Healthy Coral Research Articles

Research progress on coral reef growth factors and their ecosystem restoration

Healthy coral reef ecosystems have various functions such as reef-building, reef protection, reef stabilization, wave protection, shore protection, and the prevention of land erosion. Additionally, coral reef ecosystems are characterized by high biodiversity, often dubbed the “rainforest” of the ocean, as one of the most crucial ecosystems on Earth. In recent decades, global coral reefs have been significantly affected or damaged to varying degrees by climate change and human activities, posing threats to marine ecology and reef safety. This paper outlines the factors influencing coral reef growth, including global warming, ocean acidification, eutrophication, suspended solids, and tourism activities. It also discusses the status of coral reefs and viable restoration methods. Finally, this paper proposes an updated strategy for coral reef conservation, offering fresh insights into coral reef restoration efforts.

Impacts of “Reef Star” coral restoration on multiple metrics of habitat complexity

Coral reefs face threats from climate change and local pressures that lead to reductions in their physical structure, impacting biodiversity by limiting habitat availability. Despite many efforts to actively restore damaged reefs, few projects provide thorough evaluations of their success. This study measured the success of the “Reef Star” method at the Mars Coral Reef Restoration Project in Indonesia in reestablishing the physical structure of reef habitats that were destroyed by blast fishing. We used photogrammetry surveys to measure the physical habitat structure of 17 large sites (1000 m2 each), calculating three complementary measures of small‐ and large‐scale habitat complexity across degraded, restored, and naturally healthy coral reefs. We demonstrate that the restoration efforts have successfully restored small‐scale habitat complexity, as described by surface complexity metrics (3.22 ± 0.27 on restored reefs; 2.85 ± 0.26 on healthy reefs) and fractal dimension (2.27 ± 0.02 on restored reefs; 2.24 ± 0.02 on healthy reefs). This demonstrates the capacity for restored reefs to recover important ecosystem functions that are lost in degradation. However, while restoration has delivered some increases in large‐scale habitat complexity compared to degraded reefs, restored reefs still exhibit lower values of maximum vertical relief than healthy reefs, due to a lack of large physical structures. This lack of available large‐scale habitat might impact fish populations, meaning that restored reefs with limited large‐scale complexity may only support a restricted range of ecosystem functions. Effective reef restoration strategies must use a mixture of different methods that target the recovery of structural complexity at multiple scales.

Bleached Coral Supports High Diversity and Heterogeneity of Bacterial Communities: Following the Rule of the ‘Anna Karenina Principle’

Coral-associated bacteria are sensitive to the health status of coral and proven biomarker(s) of the coral bleaching. However, whether coral specificity or health status play a key role when coral-associated bacteria responding to coral bleaching is not known. Therefore, the bacterial communities of five species of healthy and bleached corals, Acropora millepora, Favites abdita, Galaxea fascicularis, Dipsastraea speciosa and Pocillopora damicornis, were collected along the coast of Sanya, South China Sea and targeted for associated bacterial studies. The relative abundance of the dominant class Gammaproteobacteria tended to be higher in healthy corals, while Alphaproteobacteria were more abundant in bleached corals. Dominant genus Achromobacter demonstrated higher relative abundance in healthy corals (0.675) than in bleached corals (0.151). Most of the bleached corals had high α diversity, β dispersion, heterogeneity and complexity of the co-occurrence network of bacterial communities, which support the ‘Anna Karenina Principle (AKP)’ of diverse in threatened objects and conserved in healthy ones. The bacterial communities in the bleached corals were mostly involved in the selection process, and communities in the healthy corals were involved in the undominated process, which is obtained based on the null model test of β nearest-taxon-index (βNTI) and Bray–Curtis-based Raup–Crick (RCBray). This evidence further confirmed the AKP and revealed that the bacterial communities in the bleached corals were driven by deterministic factors. These findings provide valuable insights into the connection between bacterial and coral status, and the application of the AKP in the changing patterns of bacterial communities during coral bleaching.

Habitat quality effects on the abundance of a coral-dwelling fish across spatial scales.

