Homochiral Preference Research Articles

Homochiral vs. heterochiral preference in chiral self-recognition of cyclic diols.

The structure and clustering propensity of a chiral derivative of cis-1,2-cyclohexanediol, namely, 1-phenyl-cis-1,2-cyclohexanediol (cis-PCD), has been studied under supersonic expansion conditions by combining laser spectroscopy with quantum chemistry calculations. The presence of the phenyl substituent induces conformational locking relative to cis-1,2-cyclohexanediol (cis-CD), and only one conformer of the bare molecule is observed by both Raman and IR-UV double resonance spectroscopy. The homochiral preference inferred for the dimer formation at low enough temperature is in line with the formation of a conglomerate in the solid state. The change in clustering propensity in cis-PCD relative to trans-1,2-cyclohexanediol (trans-CD), which shows heterochiral preference, is explained by the presence of the phenyl substituent rather than the effect of cis-trans isomerism. Indeed the transiently chiral cis-CD also forms preferentially heterodimers, whose structure is very close to that of the corresponding trans-CD dimer.

Sodium-ion-induced reversal of chiral preference observed in proline clusters in the gas phase

Enantioselective self-assembly can be observed in some amino acid cluster ions in the gas phase. Some interesting characters have been previously observed for proline, such as the formation of homochiral dodecamers and chiral preference oscillations of small-sized clusters. However, how alkali metal ions affect the formation and stability of the related homochiral and heterochiral proline clusters is unknown. Herein, the subtle effects of sodium ions on the chiral preference of proline clusters were studied in the gas phase. For the clusters of [Pro10,11+2H]2+ with strong heterochiral preference, the substitution of one proton with one sodium ion reverses their chiral preference, making the ions of [Pro10,11+H + Na]2+ characterized by the homochiral preference. However, the second substitution of sodium ion can reverse the preference once again. The reversal of chiral preference was found to be both cluster-size and alkali metal ion sensitive. Since sodium ions are involved in a wide variety of biological processes and usually inevitably exist in laboratory experiments, the results may have an important impact on the assembly of large-sized proline-related clusters.

Homochiral or Heterochiral: A Systematic Study of Threonine Clusters Using a FT ICR Mass Spectrometer

The strong chiral preferences of some magic clusters of amino acids have attracted continually increasing interests due to their unique structures, properties and possible roles in homochirogenesis. However, how chirality can influence the generation and stability of cluster ions in a wild range of cluster sizes is still unknown for most amino acids. In this study, the preference for threonine clusters to form homochiral and heterochiral complex ions has been investigated by electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry. Abundant cluster [Thrn+mH]m+ ions (7 ≤ n ≤ 78, 1 ≤ m ≤ 5) have been observed for both samples of enantiopure (100% L) and racemic (50:50 L:D) threonine solutions. Further analyses of the spectra show that the [Thr14+2H]2+ ion is characterized by its most outstanding homochiral preference, and [Thr7+H]+ and [Thr8+H]+ ions also clearly exhibit their homochiral preferences. Although most of the triply charged clusters (20 ≤ n ≤ 36) are characterized by heterochiral preferences, the quadruply charged [Thrn+4H]4+ ions (40 ≤ n ≤ 59) have no obvious chiral preference in general. On the other hand, a weak homochiral preference exists for most of the quintuply charged ions observed in the experiment.

Homochiral preference of serine octamer in solution and formed by dissociation of large gaseous clusters.

The ability of electrospray emitters with submicron tip diameters to significantly reduce and even eliminate aggregation of analyte molecules that can occur inside evaporating droplets was recently demonstrated to show that serine octamer exists in bulk solution, albeit in low abundance. Results using 222 nm emitter tips for D-serine and deuterium labeled L-serine show that the serine octamer that exists in 100 μM solution has a strong homochiral preference. Dissociation of large multiply protonated clusters results in formation of protonated octamer through a doubly protonated decamer intermediate. Remarkably, dissociation of the doubly protonated decamer from solution, which has a heterochiral preference, results in protonated octamer with strong homochiral preference. This homochiral preference is higher when protonated octamer is formed from larger clusters and approaches the chiral preference of the octamer in solution. These results show that the doubly protonated decamer has a different structure when formed from solution than when formed by dissociation of larger clusters. These results indicate that the unusually high abundance of protonated homochiral octamer formed by spray ionization methods that has been reported previously can be largely attributed to aggregation of serine that occurs in rapidly evaporating droplets and from dissociation of large clusters that form abundant protonated octamer at an optimized effective temperature.

