You have accessJournal of UrologyPediatrics: Stone Disease & Tumors1 Apr 20111376 ONCOLOGIC OUTCOMES OF PARTIAL (PN) VERSUS RADICAL NEPHRECTOMY (RN) FOR UNILATERAL WILMS TUMOR (UWT) Nicholas Cost, Jessica Lubahn, Heidi Penn, Candace Granberg, Bruce Schlomer, Jonathan Wickiser, Dinesh Rakheja, Patricio Gargollo, David Leonard, Linda Baker, and Vitaly Margulis Nicholas CostNicholas Cost Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Jessica LubahnJessica Lubahn Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Heidi PennHeidi Penn Kansas City, KS More articles by this author , Candace GranbergCandace Granberg Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Bruce SchlomerBruce Schlomer Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Jonathan WickiserJonathan Wickiser Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Dinesh RakhejaDinesh Rakheja Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Patricio GargolloPatricio Gargollo Dallas, TX More articles by this author , David LeonardDavid Leonard Dallas, TX More articles by this author , Linda BakerLinda Baker Dallas, TX More articles by this author , and Vitaly MargulisVitaly Margulis Dallas, TX More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2011.02.1221AboutPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES According to the Children's Oncology Group (COG) and International Society of Paediatric Oncology (SIOP), the recommended surgical management for UWT is RN. However, recent data demonstrate that when oncologically feasible, PN decreases the likelihood of chronic renal disease and associated co-morbidities. Thus, we analyzed oncologic outcomes of patients undergoing PN vs. RN for UWT. METHODS We searched Pub Med with the terms: “WT,” “Nephroblastoma,” “PN” and “Nephron Sparing Surgery.” Reviewing citations and eliminating repeat reports we found 19 groups presenting 115 patients treated with PN for UWT. These were analyzed for: stage, recurrence, recurrence location, and overall survival (OS). 82 patients from 16 groups had adequate data for analysis. As a comparison, the same endpoints were collected on all children who had RN for UWT from 1985-2010 at Children's Medical Center. RESULTS Of the 82 PN patients, 64 were stage I, 10 stage II, 6 stage III and 2 stage IV; however, this was a mix of patients staged/treated according to SIOP or COG protocols. Of the 121 RN patients, 24 were stage I, 45 stage II, 29 stage III and 23 stage IV. All of these children were treated in compliance with COG protocols. In the PN group, there were 9 total recurrences, 6 local recurrences, and 4 deaths. At a median follow up of 48mo (3–372) for the PN group, the recurrence free survival (RFS), local RFS and OS were 89.1%, 92.7% and 95.1% respectively. In the RN group, there were 20 total recurrences, 6 local recurrences, and 6 deaths. At a median follow up of 69.3mo (0.1–214.1) for the RN group, the RFS, local RFS and OS were of 83.1%, 95.0% and 95.0% respectively. When controlling for stage in a Cox Regression Analysis, there were no statistically significant differences in the above oncologic outcomes between the groups. The Hazard Ratio (HR) for the RN group vs. PN group was: for RFS HR=0.95 (95% CI 0.39–2.34), for local RFS HR=0.77 (95% CI 0.21–2.9) and for OS HR=0.45 (95% CI 0.17–4.39). CONCLUSIONS Based on reported data, the oncologic outcomes of PN for UWT in a select patient population do not appear to differ from those of RN. With the potential for renal preservation and its associated benefits, PN for appropriately selected patients should be studied in a prospective, cooperative group trial versus RN to definitively assess its role in management of UWT. © 2011 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 185Issue 4SApril 2011Page: e549 Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 2011 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.MetricsAuthor Information Nicholas Cost Dallas, TX More articles by this author Jessica Lubahn Dallas, TX More articles by this author Heidi Penn Kansas City, KS More articles by this author Candace Granberg Dallas, TX More articles by this author Bruce Schlomer Dallas, TX More articles by this author Jonathan Wickiser Dallas, TX More articles by this author Dinesh Rakheja Dallas, TX More articles by this author Patricio Gargollo Dallas, TX More articles by this author David Leonard Dallas, TX More articles by this author Linda Baker Dallas, TX More articles by this author Vitaly Margulis Dallas, TX More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement Advertisement PDF downloadLoading ...