High-frequency And -field Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Research Articles

A perspective on applications of ligand-field analysis: inspiration from electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of coordination complexes of transition metal ions

This paper describes in a somewhat personal way an overview of the use of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, including high-frequency and -field EPR (HFEPR) to unravel the electronic structure of transition metal ion complexes. The spin Hamiltonian parameters obtained from EPR experiments, namely the g matrix for systems with S =1/2 and the g and D (zero-field splitting) matrices for systems with S > 1/2 provide information on d orbital energy levels. This information can be combined with ligand-field theory (LFT) to provide information on the overall electronic structure of the paramagnetic transition metal complex. As has been discussed by others, LFT is still useful in providing such a quantitative understanding of these complexes, even in the day of advanced computational methods, such as density functional theory (DFT). The discussion is illustrated by examples across the d n configuration.

Electronic Structure of Four-Coordinate C3v Nickel(II) Scorpionate Complexes: Investigation by High-Frequency and -Field Electron Paramagnetic Resonance and Electronic Absorption Spectroscopies

A series of complexes of formula TpNiX, where Tp*- = hydrotris(3,5-dimethylpyrazole)borate and X = Cl, Br, I, has been characterized by electronic absorption spectroscopy in the visible and near-infrared (NIR) region and by high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) spectroscopy. The crystal structure of TpNiCl has been previously reported; that for TpNiBr is given here: space group = Pmc2(1), a = 13.209(2) A, b = 8.082(2) A, c = 17.639(4) A, alpha = beta = gamma = 90 degrees , Z = 4. TpNiX contains a four-coordinate nickel(II) ion (3d8) with approximate C3v point group symmetry about the metal and a resulting S = 1 high-spin ground state. As a consequence of sizable zero-field splitting (zfs), TpNiX complexes are "EPR silent" with use of conventional EPR; however, HFEPR allows observation of multiple transitions. Analysis of the resonance field versus the frequency dependence of these transitions allows extraction of the full set of spin Hamiltonian parameters. The axial zfs parameter for TpNiX displays pronounced halogen contributions down the series: D = +3.93(2), -11.43(3), -22.81(1) cm(-1), for X = Cl, Br, I, respectively. The magnitude and change in sign of D observed for TpNiX reflects the increasing bromine and iodine spin-orbit contributions facilitated by strong covalent interactions with nickel(II). These spin Hamiltonian parameters are combined with estimates of 3d energy levels based on the visible-NIR spectra to yield ligand-field parameters for these complexes following the angular overlap model (AOM). This description of electronic structure and bonding in a pseudotetrahedral nickel(II) complex can enhance the understanding of similar sites in metalloproteins, both native nickel enzymes and nickel-substituted zinc enzymes.

Tunable-frequency high-field electron paramagnetic resonance

A tunable-frequency methodology based on backward wave oscillator sources in high-frequency and -field EPR (HFEPR) is described. This methodology is illustrated by an application to three non-Kramers transition metal ion complexes and one Kramers ion complex. The complexes are of: Ni(II) ( S = 1) as found in dichlorobistriphenylphosphanenickel(II), Mn(III) ( S = 2) as found in mesotetrasulfonatoporphyrinatomanganese(III) chloride, Fe(II) ( S = 2) as found in ferrous sulfate tetrahydrate, and Co(II) ( S = 3/2) as found in azido(tris(3- tert-butylpyrazol-1-yl)hydroborate)cobalt(II). The above Ni(II) and Mn(III) complexes have been studied before by HFEPR using the multifrequency methodology based on Gunn oscillator sources, but not by the present method, while the Fe(II) and Co(II) complexes presented here have not been studied by any form of HFEPR. Highly accurate spin Hamiltonian parameters can be obtained by the experimental methodology described here, in combination with automated fitting procedures. This method is particularly successful in determining g-matrix parameters, which are very difficult to extract for high-spin systems from single frequency (or a very limited set of multi-frequency) HFEPR spectra, but is also able to deliver equally accurate values of the zero-field splitting tensor. The experimental methods involve either conventional magnetic field modulation or an optical modulation of the sub-THz wave beam. The relative merits of these and other experimental methods are discussed.

