Health System Challenges Research Articles

Defining medical deserts—an international consensus-building exercise

Abstract Background Medical deserts represent a pressing public health and health systems challenge. The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated the gap between people and health services, yet a commonly agreed definition of medical deserts was lacking. This study aims to define medical deserts through a consensus-building exercise, explaining the phenomenon to its full extent, in a manner that can apply to countries and health systems across the globe. Methods We used a standard Delphi exercise for the consensus-building process. The first phase consisted of one round of individual online meetings with selected key informants; the second phase comprised two rounds of surveys when a consensus was reached in January 2023. The first phase-the in-depth individual meetings-was organized online. The dimensions to include in the definition of medical deserts were identified, ranked and selected based on their recurrence and importance. The second phase-the surveys-was organized online. Finally, external validation was obtained from stakeholders via email. Results The agreed definition highlights five major dimensions: ‘Medical deserts are areas where population healthcare needs are unmet partially or totally due to lack of adequate access or improper quality of healthcare services caused by (i) insufficient human resources in health or (ii) facilities, (iii) long waiting times, (iv) disproportionate high costs of services or (v) other socio-cultural barriers’. Conclusions The five dimensions of access to healthcare: insufficient human resources in health or; facilities; long waiting times; disproportionate high costs of services and; other socio-cultural barriers, ought to be addressed to mitigate medical deserts. The term medical deserts might not be the most appropriate term for defining areas with insufficient access to health services as it excludes essential domains, such as access to public health and preventive services. Key messages • Medical deserts directly and negatively impact the health outcomes of the people living in it. • Medical deserts might not be the most appropriate term for defining areas with insufficient access to medical services, as it excludes public health and preventive services.

Social prescribing for healthy ageing: insights from older people referral and uptake in Portugal

Abstract The population ageing presents multifaceted challenges for health systems, with implications for healthcare delivery and health and well-being outcomes. Innovative integrated-care approaches are needed to promote healthy aging and the quality of life of older people. Social Prescribing (SP) has emerged as a promising strategy to address the complex health and social needs of populations, including those older, offering non-medical interventions that encompass social, cultural, and community-based activities. SP has been implemented in Portugal since 2018 and currently target different subgroups, including elderly. This study aims to examine referral and uptake of older people to SP in Portugal. This cross-sectional study analysed sociodemographic, health condition, referral and uptake-related data from older patients (≥65 years) engaged in SP, collected through a survey and registries at primary healthcare units in Lisbon between 2018-2023. Of the 1060 patients referred to SP, 43.9% (n = 465) were aged 65 years or older. Within this age group, 38.1% were 71-80 years old and 36.1% were 81-90 years old; 67.5% were female. Around 48% were referred to SP for social isolation, 40% for social and financial support, and 32.5% for functional dependency. Two thirds had two or more chronic conditions, with cardiovascular disease (59,1%), mental health disorders (29,2%), and obesity (27,1%) being the most frequent. The SP consultations uptake rate was 59.1%, and patients were referred to a range of activities provided by third-sector organisations, as psychosocial support, home care, senior university classes, arts activities, and support in medicine management. The elderly population accounts for a large proportion of SP referrals. Further efforts are needed to identify the factors that influence patients’ acceptability and adherence and to promote the sustainability of SP and the well-being of the population. Key messages • Older people referred to SP initiative in Portugal have complex health-social needs, which reinforces the relevance of adopting a holistic centred-care approach to respond to the aging challenges. • Through SP older people have been integrated in community-based activities that promote their health and wellbeing, thus it is needed to develop tailored strategies to improve patient uptake.

What are the health system impacts of engaging with global health activity? A qualitative study

