Before Civil War, most popular outdoor activity in New York City may have been fighting. The prize ring was popular, but rioting in streets and public squares attracted more participants. In fact, there was little distinction between professional pugilists and gang brawlers. Heavyweights like John Morrissey were also employed shoulder-hitters by political gangs like Empire Club, run by Captain Isaiah Rynders, a leading Democrat, or Boys of Bill the Butcher Poole, hero of Know-Nothings.Rynders and his crew delighted in attacking abolitionist gatherings. In May 1850 they showed up in force at antislavery convention at Broadway Tabernacle. Speaker Frederick Douglass defused attack by inviting a racist orator to share platform. To argument that Negroes were a kind of ape, Douglass, whose father was probably a slave-owner, responded:Captain Rynders, do think I am a monkey?Oh no, replied Rynders, you are half a white man.Then I am half man and half monkey?Yes.And half brother to Captain Rynders?With audience united in laughter and applause, Douglass spoke his piece. It was a short-lived triumph, however. Threats of mayhem truncated conference and, several days later, while walking with two white women in Battery Park, Douglass was assaulted.1A year later, on May 27, 1851, Elysian Fields in Hoboken was scene of what Brooklyn Eagle described as... one of most earnest and angry promiscuous fights that has ever occurred in this country. The Germans of this city, with their families, assembled in large numbers in Hoboken, for celebration of their Maifest. Scarcely two hours had elapsed when they were set upon by a party of rascals called Short Boys.At first Germans were disposed to avoid a conflict, but finding it impossible to do so, they sallied out against them, and drove them to Elysian Fields. The Boys took refuge in a house kept by one McCarthy, which was attacked by Germans, and greatly injured. McCarthy, in defense of himself and his house, shot two of Germans with a double barreled gun, killing them, it is said.2Fortunately, this incident did not disrupt plans of tenants of Club Room at McCarty's Colonnade House. The Knickerbocker Base Ball Club had been challenged to play a home-and-home series by recently formed Washington Club. After a promising start, Knickerbockers had been, in words of D. L. Adams, in pursuit of pleasure under difficulties. There was then no rivalry, he recalled, as no other club was formed until 1850, and during these five years baseball had a desperate struggle for existence.3It happened that first match, on June 3, was away game at Red House Grounds in Harlem. Down 7-3 after two innings, Knickerbockers rallied to win 21-11. Two weeks later, clubs met for a thrilling return match at Elysian Fields, with home club managing a 22-20 victory. As usual, an entertainment was given after play at McCarty's Hotel.Since 1844, waiters at Colonnade House had been privy to world of New York and Knickerbocker Base Ball clubs, had watched their game develop in neighboring fields, and were a fixture at convivial dinners when plays and points were reviewed. The Stevens family, which owned Hoboken grounds, like many upperclass New Yorkers employed colored help. Michael McCarty, born in Ireland, employed his countrymen barkeepers but conformed to expectations of his gentlemen patrons by hiring black servants (including live-in waiter Jeremiah Jackson).This link between early baseball and black New Yorkers was soon severed, however. On March 7, 1852, Brooklyn Eagle reported that Mr. McCarty of Elysian Fields Hotel, was accidentally shot and killed by his own act yesterday. Sarah McCarty, 27 years old with four children under age of nine, was leftin charge. …