Health System Coverage Research Articles

Predictors of the Use of Traditional Medicines in the Universal Health Coverage System in Indonesia

Background: Indonesia has committed to achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC) and introduced national health insurance (JKN) to meet that commitment. Despite the increasing availability of healthcare services under the JKN scheme, traditional medicine (TM) continues to be a significant part of healthcare for Indonesians. In the context of the UHC system, this study aims to examine the predictors of TM use among urban and rural communities in Indonesia. 
 
 Methods: A cross-sectional survey was conducted using a semi-structured questionnaire targeting urban and rural communities. A total of 926 households were randomly selected to participate in the survey. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to identify the significant predictors of TM use. 
 
 Results: Multivariate analysis revealed the following variables to be predictive of TM use, namely, rural residence, being more educated, experiencing some health problem, demonstrating ethnomedical knowledge, having a favourable opinion about the safety and efficacy of TM and holistic orientation to health.  On the other hand, working in the formal sector was associated with lower odds of using TM compared to those who were employed in the informal sector. 
 
 Conclusion: People’s experience, personal attributes, and attitude towards TM, rather than dissatisfaction with healthcare service, predicted the likelihood of using TM in the UHC system in Indonesia. This finding also implies the underutilisation of JKN services by the insured TM users living in rural areas. Considering the community’s strong preferences for TM, this paper argues that its inclusion in the JKN system may increase the utilisation of the JKN service.

Addressing Challenges in Health Technology Assessment Institutionalization for Furtherance of Universal Health Coverage Through South-South Knowledge Exchange: Lessons From Bhutan, Kenya, Thailand, and Zambia

Health Technology Assessment (HTA), a tool for priority setting, has emerged as a means of ensuring the sustainability of a Universal Health Coverage (UHC) system. However, setting up an effective HTA system poses multiple challenges and knowledge exchange can play a crucial role in helping countries achieve their UHC targets. This article reports the results of the discussion during a preconference session at the 2019 HTAsiaLink Conference, an annual gathering of HTA agencies in Asia, which supports knowledge transfer and exchange among HTA practitioners. As part of this discourse, 3 main HTA challenges were identified based on experiences of selected countries in Asia and Africa, namely Bhutan, Kenya, Thailand, and Zambia: availability of funding, building technical capacity, and achieving buy-in among stakeholders for successful translation of HTA research into UHC policy. The potential solutions identified through this South-South engagement included establishing a legal mandate for HTA, building local technical capacity through partnerships and enhancing strategic communication with stakeholders to increase awareness, among others. South-South Knowledge Exchange can therefore be instrumental in sharing lessons learned from common challenges and offer potential solutions to address capacity building initiatives for HTA in LMICs.

Evaluation of health system readiness and coverage of intermittent preventive treatment of malaria in infants (IPTi) in Kambia district to inform national scale-up in Sierra Leone

BackgroundIntermittent preventive treatment of malaria in infants (IPTi) with sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) is a proven strategy to protect infants against malaria. Sierra Leone is the first country to implement IPTi nationwide. IPTi implementation was evaluated in Kambia, one of two initial pilot districts, to assess quality and coverage of IPTi services.MethodsThis mixed-methods evaluation had two phases, conducted 3 (phase 1) and 15–17 months (phase 2) after IPTi implementation. Methods included: assessments of 18 health facilities (HF), including register data abstraction (phases 1 and 2); a knowledge, attitudes and practices survey with 20 health workers (HWs) in phase 1; second-generation sequencing of SP resistance markers (pre-IPTi and phase 2); and a cluster-sample household survey among caregivers of children aged 3–15 months (phase 2). IPTi and vaccination coverage from the household survey were calculated from child health cards and maternal recall and weighted for the complex sampling design. Interrupted time series analysis using a Poisson regression model was used to assess changes in malaria cases at HF before and after IPTi implementation.ResultsMost HWs (19/20) interviewed had been trained on IPTi; 16/19 reported feeling well prepared to administer it. Nearly all HFs (17/18 in phase 1; 18/18 in phase 2) had SP for IPTi in stock. The proportion of parasite alleles with dhps K540E mutations increased but remained below the 50% WHO-recommended threshold for IPTi (4.1% pre-IPTi [95%CI 2–7%]; 11% post-IPTi [95%CI 8–15%], p < 0.01). From the household survey, 299/459 (67.4%) children ≥ 10 weeks old received the first dose of IPTi (versus 80.4% for second pentavalent vaccine, given simultaneously); 274/444 (62.5%) children ≥ 14 weeks old received the second IPTi dose (versus 65.4% for third pentavalent vaccine); and 83/217 (36.4%) children ≥ 9 months old received the third IPTi dose (versus 52.2% for first measles vaccine dose). HF register data indicated no change in confirmed malaria cases among infants after IPTi implementation.ConclusionsKambia district was able to scale up IPTi swiftly and provide necessary health systems support. The gaps between IPTi and childhood vaccine coverage need to be further investigated and addressed to optimize the success of the national IPTi programme.