Abstract Background Global health partnerships between high-income health systems and low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are becoming more common as there is an appreciation of the need for collaboration to solve global health issues through knowledge and skill exchange. However, partnership evaluations largely focus on the benefits to individual participants and recipient systems, with little evidence of the impacts on the high-income system. Therefore, the aim of this study was to explore the health system-wide impacts of engaging with global health activity and consider the arguments for and against adopting these partnerships. Methods We carried out semi-structured interviews with individuals from three UK health systems that engage with global health activity to explore their motivations to in doing so. Transcripts were thematically analysed. Results We found that engagement in global health activity can contribute to workforce recruitment, retention, development, and upskilling, benefiting the system. Examples were also given of system-wide clinical, reputational, and economic benefits. However, this activity impacts short term staffing and can cause personal emotional issues that systems need to support. We also explored facilitators of engaging in global health work which included operational support, supporting healthcare staff to engage, and system acceptance. Barriers included lack of senior buy-in, opportunity access inequities, operational challenges, and the current UK health system challenges. Conclusions This study demonstrated the potentially significant system-level benefits of engaging in global health activity. These focused on improved workforce, which is a major public health issue worldwide. We have also identified system characteristics, such as buy-in and operational support, which influence success. We hope this work provides a building block demonstrating there are benefits to be had for donor health systems, but barriers must be overcome. Key messages • The potential benefits and drawbacks that may arise from high-income health systems engaging in global health, as well as facilitators and barriers, are explored. • This study creates a foundation to understand donor-system benefits and encourages further research, particularly in systems who do not engage with global health activity to understand why this is.

Barriers and enablers towards integrated care for sexual violence victims in humanitarian settings

Abstract Background Sexual violence (SV) is a complex public health issue that necessitates a coordinated multisectoral response. Ideally, this response should be provided through an integrated care package to strengthen timely access and comprehensive care for victims. However, in humanitarian settings with high levels of SV, care is often offered through fragmented silos, exacerbating the burden on the health workforce and victims. Methods Using the Valentijn framework, a qualitative, real-time Delphi study was conducted with 17 SV care experts representing 7 geographical subregions to gain informed opinions on key contextual and health system barriers and enablers for integrated care for SV victims in humanitarian settings. Results Challenges and enablers reported across the diversity of the participants’ contexts showed consistency. Contextual challenges included volatile contexts, collapsed health systems, and poor infrastructure. Professional challenges included a lack of expertise among healthcare providers (HCPs), high staff attrition, and compassion fatigue among HCPs. Health systems challenges included poor referral and coordination mechanisms, insufficient resources, misaligned donor-programme priorities and low prioritisation of SV comprehensive care. Key enablers reported were effective networking, community engagement, capacity building, co-locating services, participatory management, promoting staff’s sense of ownership, digitalised information systems, and joint patient files. Conclusions The sustainability of integrated care for SV victims can be strengthened by ensuring HCPs access regular psychological support and training and are incentivised to provide quality care. Regular coordination among actors, including donors, can support integrating care that responds to patients’ holistic needs. Further research is needed to assess HCPs’ and SV victims’ experiences of current service delivery and how to optimise integrated care in humanitarian settings. Key messages • Addressing care providers challenges in humanitarian settings, such as high attrition, lack of training, psychosocial support, and burnout, can ensure proper integration of sexual violence care. • Integration of sexual violence care demands systemic changes, including aligning donor-programme goals, building accountability mechanisms and the buy-in of political and community leaders.

How are the three environmental threats challenging health systems’ resilience?

Abstract Background Known avoidable environmental risks cause about one quarter of all deaths and disease burden worldwide, amounting to at least a steady 13 million deaths each year. Indeed, diseases caused by the environment weigh heavily on health systems. These not only harm directly human health increasing the burden of disease but also potentiate other threats, by acting as drivers (e.g. pandemics, antimicrobial resistance). In addition, the increased burden due to these environmental threats also put in risk the capacity of health systems to adapt to the new healthcare needs and to provide a proper answer to the diseases caused by other health determinants. Methods Based on a review of the literature, the presentation addresses the question of potential options in public health climate action at the interface of environmental sustainability and health systems sustainability and resilience. It identifies possible priority areas in order to guarantee environmental and healthcare sustainability. Results Approaches that focus on treatment of individual diseases rather than improvement of environmental determinants of health will be insufficient to tackle the triple environmental crises of climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution. Single-determinant approaches are unlikely to achieve expected improvements, given the complex interaction of environmental factors. Conclusions Approaches that are more integrated are required to address the root causes of disease and guarantee health systems sustainability, which are often defined by policies in key sectors other than health, such as the environment. Multi-sectoral actions are needed to prevent and mitigate the threats to human health from the ongoing and interconnected environmental crises of climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution, contributing to a Planetary Health perspective on health systems’ resilience.

