High Mass Loading Research Articles

Intercalation chemistry engineering strategy enabled high mass loading and ultrastable electrodes for High-Performance aqueous electrochemical energy storage devices

Aqueous electrochemical energy storage devices (AEESDs) are considered one of the most promising candidates for large-scale energy storage infrastructure due to their high affordability and safety. Developing electrodes with the merits of high energy density and long lifespan remains a challenging issue toward the practical application of AEESDs. Research attempts at electrode materials, nanostructure configuration, and electronic engineering show the limitations due to the inherent contradictions associated with thicker electrodes and ion-accessible kinetics. Herein, we propose an intercalation chemistry engineering strategy to enhance the electrolyte ion (de)intercalation behaviors during the electrochemical charge–discharge. To validate this strategy, the prototypical model of a high-mass-loading MnO2-based electrode is used with controlled intercalation of Na+ and H2O. Theoretical and experimental results reveal that an optimal content of Na+ and H2O on the MnO2-based electrode exhibits superior electrochemical performance. Typically, the resultant electrode exhibits an impressive areal capacitance of 1551 mF/cm2 with a mass loading of 9.7 mg/cm2 (at 1 mA/cm2). Furthermore, the assembled full-cell with obtained MnO2-based electrode delivers a high energy density of 0.12 mWh/cm2 (at 20.02 mW/cm2) and ultra-high cycling stability with a capacitance retention percentage of 89.63 % (345 mF/cm2) even after 100,000 cycles (tested over 72 days).

Fe-nanocluster embedded biomass-derived carbon for efficient photo-Fenton-like activity in water purification

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) as photo-Fenton-like catalysts have attracted widespread attention in water purification. However, the development of SACs with renewability, cleanliness, high mass loading, and raw material abundance is a formidable challenge to achieve efficient pollutant removal. In this study, we fabricated high-performance Fe-nanocluster embedded biomass-derived carbon (Fe/Bio-C) from Ficus altissima wastes for quinolone antibiotics degradation. The high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy with aberration correction (AC-HAADF-STEM) and X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (XAFS) revealed that the Fe/Bio-C exhibited a porous structure with abundant Fe-N4 active sites. The Fe/Bio-C catalysts achieved an exceptional efficiency of 98.6 % for the removal of the representative quinolone antibiotic, namely lomefloxacin (LOM), within 30 min. Furthermore, an in-depth exploration was conducted to assess the influence of reaction parameters on degradation performance, kinetics, toxicity, and mechanism. The free radical quenching experiments and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra demonstrated the existence of ·O2−, 1O2, ·OH, SO4·− in the reaction system and the ·O2− radicals played a relatively important role in the degradation progress. This work broaden the avenue for constructing metal-nanocluster photocatalysts with the high reactivity, low metal leaching, and universality to various pollutants.

Development and validation of an analytical pyrolysis method for detection of airborne polystyrene nanoparticles

Microplastic is ubiquitous in the environment. Recently it was discovered that microplastic (MP, 1 μm−5 mm) contamination is present in the atmosphere where it can be transported over long distances and introduced to remote pristine environments. Sources, concentration levels, and transportation pathways of MP are still associated with large uncertainties. The abundance of atmospheric MP increases with decreasing particle size, suggesting that nanoplastics (NP, <1μm) could be of considerable atmospheric relevance. Only few analytical methods are available for detection of nanosized plastic particles. Thermoanalytical techniques are independent of particle size and are thus a powerful tool for MP and NP analysis. Here we develop a method for analysis of polystyrene on the nanogram scale using pyrolysis gas chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry. Pyrolysis was performed using a slow temperature ramp, and analytes were cryofocused prior to injection. The mass spectrometer was operated in selected ion monitoring (SIM) mode. A lower limit of detection of 1±1 ng and a lower limit of quantification of 2±2 ng were obtained (for the trimer peak). The method was validated with urban ▪ matrices of low (7 μg per sample) and high (53 μg per sample) aerosol mass loadings. The method performs well for low ▪ loadings, whereas high ▪ loadings seem to cause a matrix effect reducing the signal of polystyrene. This effect can be minimized by introducing a thermal desorption step prior to pyrolysis. The study provides a novel analysis method for qualitative and semi-quantitative analysis of PS on the nanogram scale in an aerosol matrix. Application of the method can be used to obtain concentration levels of polystyrene in atmospheric MP and NP. This is important in order to improve the understanding of the sources and sinks of MP and NP in the environment and thereby identify routes of exposure and uptake of this emerging contaminant.