Synthesis, Characterization, and Physicochemical Properties of Manganese(III) and Manganese(V)−Oxo Corrolazines

The structural and physicochemical properties of the manganese-corrolazine (Cz) complexes (TBP8Cz)Mn(V)O (1) and (TBP8Cz)Mn(III) (2) (TBP = p-tert-butylphenyl) have been determined. Recrystallization of 2 from toluene/MeOH resulted in the crystal structure of (TBP8Cz)Mn(III)(CH3OH) (2 x MeOH). The packing diagram of 2 x MeOH reveals hydrogen bonds between MeOH axial ligands and meso N atoms of adjacent molecules. Solution binding studies of 2 with different axial ligands (Cl-, Et3PO, and Ph3PO) reveal strong binding, corroborating the preference of the Mn(III) ion for a five-coordinate environment. High-frequency and field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) spectroscopy of solid 2 x MeOH shows that 2 x MeOH is best described as a high-spin (S = 2) Mn(III) complex with zero-field splitting parameters typical of corroles. Structural information on 1 was obtained through an X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES)/extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) study and compared to XANES/EXAFS data for 2 x MeOH. The XANES data for 1 shows an intense pre-edge transition characteristic of a high-valent metal-oxo species, and a best fit of the EXAFS data gives a short Mn-O bond distance of 1.56 A, confirming the structure of the metal-oxo unit in 1. Detailed spectroelectrochemical studies of 1 and 2 were performed revealing multiple reversible redox processes for both complexes, including a relatively low potential for the Mn(V) --> Mn(IV) process in 1 (near 0.0 V vs saturated calomel reference electrode). Chemical reduction of 1 results in the formation of a Mn(III)Mn(IV)(mu-O) dimer as characterized by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy.

High-Frequency and -Field EPR Investigation of a Manganese(III) N-Confused Porphyrin Complex, [Mn(NCTPP)(py)2

We report the first high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) study of a Mn(III) N-confused porphyrin (NCP) complex (NCP is also known as inverted porphyrin or 2-aza-21-carbaporphyrin). We have found a striking variation in the electronic properties of the S = 2 Mn(III) ion coordinated by NCP compared to other Mn(III) porphyrinoid complexes. Thus, inversion of a single pyrrole ring greatly changes the equatorial ligand field exerted and leads to large magnitudes of both the axial and rhombic zero-field splitting [respectively, D = -3.084(3) cm(-1), E = -0.608(3) cm(-1)], which are unprecedented in other Mn(III) porphyrinoids.

Synthesis, Crystal Structure, and High-Precision High-Frequency and -Field Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Investigation of a Manganese(III) Complex: [Mn(dbm)2(py)2](ClO4)

The complex [Mn(dbm)(2)(py)(2)](ClO(4)) (dbm = anion of 1,3-diphenyl-1,3-propanedione (dibenzoylmethane), py = pyridine) was synthesized and characterized by X-ray crystallography. It has tetragonally distorted geometry with the axial positions occupied by the py ligands and the equatorial positions by the dbm ligands. This mononuclear complex of high-spin Mn(III) (3d(4), S = 2) was studied by high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) both as a solid powder and in frozen dichloromethane solution. Very high quality HFEPR spectra were recorded over a wide range of frequencies. The complete dataset of resonant magnetic fields versus transition energies was analyzed using automated fitting software. This analysis yielded the following spin Hamiltonian parameters (energies in cm(-1)): D = -4.504(2), E = -0.425(1), B(4)(0) = -1.8(4) x 10(-4), B(4)(2) = 7(3) x 10(-4), B(4)(4) = 48(4) x 10(-4), g(x) = 1.993(1), g(y) = 1.994(1), and g(z) = 1.983(1), where the B(4)(n) values represent fourth-order zero-field splitting terms that are generally very difficult to extract, even from single-crystal measurements. The results here demonstrate the applicability of HFEPR at high-precision measurements, even for powder samples. The zero-field splitting parameters determined here for [Mn(dbm)(2)(py)(2)](+) are placed into the context of those determined for other mononuclear complexes of Mn(III).

