Hard Tail Research Articles

Simultaneous NICER and NuSTAR observations of the ultraluminous source NGC 4190 ULX-1

Aims. We present an X-ray analysis of three different XMM-Newton observations together with simultaneous NICER and NuSTAR observations of the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 4190 ULX-1. Our goal is to constrain the structure of the accretion disk and the geometrical properties of the source. Methods. We performed temporal and spectral analyses in the 0.4−30 keV energy range in which the source is significantly detected in dedicated XMM-Newton, NICER, and NuSTAR observations. Results. The temporal analysis shows no flaring activity in the light curves. No pulsation is detected throughout. The source exhibits a typical ULX spectrum, which can be fitted with two thermal blackbody components plus a Comptonization tail at high energies. The luminosity–temperature (L − T) relation of each thermal spectral component is consistent with the L ∝ T2 relation expected from an advection-dominated supercritical disk. Conclusions. We interpret these results as a super-Eddington accreting black hole seen almost face-on. A dense wind ejected from the disk obscures the central source, and a hot electron plasma is evacuated through the funnel formed above the hole. Geometric beaming is responsible for the ULX soft emission, whereas the hard tail is the result of the Comptonization of soft photons by the electrons ejected through the funnel.

The high energy X-ray probe (HEX-P): magnetars and other isolated neutron stars

The hard X-ray emission from magnetars and other isolated neutron stars remains under-explored. An instrument with higher sensitivity to hard X-rays is critical to understanding the physics of neutron star magnetospheres and also the relationship between magnetars and Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs). High sensitivity to hard X-rays is required to determine the number of magnetars with hard X-ray tails, and to track transient non-thermal emission from these sources for years post-outburst. This sensitivity would also enable previously impossible studies of the faint non-thermal emission from middle-aged rotation-powered pulsars (RPPs), and detailed phase-resolved spectroscopic studies of younger, bright RPPs. The High Energy X-ray Probe (HEX-P) is a probe-class mission concept that will combine high spatial resolution X-ray imaging (<5 arcsec half-power diameter (HPD) at 0.2–25 keV) and broad spectral coverage (0.2–80 keV) with a sensitivity superior to current facilities (including XMM-Newton and NuSTAR). HEX-P has the required timing resolution to perform follow-up observations of sources identified by other facilities and positively identify candidate pulsating neutron stars. Here we discuss how HEX-P is ideally suited to address important questions about the physics of magnetars and other isolated neutron stars.

Insight-HXMT Detections of Hard X-Ray Tails in Scorpius X-1

Using the observations of the high-energy detector of the Hard X-ray Modulation Telescope (Insight-HXMT) for Scorpius X-1 from 2017 to 2020, we search for hard X-ray tails in the X-ray spectra in ∼30–200 keV. The hard X-ray tails are found throughout the Z-track on the hardness–intensity diagram, and the detected hard X-ray tails become hard and weak from the horizontal branch (HB), through the normal branch (NB), to the flaring branch (FB). Comparing the hard X-ray spectra of Insight-HXMT between Cyg X-1 and Sco X-1, it is concluded that the hard X-ray spectrum of Cyg X-1 shows a high-energy cutoff, implying a hot corona in it, but the high-energy cutoff is not seen in the hard X-ray spectrum of Sco X-1. From fitting the broadband spectrum of Sco X-1 in ∼2–200 keV, it is proposed that the hard X-ray tails in the HB and NB can be explained by the overall Comptonization COMPTB model, suggesting that the hard X-ray tails could have resulted from the Comptonization of the photons from the neutron star (NS) surface by the thermal electrons in the region between the NS and the disk and the energetic electrons in the freefall toward the NS in the converging flow onto the NS. However, this model cannot be responsible for the hard X-ray tails in the FB. Further study on the FB hard X-ray tails is needed.