Participatory and responsive governance in universal health coverage: an analysis of legislative provisions in Thailand

Participatory and responsive governance in universal health coverage (UHC) systems synergistically ensure the needs of citizens are protected and met. In Thailand, UHC constitutes of three public insurance schemes: Civil...

Low birth weight trends in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries, 2000\u20132015: economic, health system and demographic conditionings

BackgroundLow birth weight rates are increasing in both developed and developing countries. Although several maternal factors have been identified as associated with low birth weight, little is known of economic or organization factors influencing this increase. This study aims to ascertain the twenty-first century relationships between the contextual country factors and low birth weight rates.MethodsWe analyse trends of low birth weight rates in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries. Data from 2000 to 2015 were obtained from the OECD data base. Their relationships with demographic and economic variables, health habits, woman-related preventive measures, health care system organization and funding, health care work force and obstetric care were analysed using random-effects linear regression.ResultsLow birth weight rates are higher in Southern Europe (7.61%) and lower in Northern Europe (4.68%). Low birth weight rates escalated about 20% in Southern Europe and to less extent in Easter Europe (7%) and Asian/Oceanian countries, while remained stable in America, Central Europe and Northern Europe. Investment in health care, private health system coverage, ratios of paediatricians and obstetricians, average length of admission due to pregnancy or birth and Caesarean section rate were associated with higher low birth weight rates. Factors associated with lower low birth weight rates were health care coverage, public health system coverage, hospitals per million inhabitants, and ratios of health care workers, physicians, midwives and nurses.ConclusionsIn OECD countries, LBW rates are related to contextual country characteristics such as GDP per capita, which is inversely related to LBW rate. Health care system factors, including health care coverage or investment in public health system, are directly associated with lower LBW rates.

Post-market utilization patterns of Alzheimer's disease treatments in South Korea: comparison with countries with universal health coverage.

This study aimed to compare the utilization of Alzheimer's disease (AD) treatments, donepezil, galantamine, rivastigmine, and memantine, in Korea with Australia and other countries with universal health coverage. Reimbursement criteria and the patent status of four AD treatments in Korea and Australia were reviewed. The monthly spending and utilization of the treatments were extracted from the national electronic database in Korea and Australia. The defined daily dose per 1000 elderly population per day (DDD/1000e/day) were calculated from July 2008 to June 2019. Annual cost trends of Norway and England were compared with Korea and Australia. With the highest share of the use of donepezil in both countries, the cost and utilization of AD treatments in Korea increased more rapidly and remained higher than Australia. The cost of AD treatments in Korea increased by 15.5% every year during the study period, while the spending of the same drugs in Australia decreased by 10.5% annually. The utilization in DDD/1000e/day of AD treatments in Korea increased by 18.3% annually compared with 1.4% in Australia. When compared with Norway and England, countries with similar universal health coverage (UHC) system and elderly polupation, the cost of AD treatments in Korea was still higher with the opposite trend from other countries. Despite the similar UHC systems, there were considerable differences in the post-market utilization of AD treatments in Korea from Australia and other countries. This results can be attributed to differences in re-assessment system, pricing and reimbursement policies, and prescribing culture. This study provides a baseline to explore more comprehensive cross-country studies on rational use of medicines.

