Healthcare Structures Research Articles

Pandemic COVID-19 as a challenge for telemedicine in the Czech Republic.

The COVID-19 Pandemic contributed to accelerating the process of using information and communication technologies and digital technologies in healthcare management and delivery within healthcare systems. At that time, the Czech healthcare system faced the same problems as other European systems and struggled with a temporary limitation of direct provision of healthcare services. It was solved by switching to telemedicine. The Czech healthcare system used telemedicine to a minimal extent until then. Despite adopting the law on healthcare digitisation, it is still one of the countries with a lower level of digitisation of healthcare processes. The article presents the results of an exploratory expert investigation focused on the implementation and development of telemedicine in the Czech Republic. The conducted research aimed to identify problems related to the implementation of telemedicine in practice, place them in the broader framework of the healthcare system and structure them, propose possible solutions, and identify the future challenges of telemedicine in the Czech Republic. We based our study on the results of a three-phase QUAL-QUAN-QUAL research. Data collection in the first phase took the form of individual semi-structured interviews with patients (25) with practical experience in the field of telemedicine, followed by the second quantitative phase of the questionnaire survey with patients (650). The third qualitative phase included semi-structured interviews with experts (17) with practical experience in telemedicine. The introduction and expansion of telemedicine require several fundamental changes. These include adjustments to the legislative environment and changes to the technological infrastructure, organisation of care and work. Several barriers have been identified at the healthcare system level, healthcare providers, healthcare professionals and patients.

Innovative Regional Services and Heterogeneous Communication Channels: Results from the Nationwide German egePan Project for Pandemic Management

Background: In the COVID-19 pandemic, novel regional services and communication channels emerged across all sectors of the German healthcare system. To contribute to pandemic preparedness, this study aims to describe newly established services in response to the COVID-19 pandemic from a stakeholder perspective and to examine the interprofessional communication channels, applying a nationwide cross-sectional approach. Methods: A nationwide sample of German healthcare stakeholders comprising general practitioners, associations of statutory health insurance physicians, hospital medical directors, local health departments, rescue coordination centres, medical directors of emergency services, outpatient nursing services, nursing homes, community care access centres, and hospital nursing managers was surveyed. A web-based questionnaire asked for their level of participation in newly implemented regional COVID-19 services and communication channels. Stakeholders’ level of recommendation was measured using the Net Promotor Score (NPS), a metric that assesses their satisfaction towards the services surveyed. Results: In total, 1312 healthcare stakeholders participated in the survey. Diagnostic centres (23.0–90.9%), COVID-19 wards in hospitals (40.5–92.1%), emergency medical vehicles designated solely for COVID-19 patients (16.5–68.4%), and crisis intervention teams (11.6–30.6%) exhibited the highest rates of engagement. The services receiving the highest recommendation for future use were COVID-19 focus practices (NPS: 33.4–43.7), COVID-19 wards in hospitals (NPS: 47.6–84.4), transportation of COVID-19 patients exclusively by predefined professional groups (NPS: 12.5–36.4), and newly implemented digitally supported nursing services (NPS: 58.3–100.0). Telephones emerged as the most frequently used communication channel (58.0–96.7%), while email was the primary digital channel (23.7–81.5%). Conclusions: During the COVID-19 pandemic, Germany experienced significant variation in the implementation of pandemic-related services across healthcare sectors, with stakeholders prioritising services built on existing healthcare structures. Developing a proactive digital infrastructure to connect healthcare professionals from different sectors is crucial for better future pandemic management.

Developing a set of core items for assessing preparedness in Italy: a Delphi approach