Collection and Characterization by Mass Spectrometry of the Neutral Serine Octamer Generated upon Sublimation.

Serine forms neutral octameric clusters during sublimation, as demonstrated by electrostatically deflecting thermally ionized serine species from the sublimate, then gently ionizing the remaining neutrals for examination by mass spectrometry (MS). The MS results demonstrate a strong homochiral preference in the neutral octamer (measured after its gentle ionization), while the smaller serine clusters are achiral. In the initial stages of its sublimation, nonracemic solid serine generates a neutral serine monomer as the principal species in the vapor phase, with a significant enantiomeric enrichment relative to the solid. The serine monomer, when the flux is sufficient, assembles into the octamer, which displays a much higher chiral purity than the monomer. The serine octamer is separated from other neutral clusters in the sublimate by a new method based on the different distances that the clusters travel in an inert gas stream before they condense in a cooled collector. The deposited octamer is subsequently dissolved, and the solution is investigated by MS. The spectrum confirms that the collected serine octamer has undergone chiral enrichment relative to the starting solid used in the sublimation. The chiral enrichment observed in going from the serine monomer to octamer can be accommodated using a chemical model, grounded on the homochiral preference of the neutral serine octamer. Using the enantiomeric excess (ee %) of the vapor-phase monomer as the input, the model output matches the experimental octamer ee % when subliming solid serine with various initial ee % values.

Nebulization Prior to Isolation, Ionization, and Dissociation of the Neutral Serine Octamer Allows Its Characterization

AbstractNebulization of enantiomerically mixed serine solutions, followed by ion deflection and gentle on‐line protonation, is used to isolate and characterize the strongly preferred homochiral neutral serine octamer (Ser8). The separation of the nebulization and ionization steps and the use of the enantiomeric l‐serine ion (l‐d3Ser)8H+ as a soft protonating agent ensured that neutral (d‐Ser)8 was characterized without interference from serine octamer ((d‐Ser)8H+) ions. MS/MS experiments showed that the ionized neutral octamer and the protonated octamer formed directly by ESI have the same structures. Experiments in which the temperature of the heated transfer tube was varied indicate dissociation of the neutral octamer to the dimer. Field‐free nebulization of racemic serine forms the separate homochiral species with very high chiral selectivity. We suggest that the homochiral preference is a property of (d‐Ser)8 and that the preference observed earlier for (d‐Ser)8H+ is simply an expression of this feature of the neutral cluster.

Nebulization Prior to Isolation, Ionization, and Dissociation of the Neutral Serine Octamer Allows Its Characterization.

Nebulization of enantiomerically mixed serine solutions, followed by ion deflection and gentle on-line protonation, is used to isolate and characterize the strongly preferred homochiral neutral serine octamer (Ser8 ). The separation of the nebulization and ionization steps and the use of the enantiomeric l-serine ion (l-d3 Ser)8 H+ as a soft protonating agent ensured that neutral (d-Ser)8 was characterized without interference from serine octamer ((d-Ser)8 H+ ) ions. MS/MS experiments showed that the ionized neutral octamer and the protonated octamer formed directly by ESI have the same structures. Experiments in which the temperature of the heated transfer tube was varied indicate dissociation of the neutral octamer to the dimer. Field-free nebulization of racemic serine forms the separate homochiral species with very high chiral selectivity. We suggest that the homochiral preference is a property of (d-Ser)8 and that the preference observed earlier for (d-Ser)8 H+ is simply an expression of this feature of the neutral cluster.

The Structure of the Protonated Serine Octamer.

The amino acid serine has long been known to form a protonated "magic-number" cluster containing eight monomer units that shows an unusually high abundance in mass spectra and has a remarkable homochiral preference. Despite many experimental and theoretical studies, there is no consensus on a Ser8H+ structure that is in agreement with all experimental observations. Here, we present the structure of Ser8H+ determined by a combination of infrared spectroscopy and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations. The three-dimensional structure that we determine is ∼25 kcal mol-1 more stable than the previous most stable published structure and explains both the homochiral preference and the experimentally observed facile replacement of two serine units.