Polyaniline packed activated carbon as pseudocapacitive negative electrodes

Hybrid supercapacitors (HSCs) are attracting more attentions due to their potential high power and energy density. To exploring high capacity negative electrode materials, especially the capacitive materials, is more critical for further enhancing the energy density of HSC in comparing with more reported advanced battery-type positive materials. For perfect combination of electrochemical double layer and pseudocapacitive capacitance in negative electrode, the method of evenly filling polyaniline on nanopores of activated carbon is developed herein with keeping large surface area, the suitable ion-diffusion structure of activated carbon and further obtaining rich surface redox-active sites. The polyaniline packed activated carbons exhibit high specific capacitance (437.9 F g−1 at 0.5 A g−1) in negative voltage window (0 to −1.0 V), superior rate performance (378.0 F g−1 at 30 A g−1), and excellent capacitance retention even at a high mass loading and a high current density (326.5 F g−1 at 10 mg cm−2 and 20 A g−1). Additionally, an aqueous HSC based on the polyaniline packed activated carbon negative electrode and Ni-Co-LDH positive electrode presents higher energy density of 44.6 Wh kg−1 at a power density of 377.1 W kg−1. The present study presents novel method and materials for developing high performance capacitive negative electrode materials.

High fractal-dimensional carbon conductive agent for improving the Li storage performance of Si-based electrode

Constructing stable Si electrodes with high areal capacity is crucial for improving the total energy density of lithium ion batteries (LIBs). However, it remains challenging because the poor intrinsic conductivity and serious pulverization of Si usually lead to the active material falling-off from the conductive network. Herein, we demonstrate novel spatially extended graphene ribbons with a high fractal-dimension structure (HFGR-400), which can construct highly conductive and mechanically reinforced networks when used as the conductive agent for Si electrodes. The HFGR-400 added electrode shows 1.5–3.2 times higher conductivity and 1.4–2.3 times larger peeling strength than those of the commonly used carbon conductive agent added electrodes. Moreover, the flexible HFGR-400 ribbons with appropriate amount of functional groups ensure large contact area and strong interfacial interaction with Si particles, but without blocking the ion transport channels. Therefore, the HFGR-400 added Si electrode exhibits good cycle stability (2051.8 mAh/g after 200 cycles) and high rate performance. Moreover, the high Si mass loading HFGR-400 electrode shows a competitive areal capacity of 3.5 mAh cm−2 after 200 cycles, superior to most of the reported Si-based electrodes. Our work highlights the importance of conductive agents with high fractal-dimension structure for practical Si-based electrodes.

Perforated PVP encapsulated AgNWs for high mass loading in silver nanowire inks for printed RFID integrated wearable smart bands

A perforated PVP coating on AgNWs produces high-mass loading and low-temperature curing inks. The ink produces prints of high conductivity, and an RFID-assisted smart band for wearable position sensing is developed using the ink.

Coaxial nickel cobalt selenide/nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube array as a three-dimensional self-supported electrode for electrochemical energy storage.

Herein, we propose a one-step urea pyrolysis method for preparing a nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube array grown on carbon fiber paper, which is demonstrated as a three-dimensional scaffold for constructing a nickel cobalt selenide-based coaxial array structure. Thanks to the large surface area, interconnected porous structure, high mass loading, as well as fast electron/ion transport pathway of the coaxial array structure, the nickel cobalt selenide/nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube electrode exhibits over 7 times higher areal capacity than that directly grown on carbon fiber paper, and better rate capability. The cell assembled by a nickel cobalt selenide/nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube positive electrode and an iron oxyhydroxide/nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube negative electrode delivers a volumetric capacity of up to 22.5 C cm-3 (6.2 mA h cm-3) at 4 mA cm-2 and retains around 86% of the initial capacity even after 10 000 cycles at 10 mA cm-2. A volumetric energy density of up to 4.9 mW h cm-3 and a maximum power density of 208.1 mW cm-3 are achieved, and is comparable to, if not better than, those of similar energy storage devices reported previously.