Abstract Background Effective pandemic management relies on preparedness and several tools are available for evaluation. However, due to differences in regional healthcare organization and structures, these may not accurately evaluate Italy’s capacities. This study, part of a project funded by the Italian Ministry of Health, report on the development of an assessment tool capable of evaluating the preparedness to confront pandemics at the regional level based on the actions outlined by the Italian influenza pandemic plan. Methods A desk research was carried out for preparedness evaluation tools, consulting Public Health Agencies, and Google Scholar and Search. Tools evaluation items were extracted, associated with the Italian plan, and screened for relevance and data availability. Selected items were then subjected to a two-round Delphi procedure involving 18 stakeholders from academia, local health services, and national agencies. The agreement was assessed using a 10-point Likert scale, and defined as a mean score ≥8, and consensus as a score standard deviation (SD) ≤1.5. Items with mean score ≥ 8 and SD > 1.5 after the first round were sent to the second round. Results A total of 6 tools were included in the study, from which 303 evaluation items matched the actions of the plan. After the screening phase, 122 indicators were deemed relevant and potentially available and sent to the Delphi procedure. Eighteen (14.8%) items reached both agreement and consensus in the first round, while another fifteen (12.3%) after the second. The 33 items covered all the domains of the national plan, especially Research and Development (21.1%) and Clinical Governance (15.2%). Conclusions The development of a set of core items that are agile, relevant, and readily available was facilitated by the involvement of stakeholders from different sectors. Moreover, adherence to the Italian pandemic plan should ensure that these items are deeply integrated into the unique context of the Italian regions. Key messages • The Delphi process identified a narrow number of evaluation items with great consensus. • Consensus was searched involving stakeholders from central authorities, local units, and academia.

Primary health care models for refugees and the involvement of nurses: A systematic review

Abstract Background Primary health care is key to address the health and social needs of refugees. Nurses are often part of multidisciplinary teams in primary health care, but little is known about their roles and responsibilities in refugee health. Our systematic review aimed to synthesise the existing knowledge about models of care (MoC) for refugees in primary care settings and the involvement of nurses in these models. Methods We searched PubMed, CINAHL and Web of Science for literature published in English, Spanish, French and German. For grey literature, we additionally searched Google Search and Scholar, Microsoft Bing and DuckDuckGo. Eligible publications reported on MoC for refugees in a primary care setting and the involvement of nurses. We extracted and synthesised information about the structure of these models as well as the roles and responsibilities of nurses within these. Results 112 publications met our inclusion criteria. Our narrative synthesis focuses on 61 publications with in-depth insights into existing MoC and nurse involvement. We identified 45 MoC, mainly originating from high-income-countries and with almost a third from Australia. The majority of MoC set up a parallel health care structure that refugees could access for a limited period of time. In most MoC, the role of the nurse is described with a relatively high degree of autonomy and with clear areas of responsibility. Clinical and administrative tasks are only part of the nurse’s role, while educational and coordinating activities are often equally important. Conclusions Despite the significant number of refugees in European countries we identified only few reports on MoC specifically addressing their needs. While parallel care structures may be an appropriate approach for a short period of time, integration of refugees into the regular health system is key. Specially trained nurses are well placed to support refugees through a range of measures, including health education and case management. Key messages • Models of Care for refugees could help to navigate within a new healthcare system and ensure that no one is left behind. However, development of and research on such structures are still scarce. • Specially trained nurses are well placed to care for refugees and to support their integration into regular health systems through a range of measures, including health education and case management.

KardioNet Digital - a structured care model involving digital tools for intersectoral communication and a patient-focused strategy for treatment of heart failure

Abstract Introduction Inefficiencies and discontinuities in care at the interfaces within Germany's healthcare system, especially between acute and outpatient care, present significant challenges in managing patients with heart failure (HF). The management complexity of HF has increased with the advent of new digital tools, though patient acceptance of these tools remains contentious. The prevention of loss of diagnostic and therapeutic information for this complex disease is crucial for cross-sectoral communication (hospital - office-based cardiologist - general practitioner) and quality of care. Purpose Our goal was to examine the impact of digital app-supported coordination of HF management across different healthcare providers from hospital discharge to the ambulatory sector and to assess patients' acceptance of a structured care program. A patient-focused digital strategy, supported by a Heart Failure Nurse (HFN), aimed to facilitate structured follow-up and patient empowerment, focusing on patient-reported outcomes and experiences (refer to Table 1). Results Out of 401 patients screened during their hospital stay for HF, only 57 (14.9% male, 12.6% female) participated in the KardioNet Digital (KND) program. NYHA classifications were I (3.5%), II (49.1%), III (40.4%), and IV (7.1%); Diagnoses included CMP (26, 45.6%), CAD (19, 33.3%), valvular HF (8, 14.0%), and others (4, 7.0%). The mean age was 55.03 years, with a notable difference in participation based on age (≥70 years: 9.5% male, 33.3% female; <70 years: 90.5% male, 66.7% female). Age was a significant determinant of program participation. Patients who regularly used the app benefited from several features: A total of 35 alerts (17 patients) were triggered for reasons such as bodyweight increase (2kg or more) and device-induced alerts (i.e. false shock delivery, 3x slow-VT, Syncope), leading the HFN to contact the patients. This early intervention prevented rehospitalization due to decompensation of heart failure in 11 patients (64.7%) and addressed device-related alarms for organizing an emergency hospital visit by HFN. Despite substantial incentives, such as support from an HFN and expedited appointments with specialists for follow-up therapy, refusal rates were high (refer to Table 2). Conclusion A structured, digitally supported cross-sectoral care model for heart failure patients can potentially improve care coordination and outcomes. However, the success of such programs critically depends on patient willingness and the seamless integration into existing healthcare structures. Despite valuable incentives, we observed low acceptance of the program. Even among motivated participants (14.1%), there is a significant need for substantial support and education on digital literacy for the widespread implementation of digital tools in real-world settings for the treatment of heart failure.Workflow of structured digital supportReasons for Declining Participation