Contextual factors experienced by mothers of children with special needs

Background: Caring for children with special needs places a burden on caregivers. The challenges experienced can be conceptualised as personal and environmental, as per the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health Framework (ICF).Objectives: Supported the caregiver experiences when caring for children with special needs and to conceptualise these needs in relation to the personal and environmental factors set out in the ICF.Method: A qualitative exploratory study was conducted, using purposive and snowball sampling. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect the data, which were then analysed thematically.Results: A total of six themes arose from the data. Two of these were related to personal factors: unemployment and caregiving, and marital uncertainty. The other four themes were related to environmental factors: family and caregiving factors, educational factors, health-systems challenges and perceptions of children with special needs.Conclusion: Caregivers of children with special needs experienced personal challenges, which resulted in feelings of isolation from family and society. They also faced environmental challenges in sectors such as education and health.Clinical implications: The management of children with special needs should include interventions within their environments to assist caregivers with their tasks. This could contribute to improved quality of life for both the caregivers and their children.

Barriers and facilitators of healthcare access for long COVID-19 patients in a universal healthcare system: qualitative evidence from Austria

BackgroundLong COVID-19 challenges health and social systems globally. International research finds major inequalities in prevalence and healthcare utilization as patients describe difficulties with accessing health care. In order to improve long-term outcomes it is vital to understand any underlying access barriers, for which relevant evidence on long COVID-19 is thus far lacking in a universal healthcare system like Austria. This study aims to comprehensively identify access barriers and facilitators faced by long COVID-19 patients in Austria and explore potential socioeconomic and demographic drivers in health and social care access.MethodsApplying an exploratory qualitative approach, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 experts including medical professionals and senior health officials as well as focus groups with 18 patients with confirmed long COVID-19 diagnosis reflecting varying participant characteristics (age, gender, urbanicity, occupation, education, insurance status) (July-Nov 2023). Data were analysed following a thematic framework approach, drawing on a comprehensive ‘access to health care’ model.ResultsBased on expert and patient experiences, several access barriers and facilitators emerged along all dimensions of the model. Main themes included scepticism and stigma by medical professionals, difficulties in finding knowledgeable doctors, limited specialist capacities in the ambulatory care sector, long waiting times for specialist care, and limited statutory health insurance coverage of treatments resulting in high out-of-pocket payments. Patients experienced constant self-organization of their patient pathway as stressful, emphasizing the need for multidisciplinary care and centralized coordination. Facilitators included supportive social environments, telemedicine, and informal information provided by a nationwide patient-led support group. Differences in patient experiences emerged, among others, as women and younger patients faced gender- and age-based stigmatization. Complementary health insurance reduced the financial strain, however, did not ease capacity constraints, which were particularly challenging for those living in rural areas.ConclusionsThe findings of this study indicate a call for action to improve the long COVID-19 situation in Austria by empowering both providers and patients via increased information offerings, strengthened interdisciplinary treatment structures and telemedicine offerings as well as research funding. Our insights on potentially relevant socioeconomic and demographic drivers in access barriers lay the necessary foundation for future quantitative inequality research.

Challenges and opportunities in the mental health landscape of the Maldives.

This article outlines the history of mental health service delivery with contemporary challenges and opportunities in the Maldives. Mental health has been traditionally the domain of faith healers in the Maldives. This changed gradually with the availability of treatments as well as increased public awareness, and mental health is now recognized as an emerging health issue. The current challenges for the mental health system include governance issues, access to services, human resource limitations, poor prevention efforts, and lack of research. These challenges may be overcome by focussing on opportunities through strengthened governance, intersectoral collaboration, mainstream integration of mental health, and local research.

Distribuição espacial e características clínico epidemiológicas dos casos de síndrome respiratória aguda grave por covid-19 no Brasil: estudo das duas primeiras ondas

The new coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2), the COVID-19 etiological agent, has been established as a challenge for health systems and can present as Flu Syndrome (FS) or Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS). This work was aimed at describing the clinical epidemiological profile of SARS cases due to COVID-19 and the spatial distribution of the incidence among the Federative Units of Brazil (FU) in the first two waves. This is a descriptive and ecological study, with the FU as settings. The data collected are related to SARS cases due to COVID-19, with a time frame between March 2020 and June 2021. The sociodemographic and clinical-epidemiological variables were selected with their respective absolute and relative values. The spatial distribution of incidence was determined to identify the presence of spatial autocorrelation in the first two waves. A total of 613,324 SARS cases due to COVID-19 were reported, most were related to males, aged>60 years, typified as non-nosocomial and with a healing outcome; signs and symptoms were: cough,fever, dyspnea, and at least presence of one comorbidity. The average incidence in the countrywas 286.85 cases/100,000 inhabitants, while the Moran Index showed statistical significance I=0.329 (p value<0.001), with global spatial autocorrelation of the incidence in the second wave. The distribution was heterogeneous. These results constitute subsidies for management in health systems and services regarding the strategic implementation for the control and clinical management of this disease.

