Introduction: Diet and the prep medication affect the quality of colonoscopy examinations. The most widely accepted clear liquid diet does not leave patients with many options, and can be especially difficult for the diabetic population. This study compares prep quality between full liquid diet (FLD) and a clear liquid diet (CLD) in the setting of a split dosing sodium sulfate solution. Methods: This was a single-blinded, prospective, randomized study in a single community setting that included 160 patients who underwent elective outpatient colonoscopy for colon cancer screening or surveillance. Patients were randomized to either the standard of care CLD or the FLD which allowed patients to consume milk, ice cream, pudding, sorbet and sherbet but avoided red or purple coloring. Both groups received sodium sulfate as the prep solution. A sample size of 80 patients per group was needed to have approximately 80% power to detect a 15% difference between the two groups. The X2 Test of Independence was used to compare differences between the groups on the categorical variables and analysis of variance was used to compare differences between continuous variables. The primary outcome was the mean difference on the Ottawa Bowel Preparation scale between the two groups. Results: Of the 160 patients enrolled, 159 were randomized. 58% of the patients were female. The most common indication for the exam was average risk screening (72.5%), followed by personal history of polyp (21.3%), family history of colon cancer (5%), and family history of colon polyp (0.6%). 81 patients were enrolled in the CLD group and 78 patients in the FLD group. There was no difference in the mean Ottawa score between the CLD and FLD, 2.68 and 2.53, respectively (P = 0.653). Overall, the prep process was well-tolerated with the exception of more headache complaints in the FLD group. The overall cecal intubation rate, adenoma detection rate and average withdraw time were 99.4%, 49.6% and 10.2 minutes, respectively. Conclusion: This non-inferior result adds to the increase in literature demonstrating a strict CLD may not be necessary for a colonoscopy exam. Endoscopists should be more confident in having greater latitude in the prep diet. This, in return, may also improve the willingness of the patients to complete such an exam.
Read full abstract