Physician-led healthcare structures for patients in out-of-hospital intensive care nursing: a cross-sectional survey by the German Society for Out-of-Hospital Ventilation

Patients in out-of-hospital intensive care are usually provided with a tracheal cannula and often additionally receive mechanical ventilation. Less frequently, they receive non-invasive ventilation. Their potential to be weaned from the ventilator and to have their tracheostomy tubes removed must be evaluated twice per year from January 1, 2025 on. If there is a potential for weaning from mechanical ventilation or removal of the tracheostomy tube, referral to a specialized facility is required. The study aimed at characterizing the specialized institutions which can evaluate the potential of patients to be weaned from the ventilator and to have their tracheostomy tubes removed, and which can perform these tasks as well. Under the auspices of the German Interdisciplinary Society for Out-of-Hospital Ventilation (DIGAB) and with support from the Working group early neurological-neurosurgical rehabilitation (ENNR) a crosssectional online survey took place. Of 18 participating institutions, 11 (61.1%) were certified by professional societies representing neurorehabilitation, respiratory medicine, anaesthesiology and intensive care or paraplegiology. Most leading physicians were specialists in neurology, followed by pulmonology, anaesthesiology and paediatrics. Many professions with a variety of qualifications worked in these institutions. According to n=10 (55.6%) of the participating instituions, regional treatment capacities for patients from out-of-hospital intensive care, who need hospital admission for weaning from mechanical ventilation or a tracheal cannula, were not sufficient. About one third of the institutions offered televisits. Patients in out-of-hospital intensive care need interdisciplinary care, interconnecting out- and inpatient care structures due to medical complexity and participation restrictions. While interdisciplinary teams and a wide spectrum of diagnostic and therapeutic methods were provided in the participating institutions, their structure differed considerably. Quality criteria should be established for centres evaluating the patients' potential to be weaned from the ventilator and to have their tracheostomy tubes removed and performing weaning from mechanical ventilation and tracheal cannulas. Further research is needed to specify those criteria, to quantify inpatient treatment capacities for patients from out-of-hospital intensive care to be weaned from mechanical ventilation or tracheal cannulas,to evaluate the feasibility of weaning from mechanical ventilation and tracheal cannulas in an out-of-hospital setting and to understand the role of telemedicine in the treatment of patients in out-of-hospital intensive care.

Factor Structure and Measurement Invariance of the Cultural Attitudes Toward Healthcare and Mental Illness Questionnaire Among Latino Sexual Minority Men

Mental health disparities among Latino sexual minority men (LSMM) are exacerbated by un(der)treated mental health needs. This study sought to establish the factor structure of the Cultural Attitudes Toward Healthcare and Mental Illness Questionnaire (CAHMIQ) and examine measurement invariance across nativity (born in vs. outside the continental U.S.). Participants included 290 LSMM in South Florida. Confirmatory factor analysis examined the factor structure of CAHMIQ and measurement invariance examined equivalence across LSMM born outside (51.4%) and inside (48.3%) the continental U.S. The second-order factor model showed an acceptable fit (CFI/RMSEA = .91/.03) and consisted of first-ordered factors representing manifest indicators of causes and supports for mental health. Measurement invariance results suggest that the CAHMIQ performs equivalently across nativity groups (∆χ2(18) = 16.941, p = .5272). The CAHMIQ may be used among both nativity groups to understand attitudes toward healthcare and mental illness and inform LSMMs’ engagement in mental health treatment.

Addressing Challenges in Antibiotic Access: Barriers, Implications and Strategies for Solution.