Synthesis and pKa determination of new enantiopure dimethyl-substituted acridino-crown ethers containing a carboxyl group: Useful candidates for enantiomeric recognition studies.

New enantiopure dimethyl-substituted acridino-18-crown-6 and acridino-21-crown-7 ethers containing a carboxyl group at position 9 of the acridine ring [(S,S)-8, (S,S)-9, (R,R)-10] were synthesized. The pKa values of the new crown ethers [(S,S)-8, (S,S)-9, (R,R)-10] and of an earlier reported macrocycle [(R,R)-2] were determined by UV-pH titrations. Crown ether (S,S)-8 was attached to silica gel by covalent bonds and the enantiomeric separation ability of the newly prepared chiral stationary phase [(S,S)-CSP-12] was studied by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Homochiral preference was observed and the best separation was achieved for the enantiomers of 1-NEA. Ligands (S,S)-9 and (R,R)-10 are precursors of enantioselective sensor and selector molecules for the enantiomers of protonated primary amines, amino acids, and their derivatives.

ChemInform Abstract: Self‐Assembly of Dendritic Dipeptides as a Model of Chiral Selection in Primitive Biological Systems

AbstractReview: 98 refs.

Chirality and Packing in Small Proline Clusters

The chiral composition of amino acid clusters may be related to the origin of chirality in biological systems. Here, we use ion mobility/mass spectrometry techniques to investigate the gas phase structures of singly charged proline clusters containing two to six monomers. Using deuterated L-proline (L(D7)) and different electrospray solution compositions varying from enantiopure (50:50 L:L(D7)) to racemic (50:50 L(D7):D), it is possible to study collision cross sections of L-, D-, and mixed xL:xD-proline clusters (where x refers to the number of monomers). These results show that [2Pro+H](+) and [3Pro+H](+) clusters, previously shown (Holliday et al. J. Phys. Chem. A 2012, DOI: 10.1021/jp302677n) to have a very small heterochiral preference, have similar collision cross sections for homochiral and heterochiral proline assemblies. The [4Pro+H](+) and [6Pro+H](+) clusters that exhibit homochiral preference have smaller collision cross sections for homochiral clusters and larger collision cross sections for heterochiral clusters. The [5Pro+H](+) cluster with heterochiral preference has a smaller collision cross section for its heterochiral compositions than for its homochiral compositions. These results suggest that the packing efficiency of subunits within each cluster influences the stability and prevalence of proline multimers as either homochiral or mixed L- and D- clusters.

Origin of chiral selectivity in gas-phase serine tetramers

Serine "magic-number" clusters have attracted substantial experimental and theoretical interest since their discovery. Serine undergoes marked chiral enrichment upon sublimation, which has been associated with the homochiral selectivity of the octamer. This process has been implicated in one possible mechanism leading to the origin of biological homochirality. While the octamer is the best known of the serine clusters, here we focus on the tetramer, the smallest serine cluster known to exhibit homochiral preference. This choice is based on its greater simplicity and tractability with accessible computational resources. Basin-hopping molecular dynamics simulations coupled to density functional theory calculations yield a "structural landscape" for low-lying configurations on the potential energy surface. The full range of enantiomeric compositions and charge states is investigated. Global energy minimum serine tetramers consist of a cage structure bonded by zwitterionic terminal groups. The participation of the serine hydroxyl side chains in hydrogen bonds with adjacent monomers drives the homochiral selectivity of serine tetramers. The configuration of the hydrogen bonding network is strongly dependent on enantiomeric composition and charge state. Smaller cations are incorporated into the center of the tetramer cage and effectively disable all side chain hydrogen bonding, while larger cations appear not to incorporate into the tetramer cage and are stabilized outside only in the homochiral case. The current theoretical data requires the introduction of a kinetic barrier to complete the model, limiting rearrangement from the basic cage configuration in some cases, which is discussed and probed directly by doubly-nudged elastic band transition state searches. These calculations elucidate a large barrier for reorganization of the cage, completing the theoretical understanding of the tetramers.

