Gaithersburg, Md. – The benefits of a transcatheter heart valve outweigh its risks for older patients with severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis who are at a high risk for surgery, voted the majority of an advisory panel to the Food and Drug Administration recently. All panel members also voted that the valve was effective, and 10 of 12 members said that it was safe. The valve entered the U.S. market last November after receiving FDA approval for patients who have severe aortic stenosis and are deemed too sick to undergo surgical heart valve replacement (N. Engl. J. Med. 2010;363:1597-607). On June 12, Edwards Lifescience, the maker of the SAPIEN transcatheter heart valve, said that based on the results of the PARTNER pivotal trial, the valve is also safe and effective in the high-risk cohort. Although FDA officials agreed that the trial met its primary endpoints, they expressed concern with the higher risk of stroke in patients who underwent transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR), compared with those who underwent surgery. They also raised questions about the long-term durability of the device, for which there are no data yet available yet. In his final remarks, Dr. Craig R. Smith, chair of the department of surgery at Columbia University and coprincipal investigator of the PARTNER trial, said that although the risks associated with the procedures must be taken seriously, they should not be an obstacle to the indication’s approval. The main results of the trial showed that all-cause mortality at 30 days favored TAVR at 3.4%, compared with 6.5% for open surgery, and was similar at 1 year (24% and 27%, respectively). The difference at 1 year reached the trial’s prespecified noninferiority margin, yet again, neurologic complications occurred more frequently after TAVR. Surgical valve replacement has evolved over the past 50 years, and although TAVR is radical, it’s the next logical step in that evolution, Dr. Smith told the panel. The results of cohort A of PARTNER, he said, bring the field one step closer to the day that valves can be replaced with no large incisions, no heart-lung machine, and potentially no general anesthesia. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services decided in May that it will cover the procedure in inoperable patients, under certain conditions, including evaluation of the patient by two cardiac surgeons. Dr. Gregory J. Dehmer, professor of medicine at Texas A&M University, said that the field was only at its infancy. Dr. Dehmer disclosed no conflict of interest. Dr. Smith noted that he is an investigator in the PARTNER trial. CfA