Adem and G\'omez. We also study the relationship between the mod-$\ell$ type of a Lie group $G(\mathbb{C})$ and the locally finite group $G(\bar{\mathbb{F}}_p)$ where $G$ is a Chevalley group. We see that the na\"ive analogue for $B(\mathbb{Z}, G)$ of the celebrated Friedlander--Mislin result cannot hold, but we show that it does hold after taking the homotopy quotient of a $G$ action on $B(\mathbb{Z}, G)$.