Current Capacity for Diagnosing Alzheimer's Disease in Germany and Implications for Wait Times.

Amyloid-targeting therapies for Alzheimer's disease (AD) might become available in Germany soon. The combination of a large pool of prevalent cases and a complex diagnostic process to determine eligibility for these treatments is likely to challenge health systems' capacity. To analyze Germany's healthcare system capacity to identify treatment-eligible patients in a timely and equitable manner. We modeled patients' diagnostic journey and projects wait times due to capacity constraints for AD specialist visits and PET scans from 2024 to 2043. Model parameters were derived from published data and expert input. Wait times would be ∼50 months over the model horizon, if patients were referred to specialists based on a brief cognitive assessment in primary care. Wait times for patients with social health insurance are projected to be 1.9 times those of patients with private insurance, with peak wait times of around 76 and 40 months, respectively. Adding a blood test for the AD pathology as additional triage step would reduce wait times to below 24 months. In spite of having a well-resourced health system, Germany is projected to be unable to cope with the demand for biomarker-based AD diagnosis, if a disease-modifying AD treatment were introduced. As these treatments might become available by the end of 2024, decisive action, in particular dissemination of high-performing AD blood tests for triage in primary care, will be needed to prevent delays in access and potentially avoidable and inequitable disease progression.

Transition and change: opportunities and challenges of CHW programme reform for community health systems and vertical disease programmes in Liberia

BackgroundGlobally, community health worker (CHW) programmes are critical to addressing health worker shortages and have been recognised as critical pillars within the drive towards universal health coverage (UHC). In 2016, the Liberian Ministry of Health launched the National Community Health Services Policy 2016–2021, which included significant CHW programme reform to address ongoing health workforce capacity gaps in the country. However, little consideration was given to the impact of such reforms on ongoing health interventions that rely heavily on the use of CHW cadres. Our study explores how CHW programme reform in Liberia influenced performance of CHWs involved in the delivery of Neglected Tropical Disease (NTD) programmes to elucidate how health systems reform can impact the delivery of routine health interventions and vice versa.MethodsWe used a qualitative case study approach conducted between March 2017 and August 2018. Our instrumental case study approach uses qualitative methods, including document review of five CHW and NTD program-related policy documents; 25 key informant interviews with facility, county, and national level decision-makers; and 42 life and job histories with CHWs in Liberia. Data were analysed using a thematic framework approach, guided by Kok et al. framework of CHW performance. Data were coded in QRS NVIVO 11 Pro.ResultsOur findings show that CHW programme reform provides opportunities and challenges for supporting enhanced CHW performance. In relation to health system hardware, we found that CHW programme reform provides better opportunities for: formal recognition of CHWs; strengthening capacity for effective healthcare delivery at the community level through improved and formalised training; a more formal supervision structure; and provision of monthly incentives of 70 US dollars. Efficiency gaps in routine intervention delivery can be mitigated through the strengthening of these hardware components. Conversely, supervision deficits in routine CHW functioning can be supported through health interventions. In relation to systems software, we emphasise the ongoing importance of community engagement in CHW selection that is responsive to gendered power hierarchies and accompanied by gendered transformative approaches to improving literacy.ConclusionsThis study shows how CHW programme reform provides opportunities and challenges for health system strengthening that can both positively and negatively impact the functioning of routine health interventions. By working together, CHW programmes and routine health interventions have the opportunity to leverage mutually beneficial support for CHWs, which can enhance overall systems functioning by enhancing CHW performance.

