Three scenarios involving aqueous mixtures of neoteric solvents have been evaluated as solvents and catalysts for the cellulose hydrolysis reaction to obtain CNC in high yields (>70%). The scenarios considered were: scenario 1 (S1) involves a recyclable ionic liquid dilution of [Hmim][(HSO4)(H2SO4)]/H2O (64 wt% IL); scenario 2 (S2) another recyclable dilution of [Hmim][(HSO4)(H2SO4)]//H2O (80 wt% IL) and scenario 3 (S3) a non-recyclable ternary deep eutectic solvent (60 wt% DES: choline chloride: oxalic acid/30 wt% PA/10 wt% water). Experimental analysis, techno-economic, and life cycle analysis (LCA) indicate that S1 emerges as a suitable scenario among the three analyzed. S1 demonstrated the highest competitiveness, with a lower raw material cost per gram of CNC produced (US$0.81/g) and lower environmental contributions concerning climate change and fossil fuel depletion, accounting mainly for its recyclability. Therefore, the recyclable dilution of 64 wt% IL used in S1 appears to be the most viable option for sustainable and environmentally conscious CNC production. Besides, the physicochemical properties of the CNC were revealed: aspect ratio range 7-8, high dispersion stability related to zeta potential > -40 mV, good crystallinity range 50-80%, and thermal stability with Tonset> 300 °C. These results guided towards a scenario with crucial advantages: a diluted IL that retains its acidity after reuse cycles by a facile recovery process, maintaining high CNC production performance and providing low environmental impacts.