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) poses a significant threat to global public health, disproportionately affecting low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). While excessive antibiotic use is often discussed, the issue of access to antibiotics demands attention. This viewpoint explores the multidimensional nature of the issue of access to antibiotics. We have examined the issue through the lens of social, economic, healthcare structures, manufacturing and supply chain, policy and practices. Inter-relatedness of these issues has also been explored. The review further discusses potential solutions involving but not limited to increased awareness, improvement in healthcare infrastructure, models for sustained manufacturing and supply chains. Additionally, enhancing antimicrobial stewardship at hospital and community levels, empowering healthcare professionals, and emphasizing infection prevention are crucial. Global initiatives that aim to address access challenges, emphasizing collaboration and innovation are important to foster for a sustained response to the issue of antibiotic access.

Experiences and life circumstances of unintentionally pregnant women affected by intimate partner violence-stress factors, resources, healthcare structures and needs: a scoping review protocol.

Open Science Framework: https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZMVPE.

Required Capabilities for Employee-Driven Innovation Emerges in Healthcare Organizations; Comment on "Employee-Driven Innovation in Health Organizations: Insights From a Scoping Review"

Employee-driven innovation (EDI) is still under-researched in health policy and system research, particularly in low and middle-income countries. EDI is recognized as a lever to improve the commitment of health workers, promote quality of care, and contribute to creating value and transforming healthcare practices, services, structures, and processes. The mechanisms underlying the emergence of EDI processes and outcomes include core capabilities to cope with complexity, building spaces for learning, fostering sense-making and sense-giving, and collective problem-solving. The development of such capabilities depends on organizational and individual conditions. Organizational capabilities include complex leadership, trust management practices, task complexity, and the availability of slack resources. Individual capabilities comprise capabilities to cope with complexity, such as sense-making, autonomy, system thinking, and adaptive learning. The sustainability of EDI depends on local ownership and frontline employees' involvement during problem definition, innovation design, and implementation.

Conceptual Considerations for Understanding Resilience in Healthcare Students.

Increasing attention has been given to the concept resilience in the context of healthcare especially during and post the COVID pandemic. Much of the inquiry and evidence reported has focused on promoting or enhancing resilience in healthcare for improving the quality of care and reducing medical negligence. This discursive paper aims to highlight how resilience is conceptualised and identify any potential limitations or gaps in the context of healthcare students, acknowledging considerations for further development and research into this topic. This discursive discussion draws on relevant theoretical underpinnings from the fields of adjustment and coping psychology, and research and evidence from health sciences, for facilitating an understanding of resilience in supporting healthcare students to adapt into professional practice. Investigation of resilience in healthcare students is mainly identified at an individual level as personal traits or skills for working within complex healthcare systems and clinical environments. Less attention has been given to examining resilience at the organisation or systemic level. This is primarily because of limited frameworks for investigating resilience from a multidimensional perspective recognising a wider systemic level influenced by external factors including socioecological determinants, for example, available support services for healthcare students. The link between resilience and its function to mitigate against associated neuropsychological distress and subsequent pathopsychological disorders in healthcare student cohorts is recognised; however, greater understanding of resilience as a multidimensional construct is warranted. A multidimensional investigation of resilience is critical for the preparation and readiness of healthcare structures and organisations in facilitating the needs of healthcare students entering challenging and diverse healthcare working environments. No patient or public contribution.

Changes in practices concerning urethral stricture surgery: Analysis of French data for the period 2013–2022

IntroductionThe prevalence of urethral stricture is estimated at 0.9%. American, European and French recommendations have reduced the place of endoscopic treatments due to their poor outcomes, especially in the case of repeated procedures. Urethroplasty is the new reference treatment for urethral stricture. Our aim was to assess the evolution of national practices from 2013 to 2022. Material and methodsWe collected national CCAM coding data for all procedures involving urethral stricture surgery using the Scansanté internet platform produced by the Technical Agency for Information on Hospitalization, which prospectively collects all procedures coded according to CCAM coding from public, liberal and ESPIC healthcare structures. ResultsThe overall number of urethral surgical procedures has been steadily increasing over the past 10 years. Endoscopic procedures remain largely predominant in 2022, totaling 23,982, but have remained stable over the decade. Urethroplasties have been on the rise since 2019, reaching 1600 cases in 2022 compared with 1100 cases in 2020. Although urethrotomies currently outnumber urethroplasties by a factor of 10, this ratio has been consistently decreasing since 2016. The most significant contributor to the 10-year increase is urethroplasty by augmentation, particularly free flap techniques on the anterior urethra. Resection-anastomosis and urethrostomy techniques have remained stable. DiscussionIn 2022, endoscopic treatments remain by far the majority, but urethroplasties are on the increase. A significant number of patients can benefit from initial endoscopic treatment because short bulbar localization is the most common presentation, but long-term success rates are poor compared to urethroplasty, which boasts approximately 80% success rates. Urethroplasty should no longer be considered a last-resort surgery but rather a reference technique in treating urethral stricture.