Improving access to outpatient computed tomography

Demand for diagnostic imaging services in the United States continues to rise, posing challenges for health systems to maintain efficient scheduling processes. This study documents a quality improvement initiative undertaken at our institution in response to a surge in demand for outpatient imaging during 2022, which led to a notable scheduling backlog. By October 2022, the average scheduling interval, defined as the time from order placement to scheduled examination date, had increased from 2 weeks to 6 weeks. The objective of this initiative was to reduce the scheduling interval from 6 weeks to 10 days by January 2023. Utilizing feedback from schedulers, technologists, and radiologists, several interventions were implemented. The impact of each intervention was monitored with a control chart with weekly appointment delays tracked as a balancing measure. Initially, examination slots were double-booked for a period of 4 weeks to address the backlog, resulting in a reduction of the scheduling interval to 12 days (72 % decrease). Subsequently, examination slot duration was shorted from 20 to 15 min and contrast protocols were standardized across all sites. These adjustments further decreased the interval to 7 days (41 % reduction) over the following 9 weeks. While staffing shift adjustments had no impact on the scheduling interval, the introduction of an extra CT scanner reduced the interval to 3 days (57 % decrease). These interventions resulted in a notable increase in examination volume, from a weekly average of 722 to 860 examinations (19 % increase), approximately an additional $1,612,000 in annual revenue. Importantly, there was no change in the average appointment delay, which remained at 15 min over the study period. These improvements were sustained across the subsequent months and received favorable subjective feedback from staff. While the initiative successfully addressed scheduling inefficiencies across our health system, the rise in examination volumes has led to an increased turnaround time for completed reports. Future directions for enhancing the outpatient scheduling process include expanding online scheduling platforms, implementing systems to assess imaging appropriateness, and developing urgency stratification to prioritize time-sensitive examinations.

Évaluer la réponse en cancérologie : l’imagerie un outil essentiel ?

Identifying patients for whom the treatment is effective is an absolute necessity regarding the effectiveness of their care and ethics and avoiding them from losing opportunities and unnecessary adverse effects. It is also an economic necessity due to the very high cost of new treatments called “expensive molecules”, in particular immunotherapy, which poses problems of access to these treatments and constitutes a real financial challenge for health systems. In clinical routine as in research, imaging is the essential tool for deciding the success or failure of treatment, with a major medico-economic impact if we consider that these very expensive treatments are only effective in a fraction of patients and that they do not always bring a major benefit.

Intra- and inter-facility experiences of coordinating care for patients with lung cancer in KwaZulu-Natal public health facilities: a qualitative study

Aim Despite evidence that effective cancer care coordination has yielded positive results in facilitating and supporting high-quality care, it remains a complex and challenging system to implement. South Africa’s mortality of lung cancer is reported at 13.4%, ranking highest among all cancers. Coordinating the care of cancer patients is complex and can last several months or years, with multiple consultations, rounds of treatment, and follow-up in various settings. With so many health professionals, services, and settings involved, the care of these patients can become fragmented and uncoordinated. This interface between primary and specialty care offers a valuable opportunity to appreciate the challenges of delivering well-coordinated cancer care. Consequently, this paper explores healthcare professionals’ perspectives on coordinating lung cancer care within and between healthcare services. Methods This study was conducted through virtual, telephonic, and face-to-face in-depth interviews with 26 purposively selected participants from primary to tertiary health professionals, using a semi-structured tool and drawing from grounded theory design. Data generation and analysis were conducted iteratively, followed by systematic thematic analysis to organise data, review, and interpret the findings. Findings The overall public health system challenges reported by participants involved service fragmentation, staff shortages, and communication problems. Drivers of lack of care coordination varied widely across healthcare professionals, with interoperability and communication challenges standing out as the most prominent themes. Consequently, better communication, interoperability, and improved care transitions between providers and health systems were proposed. This study provides pertinent information for policymakers and healthcare professionals to develop appropriate strategies for improving cancer care coordination interventions. Conclusions A fundamental change is required to shift the direction of the KwaZulu-Natal public health system towards responsive, patient-centred, comprehensive, and coordinated care. Enabling the primary healthcare level to play a substantial role in care coordination may provide a plausible intervention to circumvent healthcare complexities.

Healthcare workers' perspectives on diabetic foot complications among type 2 diabetes mellitus patients in Fiji.