Microhabitat associated fishes are expected to be negatively affected by coral reef degradation, given that many species are coral dwellers. However, the factors underlying this negative impact and the spatial scale(s) at which it occurs are poorly understood. We explored how habitat quality metrics and host preferences influence fish abundance across multiple spatial scales, using the functionally important cleaner fish Elacatinus evelynae as a study species. We surveyed fish at 10 sites in Curaçao that varied in coral cover and health. At the microhabitat scale, we found that E. evelynae group size increases on large, healthy corals and on some coral host species, namely Montastraea cavernosa. We also found that, although E. evelynae can occupy at least 10 coral host species, it selectively inhabits just three corals: M. cavernosa, Colpophyllia natans, and Diploria labrynthiformis. Scaling up to explore goby abundance along 30-m transects, we did not find a clear relationship between live coral cover and goby abundance. However, goby abundance was substantially higher at one location with elevated coral cover and a high relative abundance of E. evelynae host species. Collectively, these results confirm that E. evelynae abundance is impacted by reef health. They also indicate that the species' long-term persistence may depend on both the maintenance of healthy coral hosts and the gobies' plasticity in host preferences on changing reefscapes. Cryptobenthic fishes such as E. evelynae play a vital role in the ecosystem and understanding drivers of their abundance is important as reefs face increased degradation.

Novel metagenomics analysis of stony coral tissue loss disease.

Stony coral tissue loss disease (SCTLD) has devastated coral reefs off the coast of Florida and continues to spread throughout the Caribbean. Although a number of bacterial taxa have consistently been associated with SCTLD, no pathogen has been definitively implicated in the etiology of SCTLD. Previous studies have predominantly focused on the prokaryotic community through 16S rRNA sequencing of healthy and affected tissues. Here, we provide a different analytical approach by applying a bioinformatics pipeline to publicly available metagenomic sequencing samples of SCTLD lesions and healthy tissues from 4 stony coral species. To compensate for the lack of coral reference genomes, we used data from apparently healthy coral samples to approximate a host genome and healthy microbiome reference. These reads were then used as a reference to which we matched and removed reads from diseased lesion tissue samples, and the remaining reads associated only with disease lesions were taxonomically classified at the DNA and protein levels. For DNA classifications, we used a pathogen identification protocol originally designed to identify pathogens in human tissue samples, and for protein classifications, we used a fast protein sequence aligner. To assess the utility of our pipeline, a species-level analysis of a candidate genus, Vibrio, was used to demonstrate the pipeline's effectiveness. Our approach revealed both complementary and unique coral microbiome members compared with a prior metagenome analysis of the same dataset.

Priority sites for coral aquaculture in Kume Island based on numerical simulation

Global and local stresses such as increased water temperature and terrestrial sediment runoff significantly affect coral reef ecosystems. Over the past three decades, the increase in the intensity and frequency of coral bleaching has been a significant problem in tropical and subtropical coastal seas, and maintaining healthy coral reef ecosystems has long been a challenge. Coral cover in Shimajiri Bay on Kume Island, located in the Nansei Islands (Okinawa Prefecture, southern Japan), has declined due to exposure to high water temperatures, an outbreak of coral predators, and sediment (red soil) inflow from the land. From such a background, coral aquaculture has been implemented at a few stations in the bay. Therefore, it is essential to conduct aquaculture in suitable locations for coral growth and survival. This study aimed to select suitable locations for coral culture with high spatial resolution in an enclosed bay that was greatly affected by red soil runoff, mainly from a sugarcane field. A freshwater and red soil runoff model for the watershed was merged with a coastal hydrodynamic, red soil dispersal, and accumulation model at a spatial resolution of 75 m for Shimajiri Bay. The simulation results were validated using in situ continuous and routine observations. Simulations were conducted over ten years. Locations not subjected to high water temperature in the bay or river loading were selected based on topography, simulated water temperature, salinity, and red soil content of sea sediment. This coupled model enables us to evaluate the growth and survival conditions of cultured corals with high spatiotemporal resolution and quantitatively consider the reduction target of red soil runoff to realize robust coral growth and survival.