Time Trends, Regional Variation and Associations of Low-Allergy Formula Prescribing in England.

Cow's milk allergy (CMA) overdiagnosis appears to be increasing and is associated with excessive low-allergy formula prescription. We evaluated recent trends and regional variation in low-allergy formula prescribing for CMA in England, and assessed potential risk factors for higher prescribing rates. Data on national and regional prescribing of low-allergy formulas were extracted from England's electronic prescription database using R. Region-level factors were evaluated for potential associations with regional low-allergy formula prescription rates using multivariate linear regression. Analysis of national prescribing trends covered 2007-2023, analysis of regional variation and region-level factors examined 2017-2019, prior to a re-organisation of the regional healthcare structure in England. Low-allergy formula prescribing increased from 6.1 to 23.3 L per birth nationally, between 2007 and 2023. Regional prescribing rate varied from 0.8 to 47.6 L per birth in 2017-2019. We found significant associations between regional low-allergy formula prescribing rate and regional prescribing rates for milk feed thickeners Gaviscon Infant and Carobel Instant (β = 0.10, p < 0.01), and for other anti-reflux medications used in young children (β = 0.89 p < 0.01). Inconsistent associations were seen with prescribing junior adrenaline auto-injectors and oral antibiotics. A model including these four variables accounted for 37% of regional variation in low-allergy formula prescribing rate. Region-level socio-economic deprivation, CMA guideline recommendations and paediatric allergy service provision were not associated with low-allergy formula prescribing. Low-allergy formula prescribing in England is increasing, varies significantly by region and is consistently associated with prescribing rates for milk feed thickeners and other anti-reflux medication for young children. Community prescribing behaviours may be important determinants of CMA overdiagnosis.

Provider perception of presentations with nonspecific back pain in the emergency department and primary care practices: a semi-structured interview study

BackgroundIncreasing numbers of patients treated in the emergency departments pose challenges to delivering timely and high-quality care. Particularly, the presentation of patients with low-urgency complaints consumes resources needed for patients with higher urgency. In this context, patients with non-specific back pain (NSBP) often present to emergency departments instead of primary care providers. While patient perspectives are well understood, this study aims to add a provider perspective on the diagnostic and therapeutic approach for NSBP in emergency and primary care settings.MethodsIn a qualitative content analysis, we interviewed seven Emergency Physicians (EP) and nine General Practitioners (GP) using a semi-structured interview to assess the diagnostic and therapeutic approach to patients with NSBP in emergency departments and primary care practices. A hypothetical case of NSBP was presented to the interviewees, followed by questions on their diagnostic and therapeutic approaches. Recruitment was stopped after reaching saturation of the qualitative content analysis. Reporting this work follows the consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ) checklist.ResultsEPs applied two different strategies for the workup of NSBP. A subset pursued a guideline-compliant diagnostic approach, ruling out critical conditions and managing pain without extensive diagnostics. Another group of EPs applied a more extensive approach, including extensive diagnostic resources and specialist consultations. GPs emphasized physical examinations and stepwise treatment, including scheduled follow-ups and a better knowledge of the patient history to guide diagnostics and therapy. Both groups attribute ED visits for NSBP to patient related and healthcare system related factors: lack of understanding of healthcare structures, convenience, demand for immediate diagnostics, and fear of serious conditions. Furthermore, both groups reported an ill-suited healthcare infrastructure with insufficiently available primary care services as a contributing factor.ConclusionsThe study highlights a need for improving guideline adherence in younger EPs and better patient education on the healthcare infrastructure. Furthermore, improving access and availability of primary care services could reduce ED visits of patients with NSBP.Trial registrationNo trial registration needed.