Diabetic Foot Complications (DFCs) are a growing cause of morbidity and mortality with less than one third of physicians able to discern the signs of diabetes related peripheral neuropathy. DFCs and resultant amputations account for a considerable proportion of surgeries in Fiji, with very limited literature available to verify the factors that influence these alarming figures. This study aimed to explore Health Care Workers' (HCWs) perspectives on diabetic foot complications and challenges of foot care management in Fiji. An exploratory descriptive qualitative design was used among HCWs at the Sigatoka Sub Divisional Hospital (SDH), Fiji in 2021. HCWs at the SDH were required to have a minimum work experience of at least six months in public health. All participants who met the inclusion criteria were selected through purposive sampling. Data was collected using a focus group discussion guide composed of semi-structured open-ended questions to guide the Focus Group Discussions (FGDs). Focus discussions were audio recorded and transcribed with thematic analysis applied to derive the themes and sub-themes outlined in the study. Twenty HCWs participated in four FGDs with four major themes identified. The first theme was HCWs' perceptions and practice of foot care which revealed that all participants had adequate diabetic foot care knowledge. The second theme was factors affecting foot care which was mainly focused on identified barriers such as inadequate patient foot care knowledge, the lack of resources such as manpower, and health system challenges like the COVID-19 pandemic. The third theme is creating awareness among patients and HCWs to improve foot care practices. The fourth theme is strengthening foot care practices at the different levels of health care that is aimed at optimizing diabetic foot outcomes. Various foot care barriers namely patient factors and the lack of resources is a concern depicted in this study. There is a need to address health system barriers and enforce diabetic foot education, screening and care for patients and the community.

A qualitative analysis of health service problems and the strategies used to manage them in the COVID-19 pandemic: exploiting generic and context-specific approaches

BackgroundThe COVID-19 pandemic disrupted health systems around the globe. Lessons from health systems responses to these challenges may help design effective and sustainable health system responses for future challenges. This study aimed to 1/ identify the broad types of health system challenges faced during the pandemic and 2/ develop a typology of health system response to these challenges.MethodsSemi-structured one-on-one online interviews explored the experience of 19 health professionals during COVID-19 in a large state health system in Australia. Data were analysed using constant comparative analysis utilising a sociotechnical system lens.ResultsParticipants described four overarching challenges: 1/ System overload, 2/ Barriers to decision-making, 3/ Education or training gaps, and 4/ Limitations of existing services. The limited time often available to respond meant that specific and well-designed strategies were often not possible, and more generic strategies that relied on the workforce to modify solutions and repair unexpected gaps were common. For example, generic responses to system overload included working longer hours, whilst specific strategies utilised pre-existing technical resources (e.g. converting non-emergency wards into COVID-19 wards).ConclusionDuring the pandemic, it was often not possible to rely on mature strategies to frame responses, and more generic, emergent approaches were commonly required when urgent responses were needed. The degree to which specific strategies were ready-to-hand appeared to dictate how much a strategy relied on such generic approaches. The workforce played a pivotal role in enabling emergent responses that required dealing with uncertainties.

Quality Enhancement Research Initiative Rapid Response Teams: A learning health system approach to addressing emerging health system challenges.

Quality Enhancement Research Initiative Rapid Response Teams: A learning health system approach to addressing emerging health system challenges.

Impact on Fatality Rates and Years of Life Lost During the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Experience of the Mexican Public Health Incident Management Command

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic challenged health systems worldwide. In Mexico, the Public Health Incident Management Command (COISS) strategy was implemented to improve health care for patients with COVID-19 who required hospitalization. To evaluate the impact of the COISS strategy on case fatality rates (CFR) and years of life lost (YLL) in hospitalized patients with COVID-19. The COISS strategy included eight actions implemented in states with high epidemic risk (COISS states). A secondary analysis of the public database from the Mexican Ministry of Health was performed considering patients with confirmed diagnoses of SARS-CoV-2 infection. The COISS strategy effectiveness was evaluated by its impact on in-hospital CFR and YLL at the beginning (T0) and end (T1) of the third wave, and at the end of the fourth wave (T2) and compared to states without intervention (non-COISS states). At T0, COISS states showed a higher CFR for hospitalized patients than non-COISS states, which decreased after the strategy implementation. After correction for baseline conditions, lower relative CFR at T1 and T2, compared to T0, and a protective effect in different age groups, especially in those ≥65 years, were found in hospitalized patients in COISS states. The COISS strategy was associated with lower CFR in hospitalized patients with COVID-19 at both T1 and T2. At T0, YLLs were higher in COISS states, but there were no significant differences at T1 and T2. COISS interventions effectively reduced CFR in hospitalized patients with COVID-19, providing protection to vulnerable patients and reducing the YLL gap.