Performance evaluation of lithium metal rechargeable batteries with a lithium excess cation-disordered rocksalt based positive electrode under high mass loading and lean electrolyte conditions

Operation of 500 W h kg−1 class rechargeable batteries was demonstrated. Non-destructive XCT analysis revealed volume expansion of the lithium metal electrode as the primary reason for the capacity fading.

Heteroatom-doped hierarchically porous thick bulk carbon derived from a Pleurotus eryngii/lignin composite: a free-standing and high mass loading electrode for high-energy-density storage

It is critical to prepare self-supported carbonaceous electrode materials that enable high-mass loading and efficient ion/electron transport through a simple and sustainable method.

Manganese-cobalt geomimetic materials for supercapacitor electrode.

A manganese-cobalt asbolane material synthesized by low-temperature cationic exchange from birnessite in cobalt nitrate solution has been comprehensively characterized and tested for the first time as a massive (with high active mass loading) positive electrode material for to asymmetric aqueous supercapacitors. The structure of this Mn-rich material, which is homologous to the natural asbolanes well known by mineralogists, consists of MnO2-type slabs with partial substitution of Co3+ for Mn; the slabs alternate with Co(OH)2 islands located in the interlayer spacing. This structural arrangement was confirmed through in-depth electronic transmission microscopy analyses, which reveal two interlocking hexagonal sublattices with distinct a lattice-cell parameters but identical c parameters. The electrochemical performance of this geomimetic phase in alkaline electrolytes is highly promising, with specific capacitance of up to 180 F g-1 at moderate current densities and 94 F g-1 at 10 A g-1. Investigation into the charge storage mechanisms indicates effective synergy between the pseudocapacitive properties of the MnO2 slabs and the Co(OH)2 islands, in which protonic conduction is suspected to play a key role. Additionally, long-term cycling and calendar aging tests suggest that the interlayer cobalt gradually migrates to the metal oxide layer upon cycling while maintaining excellent energy storage performance. This study clearly underscores the value of exploring geomimetic minerals as potential electrode materials for energy storage applications.

Boosting the performance of Zn ion hybrid supercapacitors by regulating the chemically and physically active sites of graphene films.

Reduced graphene oxide (RGO) is an ideal material as an electrode used in the electrochemical energy storage field. However, the serious aggregation of graphene sheets and fewer chemically active sites limit it from exhibiting higher performance. Herein, we introduce a facile solvothermal reaction method to simultaneously regulate the functional groups on RGO, balance the aggregation and connection of graphene sheets, and dope the nitrogen element in a graphene network. The obtained electrode (RGO-N(DMF)) has a high content of carbonyl and nitrogen functional groups, and shows a fluffy structure as well as good electron conductivity, exhibiting both high chemically and physically actives sites. Benefiting from these advantages, RGO-N(DMF) shows a high specific capacity of 135 mA h g-1 at 0.2 A g-1 and favorable rate performance of maintaining 53% capacity at 50 A g-1, which are both higher than those of the normal hydrothermally obtained RGO electrodes. More interestingly, RGO-N(DMF) can maintain the high electrochemical performance at a high mass loading of 5.1 mg cm-2. In addition, when the RGO-N(DMF) electrode is used in the flexible Zn-ion hybrid supercapacitor (ZHS), the capacity retention remains at 100% after 500-time bending, showing excellent mechanical flexibility. This study not only provides an effective strategy for constructing carbon-based cathode materials with excellent properties, but also provides prospects and enlightenment for the practical application of aqueous ZHSs.

New approaches to three-dimensional positive electrodes enabling scalable high areal capacity

A novel in situ powder infiltration method was used to fabricate 3D positive electrodes with scalable high areal capacity, highlighting the high mass loading of active materials and interfaces of binder-free 3D electrodes.

Stretchable and biodegradable plant-based redox-diffusion batteries.