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Home Mechanical Ventilation in Germany: A Descriptive Observational Study

Introduction: Over the last decade, the number of patients receiving home mechanical ventilation (HMV) has increased significantly, which has led to a limited availability of specialist centres, not least due to the scarcity of healthcare professionals. This situation was exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. It is therefore assumed that the repurposing of resources has led to an aggravated change in the healthcare structure in HMV. Methods: This descriptive observational study analysed the Operation and Procedure Classification Codes for patients receiving HMV from 2008 to 2022. The data were provided by the Federal Statistical Office of Germany. Data were additionally analysed with respect to geographical distribution and ventilation status. Results: A total of 737,770 datasets were analysed (mean age in 2020: 66.5 years). There was a steady increase in HMV initiations (+6%) and controls (+9%) per year before the pandemic (2008–2019). Patient admissions during the pandemic revealed a 28% decrease, with the largest decrease in invasive ventilation (IV) follow-up visits (2019: 3,053; 2020: 2,199; −39%), while the number of IV initiations remained stable. There was a 19% decrease in the number of non-IV initiations in 2020 (16,919 vs. 14,227) and a 32% decrease in the number of follow-ups (45,812 vs. 34,813) in comparison with 2019. Conclusion: The pandemic has led to a significant decline of inpatient admissions for patients receiving HMV. This decline was most pronounced in the first year of the pandemic. Control visits in particular did not reach the pre-pandemic level. This is an indication of the ongoing change in the healthcare landscape as a result of the pandemic.

Improving health behaviours and attitudes around podoconiosis in Northern Western Ethiopia: Implementation and intervention effectiveness.

Assessing how interventions are implemented is essential to understanding why interventions may or may not achieve their intended outcomes. There is little evidence about how interventions against Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) are being implemented. Guided by the Context and Implementation of Complex Intervention (CICI) framework, we evaluated an ongoing intervention against the NTD podoconiosis to examine the implementation process and its effectiveness in terms of improving shoe wearing practices, increasing knowledge and reducing stigmatizing attitudes towards podoconiosis in rural Ethiopia. We employed an exploratory mixed methods approach, qualitative followed by quantitative, between April and July 2022 to assess implementation agents, theory, strategy, process and outcomes of the intervention. We conducted document analysis, observations, focus group discussions, in-depth interviews and key informant interviews for the qualitative phase. We administered a survey to 369 rural residents, of whom 42 were affected by podoconiosis. The implementers utilized government healthcare centers in a bid to mainstream podoconiosis services within local healthcare structures. The implementers provided training for health professionals and the public and distributed supplies to patients over a three-month period. The intervention reached 62% of patients, but female patients were less likely to participate than male patients. Only 18% of community members had participated in health education campaigns linked to the intervention. Involvement in the intervention resulted in improved shoe wearing practice and holding fewer stigmatizing attitudes. However, internalized stigma among patients was still rife; and the plan to utilize community assets to extend the intervention activities was not effective. Implementers must monitor the fidelity and progression of programs on a constant basis to make corrections. They also need to expand health education, provide psychosocial support and design economic empowerment programs for patients to reduce stigma. They must also collaborate with policy makers and international partners to sustain program activities at intervention delivery points.

Shifting from Theoretical Best Evidence to Practical Best Evidence: an Approach to Overcome Structural Conservatism of Evidence-Based Medicine and Health Policy.

There is disparity in the healthcare sector between the extent of innovation in medical products (e. g., drugs) and healthcare structures. The reason is not a lack of ideas, concepts, or (quasi-) experimental studies on structural innovations. Instead, we argue that the slow implementation of structural innovations has created this disparity partly because evidence-based medicine (EBM) instruments are well suited to evaluate product innovations but less suited to evaluate structural innovations. This article argues that the unintentional interplay between EBM, which has changed significantly over time to become primarily theoretical, on the one hand, and caution and inertia in health policy, on the other, has resulted in structural conservatism. Structural conservatism is present when healthcare structures persistently and essentially resist innovation. We interpret this phenomenon as an unintended consequence of deliberate EBM action. Therefore, we propose a new assessment framework to respond to structural innovations in healthcare, centered on the differentiation between the theoretical best (possible) evidence, the practical best (possible) evidence, and the best available evidence.