Abia State Telehealth Initiative: A Novel Ingenuity

In Nigeria, Universal health coverage has been sub-optimal due to limited access and inequality. This is worsened by poor health-seeking behavior due to out-of-pocket expenditure health system financing being practiced by a greater percentage of the population. However, leveraging on the increasing population of Nigerian’s using communication technologies provides a viable and robust platform for improving patient’s care. Consequently, tele-health initiative provides a complementary approach to improving access to quality health and universal health system coverage. Tele-health initiative is Abia state’s input in progressing the Universal Health Coverage mandate of the Federal Government of Nigeria, anchored on the e-Health policy of Nigeria, after its adoption at the 58th NCH in Sokoto in 2016, of which Abia became the pioneer state for the Project. Abia state’s telecommunication market caters to almost 3.5 million active subscribers, making it the single largest provider of services in the state. Objective: The project is designed to ascertain the impact of the tele-health initiative on healthcare service coverage in Abia State. Methodology: This is a descriptive study with the quantitative and qualitative arm. The study was conducted in all the seventeen local government areas in the State. Result: 29,488 incoming calls were related to general health inquiries about basic information, counseling, and support that improved callers’ knowledge and attitude towards their health, concerns, and symptoms. Also, 66.8% of all calls (19,382) were for routine health information, complaints on mild everyday symptoms, chronic disease management, and follow-up care. About 29.6% of total calls (8751) were made by persons seeking information on socially stigmatizing topics and conditions.

The belated implementation of a long-awaited health system in Cyprus and the role of interest groups

It is really a paradox that 60 years were required to establish a modern health system in Cyprus, despite the expressed positive attitude οf all political parties and most governments. This article investigates the planning and implementation of the National Health System (NHS) and its delay determinants, by employing qualitative research of published sources, audio material and 33 interviews with elite key informants. A major anti-reform alliance, consisting of private doctors, private hospitals and health insurance companies was identified, further supported by doctors of the “old” public system, whose benefits were threatened. Delay contributions additionally arose from media and patient groups, whilst the pharmaceutical sector imposed insignificant influence. Τhe prevailing political, economic and social environment, along with aspects of the proposed reform, fueled this anti-reform movement. However, climate in favour of the NHS implementation gradually developed, attributed to the power balance shift supportingthe Minister of Health and the government, mobilization of important actors/stakeholders, including the Federation of Patients' Organizations of Cyprus and the Media, and significant decrease in the influence of reform-resistant groups. The new dynamics created a supportive environment leading to the NHS launch on June 1st, 2019; thus Cyprus has ceased to be the last state of the European Union (EU) without a universal health coverage system. The process of introducing this new system in Cyprus is a prime example of resource and power redistribution amongst different interest groups and of the catalysts required to exit the orbit of an extremely “path-dependent” system, potentially inspiring future reformers.

PP495 Addressing The Interactions Between Health Regulation And Health Technology Assessment In Brazil

IntroductionThe interaction of health technology assessment (HTA) and health regulatory agencies has been widespread, especially for decision-making in health system coverage. The objective of this paper is to report the HTA-regulatory interaction in Brazil.MethodsThis is a case study on the interaction between HTA and regulation in Brazil. Technical documents and Brazilian legislation on health regulation and HTA were analyzed. The study was conducted in July 2019.ResultsHTA-Regulatory Interaction in Brazil is still incipient. There is no responsible agency for interaction between agencies, as there is in Europe and Canada, for example. In the last 4 years, cooperation has started between the Brazilian Health Surveillance Agency (Anvisa) and the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz) for post-registration monitoring of medicines. During this partnership, 170 post-marketing drug opinions were prepared, assisting the regulatory agency in decision-making.ConclusionsBrazil legislation guarantees essential medicines at low cost or free. The interaction between HTA and regulation has the potential to reduce the time taken to incorporate technology to the patient, in addition to ensuring greater safety for users of the Unified Health System. In this sense, it was observed that the interaction between health regulation and science and technology institutions has innovative potential in this approach.

