The authors report a case of a full-term male neonate born to a 34-year-old woman with heterosexually acquired asymptomatic HIV infection, with a CD4 cell count of 390/mm3 (26%) and an HIV-RNA level of 7600, receiving zidovudine, stavudine and efavirenz therapy before pregnancy. She was counselled regarding the potential risks of this therapy and the necessity for adequate birth control. After a period of amenorrhoea she performed a pregnancy test, which was positive. For this reason antiretroviral therapy was switched to an alternative regimen with lamivudine, stavudine and nelfinavir at 24 weeks of pregnancy. Obstetric controls were performed regularly and no side-effects were reported. Before and during the whole pregnancy the patient was submitted to daily folic acid supplementation. Ultrasound surveillance performed at the second trimester of gestation showed regular fetal growth and the presence of a lumbar mass and a triventricular hydrocephalus. The baby was born at the 38th week of gestational age, weight 3450 g, length 49 cm and head circumference 34.5 cm, presenting with a lumbo-sacral mass compatible with a myelomeningocele of 13 cm diameter with full intact skin (Fig. 1). A cerebral ultrasound showed a triventricular hydrocephalus. Magnetic resonance imaging confirmed a large sacral myelomeningocele lesion (10 cm diameter). Laboratory evaluation showed hepatic, renal and metabolic assessment in the normal range. The serological test for HIV (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and Western blot) was positive. HIV-1 DNA polymerase chain reaction at birth on plasma and cerebrospinal fluid was negative. The newborn was submitted to surgical repair of the myelomeningocele lesion and ventriculo–peritoneal shunting. Prophylactic therapy with zidovudine 2 mg/kg a day trial was started.Fig. 1.: Myelomeningocele in efavirenz-exposed newborn.The aetiology of myelomeningocele and other neural-tube defects still remain to be completely understood, although genetics, race, socioeconomics and environmental factors are recognized [1]. The role of folic acid deficiency as the major cause of spina bifida has been recognized, but at least 30% of cases are not prevented by periconceptional multivitamins containing folic acid supplementation. Therefore other specific environmental causes have been involved; to date maternal diabetes and fetal exposure to some anti-epileptic drugs such as valproic acid have been identified [2]. Efavirenz is a potent non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor that shows a durable suppression of HIV replication. In animal studies [3], efavirenz crosses the placenta and produces fetal blood concentrations similar to maternal blood concentrations. Teratogenic effects have been observed in three out of 20 fetuses from efavirenz-treated cynomolgus monkeys from the 20th to the 150th days of gestation in a developmental toxicity study. Drug-induced neural tube defects such as anencephaly and unilateral anophthalmia were observed in one fetus, microophthalmia was observed in another fetus, and cleft palate was observed in a third fetus. These effects were not noted on rats and rabbits probably because of different pharmacokinetics. The use of this drug is not allowed in pregnant women for two reasons: first, the teratogenic effects were observed in monkeys exposed at the same recommended dose as in humans; second, the drug follows the same metabolic pathway in humans and monkeys (the 8-OH conjugated glucuronide is the major metabolite in plasma and urine) [4]. To date, this case is the first report of neural tube defect in a human fetus accidentally exposed to efavirenz during the first month of pregnancy. This hypothesis is supported by strong evidence: (i) the extension of fetal exposure to efavirenz occurred within the first 28 days of gestation, exactly corresponding to the embryological period of neural tube closure [5]; (ii) the teratological effect observed in our neonate involved neural tube development, as did the anencephalia observed in fetuses from efavirenz-treated monkeys. In conclusion, this case suggests special considerations: the demonstration of a possible teratogenic effect in humans strengthens the recommendation that pregnancy should be avoided in women receiving efavirenz. Moreover, efavirenz-treated women should be carefully advised to shift to an alternative antiretroviral treatment before pregnancy. If our report is confirmed by further observations, we believe that the advisability of efavirenz proscription in women of reproductive age should be prudently considered. Carlo Fundarò Orazio Genovese Claudia Rendeli Enrica Tamburrini Elio Salvaggio
Read full abstract