Nustar observation of the binary system 4U 0114 + 65

ABSTRACT The high-mass X-ray binary system 4U 0114 + 65 was observed by Nustar in October 2019 and by XMM-Newton in August 2015. Here we performed spectral and timing analysis of the Nustar observation and carry out timing analysis on the XMM-Newton data. We measured the spin period of the neutron star from both observations and found a spin-up rate $\dot{p}$ = 1.54 ± 0.38 × 10−6$\mathrm{s\, s}^{-1}$ . During the Nustar observation, two flares occurred, one shortly after the start of the observation and the other near the end separated by a long period of low/quiescent state. The large and sudden flares mostly resulted from accretion of corotating interaction region (CIR) material. A common spectral model to high mass X-ray binaries (HMXBs), powerlaw with high energy cutoff and absorption at low energy, gave a good fit to both flaring and quiescent states. A fluorescent iron line was not required in fitting any of the states. On the other hand, very tentative evidence of Cyclotron Resonant Scattering Feature (CRSF) at ∼17 keV was found during fitting using cyclabs model; however, fitting improvement was not significant enough to confirm its detection, plus a very narrow width (<1 keV) was obtained for the line and its first harmonic. Visual inspection of the spectra showed a deficiency of emission near the expected first and second harmonic. Another important feature visually noticed in the spectra is the presence of hard tail above 50 keV. This could be explained by the shocked material bounding the CIR.

AstroSat and NuSTAR observations of XTE J1739−285 during the 2019–2020 outburst

ABSTRACT We report results from a study of XTE J1739−285, a transient neutron star low mass X-ray binary observed with AstroSat and NuSTAR during its 2019–2020 outburst. We detected accretion-powered X-ray pulsations at 386 Hz during very short intervals (0.5–1 s) of X-ray flares. These flares were observed during the 2019 observation of XTE J1739−285. During this observation, we also observed a correlation between intensity and hardness ratios, suggesting an increase in hardness with the increase in intensity. Moreover, a thermonuclear X-ray burst detected in our AstroSat observation during the 2020 outburst revealed the presence of coherent burst oscillations at 383 Hz during its decay phase. The frequency drift of 3 Hz during X-ray burst can be explained with r modes. Thus, making XTE J1739−285 belong to a subset of NS-LMXBs which exhibit both nuclear- and accretion-powered pulsations. The power density spectrum created using the AstroSat-laxpc observations in 2020 showed the presence of a quasi-periodic oscillation at ∼0.83 Hz. Our X-ray spectroscopy revealed significant changes in the spectra during the 2019 and 2020 outburst. We found a broad iron line emission feature in the X-ray spectrum during the 2020 observation, while this feature was relatively narrow and has a lower equivalent width in 2019, when the source was accreting at higher rates than 2020. Hard X-ray tail was observed during the 2019 observations, indicating the presence of non-thermal component in the X-ray spectra.

The 2022 High-energy Outburst and Radio Disappearing Act of the Magnetar 1E 1547.0–5408

We report the radio and high-energy properties of a new outburst from the radio-loud magnetar 1E 1547.0−5408. Following the detection of a short burst from the source with Swift-BAT on 2022 April 7, observations by NICER detected an increased flux peaking at (6.0 ± 0.4) × 10−11 erg s−1 cm−2 in the soft X-ray band, falling to a baseline level of 1.7 × 10−11 erg s−1 cm−2 over a 17 day period. Joint spectroscopic measurements by NICER and NuSTAR indicated no change in the hard nonthermal tail despite the prominent increase in soft X-rays. Observations at radio wavelengths with Murriyang, the 64 m Parkes radio telescope, revealed that the persistent radio emission from the magnetar disappeared at least 22 days prior to the initial Swift-BAT detection and was redetected two weeks later. Such behavior is unprecedented in a radio-loud magnetar, and may point to an unnoticed slow rise in the high-energy activity prior to the detected short bursts. Finally, our combined radio and X-ray timing revealed the outburst coincided with a spin-up glitch, where the spin frequency and spin-down rate increased by 0.2 ± 0.1 μHz and (−2.4 ± 0.1) × 10−12 s−2, respectively. A linear increase in the spin-down rate of (−2.0 ± 0.1) × 10−19 s−3 was also observed over 147 days of postoutburst timing. Our results suggest that the outburst may have been associated with a reconfiguration of the quasi-polar field lines, likely signaling a changing twist, accompanied by spatially broader heating of the surface and a brief quenching of the radio signal, yet without any measurable impact on the hard X-ray properties.