Ethnobotanical study of plants used by the traditional healers to treat malaria in Mogovolas district, northern Mozambique

IntroductionMalaria is an important parasitic disease that affects mostly the African continent. Traditional medicine is very important in Mozambique and traditional healers play a key role in the primary health care services, particularly in rural areas. We aim to report the results of an ethnobotanical survey undertaken in Mogovolas district, northern region of Mozambique. We recorded and identified the medicinal plants used by traditional healers for treatment of malaria, as well as the mode of preparation and administration. MethodsThe study was conducted in 14 villages from Mogovolas between June and August 2015. Sixteen traditional healers were interviewed using semi-structured questionnaires. Under their guidance, we collected medicinal plants and prepared herbarium specimens that were sent and kept at Eduardo Mondlane University Herbarium for scientific identification. We searched for information on the in vitro and in vivo studies of the cited plants for antiplasmodial activity. ResultsTraditional healers from Mogovolas district reported the use of 37 plants to treat malaria, belonging to 22 families. The most used species are Ochna kirkii Oliv. (5 citations), Ehretia amoena Klotzsch and Pteleopsis myrtifolia (M.A.Lawson) Engl. & Diels (both with 3 citations). These plants belong to Ochnaceae, Boraginaceae and Combretaceae families, respectively. The herbal remedies are prepared using leaves (22/37), roots (18/37), stem barks (16/37) and stems (3/37). The administration of the herbal remedies was made essentially by oral route and bathing. ConclusionThe ethnobotanical data resulted from this study can be the starting point for further chemical and pharmacological studies aiming to identify medicinal species with antimalarial activity, thus, open the insights for the discovery of new antimalarial substances, as well as better integration of the traditional medicine into the national health systems, particularly in developing countries, as the health system coverage is limited.

District-level health system strengthening for universal health coverage: evidence from a longitudinal cohort study in rural Madagascar, 2014-2018

IntroductionDespite renewed commitment to universal health coverage and health system strengthening (HSS) to improve access to primary care, there is insufficient evidence to guide their design and implementation. To address...

Multi-layer health insurance coverage, medical services use and health in a Universal National Health System, the case of Portugal

The Portuguese health system has the peculiar characteristic of being a Beveridge-Bismarck type aiming at universal coverage. On top of the national health system coverage, there is a second coverage provided to some professionals, plus a third layer of coverage that can be acquired by taking out voluntary private health insurance. The aim of this work is to ascertain whether people benefiting from supplemental multi-layer health coverage (on top of the existing National Health System) have more consultations, either with general practitioners or with specialists, and enjoy better health status. We used data from the National Health Survey from 2014 to estimate a recursive system of ordered probits. The main results confirm that multi-layer health coverage is correlated with the use of more specialist consultations, but not with more GP consultations. It is also correlated with better health status. These results may indicate the existence of moral hazard, induced demand and/or 'access effect'. Regarding policy matters, the measures aimed to reduce waiting times, improve patient choice, and increase access could counteract such results and mitigate the potential inequity of access and health status, and also excessive use of medical services that can happen under double health coverage.

Building a Digital Tool for the Adoption of the World Health Organization's Antenatal Care Recommendations: Methodological Intersection of Evidence, Clinical Logic, and Digital Technology.

BackgroundOne of the key mandates of the World Health Organization (WHO) is to develop guidelines, defined as “a document containing recommendations for clinical practice or public health policy.” Guidelines represent the global standard for information sources shaping clinical practice and public health policies. Despite the rigorous development process and the value of guidelines for setting standards, implementing such standards within local contexts and at the point of care is a well-documented challenge. Digital technologies enable agile information management and may facilitate the adaptation of guidelines to diverse settings of health services delivery.ObjectiveThe objective of this paper is to detail the systematic and iterative process involved in transforming the WHO Antenatal Care (ANC) guidelines into a digital decision-support and patient-record application for routine use in primary health care settings, known as the WHO digital ANC module.MethodsThe WHO convened a team of clinical and digital health experts to develop the WHO digital ANC module as a tool to assist health care professionals in the implementation of WHO evidence-based recommendations for pregnant women. The WHO digital ANC module’s creation included the following steps: defining a minimum viable product (MVP), developing clinical workflows and algorithms, algorithm testing, developing a data dictionary, and the creation of a user interface or application development. The overall process of development took approximately 1 year to reach a stable prototype and to finalize the underlying content requirements of the data dictionary and decision support algorithms.ResultsThe first output is a reference software reflecting the generic WHO ANC guideline content, known as the WHO digital ANC module. Within it, all actionable ANC recommendations have related data fields and algorithms to confirm whether the associated task was performed. WHO recommendations that are not carried out by the health care worker are saved as pending tasks on a woman’s health record, and those that are adequately fulfilled trigger messages with positive reinforcement. The second output consists of the structured documentation of the different components which contributed to the development of the WHO digital ANC module, such as the data dictionary and clinical decision support workflows.ConclusionsThis is a novel approach to facilitate the adoption and adaptation of recommendations through digital systems at the health service delivery level. It is expected that the WHO digital ANC module will support the implementation of evidence-based practices and provide information for monitoring and surveillance; however, further evidence is needed to understand how the WHO digital ANC module impacts the implementation of WHO recommendations. Further, the module’s implementation will inform the WHO’s ongoing efforts to create a pathway to adaptive and integrated (Smart) Guidelines in Digital Systems to improve health system quality, coverage, and accountability.

