Anemia in patients with alcohol use disorder (AUD) has a wide range of differential diagnoses, which can be challenging to interpret. It is often multifactorial, such as due to blood loss with or without coagulopathy, direct toxic effect of alcohol on hematopoietic cells, chronic inflammation, abnormalities in red blood cells (RBC) membranes, and nutritional deficiencies. Alcohol-induced liver disease may contribute to anemia through coagulopathy, splenomegaly, and hypersplenism. Macrocytosis is a common finding in patients with AUD due to B12 or folate deficiency or RBC membrane abnormality due to changes in lipid composition of RBC membranes. Patients with cirrhosis may have low haptoglobin due to impaired synthetic liver function. However, non-autoimmune hemolytic anemia and concomitant alcohol-induced liver damage should raise suspicion for spur cell anemia (SCA) and Zieve's syndrome. These medical conditions tend to be underreported or misdiagnosed. We describe a 44 year old male patient with a past medical history of AUD who presented with alcohol intoxication and was found to have newly diagnosed decompensated cirrhosis with severe macrocytic anemia with Hgb of 5.9 g/dl. Patient denied overt bleeding. Initial workup revealed high absolute reticulocyte count of 10.8% with retic index of 3, low haptoglobin of <15 mg/dl, elevated LDH of 275 u/l, negative Coombs test consistent with non-autoimmune hemolytic anemia, normal folate and B12 levels, and mixed direct and indirect hyperbilirubinemia. Peripheral blood smear showed anisopoikilocytosis, macrocytes, many spur cells, increased reticulocytes, but no schistocytes. Endo-colonoscopy showed grade 1 esophageal varices without evidence of recent bleeding. Given the history of heavy alcohol intake and cirrhosis, combined with Coombs-negative hemolytic anemia and peripheral blood smear findings of numerous spiculated red cells, our patient was diagnosed with SCA. At the time, due to active alcohol use, the patient was deemed not to be a candidate for liver transplant. This case report aims to aid physicians with the recognition of acute hemolytic anemia in patients with alcoholic liver injury and consideration of SCA and Zieve's syndrome as potential underlying causes. Prompt recognition and differentiation between these medical conditions are crucial as prognosis and treatment are different. Early recognition of SCA and timely consideration of liver transplantation can significantly improve patient outcomes.