NICER/NuSTAR Characterization of 4U 1957+11: A Near Maximally Spinning Black Hole Potentially in the Mass Gap

4U 1957+11 is a black hole candidate system that has been in a soft X-ray spectral state since its discovery. We present analyses of recent joint NICER and NuSTAR spectra, which are extremely well described by a highly inclined disk accreting into a near maximally spinning black hole. Owing to the broad X-ray coverage of NuSTAR, the fitted spin and inclination are strongly constrained for our hypothesized disk models. The faintest spectra are observed out to 20 keV, even though their hard tail components are almost absent when described with a simple corona. The hard tail increases with luminosity, but shows clear two-track behavior with one track having appreciably stronger tails. The disk spectrum color-correction factor is anticorrelated with the strength of the hard tail (e.g., as measured by the Compton y parameter). Although the spin and inclination parameters are strongly constrained for our chosen model, the mass and distance are degenerate parameters. We use our spectral fits, along with a theoretical prior on color-correction, an observational prior on likely fractional Eddington luminosity, and an observational prior on distance obtained from Gaia studies, to present mass and distance contours for this system. The most likely parameters, given our presumed disk model, suggest a 4.6 M ⊙ black hole at 7.8 kpc observed at luminosities ranging from ≈1.7% to 9% of Eddington. This would place 4U 1957+11 as one of the few actively accreting sources within the mass gap of ≈2–5 M ⊙ where there are few known massive neutron stars or low-mass black holes. Higher mass and distance, however, remain viable.

MAXI J1535–571 2017 Outburst Seen by INTEGRAL/SPI and Investigating the Origin of Its Hard Tail

On 2017 September 2 MAXI J1535–571 went into outburst and peaked at ∼5 Crab in the 2–20 keV energy range. Early in the flare, the INTErnational Gamma-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory (INTEGRAL) performed target of opportunity pointings and monitored the source as it transitioned from the hard state to the soft state. Using quasi-simultaneous observations from MAXI/GSC and INTEGRAL/SPI, we studied the temporal and spectral evolution of MAXI J1535–571 in the 2–500 keV range. Early spectra show a Comptonized spectrum and a high-energy component dominant above ∼150 keV. CompTT fits to the SPectrometer on INTEGRAL (SPI) data found electron temperatures (kT e ) evolve from ∼31 keV to 18 keV with a tied optical depth (τ ∼ 0.85) or τ evolving from ∼1.2–0.65 with a tied kT e (∼24 keV). To investigate the nature of the high-energy component, we performed a spectral decomposition of the 100–400 keV energy band. The CompTT flux varies significantly during the hard state while the high-energy component flux is consistent with a constant flux. This result suggests that the two components originate from different locations, which favors a jet origin interpretation for the high-energy component over a hybrid corona interpretation. Lastly, two short rebrightenings during the hard-to-soft transition are compared to similar events reported in MAXI J1820+070.

Contributors

Contributors

Monitoring observations of SMC X-1’s excursions (MOOSE)–I. Programme description and initial high state spectral results

ABSTRACT SMC X-1 has exhibited three superorbital period excursions since the onset of X-ray monitoring beginning with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer's launch in 1995. TheNeutron star Interior Composition Explorer has recently probed a fourth observed excursion beginning in 2021 with our programme monitoring observations of SMC X-1’s excursions (moose). These sensitive new moose data probe different superorbital periods and phases within them. Spectral fits to the high-state continuum during 2021 April to 2022 January show that the intrinsic spectral shapes are characterized by a soft (kT ∼ 0.19 keV) disc component and a hard (Γ ∼ 0.7) power-law tail. When the 2021–2022 NICER observations, taken during an excursion, are compared to 2016 XMM–Newton observations (outside of an excursion), we find little evidence for intrinsic spectral variability across the high states, but find evidence for a >3σ change in the absorption, although we caution that there may be calibration differences between the two instruments. Thus, over different lengths of superorbital periods, we see little evidence for intrinsic spectral changes in the high state. Upcoming studies of the pulse profiles may shed light on the mechanism behind the excursions.

Fe Kαand Fe Kβline detection in theNuSTARspectrum of the ultra-bright Z source Scorpius X–1