Chiral Discrimination in Stearoyl Amine Glycerol Monolayers

Chiral discrimination in Langmuir monolayers of amphiphilic 1-stearylamine-glycerol is studied using the hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical method. Using the experimental information about the lattice structure [D. Vollhardt, U. Gehlert, J. Phys. Chem. B. 2002, 106, 4419], the intermolecular interaction profiles for enantiomeric and racemic pair are studied as a function of mutual tilt and azimuth for different values of intermolecular separation. The present study reveals that, at shorter separation, the interaction profile of the racemic pair has deeper minima than the enantiomeric pair, whereas at larger separation the minimum of the enantiomeric pair is deeper. Thus, the theoretical studies reveal an interesting crossover from heterochiral preference to homochiral preference in 1-stearylamine-glycerol monolayers, with the increase in the intermolecular separation corresponding to a larger area per molecule in the monolayer. This predicts that, with gradual compression, the interactions between racemic pair dominate the experimental features, whereas, under nonequilibrium conditions at the beginning of the formation of the condensed phase, the experimental characteristics of homochirality are observable. The study conclusively shows that the chiral structure of the molecule and the lattice packing drive the chiral preference at the mesoscopic level.

Detection of Serine Octamer by Desorption Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry in Resultant Mixture of Aspartic Acid Exposed to Sunshine Under Natural Conditions

Serine, one of the nonessential amino acids, is of principal interest because of its capability to form magic-number ionic clusters, which provide a remarkable preference for homochirality. With L-aspartic acid as the precursor, this study provides experimental evidence for serine formation in weak acidified aqueous solutions in the presence of iron, with exposure to sunlight, which simulates the natural conditions of the prebiotic aqueous environment. The resultant mixture is directly analyzed via desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (DESI-MS), without any sample preseparation. The serine monomer is successfully detected as protonated molecules, giving a peak at m/z 106, which is confirmed by the MS/MS fragments. Protonated serine octamer (m/z 841) is also observed with significant abundance in the MS spectra and is confirmed by the MS/MS data, which shows the formation of the serine octamer by a synthesized serine in the resultant mixture. It is also found that the serine octamer yielded equivalent abundance in the DESI mass spectra in a wide pH range (pH = 1—5), and that existence of ferrous salt and sunshine are essential for the conversion of aspartic acid to serine in the acidic water solution.

Homochiral Preference in Peptide Synthesis in Ribosome: Role of Amino Terminal, Peptidyl Terminal, and U2620

Experimental studies have shown that peptide synthesis in ribosome exhibits a homochiral preference. We present, for the first time, an analysis of the origin of the phenomenon using hybrid quantum chemical studies based on a model of peptidyl transferase center from the crystal structure of the ribosomal part of Haloarcula marismortui. The study quantitatively shows that the observed homochiral preference is due to the difference in the nonbonded interaction between amino acids at the A- and P-terminals as well as due to the difference in interaction with the U2620 residue. A major part of the discrimination comes from the variation of nonbonded interaction of rotating A-terminal during the approach of the former toward the P-terminal. The difference indicates that, during the rotatory motion between A- and P-terminals for the proximal positioning of the reactant for reaction to occur, the interaction for a L-L pair is far less repulsive compared to the same process for a D-L pair. The activation barriers for L-L and D-L pairs of the neutral state of phenylalanine leading to corresponding dipeptides are also compared. The corresponding difference in rate constants is 40-fold. The study provides an understanding of how preferred addition of L-L pairs of amino acids rather than D-L pairs leads to retention of homochirality in peptides.

Alkali Metal-Cationized Serine Clusters Studied by Sonic Spray Ionization Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Serine solutions containing salts of alkali metals yield magic number clusters of the type (Ser(4)+C)(+), (Ser(8)+C)(+), (Ser(12)+C)(+), and (Ser(17)+2C)(+2) (where C = Li(+), Na(+), K(+), Rb(+), or Cs(+)), in relative abundances which are strongly dependent on the cation size. Strong selectivity for homochirality is involved in the formation of serine tetramers cationized by K(+), Rb(+), and Cs(+). This is also the case for the octamers cationized by the smaller alkalis but there is a strong preference for heterochirality in the octamers cationized by the larger alkali cations. Tandem mass spectrometry shows that the octamers and dodecamers cationized by K(+), Rb(+), and Cs(+) dissociate mainly by the loss of Ser(4) units, suggesting that the neutral tetramers are the stable building blocks of the observed larger aggregates, (Ser(8)+C)(+) and (Ser(12)+C)(+). Remarkably, although the Ser(4) units are formed with a strong preference for homochirality, they aggregate further regardless of their handedness and, therefore, with a preference for the nominally racemic 4D:4L structure and an overall strong heterochiral preference. The octamers cationized by K(+), Rb(+), or Cs(+) therefore represent a new type of cluster ion that is homochiral in its internal subunits, which then assemble in a random fashion to form octamers. We tentatively interpret the homochirality of these tetramers as a consequence of assembly of the serine molecules around a central metal ion. The data provide additional evidence that the neutral serine octamer is homochiral and is readily cationized by smaller ions.