Bioecological Comparison of Angelfish (Pomacanthus sp.): Diversity of Habitat, Sex Ratio, Growth and Production Status in Coral Triangle Waters

Angelfish (Pomacanthus sp.) is an ornamental fish that inhabits lush coral reefs. Despite requiring a healthy coral environment to grow and develop, this fish species is often hunted for its high price in the international market. This research aimed to determine the bio-ecology of angelfish, including its habitat, activity, size, structure, growth, and sex ratio, as well as to provide insights into its production status in the last nine years in South Sulawesi, especially in the waters of Pangkajene dan Kepulauan (Pangkep). The angelfish population was observed in waters adjacent to coral reefs in the coastal area of Pangkep. For this research, we used locally caught samples and determined their age using Gulland plot analysis. This study shows that the presence of angelfish does not have a positive correlation with live coral cover. However, their existence is influenced by coral growth forms, such as branching, sub-massive, and massive coral fissures. The samples of the caught angelfish were young, and their gonads were undeveloped. The allometric relationship between the weight and length of angelfish is slow, with them reaching a maximum length of 41.7 cm at 13 years. Based on the results of the study, we found that angelfish with a length of 10.1cm to 15cm are still relatively young and their gonads are still not developed. This size is in great demand in the market. This research also shows a decline in angelfish production. Thus, it is necessary to control the amount of catch and the minimum size of the first catch or provide a catch quota system for each year. The findings of this research can serve as a reference for policymakers, fishermen, and aquascape experts who wish to protect the angelfish population in their natural habitat.

In situ hydrodynamic observations on three reef flats in the Nansha Islands, South China Sea

Waves and currents are responsible for sediment movement around and off coral reefs, affecting reef growth at both geological and modern timescales. Given the wide distribution and limited hydrodynamic information of reefs in the South China Sea, we carried out observations on tidal-cycle hydrodynamics in the Nansha Islands with tripod stationary instruments on the seafloor in order to fill the gap in our understanding of these processes. It was found that the magnitudes of near-bed orbital velocity were comparable with that of the mean tidal current, despite generally calm wave conditions. Waves dominated the combined wave-current skin-friction shear velocities acting on reef sediment, which were significantly higher than those generated by currents alone. Due to the large physical roughness of reef, drag coefficient and hydrodynamic roughness length estimated from logarithmic velocity profiles were two orders of magnitude higher than that in macro-tidal-estuary or inner shelf areas covered with siliceous muds or sands. The combined sinusoidal wave and asymmetric tidal current, along with the physical reef roughness, shaped velocity profile structures in the bottom boundary layer, which exhibited a logarithmic profile during the flood tide and a potential flow during the ebb. In absence of wave breaking, strong turbulence dissipation was observed across the rough reef, promoting strong mixing of water, which is crucial for delivering nutrients for coral growth. These findings imply the need to consider the unique characteristics of rough reef structure and combined effects of waves and currents to model the hydrodynamics in reef environment correctly. This understanding is critical for predicting energy and material transport in reef environments, which is essential for maintaining healthy coral ecosystems, and opens new paths for managing and preserving coral reefs in the face of environmental change.

Genomics of a novel ecological phase shift: the case of a ‘weedy’ Montipora coral in Ulithi, Micronesia

Local and global ecological stressors are leading to increased documentation of phase shifts in coral reefs from healthy stony corals to macrophytes. In more rare cases, phase shifts result in sponge, zoantharian or other dominant species. In Ulithi Atoll, Federated States of Micronesia, we have documented an unusual phase shift from reefs with a diverse stony coral assemblage to reefs dominated by a single species of stony coral: Montipora sp.—a coral-to-coral phase shift. This monospecific type of reef lowers fish diversity and biomass, impacting both ecological integrity, and livelihoods of reef-dependent human communities. In this study, we used a genomic approach to characterize such a reef. We assembled a de-novo reference genome and used RAD seq data with thousands of SNPs to determine if different reefs result from sexual or asexual reproduction, if weedy Montipora fragments are transported between islands by human activities, and if there is evidence of natural selection on specific genotypes, thus favoring spreading success. We found that sexual reproduction is predominant in the focal species, that there is no evidence of human-mediated spread, and that some genomic regions might be under selection. While such results eliminate a number of spreading hypotheses, more precise dispersal maps will be important to determine the tempo and mode of ‘invasion’ of Montipora in Ulithi Atoll. This study shows that selection and adaptation may be contributing to the success of a stony coral (e.g., Phase shift). While a stony coral may be successful in a disturbed environment, it does not necessarily provide the type of habitat that is conducive to high fish biomass and coral diversity. These results serve as a cautionary tale for restoration efforts that focus on single species coral resilience rather than ecosystem function.