Context.Low-mass X-ray binaries hosting a low-magnetised neutron star, which accretes matter via Roche-lobe overflow, are generally grouped into two classes called Atoll and Z sources after the path described in their X-ray colour-colour diagrams. Scorpius X–1 is the brightest persistent low-mass X-ray binary known so far, and it is the prototype of the Z sources.Aims.We analysed the firstNuSTARobservation of this source to study its spectral emission, exploiting the high-statistics data collected by this satellite. The colour-colour diagram shows that the source was probably observed during the lower normal and flaring branches of its Z track. We separated the data from the two branches in order to investigate the evolution of the source along the track.Methods.We fitted the 3−60 keVNuSTARspectra using the same models for the two branches. We adopted two descriptions for the continuum: in the first case, we used a blackbody and a thermal Comptonisation with seed photons originating in the accretion disc, and in the second case, we adopted a disc-blackbody and a Comptonisation with a blackbody-shaped spectrum of the incoming seed photons. A power-law fitting of the high-energy emission above 20 keV was also required in both cases.Results.The two models provide the same physical scenario for the source in the two branches: a blackbody temperature between 0.8 and 1.5 keV, a disc-blackbody with a temperature between 0.4 and 0.6 keV, and an optically thick Comptonising corona with an optical depth between 6 and 10 and a temperature about 3 keV. Furthermore, two lines related to the Kαand Kβtransitions of the He-like Fe XXVions were detected at 6.6 keV and 7.8 keV, respectively. A hard tail modelled by a power law with a photon index between 2 and 3 was also required for the two models.

Exploring the inner-disc region of the atoll source 4U 1705-44 using AstroSat’s SXT and LAXPC observations

ABSTRACT For the first time, simultaneous broad-band spectral and timing study of the atoll source 4U 1705-44 was performed using AstroSat Soft X-ray Telescope (SXT) and Large Area X-ray Proportional Counter (LAXPC) data (0.8–70 keV). Based on the HID, the source was in the soft banana state during these observations. Spectral modelling was performed using the full reflection framework and an inner disc radii of 14 Rg was obtained. A hard power-law tail was noticed in the soft state and hot component fluxes and varying power-law indices point towards a varying corona/sub-Keplerian flow. Based on the spectral fits, the boundary layer radius and magnetospheric radius were constrained to be ∼14–18 and ∼9–19 km, respectively. Cross-correlation function studies were performed between the 0.8–3 keV soft SXT light curve and 10–20 keV hard LAXPC light curve and correlated and anticorrelated lags were found, which was used to constrain the coronal height to 0.6–20 km (β = 0.1). Since the inner disc radius is not varying during the observations, we conclude that the detected lags are possibly caused by a varying structure of corona/boundary layer in the inner region of the accretion disc. Based on the observations, a geometrical model is proposed for explaining the detected lags in the atoll source 4U 1705-44.

Spectral and timing properties of the black hole candidate X1755−338 observed in 1989–1995

Abstract We report results of an analysis of the black hole (BH) candidate source X1755−338 made in 1989, 1990, and 1991 with Ginga, and in 1995 with ASCA. The spectra were well represented by a model consisting of a soft thermal emission from an accretion disk and a hard X-ray tail. The normalization of the multi-color disk, related to the inner disk radius, was similar to each other. The unabsorbed X-ray fluxes from the disk component in the 0.01–10 keV band were estimated to be 1.3 × 10−9, 3.0 × 10−9, 9.8 × 10−10, and 2.4 × 10−9 erg s−1 cm−2 in 1989, 1990, 1991, and 1995, respectively, and are proportional to $kT_{\rm in}^4$, where kTin is a temperature at the inner disk radius. Based on the standard accretion disk model for a non-rotating BH, our results suggest either a small BH mass or a large inclination angle. Otherwise, X1755−338 is a rotating BH. The hard X-ray intensity was found to be variable, while the soft X-ray intensity was stable. Although previous work showed the existence of an iron line at 6.7 keV, no clear iron line feature was found in any of the spectra. We infer that most of the iron line flux reported in the previous work was due to contamination of the Galactic diffuse X-ray emission.

Insight-HXMT Observations of a Possible Fast Transition from the Jet- to Wind-dominated State during a Huge Flare of GRS 1915+105

Abstract We present the analysis of the brightest flare that was recorded in the Insight-HMXT data set in a broad energy range (2–200 keV) from the microquasar GRS 1915+105 during an unusual low-luminosity state. This flare was detected by Insight-HXMT among a series of flares during 2019 June 2 UTC 16:37:06–20:11:36 with a 2–200 keV luminosity of 3.4–7.27 × 1038 erg s−1. Basing on the broadband spectral analysis, we find that the flare spectrum shows different behaviors during bright and faint epochs. The spectrum of the flare can be fitted with a model dominated by a power-law component. Additional components show up in the bright epoch with a hard tail and in the faint epoch with an absorption line of ∼6.78 keV. The reflection component of the latter is consistent with an inner disk radius ∼five times larger than that of the former. These results on the giant flare during the “unusual” low-luminosity state of GRS 1915+105 may suggest that the source experiences a possible fast transition from a jet-dominated state to a wind-dominated state. We speculate that the evolving accretion disk and the large-scale magnetic field may play important roles in this peculiar huge flare.