Mapping Regional Well-Being in the Universal Health Coverage System in Taiwan.

PurposeRegarding the universal health coverage (UHC) goal of eliminating health disparity, this study seeks to examine whether this objective has actually been achieved and whether residence affects health and well-being inequality.MethodsBased on Taiwan’s experience with its UHC system, this research quantifies health and well-being indicators, including quality-adjusted life expectancy (QALE), consumption, and utility-adjusted life expectancy (UALE), and uses the geographic information system (GIS) to map regional well-being throughout Taiwan. Using spatial lag regressions, this study estimates how residence and socio-economic factors affect population’s well-being.ResultsEstimation results indicate a 1‰ increase in the mortality rate reduces the population’s UALE by 0.4131 utility-adjusted life-years (UALYs). The differences in health and well-being indicators between urban and rural residents were 6.49 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) and 3.84 UALYs. Residents living in Taipei City had the highest level of QALE, consumption, and well-being, and those in Taitung County had the lowest level of QALE and well-being. The regional spatial autocorrelation results show that a population’s health status and well-being are connected to residence.ConclusionOur estimation results show that risk of higher mortality rates in disadvantaged areas appears to be associated with well-being inequality, even with universal healthcare coverage. We suspect that related health intervention efforts, such as preventive and curative medical devotion, in Taiwan might not have effectively reached more rural residents, and thus recommend more work be undertaken to reduce mortality rates in these communities.

Nonadherence to Immunosuppressive Medications Following Pediatric Kidney Transplantation Within Full Cost Coverage Health System: Prevalence and Correlates.

Pediatric patients are at higher risk of nonadherence to immunosuppressive medication after kidney transplant and the resulting adverse outcomes. Factors associated with nonadherence vary, which follow an epidemiological framework and according to health system patterns. The Brazilian public health system covers all costs of kidney transplant, including immunosuppressive medications. We aimed to assess the prevalence and correlates of nonadherence to immunosuppressive medications in a pediatric kidney transplant population who received free access to immunosuppressive medications within the health care system. In this single-center crosssectional study, we studied a convenience sample of 156 outpatients (< 18 years old) who were a minimum of 4 weeks posttransplant. Implementation nonadherence to immunosuppressive medications was measured by the 4 questions of the Basel Assessment of Adherence to Immunosuppressive Medications Scale. Multilevel correlates to non - adherence (patient, micro, and macro levels) were assessed. In our patient population, 61% were males, mean age was 13.6 ± 3.1 years, 77% were adolescents, and 84% received organs from deceased donors. We found that 33% were nonadherent to immuno - suppressive medications, mainly in timing (25%) and taking (10.9%) dimensions. Being an adolescent (odds ratio: 2.66; CI, 1.02-6.96), religion other than Catholic or Protestant (odds ratio: 4.33; CI, 1.13-16.67), and family income higher than 4 reference wages (odds ratio: 3.50; CI, 1.14-10.75) were factors associated with nonadherence. In our patient population of mostly adolescents, one-third displayed nonadherence to immunosuppressants. Unexpectedly, a higher economic profile, potentially representing better previous access to health care, was independently associated with nonadherence. This result highlights the need for identifying specific correlates to non - adherence before designing interventions.