Comparison of DenseNet-121 and MobileNet for Coral Reef Classification

Coral reefs are a type of marine organism that has beauty and benefits for other sea creatures’ ecosystems. However, despite its beauty and usefulness, coral reefs are vulnerable to damage such as coral bleaching, which can impact other coral reef ecosystems. This research aims to classify digital images of healthy, bleached, and dead coral reefs. This research method is DenseNet-121 and MobileNet is based on Convolutional Neural Networks. This research uses a dataset from 1582 coral reef image data with three main classes: 720 were bleached, 150 were dead, and 712 were healthy. The testing process is carried out using several forms of split datasets, namely 60:10:30, 50:10:40, and 70:10:20. The test results obtained with a data sharing percentage of 60:10:30 show that MobileNet architecture achieved 88.00% accuracy, and DenseNet-121 achieved 91.57% accuracy. Using a data split percentage of 50:10:40, MobileNet achieved 84.51% accuracy, and DenseNet- 121 achieved 90.52% accuracy. Meanwhile, with a data separation percentage of 70:10:20, MobileNet achieved 85.48% accuracy, and DenseNet-121 achieved 92.74% accuracy.

Deoxygenation following coral spawning and low-level thermal stress trigger mass coral mortality at Coral Bay, Ningaloo Reef

Oxygen depletion is well recognized for its role in the degradation of tropical coral reefs. Extreme acute hypoxic events that lead to localized mass mortality and the formation of ‘dead zones’ (a region where few or no organisms can survive due to a lack of oxygen) are particularly concerning as they can result in wide-ranging losses of biodiversity, ecosystem productivity and functioning, economic prosperity, and wellbeing. In March of 2022, the annual coral spawning event at Bills Bay (Coral Bay, Ningaloo Reef, Western Australia) coincided with elevated seawater temperature, calm weather conditions and a flood tide resulting in coral spawn becoming trapped in Bills Bay. Immediately after, there was a mass fish kill, which is believed to have been caused by local eutrophication resulting in severe oxygen depletion. The impact the deoxygenation and thermal stress event had on benthic communities has not yet been quantified; hence, the principal aim of this study is to document the extent of change that occurred in the benthic communities before and after the 2022 coral spawning event over a spatial gradient from the nearshore to mid-reef. Percent coral cover in the Bay decreased from 55.62 ± 2.26% in 2016–2018 and 70.44 ± 5.24% in 2021 to 1.16 ± 0.51% in 2022. Over the same period, the percent cover of turf algae increased from 27.40 ± 2.00% in 2016–2018 and 24.66 ± 6.67% in 2021 to 78.80 ± 3.06% in 2022, indicating a dramatic phase shift occurred at Bills Bay. The abundance of healthy coral colonies recorded on replicated belt transects at nine sites declined from 3452 healthy individuals in 2018 to 153 individuals in 2022 and coral generic richness decreased by 84.61%, dropping from 26 genera in 2018 to 4 genera in 2022. Previously dominant genera such as Acropora,Montipora and Echinopora, were extirpated from survey sites. Isolated colonies of massive Porites spp. and encrusting Cyphastrea sp. survived the event and understanding the mechanisms underpinning their greater survivorship is an important area of future research. Long-term monitoring is recommended to track the community recovery process and improve our understanding of the longer-term implications of this acute mortality event on the ecological, socio-economic and cultural values of Ningaloo Reef.

Intra-colony spatial variance of oxyregulation and hypoxic thresholds for key Acropora coral species.

Oxygen (O2) availability is essential for healthy coral reef functioning, yet how continued loss of dissolved O2 via ocean deoxygenation impacts performance of reef building corals remains unclear. Here, we examine how intra-colony spatial geometry of important Great Barrier Reef (GBR) coral species Acropora may influence variation in hypoxic thresholds for upregulation, to better understand capacity to tolerate future reductions in O2 availability. We first evaluate the application of more streamlined models used to parameterise Hypoxia Response Curve data, models that have been used historically to identify variable oxyregulatory capacity. Using closed-system respirometry to analyse O2 drawdown rate, we show that a two-parameter model returns similar outputs as previous 12th-order models for descriptive statistics such as the average oxyregulation capacity (Tpos) and the ambient O2 level at which the coral exerts maximum regulation effort (Pcmax), for diverse Acropora species. Following an experiment to evaluate whether stress induced by coral fragmentation for respirometry affected O2 drawdown rate, we subsequently identify differences in hypoxic response for the interior and exterior colony locations for the species Acropora abrotanoides, Acropora cf. microphthalma and Acropora elseyi. Average regulation capacity across species was greater (0.78-1.03 ± SE 0.08) at the colony interior compared with exterior (0.60-0.85 ± SE 0.08). Moreover, Pcmax occurred at relatively low pO2 of <30% (±1.24; SE) air saturation for all species, across the colony. When compared against ambient O2 availability, these factors corresponded to differences in mean intra-colony oxyregulation, suggesting that lower variation in dissolved O2 corresponds with higher capacity for oxyregulation. Collectively, our data show that intra-colony spatial variation affects coral oxyregulation hypoxic thresholds, potentially driving differences in Acropora oxyregulatory capacity.