A study of the hard X-ray spectral tails in Scorpius X-1 using RXTE observations

ABSTRACT Using all the data of the High Energy X-ray Timing Experiment (HEXTE) on board the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer for Scorpius X-1 from 1996 February to 2012 January, we systematically search for hard X-ray tails in the X-ray spectra in 20–220 keV and, together with the data of the Proportional Counter Array (PCA), investigate the evolution of the detected hard X-ray tails along the Z-track on its hardness-intensity diagram (HID). The hard X-ray tails are detected in 30 observations and their presence is not confined to a specific position on the HID. Our analysis suggests that from the horizontal branch (HB), through the normal branch (NB), to the flaring branch (FB) on the HID, the hard X-ray tail becomes hard and its flux decreases. Jointly fitting the PCA+HEXTE spectra in 3–220 keV, it is found that the Bulk-Motion Comptonization (BMC) could be an alternative mechanism for producing the hard X-ray tails on the HB and the NB of this source. The temperature of the seed photons for the BMC spans in the range of ∼(2.4–2.6) keV, indicating that the seed photons might come from the surface of the neutron star (NS) or the boundary layer and, therefore, the BMC process could take place around the NS or in the boundary layer. Some possible mechanisms for producing the hard X-ray tails on the FB are given.

Correction to: AstroSat/LAXPC view of GX 17+2: spectral evolution along the Z-track

In the Discussion section of the initial online publication an incorrect percentage was specified for the observed contribution of the hard X-ray tail in the middle and upper flaring branch to the total flux of 3.0–80.0 keV. The original article has been corrected.

Fundamental physics with blazar spectra: a critical appraisal

ABSTRACT Very-high-energy (VHE) BL Lacertae (BL Lac) spectra extending above $10 \, \rm TeV$ provide a unique opportunity for testing physics beyond the standard model of elementary particle and alternative blazar emission models. We consider the hadron beam scenario, the conversion of photons to axion-like particles (ALPs) and the Lorentz invariance violation (LIV) by analysing their consequences and induced modifications to BL Lac spectra. In particular, we consider how different processes can provide similar spectral features (e.g. hard tails) and we discuss the ways they can be disentangled. We use data from High-Energy Gamma-Ray Astronomy (HEGRA) of a high state of Markarian 501 and the High-Energy Stereoscopic System (H.E.S.S.) spectrum of the extreme BL Lac (EHBL) 1ES 0229+200. In addition, we consider two hypothetical EHBLs similar to 1ES 0229+200 located at redshifts z = 0.3 and z = 0.5. We observe that both the hadron beam and the photon–ALP oscillations predict a hard tail extending to energies larger than those possible in the standard scenario. Photon–ALP interaction predicts a peak in the spectra of distant BL Lacs at about $20\rm {-}30 \, \rm TeV$, while LIV produces a strong peak in all BL Lac spectra around $\sim 100 \, \rm TeV$. The peculiar feature of the photon–ALP conversion model is the production of oscillations in the spectral energy distribution, so that its detection/absence can be exploited to distinguish between the considered models. The above-mentioned features of the three models might be detected by the upcoming Cherenkov Telescope Array. Thus, future observations of BL Lac spectra could eventually shed light on new physics and alternative blazar emission models, driving fundamental research towards a specific direction.

New insights on the puzzling LMXB 1RXS J180408.9-342058: the intermediate state, the clocked type-I X-ray bursts, and much more