Definitive spectroscopic determination of zero-field splitting in high-spin cobalt(II).

A high-spin Co(II) complex (3d(7), S = 3/2), Co(PPh(3))(2)Cl(2) (Ph = phenyl), has been investigated in the solid state by both high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) and by variable-temperature, variable-field magnetic circular dichroism (VTVH-MCD). In HFEPR spectroscopy, the combination of variable sub-THz frequencies generated by backward wave oscillators (150-700 GHz, corresponding to energy 5-23 cm(-1)) and high magnetic fields (0-25 T) constitutes a novel experimental technique allowing accurate determination of a complete set of spin Hamiltonian parameters for this complex: D = -14.76(2) cm(-1), E = 1.141(8) cm(-1), g(x) = 2.166(4), g(y) = 2.170(4), g(z) = 2.240(5). Independent VTVH-MCD studies on multiple absorption bands of the complex yield D = -14(3) cm(-1), E = 0.96(20) cm(-1) (absolute value of E/D = 0.08(2)), g(x) = 2.15(5), g(y) = 2.16(4), and g(z) = 2.17(3). This very good agreement between HFEPR and MCD indicates that there is no inherent discrepancy between these two quite different experimental techniques. Thus, depending on the nature of the sample, either can be reliably used to determine zero-field splitting parameters in high-spin Co(II), with the HFEPR being more accurate but VTVH-MCD being more sensitive.

High-frequency and -field EPR spectroscopy of tris(2,4-pentanedionato)manganese(III): investigation of solid-state versus solution Jahn-Teller effects.

High-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) spectroscopy of a classical coordination complex, Mn(acac)(3) (Hacac = 2,4-pentanedione), has been performed on both solid powder and frozen solution (in CH(2)Cl(2)/toluene, 3:2 v/v) samples. Parallel mode detection X-band EPR spectra exhibiting resolved (55)Mn hyperfine coupling were additionally obtained for frozen solutions. Magnetic susceptibility and field-dependent magnetization measurements were also made on powder samples. Analysis of the entire EPR data set for the frozen solution allowed extraction of the relevant spin Hamiltonian parameters: D = -4.52(2); |E| = 0.25(2) cm(-1); g(iso) = 1.99(1). The somewhat lower quality solid-state HFEPR data and the magnetic measurements confirmed these parameters. These parameters are compared to those for other complexes of Mn(III) and to previous studies on Mn(acac)(3) using X-ray crystallography, solution electronic absorption spectroscopy, and powder magnetic susceptibility. Crystal structures have been reported for Mn(acac)(3) and show tetragonal distortion, as expected for this Jahn-Teller ion (Mn(3+), 3d(4)). However, in one case, the molecule exhibits axial compression and, in another, axial elongation. The current HFEPR studies clearly show the negative sign of D, which corresponds to an axial (tetragonal) elongation in frozen solution. The correspondence among solution and solid-state HFEPR data, solid-state magnetic measurements, and an HFEPR study by others on a related complex indicates that the form of Mn(acac)(3) studied here exhibits axial elongation in all cases. Such tetragonal elongation has been found for Mn(3+) and Cr(2+) complexes with homoleptic pseudooctahedral geometry as well as for Mn(3+) in square pyramidal geometry. This taken together with the results obtained here for Mn(acac)(3) in frozen solution indicates that axial elongation could be considered the "natural" form of Jahn-Teller distortion for octahedral high-spin 3d(4) ions. The previous electronic absorption data together with current HFEPR and magnetic data allow estimation of ligand-field parameters for Mn(acac)(3).