Coral restoration can drive rapid reef carbonate budget recovery

Restoration is increasingly seen as a necessary tool to reverse ecological decline across terrestrial and marine ecosystems.1,2 Considering the unprecedented loss of coral cover and associated reef ecosystem services, active coral restoration is gaining traction in local management strategies and has recently seen major increases in scale. However, the extent to which coral restoration may restore key reef functions is poorly understood.3,4 Carbonate budgets, defined as the balance between calcium carbonate production and erosion, influence a reef's ability to provide important geo-ecological functions including structural complexity, reef framework production, and vertical accretion.5 Here we present the first assessment of reef carbonate budget trajectories at restoration sites. The study was conducted at one of the world's largest coral restoration programs, which transplants healthy coral fragments onto hexagonal metal frames to consolidate degraded rubble fields.6 Within 4 years, fast coral growth supports a rapid recovery of coral cover (from 17%± 2% to 56%± 4%), substrate rugosity (from 1.3± 0.1 to 1.7± 0.1) and carbonate production (from 7.2± 1.6 to 20.7± 2.2kg m-2 yr-1). Four years after coral transplantation, net carbonate budgets have tripled and are indistinguishable from healthy control sites (19.1± 3.1 and 18.7± 2.2kg m-2 yr-1, respectively). However, taxa-level contributions to carbonate production differ between restored and healthy reefs due to the preferential use of branching corals for transplantation. While longer observation times are necessary to observe any self-organization ability of restored reefs (natural recruitment, resilience to thermal stress), we demonstrate the potential of large-scale, well-managed coral restoration projects to recover important ecosystem functions within only 4 years.

Soundscape enrichment increases larval settlement rates for the brooding coral Porites astreoides.

Coral reefs, hubs of global biodiversity, are among the world's most imperilled habitats. Healthy coral reefs are characterized by distinctive soundscapes; these environments are rich with sounds produced by fishes and marine invertebrates. Emerging evidence suggests these sounds can be used as orientation and settlement cues for larvae of reef animals. On degraded reefs, these cues may be reduced or absent, impeding the success of larval settlement, which is an essential process for the maintenance and replenishment of reef populations. Here, in a field-based study, we evaluated the effects of enriching the soundscape of a degraded coral reef to increase coral settlement rates. Porites astreoides larvae were exposed to reef sounds using a custom solar-powered acoustic playback system. Porites astreoides settled at significantly higher rates at the acoustically enriched sites, averaging 1.7 times (up to maximum of seven times) more settlement compared with control reef sites without acoustic enrichment. Settlement rates decreased with distance from the speaker but remained higher than control levels at least 30 m from the sound source. These results reveal that acoustic enrichment can facilitate coral larval settlement at reasonable distances, offering a promising new method for scientists, managers and restoration practitioners to rebuild coral reefs.

SoundGarden: Applying healthy soundscapes to support coral reef restoration

Coral reefs are a hub of ocean biodiversity supporting a range of socioeconomic and ecosystem services. Yet reefs and these important services are imperiled due to climate change and related stressors. Healthy coral reefs can be characterized by distinctive soundscapes, and there is increasing realization that acoustic cues are vital ecosystem components. Here we present a series of experiments examining if replaying healthy soundscapes can increase the settlement of coral larvae, a fundamental ecological process. Work was conducted in the U.S. Virgin Islands, leveraging a decade of soundscape studies on those reefs, and used a novel solar-powered acoustic playback system calibrated in sound pressure and particle motion. We studied larvae from three coral species, brooding Porites astreoides and Favia fragum, and broadcast-spawning Diploria labyrinthiformis. Larvae on degraded reefs enriched with healthy reef sounds settled at significantly higher rates compared to control sites that were not acoustically enriched. Acoustic enrichment settlement rates were influenced by received level, ecosystem properties and species biology reflecting the need for holistically evaluating the reef restoration process. Overall, this work outlines a new, potentially scalable means of supporting healthy reef habitat, and enhancing coral settlement on imperiled reefs undergoing restoration.