The redox-diffusion (RD) battery concept introduces an environmentally friendly solution for stretchable batteries in autonomous wearable electronics. By utilising plant-based redox-active biomolecules and cellulose fibers for the electrode scaffold, separator membrane, and current collector, along with a biodegradable elastomer encapsulation, the battery design overcomes the reliance on unsustainable transition metal-based active materials and non-biodegradable elastomers used in existing stretchable batteries. Importantly, it addresses the drawback of limited attainable battery capacity, where increasing the active material loading often leads to thicker and stiffer electrodes with poor mechanical properties. The concept decouples the active material loading from the mechanical structure of the electrode, enabling high mass loadings, while retaining a skin-like young's modulus and stretchability. A stretchable ion-selective membrane facilitates the RD process, allowing two separate redox couples, while preventing crossovers. This results in a high-capacity battery cell that is both electrochemically and mechanically stable, engineered from sustainable plant-based materials. Notably, the battery components are biodegradable at the end of their life, addressing concerns of e-waste and resource depletion.

Wildfire and African dust aerosol oxidative potential, exposure and dose in the human respiratory tract

Exposure to wildfire smoke and dust can severely affect air quality and health. Although particulate matter (PM) levels and exposure are well-established metrics linking to health outcomes, they do not consider differences in particle toxicity or deposition location in the respiratory tract (RT). Usage of the oxidative potential (OP) exposure may further shape our understanding on how different pollution events impact health. Towards this goal, we estimate the aerosol deposition rates, OP and resulting OP deposition rates in the RT for a typical adult Caucasian male residing in Athens, Greece. We focus on a period when African dust (1–3 of August 2021) and severe wildfires at the northern part of the Attika peninsula and the Evia island, Greece (4–18 of August 2021) affected air quality in Athens. During these periods, the aerosol levels increased twofold leading to exceedances of the World Health Organization (WHO) [15(5) μg m−3] PM10 (PM2.5) air quality standard by almost 100 %. We show that the OP exposure is 1.5-times larger during the wildfire smoke events than during the dust intrusion, even if the latter was present in higher mass loads – because wildfire smoke has a higher specific OP than dust. This result carries two important implications: OP exposure should be synergistically used with other metrics - such as PM levels - to efficiently link aerosol exposure with the resulting health effects, and, certain sources of air pollution (in our case, exposure to biomass burning smoke) may need to be preferentially controlled, whenever possible, owing to their disproportionate contribution to OP exposure and ability to penetrate deeper into the human RT.

Co/Mon Invigorated Bilateral Kinetics Modulation for Advanced Lithium-Sulfur Batteries.

Sluggish sulfur redox kinetics and Li-dendrite growth are the main bottlenecks for lithium-sulfur (Li-S) batteries. Separator modification serves as a dual-purpose approach to address both of these challenges. In this study, the Co/MoN composite is rationally designed and applied as the modifier to modulate the electrochemical kinetics on both sides of the sulfur cathode and lithium anode. Benefiting from its adsorption-catalysis function, the decorated separators (Co/MoN@PP) not only effectively inhibit polysulfides (LiPSs) shuttle and accelerate their electrochemical conversion but also boost Li+ flux, realizing uniform Li plating/stripping. The accelerated LiPSs conversion kinetics and excellent sulfur redox reversibility triggered by Co/MoN modified separators are evidenced by performance, in-situ Raman detection and theoretical calculations. The batteries with Co/MoN@PP achieve a high initial discharge capacity of 1570 mAh g-1 at 0.2 C with a low decay rate of 0.39%, uniform Li+ transportation at 1mA cm-2 over 800h. Moreover, the areal capacity of 4.62 mAh cm-2 is achieved under high mass loadings of 4.92mg cm-2. This study provides a feasible strategy for the rational utilization of the synergistic effect of composite with multifunctional microdomains to solve the problems of Li anode and S cathode toward long-cycling Li-S batteries.

Deploying Cationic Cellulose Nanofiber Confinement to Enable High Iodine Loadings Towards High Energy and High‐Temperature Zn‐I2 Battery