Thermal Formation of Homochiral Serine Clusters and Implications for the Origin of Homochirality

Spontaneous assembly of amino acids into vapor-phase clusters occurs on heating the solid compounds in air. In comparison to the other amino acids, serine forms clusters to an unusual extent, showing a magic number octamer on sublimation; this octamer can be ionized and characterized by mass spectrometry. Two isomers of the vapor-phase serine octamer are generated, the minor one at 130 degrees C and the major at 220 degrees C. The higher temperature cluster shows a strong homochiral preference, as confirmed by isotopic labeling experiments. This serine cluster, like that generated earlier from solution in electrospray ionization experiments, undergoes gas-phase enantioselective substitution reactions with other amino acids. These reactions transfer the chirality of serine to the other amino acid through enantioselective incorporation into the octamer. Other serine pyrolysis products include alanine, glycine, ethanolamine, and small dipeptides, and many of these, too, are observed to be incorporated into the thermally formed serine octamers. Chiral chromatographic analysis confirmed that L-serine sublimation produced DL-alanine, glycine, and ethanolamine, while in the presence of hydrogen sulfide, L-serine yielded L-cysteine. The data demonstrate that sublimation of serine under relatively mild conditions yields chirally enriched serine octamers and that the chiral preference of the starting serine can be transferred to other compounds through cluster-forming chemical reactions.

Serine Octamers: Cluster Formation, Reactions, and Implications for Biomolecule Homochirality

AbstractChemInform is a weekly Abstracting Service, delivering concise information at a glance that was extracted from about 200 leading journals. To access a ChemInform Abstract, please click on HTML or PDF.

Comparison of the Intermolecular Energy Surfaces of Amino Acids: Orientation-Dependent Chiral Discrimination

In the present work, we compare the intermolecular energy surfaces of the alanine molecule in its neutral and zwitterionic state using ab initio theory (HF/6-311++G) as a function of mutual orientation. Starting from the optimized structures of the nonbonded homochiral (l-l) and heterochiral (d-l) pairs of molecules, the energy surfaces are studied with rigid geometry by varying the distance and orientation. The potential energy surfaces of the l-l and d-l pairs are found to be dissimilar and reflect the underlying chirality of the homochiral pair and racemic nature of the heterochiral pair. The intermolecular energy surface of the l-l pair is more favorable than the corresponding energy surface of the d-l pair. The study, for the first time, reveals clear homochiral preference without use of parameters, which was unobserved in previous detailed simulations but predicted by theory. The electrostatic interaction further augments the chiral discrimination. The basis set superposition error (BSSE) corrected results show enhanced discrimination. Use of higher-level Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) and further BSSE correction do not change the conclusions made at the Hartree-Fock (HF) level. The major conclusions based on HF and MP2 level calculations remain unaltered when the calculations of the potential energy surfaces for the neutral and zwitterionic pairs are repeated using the density functional theory (DFT) (B3LYP/6-311++G). The observed orientation dependence has significance in the biological chiral recognition as well as peptide synthesis at the peptidyl transferase center where the amino terminal and peptidyl terminal undergo mutual rotatory motion.

Serine Octamers: Cluster Formation, Reactions, and Implications for Biomolecule Homochirality

The emergence of homochirality continues to be one of the most challenging topics associated with the origin of life. One possible scenario is that aggregates of amino acids might have been involved in a sequence of chemical events that led to chiral biomolecules in self-replicating systems, that is, to homochirogenesis. Serine is the amino acid of principal interest, since it forms "magic-number" ionic clusters composed of eight amino acid units, and the clusters have a remarkable preference for homochirality. These serine octamer clusters (Ser8) can be generated under simulated prebiotic conditions and react selectively with other biomolecules. These observations led to the hypothesis that serine reactions were responsible for the first chiral selection in nature which was then passed through chemical reactions to other amino acids, saccharides, and peptides. This Review evaluates the chemistry of Ser8 clusters and the experimental evidence that supports their possible role in homochirogenesis.