Community-Based Monitoring for Rapid Assessment of Nearshore Coral Reefs Amid Disturbances in Teahupo’o, Tahiti

Nearshore coral reefs at Teahupo’o, Tahiti, are currently threatened by destruction from proposed plans to build a new judging tower in the reef lagoon for the 2024 Olympic surfing event. Local community members were trained to utilize 3D photogrammetry techniques to create high-resolution habitat maps of three sites that will be impacted by dredging and tower construction. The resulting orthomosaics were analyzed to quantify and characterize the coral community structure at each study site. Species diversity, coral colony count, coral colony size, and percent cover of live coral and living benthos were extracted from all survey plots. The resulting data show these sites support healthy and diverse coral communities that contribute to the ecological function of the larger reef system at Teahupo’o. The Hawai’i State Division of Aquatic Resources Penalty Matrix was used to estimate the USD value of the live corals and algae identified among the study sites and the total area that will be impacted by the planned development project. This study highlights the utility of 3D photogrammetry for effective citizen science as well as the large economic and ecological impacts that may occur if this proposed construction occurs.

Disease prevalence and bacterial isolates associated with Acropora palmata in the Colombian Caribbean

The decline in Acropora palmata populations in Colombian reefs has been mainly attributed to diseases outbreaks. The population size structure and prevalence of white pox and white band disease were evaluated in six localities of the Colombian Caribbean. Here, we aimed to isolate enteric bacteria and Vibrios from healthy and diseased coral mucus to relate its presence to the health status of Acropora palmata. The isolated bacteria were identified using molecular analyses with the 16S rRNA gene. Larger colonies had the highest percentage of the prevalence of both diseases. The strains that were identified as Vibrio sp. and Bacillus sp. were common in the healthy and diseased mucus of the holobiont. The Exiguobacterium sp. and Cobetia sp. strains isolated from diseased mucus may indicate maintenance and resilience mechanisms in the coral. Enterococcus sp. and other bacteria of the Enterobacteriaceae family were isolated from some localities, suggesting that probably contamination due to poor treatment of domestic wastewater and contributions from river discharges can affect coral health. The spatial heterogeneity of Colombian coral reefs exhibited variability in the bacteria, wherein environmental alterations can trigger signs of disease.

Genome sequence of Alteromonas macleodii strain OCN004 isolated from the extracellular mucus of an apparently healthy rice coral (Montipora capitata).

Alteromonas macleodii strain OCN004, a marine gammaproteobacterium in the Alteromonadaceae family, has primarily been studied as a non-pathogenic negative control bacterium during laboratory infection trials to test the virulence of bacterial coral pathogens. The draft genome sequence of A. macleodii strain OCN004 is presented here.

Coral thermal stress and bleaching enrich and restructure reef microbial communities via altered organic matter exudation

Coral bleaching is a well-documented and increasingly widespread phenomenon in reefs across the globe, yet there has been relatively little research on the implications for reef water column microbiology and biogeochemistry. A mesocosm heating experiment and bottle incubation compared how unbleached and bleached corals alter dissolved organic matter (DOM) exudation in response to thermal stress and subsequent effects on microbial growth and community structure in the water column. Thermal stress of healthy corals tripled DOM flux relative to ambient corals. DOM exudates from stressed corals (heated and/or previously bleached) were compositionally distinct from healthy corals and significantly increased growth of bacterioplankton, enriching copiotrophs and putative pathogens. Together these results demonstrate how the impacts of both short-term thermal stress and long-term bleaching may extend into the water column, with altered coral DOM exudation driving microbial feedbacks that influence how coral reefs respond to and recover from mass bleaching events.

Hawkfish protecting healthy coral colonies in the Gulf of California during a strong El Niño event

Hawkfish protecting healthy coral colonies in the Gulf of California during a strong El Niño event