ABSTRACT 1RXS J180408.9–342058 is a low-mass X-ray binary hosting a neutron star, which shows X-ray activity at very different mass-accretion regimes, from very faint to almost the Eddington luminosity. In this work, we present a comprehensive X-ray study of this source using data from the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory, NuSTAR, and INTEGRAL/JEM-X. In order to follow the spectral evolution, we analysed the 2015 outburst using Swift data and three NuSTAR observations. Besides the canonical hard and soft spectral states, we identified the rarely observed intermediate state. This was witnessed by the appearance of the accretion disc emission in the spectrum (at kTdisc ∼0.7 keV) and the simultaneous cooling of the hot corona. In addition, we also unveiled a hard tail above 30 keV in this state. In the hard state, a thermal Comptonization model with two seed photons populations (kTs,1 ∼ 1.5 keV and kTs,2 ∼ 0.4 keV, respectively) and a hot Comptonizing plasma, represents the physically best motivated scenario to describe the data. We also estimated a reflection fraction below 20 per cent in all states, while no constraints on the inclination and only lower limits on the inner disc radius could be inferred. Finally, we studied a number of type-I X-ray bursts displayed from the source, one of them at the Eddington limit (observed with JEM-X). Their characteristics, combined with the clocked behaviour observed during the intermediate state, point out H/He composition for the accreted material, which makes unlikely the helium dwarf nature for the companion.

Opacities for photon splitting and pair creation in neutron star magnetospheres

ABSTRACT Over the last four decades, persistent and flaring emission of magnetars observed by various telescopes has provided us with a suite of light curves and spectra in soft and hard X-rays, with no emission yet detected above around 1 MeV. Attenuation of such high-energy photons by magnetic pair creation and photon splitting is expected to be active in the magnetospheres of magnetars, possibly accounting for the paucity of gamma-rays in their signals. This paper explores polarization-dependent opacities for these two QED processes in static vacuum dipole magnetospheres of highly magnetized neutron stars, calculating attenuation lengths and determining escape energies, which are the maximum photon energies for transparency out to infinity. The numerical trajectory integral analysis in flat and curved space–times provides upper bounds of a few MeV or less to the visible energies for magnetars for locales proximate to the stellar surface. Photon splitting opacity alone puts constraints on the possible emission locales in their magnetospheres: regions within field loops of maximum altitudes $\, r_{{\rm max}}\sim 2\!-\!4\,$ stellar radii are not commensurate with maximum detected energies of around 250 keV. These constraints apply not only to magnetar flares but also to their quiescent hard X-ray tail emission. An exploration of photon splitting attenuation in the context of a resonant inverse Compton scattering model for the hard X-ray tails derives distinctive phase-resolved spectroscopic and polarimetric signatures, of significant interest for future MeV-band missions such as AMEGO and e-ASTROGAM.

Investigating ULX accretion flows and cyclotron resonance in NGC 300 ULX1

Aims. We investigate accretion models for the newly discovered pulsating ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX) NGC 300 ULX1. Methods. We analyzed broadband XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of NGC 300 ULX1, performing phase-averaged and phase-resolved spectroscopy. Using the Bayesian framework, we compared two physically motivated models for the source spectrum: Non-thermal accretion column emission modeled by a power law with a high-energy exponential roll-off (AC model), and multicolor thermal emission from an optically thick accretion envelope plus a hard power-law tail (MCAE model). The AC model is an often used phenomenological model for the emission of X-ray pulsars, while the MCAE model has recently been proposed for the emission of the optically thick accretion envelope that is expected to form in ultraluminous (LX > 1039 erg s−1), highly magnetized accreting neutron stars. We combined the findings of our Bayesian analysis with qualitative physical considerations to evaluate the suitability of each model. Results. The low-energy part (< 2 keV) of the source spectrum is dominated by non-pulsating, multicolor thermal emission. The (pulsating) high-energy continuum is more ambiguous. If modeled with the AC model, a residual structure is detected that can be modeled using a broad Gaussian absorption line centered at ∼12 keV. However, the same residuals can be successfully modeled using the MCAE model, without the need for the absorption-like feature. Model comparison using the Bayesian approach strongly indicates that the MCAE model without the absorption line is the preferred model. Conclusions. The spectro-temporal characteristics of NGC 300 ULX1 are consistent with previously reported traits for X-ray pulsars and (pulsating) ULXs. All models considered strongly indicate the presence of an accretion disk that is truncated at a large distance from the central object, as has recently been suggested for a large portion of both pulsating and non-pulsating ULXs. The hard, pulsed emission is not described by a smooth spectral continuum. If modeled by a broad Gaussian absorption line, the fit residuals can be interpreted as a cyclotron scattering feature (CRSF) compatible with a ∼1012 G magnetic field. However, the MCAE model can successfully describe the spectral and temporal characteristics of the source emission, without the need for an additional absorption feature, and it yields physically meaningful parameter values. Therefore strong doubts are cast on the presence of a CRSF in NGC 300 ULX1.