Child drowning mortality in the Sundarbans, India: Applying the Community Knowledge Approach

Abstract Background The Sundarbans in India is a rural, forested region where children are exposed to a high risk of drowning due to its waterlogged geography. Current data collection systems capture few drowning deaths in this region due to its remoteness and poor coverage of health and police systems. Household methodology was found to be resource and time intensive, and so a Community Knowledge Approach was used and applied to calculate injury mortality for the first time. Methods A community-based survey was conducted in the Sundarbans to determine the drowning mortality rate for 1-4 and 5-9 year old children. A Community Knowledge Approach was applied. Meetings were held with law community residents and key informants to identify drowning deaths in the population. Identified deaths were verified by the child's household through a structured survey, inquiring on the circumstances around the drowning death. Results The drowning mortality rate for children aged 1-4 years old was 243.8 per 100,000 children and 38.8 per 100,000 children for 5-9-year olds. 58.0% of deaths were of 1-2-year-old children. Most children drowned in ponds within 50 metres of their homes. Children were usually unaccompanied with their primary caretaker engaged in household work. Only one third of deaths were reported to hospitals or civil registration systems. Of deaths listed by community members, 63.0% were identified by both residents and by at least one key informant, 25.6% by key informants only, and 11.4% (n = 79) by community residents only. Conclusions Drowning is a major cause of death among children in the Sundarbans, particularly those aged 1-4 years old. The results illustrate how routine data collection systems grossly underestimate drowning deaths, emphasising the importance of community-based in rural low-and middle-income country contexts. Key messages Drowning is likely the largest killer of 1-9 year old children in the Sundarbans region, emphasising the need to better understanding drowning epidemiology in similar rural LMICs contexts. The Community Knowledge Approach provides a low-resource, valid method for capturing injury mortality data.

Vision 2020: looking back and thinking forward on The Lancet Oncology Commissions.

The Lancet Oncology was launched 20 years ago with a mission to bridge the divide between science and clinical practice, and to address the enormous global burden of cancer. Since 2011, The Lancet Oncology Commissions (figure) have been at the core of fulfilling that mandate, representing an important global public good. Together with many relevant Commissions published in The Lancet, the Commissions have made invaluable contributions to understanding and meeting the global cancer challenge, and highlighting the importance of cancer within the health system and universal health coverage.

The Lancet Oncology at 20-two decades of influencing the oncology landscape.

This month's issue of The Lancet Oncology marks our 20-year anniversary. Much has changed in the journal and in oncology alike over the past two decades. The journal has grown from its formative years as a review-only publication into a full research journal; from its early steps as The Lancet's first specialty title to one of the most prominent clinical oncology journals worldwide; and from an educational journal to a publication driving major advances in treatment and health systems. Vision 2020: looking back and thinking forward on The Lancet Oncology CommissionsThe Lancet Oncology was launched 20 years ago with a mission to bridge the divide between science and clinical practice, and to address the enormous global burden of cancer. Since 2011, The Lancet Oncology Commissions (figure) have been at the core of fulfilling that mandate, representing an important global public good. Together with many relevant Commissions published in The Lancet, the Commissions have made invaluable contributions to understanding and meeting the global cancer challenge, and highlighting the importance of cancer within the health system and universal health coverage. Full-Text PDF Multiple brown papules at the site of mastectomy for breast cancerA 39-year-old woman with a history of cancer in the left breast presented to the dermatology department of the Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg (Strasbourg, France) in August, 2019, with progressive multiple brown macules and papules at the site of mastectomy (figure, A). Her breast cancer had been treated with trastuzumab, mastectomy, and radiotherapy (50 Gy) about 1 year before the dermatology appointment. She had a history of Behçet's disease, currently being treated with colchicine and prednisone. Full-Text PDF Ireland's general election: new goals for cancer care?The 2020 Irish general election took place on Feb 8, delivering a major shift in direction for mainstream Irish politics. For the first time in history, Sinn Féin—previously a minority party with historical links to paramilitary organisation the Irish Republican Army (IRA)—won the highest number of votes, changing the once two-party system into a clear three-horse race. Many voters seemed to be calling for change in bringing Sinn Féin to the fore, neck-and-neck with previous opposition party Fianna Fáil, and leaving outgoing Taoiseach (prime minister) Leo Varadkar's Fine Gael party in third place. Full-Text PDF