AbstractHigh iodine loading and high‐temperature adaptability of the iodine cathode are prerequisites to achieving high energy density at full battery level and promoting the practical application for the zinc‐iodine (Zn‐I2) battery. However, it would aggravate the polyiodide shuttle effect when employing high iodine loading and working temperature. Here, a sustainable cationic cellulose nanofiber (cCNF) was employed to confine the active iodine species through strong physiochemical adsorption to enlarge the iodine loading and stabilize it even at high temperatures. The cCNF could accommodate dual‐functionality by enlarging the iodine loading and suppressing the polyiodide shuttle effect, owing to the unique framework structure with abundant surface positive charges. As a result, the iodine cathode based on the cCNF could deliver high iodine mass loading of 14.1 mg cm−2 with a specific capacity of 182.7 mAh g−1, high areal capacity of 2.6 mAh cm−2, and stable cycling over 3000 cycles at 2 A g−1, thus enabling a high energy density of 34.8 Wh kg−1 and the maximum power density of 521.2 W kg−1 at a full Zn‐I2 battery level. In addition, even at a high temperature of 60 °C, the Zn‐I2 battery could still deliver a stable cycling.

Deploying Cationic Cellulose Nanofiber Confinement to Enable High Iodine Loadings Towards High Energy and High-Temperature Zn-I2 Battery.

High iodine loading and high-temperature adaptability of the iodine cathode are prerequisites to achieving high energy density at full battery level and promoting the practical application for the zinc-iodine (Zn-I2 ) battery. However, it would aggravate the polyiodide shuttle effect when employing high iodine loading and working temperature. Here, a sustainable cationic cellulose nanofiber (cCNF) was employed to confine the active iodine species through strong physiochemical adsorption to enlarge the iodine loading and stabilize it even at high temperatures. The cCNF could accommodate dual-functionality by enlarging the iodine loading and suppressing the polyiodide shuttle effect, owing to the unique framework structure with abundant surface positive charges. As a result, the iodine cathode based on the cCNF could deliver high iodine mass loading of 14.1 mg cm-2 with a specific capacity of 182.7 mAh g-1 , high areal capacity of 2.6 mAh cm-2 , and stable cycling over 3000 cycles at 2 A g-1 , thus enabling a high energy density of 34.8 Wh kg-1 and the maximum power density of 521.2 W kg-1 at a full Zn-I2 battery level. In addition, even at a high temperature of 60 °C, the Zn-I2 battery could still deliver a stable cycling.

Revealing the Rate-Limiting Electrode of Lithium Batteries at High Rates and Mass Loadings

Lithium-ion batteries with superior capacities and rate performance are needed due to the soaring demands for even higher energy and power device requirements. [1-2] However, the main hurdle on achieving this predominately results from poor rate performance of the electrode, related to thermodynamic limitations and slow kinetics. To determine the rate-limiting electrochemical processes in a NMC622 vs graphite cell, a methodology based upon the galvanic intermittent titration technique, for investigating the diffusion coefficient and rate kinetics from the observed overpotential at each electrode has been developed. Variable current densities have been used to simultaneously extract the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of each electrode with increasing mass loading. Graphite is observed to reach its thermodynamic limits quicker than NMC, due to the flat plateaus and overpotentials observed from the charge transfer kinetics and mass transport. At high rates and high mass loadings, the graphite electrode is responsible for limiting both lithium-ion diffusion and reaction rates in the full cell. Slow diffusion kinetics are caused by the transport of the electrolyte in the porous electrode, which limits the availability of lithium for reaction at the surface of the graphite. This current interrupt testing methodology is proposed as a fast single technique for comprehensively parameterizing the rate limitations observed in a full cell configuration [3].