Determinants of dropout from the maternal continuum of care in Ethiopia, multilevel analysis of the 2016 demographic and health survey.

Over the past two decades (2000-2020), Ethiopia achieved significant reductions in maternal and neonatal mortality, with a 72% and 44%, respectively. However, low maternal health service utilization and dropout from the maternal continuum of care remain major health system challenges. This study aimed to investigate individual and community-level determinants of dropout from the maternal continuum of care. We used the recent, 2016 Ethiopian Demographic and Health Survey (EDHS) data. In the maternal continuum of care pathway, i) less than four antenatal care (ANC) attendance, ii) subsequent dropout from skilled birth attendance (SBA) after 4 or more ANC, and iii) dropout from postnatal care (PNC) after attendance of facility delivery were the outcomes for dropout. A Multilevel logistic regression analysis of individual and community level factors (e.g., place of residence, geographical regions) were included in the model. The variation in the outcomes were presented by odds ratio (OR), 95% confidence interval and intra-cluster correlation coefficient (ICC). In the maternal continuum of care pathway higher dropouts were observed from SBA to PNC (85%) and from 4+ ANC to SBA (43.4%). Poorest wealth quantile (AOR = 2.31, 95% [CI = 1.69,3.16]), having no health insurance coverage (AOR = 1.44, 95% [CI = 1.01,2.06]), and high community poverty (AOR = 1.28, 95% [CI = 1.01,1.63]) were associated with having < 4 ANC attendance. Perceived distance from health facility as a big problem (AOR = 1.45, [95% = CI, 1.12,1.88), lower community media exposure (AOR = 1.6, 95% [CI = 1.14,2.23]) and rural residency (AOR = 3.03, 95% [CI = 1.75,5.26]) increased the odds of dropout from SBA after 4+ ANC visits. The dropout from the maternal continuum of care was higher in Ethiopia and postnatal care were the most affected maternal care. Oromia and Somali regions were associated with dropouts from all levels of care. Policy strategies should prioritize geopolitical regions with higher dropout levels. In addition to improving access and quality of institutional health services, designing an alternative strategy for targeted outreach for ANC visits and postnatal checkups is recommended.

Self-reported follow-up care needs can be met in both facility and self-managed abortion: Evidence from low- and middle-income countries

ObjectivesTo understand in-facility follow-up care-seeking behavior among both people who self-managed medication abortions and those who obtained facility-managed care in low-and-middle-income countries. We explore factors that contribute to meeting individual self-reported follow-up care needs, core to person-centered care. Study designWe conducted a qualitative, codebook thematic analysis of 67 in-depth interviews conducted with people who self-managed medication abortions or obtained facility-managed medication abortion care. We first classified individuals as having their follow-up care needs met (not seeking care when the participant felt confident that additional care was not warranted or desired or receiving care if it was desired) or not. Our a priori analytic domains came from the Anderson model of health services utilization - predisposing, enabling, or need factors (perceived and evaluated need for health services) that contributed to having follow-up care needs met or not. We also describe emergent themes within each domain. ResultsMost participants (n=59, 88%) had their follow-up care needs met; half (n=33, 49%) sought follow-up care in a facility. Prior birth or abortion experiences emerged as predisposing factors for having follow-up care needs met. Having accompaniment support (from activists or hotlines who provide abortion guidance outside of clinical settings), knowing what to expect, and information sources were key enabling factors for having follow-up care needs met. Need factors included flexible follow-up care guidelines. Those who did not have their follow-up care needs met described predisposing negative health system experiences; enabling factors including health system challenges, stigma from providers, and legal risk; and need factors of required follow-up care guidelines. ConclusionsMedication abortion follow-up care experiences are diverse, and individual needs can be met both in and outside of health facilities. Understanding prior experiences, enabling accompaniment support, and considering flexible follow-up care guidelines can support meeting individual follow-up care needs, which is essential to person-centered abortion care. ImplicationsFollow-up care needs, essential to ensuring access to high-quality abortion services, can be met in both self-managed and in-facility medication abortion models. Policies that require follow-up care when it is not needed or desired by the person can reinforce ideas that self-managed abortion is not safe or effective, despite existing evidence.