Biomimetic mineralized mortar (BMM) represents a novel green cementitious material, increasingly recognized for its environmental sustainability. In this study, four typical amino acids including acidic amino acids (aspartic acid, glutamic acid), neutral amino acid (threonine), and basic amino acid (arginine), are employed as crystal modifiers to develop the high-strength BMM (HBMM) based on the biomimetic chemically induced calcium carbonate precipitation (BCICP) method. The mechanical properties and failure morphology of HBMM were evaluated through unconfined compressive strength (UCS) test. The microstructure characteristics of HBMM were investigated using X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and contact angle test. The results show that amino acid-modified calcium carbonate precipitation can effectively cement loose sand particles and significantly improve the strength of the HBMM. The failure modes of HBMM observed include local failure, vertical splitting failure, shear failure, and splitting-shear mixed failure. Notably, aspartic acid and glutamic acid can induce the formation of vaterite-phase calcium carbonate crystals, while threonine and arginine facilitate the formation of aragonite-phase calcium carbonate crystals. The hydrogen bonding between modified calcium carbonate crystals and silanol groups on the silica surface ensures a tight adhesion of the precipitate to sand surfaces, filling gaps and cementing particles. This study elucidates that using amino acids as modifiers in the BCICP method can significantly enhance the strength of HBMM and influence its microstructure, offering valuable insights for its potential practical applications.