Towards All-Extruded Custom-Shape Batteries

The rapid growth of flexible electronics for wearable devices, on-skin or environmental sensors, and flexible displays have resulted in intensive research in the field of free form-factor energy-storage systems. Since batteries must withstand bending, folding, or stretching while maintaining their electrochemical performance, the design and processing of battery components, must be reconsidered. Moreover, there is a clear tendency to shift battery technology to clean and cost-effective dry methods with no toxic solvents. Dry fabrication methods are environmentally friendly, involve lower energy consumption, shorter time and are cost-effective. Hot-pressing and melting-extrusion strategies are appropriate for the fabrication of flexible, solid-polymer electrolytes and electrodes with high contents of active materials and high mass loading.Here we present the progress towards the simple, one-step extrusion of a solid-state battery with a multi-shell and layered architecture. Such structures fundamentally minimize the ionic pathway for Li+. As in the conventional battery, high ionic conductivity of extruded electrolyte and compatibility with electrode materials, are the essential properties for enabling high performance of the battery. The electrolytes are composed of LiTFSI, polyethylene oxide (PEO), which is a known lithium-ion conductor, and thermoplastic recyclable and biodegradable polymer- polyurethane (TPU) - for enhanced mechanical properties and high-temperature durability. The extruded electrolytes of different PEO-to-TPU ratios and salt content were characterized by means of ESEM imaging, mass spectroscopy, differential-scanning calorimetry (DSC), electrochemical-impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) diffusion measurements. The structure and electrochemical properties of extruded electrolytes were compared with cast films. It was found that TPU, having in its structure, both soft segments from polyol regions and hard segments from isocyanate not only improves the mechanical properties of neat PEO-based polymer electrolyte, but also forms complexes with lithium salt and serves as a conducting medium. Bulk conductivity vs. temperature dependencies obey Arrhenius behavior. The highest conductivity values varying from 0.3 to 1mS/cm over a temperature range from RT to 90ºC were achieved for the extruded 1:15 (Li:EO) solid polymer electrolyte. The NMR tests show that lithium self-diffusion coefficients in extruded PE with alumina filler are close to that in cast PE, but the anion diffusion coefficients (accessible through 19F NMR) are lower in extruded filaments, indicating a correspondingly higher Li+ transference number induced by the extrusion. Lithium cells with extruded LFP cathode and solid extruded polymer electrolyte demonstrated 40 reversible cycles with close to 96% coulombic efficiency. The electrochemical performance of half-cells composed of extruded LFP-based cathode and extruded TPU-MWCNT-based current collector will be presented.

SiO2 Nanoparticle Coating to Enable Polyethylene-Based Na-Ion Battery Separators

The increasing demand for Li-ion batteries (LIBs), pushed even more by the electrical vehicle industry, has highlighted the concern with the scarcity and uneven distribution of LIB raw materials. Electrochemical energy storage based on alternative chemistries, once properly developed, may provide sufficient energy density to partly supply that demand, reducing the dependence on Li natural reserves. Among the studied chemistries, Na-ion-based storage is currently attracting a lot of research attention. This is partly due to the similarities between Li and Na, which allow for the utilisation of analogous materials and methods already in place for LIBs. However, not every component of LIBs can be directly applied to Na-ion batteries (SIB).[1] This is the case for battery separators, the membranes used to avoid physical contact between the two battery electrodes to prevent short circuiting while conducting ions from one battery pole to the other. Porous polyolefin films, such as polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP), have been successfully used in LIBs, but are not compatible with SIB electrolytes. In the latter case, issues arise from the poor wettability of the separator with the electrolyte, which leads to low ionic conductivity, and creates an uneven flux of ions that can cause cell failure. To address this issue, previous reports have shown that the presence of inorganic oxides such as ZrO2 [2] and SiO2 [3] on polyolefin films can increase the affinity of the separator with commonly used LIB and SIB electrolytes. Moreover, ceramic-modified films also show higher thermal stability and hindered thermal shrinkage, which improves battery safety.In this work, we investigated PE coated with spherical SiO2 particles (designed by Glantreo, Ireland) with different sizes of 85 and 200 nm. The coatings were made by tape casting both sides of a PE film with slurries containing SiO2 particles and a binder. Binder type, SiO2 concentration and SiO2/binder ratio were optimized for each particle size. The obtained films were characterized by scanning electron microscopy and infrared spectroscopy, and were compared regarding their wettability, thermal stability, and ionic conductivity. The films were tested as separators in hard-carbon half-cells with 1 mol/L NaClO4 in either diethylene glycol dimethyl ether (DEGDME) or ethylene carbonate (EC)/ propylene carbonate (PC) electrolyte. With carbonate-based electrolyte, PE has very low wettability and cells short circuit within the first cycle. However, SiO2-PE samples showed higher wettability, which allowed for cycling at low current densities. In DEGDME-based electrolyte, cells with PE separator presented capacity fade, with 50% capacity loss after 250 cycles at 400 mA/g. On the other hand, cells with SiO2-PE separator had stable cycling for more than 300 cycles and no short-circuiting was observed, even when high active mass loading electrodes (8 mg/cm2) were used. These are promising results showing that a surface layer of SiO2 particles can make PE a viable option for SIB separators.