Development and pilot implementation of a novel protocol to assess capacity and readiness of health systems to adopt HPV detection-based cervical cancer screening in Europe

BackgroundCervical cancer remains a significant public health concern in Europe. Effective introduction and scaling up of human papillomavirus (HPV) detection-based cervical cancer screening (CCS) requires a systematic assessment of health systems capacity. However, there is no validated capacity assessment methodology for CCS programmes, especially in European contexts. Addressing this gap, our study introduces an innovative and adaptable protocol for evaluating the capacity of CCS programmes across varying European health system settings.MethodsOur research team developed a three-step capacity assessment framework, incorporating a health policy review checklist, a facility visit survey, and key informants’ interview guide followed by a strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT) analysis. Piloting this comprehensive approach, we explored the CCS capacity in three countries: Estonia, Portugal and Romania. These countries were selected due to their contrasting healthcare structures and resources, providing a diverse overview of the European context.ResultsConducted over a period of 9 months, the capacity assessment covered multiple resources, 27 screening centres, 16 colposcopy and treatment centres and 15 key informant interviews. Our analysis highlighted both shared and country-specific challenges. A key common issue was ensuring high compliance to follow-up and management of screen-positive women. We identified considerable heterogeneity in resources and organization across the three countries, underscoring the need for tailored, rather than one-size-fits-all, solutions.ConclusionsOur study’s novelty lies in the successful development of this capacity assessment methodology implementable within a relatively short time frame, proving its feasibility for use in various contexts and countries. The resulting set of materials, adaptable to different cancer types, is a ready-to-use toolkit to improve cancer screening processes and outcomes. This research marks a significant stride towards comprehensive capacity assessment for CCS programmes in Europe. Future directions include deploying these tools in other countries and cancer types, thereby contributing to the global fight against cancer.

Breaking the Silence: The Role of Health Professionals in the Gaza Crisis

Having the opportunity to write something in this moment, I would use it to raise my voice on behalf of the health professional community for the people of Gaza. As mentioned by Sualeha Shekhani and Dr. Aamir Jafarey, doctors represent the moral voice of their era. However, in light of the events of October 7, 2023, and the subsequent armed assault by Israeli forces on Gaza, which has led to a significant humanitarian crisis, the response from the global bioethics community seems muted (Shekhani &amp; Jafarey, 2024). This silence can be partly explained by editorial restraints that may prevent a more robust response from the health community towards the Gaza crisis. Health professionals are uniquely positioned to influence policy decisions and advocate for equitable healthcare. They possess specialized knowledge of medical ethics and healthcare structures, enabling them to champion the causes of the vulnerable and reduce disparities across society. Physicians, trained in evidence-based medicine, can ensure that policy decisions are grounded in scientific research rather than political expediency (Fernandes, 2024). The medical community's silence regarding the Gaza crisis is troubling. Healthcare workers in Gaza are targeted, and doctors work without essential medicines and resources, risking their lives for the population they serve. The current health sector in Gaza is at a breaking point, exacerbating the public health crisis and psychological trauma experienced by the residents (Fernandes, 2024).

Developing a Consensus Statement to Target Oral Health Inequalities in People With Severe Mental Illness.

Oral diseases are more prevalent in people with severe mental illness (SMI) compared to those without mental illnees. A greater focus on oral health is needed to reverse unacceptable but often neglected oral health inequality in people with SMI. This provided the impetus for developing 'The Right to Smile' consensus statement. We aimed to develop and disseminate a consensus statement to address oral health inequality, highlighting the main areas for concern and recommending an evidence-based 5-year action plan to improve oral health in people with SMI. The Right to Smile consensus statement was developed by experts from several professional disciplines and practice settings (mental, dentaland public health) and people with lived experience, including carers. Stakeholders participated in a series of online workshops to develop a rights-based consensus statement. Subsequent dissemination activities were conducted to maximise its reach and impact. The consensus statement was developed to focus on how oral health inequalities could be addressed through a set of 5-year improvement targets for practice, policyand training. The consensus was reached on three 5-year action plans: 'Any assessment of physical health in people experiencing SMI must include consideration of oral health', 'Access to dental services for people with SMI needs to improve' and 'The importance of oral health for people experiencing SMI should be recognised in healthcare training, systems, and structures'. This consensus statement urges researchers, servicesand policymakers to embrace a 5-year action plan to improve oral health for people with SMI. The team included people with lived experience of SMI, their carers/family membersand mental and dental health service providers. They were involved in every stage of developing the consensus statement, from conception to development and dissemination.