21.G. Round table: Strengthening national level health systems governance

Abstract Very often, important health system reforms are delayed, rendered ineffective or they simply go badly wrong. All too often this happens not because of a lack of money, health workers or health care facilities but because we adopt unfit ideas and decision and/or implement them insufficiently. The incapacity to develop, adopt and implement good decision is quintessentially the definition of bad governance. If we are to develop our health systems towards Universal Health Coverage and health systems performance improvement, we will need to strengthen our health system governance. Governance is vitally important to health systems reform and refers to how decisions are made and implemented - everything from the ability of policy-makers to take evidence-based and relevant decisions to their ability to implement policies and create alignment between different actors. In this workshop we will share experiences from a governance spring course for policy makers from Eastern Europe and Central Asia. Connected to this we will also share preliminary results of a study on National Level Health Systems Governance. The panelists will address five key issues The contribution of governance to Universal Health Coverage. This contribution will focus on a) the concept of governance defined as the way societies make and implement collective decisions and b) its 5 main domains including transparency, accountability, participation, integrity and capacity. (S Greer)Governance improvement needs in Eastern Europe and Central Asia: experiences from working with policy makers including countries like Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova Tajikistan, Ukraine and Uzbekistan. For purpose of peer-learning and contrasting experiences we have paired these countries with policy makers from Austria, Finland and Ireland (G Pastorino)Stakeholder participation in decision making and implementation: Very often, powerful stakeholders, like the medical profession, is over-represented and exerts immense veto power, while the voice of other professions, patients, and citizens remained unheard. What are the governance strategies and instruments to harness those underrepresented stakeholders for Universal Health Coverage? (G Fattore)Governing centralized and decentralized budgets in primary, social and hospital care: population-based health care in larger countries requires decentralization of part of the health care budget. What are the accountability lines and instruments that ensure that regional and local budget holders aligning with national policies for Universal Health Coverage? (L Hawkins)Governance contribution addressing corruption: According to surveys health systems are perceived prone to corruption. What is the contribution of governance to heal corruption and make the system work according to rules? (D Clarke) Key messages If we are to make progress towards Universal Health Coverage, we will need to strengthen health systems governance. Without strengthening health systems governance we will fail to manage stakeholders, budgets and corruption.

Financial risk protection of individuals with private health insurance

Abstract Background Financial Protection is a key dimension of universal health coverage and health system performance assessment and is also monitored within the framework of the sustainable development goals. Analyses of financial hardship among people who have out-of-pocket (OOP) spending through the use of health services in Germany usually focus solely on households with statutory health insurance due to the peculiarities of private health insurance (PHI) data. This study aims to analyse financial protection among privately insured in Germany. Methods A cross-sectional survey was conducted in 2018 with 20,000 privately insured in Germany. The survey comprised questions on household net-income, OOP spending on health, unmet needs, perceived financial burden). Catastrophic expenditure was analysed and defined as share of households with OOP spending greater than 10% of household income. Further results on financial protection and access are based on descriptive analyses. Results A total of 3,601 participants (18.0%) completed the survey (58.6 years ± 14.6; 64.6% male). 82.2% of households reported OOP spending, mostly on OTC drugs, deductibles and medical aids. Median OOP spending was €300-499 per year. Average OOP spending as share of household income was 1.3% and 0.6% of households have catastrophic OOP spending. In total, 6.6% of respondents reported unmet needs due to financial barriers, of which 5.3% had no OOP spending. 11.2% of all respondents reported to feel strongly financially burdened by OOP spending with a gap between the lowest (26.2%) and highest income group (9.9%). Conclusions PHI insured have comparatively low OOP spending with less than 1% of households having catastrophic expenditures on health. However, 6.2% of respondents reported to forgo care due to financial reasons which supports the assumption that OOP payments can create a barrier to access. Unmet needs and financial burden are higher in lower income groups which raises concerns about equity. Key messages Financial protection is good among privately insured in Germany with only few households reporting catastrophic expenditures which indicates a broad and sufficient benefit coverage under PHI. Although out-of-pocket spending is low, privately insured perceive a strong financial burden (particularly in lower income groups) and face financial barriers to access care mirrored in forgone care.