High frequency and field EPR spectroscopy of Mn(III) complexes in frozen solutions

We have performed high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) experiments on two complexes of high-spin Mn(III) (3d 4, S=2): mesotetrasulfonato-porphyrinatomanganese(III) (Mn(TSP)) and [( R, R)-(−)- N, N ′-bis(3,5-di- tert-butylsalicylidene)-1,2-cyclohexanediaminomanganese(III)] (Mn(salen)). The main aim of this work was to qualitatively and quantitatively characterize the conditions suitable for HFEPR of high-spin transition metal complexes in frozen solutions, and compare them with experiments performed on solid samples. Mn(TSP) is a porphyrin complex soluble in water, in contrast to most metalloporphyrins. Mn(salen), often referred to as Jacobsen’s catalyst, is a complex widely used in organic synthesis for alkene epoxidation, and is soluble in organic solvents. High-quality HFEPR signals were observed for solid state Mn(TSP), as has been previously shown for many Mn(III) complexes. The present study is, however, the first to report high-quality HFEPR spectra of a Mn(III) complex in frozen aqueous solution. Analysis of the data yielded the following spin Hamiltonian parameters: S=2; D=−3.16±0.02 cm −1 , E=0, and isotropic g=2.00(2). No X-band EPR signals were observed for Mn(TSP), which is a consequence of this being a rigorously axial spin system. Mn(salen), in contrast, did not give good quality HFEPR spectra in the solid state, but high-quality HFEPR spectra were recorded in frozen organic solutions. Analysis of the data yielded the following spin Hamiltonian parameters: S=2; D=−2.47±0.02 cm −1 , |E|=0.17±0.01 cm −1 , and isotropic g=2.00(2). These values differ from those reported using X-band parallel mode EPR [J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123 (2001) 5710], as discussed in the text. Therefore, a comparison between HFEPR and parallel-mode X-band spectroscopy is made. Finally, the concentration sensitivity aspect of HFEPR spectroscopy is also discussed.

Mixed-valence tetranuclear manganese single-molecule magnets.

The preparations, X-ray structures, and detailed physical characterizations are presented for two new mixed-valence tetranuclear manganese complexes that function as single-molecule magnets (SMM's): [Mn4(hmp)6Br2(H2O)2]Br2-4H2O (2) and [Mn4(6-me-hmp)6Cl4]-4H2O (3), where hmp(-) is the anion of 2-hydroxymethylpyridine and 6-me-hmp(-) is the anion of 6-methyl-2-hydroxymethylpyridine. Complex 2-4H2O crystallizes in the space group P2(1)/c, with cell dimensions at -160 degrees C of a = 10.907(0) A, b = 15.788(0) A, c = 13.941(0) A, beta = 101.21(0) degrees, and Z = 2. The cation lies on an inversion center and consists of a planar Mn4 rhombus that is mixed-valence, Mn2(III)Mn2(II). The hmp(-) ligands function as bidentate ligands and as the only bridging ligands in 2-4H2O. Complex 3-4H2O crystallizes in the monoclinic space group C2/c, with cell dimensions at -160 degrees C of a = 17.0852(4) A, b = 20.8781(5) A, c = 14.835(3) A, beta = 90.5485(8) degrees, and Z = 4. This neutral complex also has a mixed-valence Mn2(III)Mn2(II) composition and is best described as having four manganese ions arranged in a bent chain. A mu2-oxygen atom of the 6-me-hmp(-) anion bridges between the manganese ions; the Cl(-) ligands are terminal. Variable-field magnetization and high-frequency and -field EPR (HFEPR) data indicate that complex 2-4H2O has a S = 9 ground state whereas complex 3.4H(2)O has S = 0 ground state. Fine structure patterns are seen in the HFEPR spectra, and in the case of 2.4H(2)O it was possible to simulate the fine structure assuming S = 9 with the parameters g = 1.999, axial zero-field splitting of D/k(B) = -0.498 K, quartic longitudinal zero-field splitting of B4(omicron)/k(B) = 1.72 x 10(-5) K, and rhombic zero-field splitting of E/k(B) = 0.124 K. Complex 2-4H2O exhibits a frequency-dependent out-of-phase AC magnetic susceptibility signal, clearly indicating that this complex functions as a SMM. The AC susceptibility data for complex 2-4H2O were measured in the 0.05-4.0 K range and when fit to the Arrhenius law, gave an activation energy of DeltaE = 15.8 K for the reversal of magnetization. This DeltaE value is to be compared to the potential-energy barrier height of U/k(B) = absolute value DSz(2) = 40.3 K calculated for 2-4H2O.