The design of new renders and repair mortars requires a certain knowledge about the mechanical properties of historic materials. The common problem is that the extracted samples of historic mortars often have an irregular shape not suitable for standardised physical and mechanical laboratory tests. This is for example a problem with the testing of bedding mortars from historic brick masonry and/or renders where a typical sample width is around 10–15mm. Typical samples from wall cores are mortar bulks of very irregular shapes. In addition to the various non-standard sizes and shapes there is often a need for minimum intervention which leads to minimalisation of samples in numbers and sizes. The experimental part describes testing of specimens made of irregular samples of historic and modern mortars in compression and bending. The key problem was obtaining a certain measurable shape. This was done by cutting of the sample or by adding some material. The determined properties are compared to the properties obtained from the tests on standard specimens. The methods of testing are discussed and evaluated.