A 74-meter Late Pleistocene to Holocene sedimentary sequence was recovered from southern Lake Vättern in the autumn of 2012. At ∼54 m below the lake floor, shear strength and high-resolution bulk density measurements suggest the presence of an unconformity in the varved proglacial clays. Incremental load consolidation tests reveal highly overconsolidated sediments below this level. Preconsolidation pressures for the underlying sediments are between 1250 and 2100 kPa, up to ∼1700 kPa more than the current in-situ effective stress. The highly overconsolidated sediments indicate either substantial erosion (the removal of 215–360 m of sediment), or consolidation under a large grounded ice mass sitting up to 230 m above paleo-lake level. Glaciotectonic deformation in underlying sediments supports the interpretation of a grounded ice mass. It is likely that this horizon is either contemporaneous with or older than the Levene moraine, formed between 13.4 and 13.8 ka. In the ∼30 m of overlying proglacial clays, there is no further evidence for grounded ice, indicating that any ice advance to southern Lake Vättern during the Younger Dryas would have been limited to an extremely thin ice tongue.