Growth Rate-dependent Regulation Research Articles

In vivo regulatory responses of four Escherichia coli operons which encode leucyl-tRNAs.

Four Escherichia coli operons, the leuV operon which encodes tRNA(1Leu), the leuX operon which encodes tRNA(6Leu), the metT operon which encodes tRNA(3Leu), and the argT operon which encodes tRNA(1Leu), were examined for the stringent response induced by serine hydroxamate and for growth rate-dependent regulation. In nuclease protection assays, the leuV operon displayed the stringent response in response to leucine starvation, analog inhibition, and growth of a temperature-sensitive leucyl-tRNA synthetase mutant at nonpermissive temperatures. The leuV operon also exhibited the stringent response in multicopy plasmids. The promoters of all four leucyl operons were fused to the gene for beta-galactosidase and inserted into the chromosome by using bacteriophage lambda. All except the leuX promoter displayed growth rate-dependent regulation, consistent with the recent report that the concentration of tRNA(6Leu) actually decreases as growth rate increases. The leuV promoter fused to the beta-galactosidase gene showed a decrease in efficiency in the presence of extrachromosomal copies of rRNA genes. All chromosomal tRNA genes examined showed decreased transcriptional activity following a stringent response, but the leuX gene responded to a lesser extent (3-fold versus 10-fold or more) than the others. Primer extension analysis of this promoter showed little if any response to serine hydroxamate treatment, suggesting that multiple levels of control may exist or that promoter context effects are important in regulation.

Mutagenesis and functional analysis of the Escherichia coli tRNA(1Leu) promoter.

The leuV promoter which produces tRNA(1Leu) in Escherichia coli has been extensively mutagenized in order to determine the effects of altered sequences on promoter efficiency (strength) and on growth-rate-dependent regulation (GDR). Each mutant promoter was ligated with a beta-galactosidase reporter gene into the chromosome of a host cell by phage lambda lysogenization. Reporter gene activities were measured for cells growing in selected media at various growth rates. Sequences which flank the -10 consensus region, when altered, caused remarkable up-promoter effects, increasing efficiency in some cases almost 10-fold. One up mutation which had five successive T residues in the 'discriminator' region completely abolished GDR, whereas several mutations with single base changes in the discriminator had little or no effect on GDR. Another mutation which changed one base in the -35 region to bring it to consensus increased promoter strength 18-fold and sharply reduced GDR. Chimaeric promoters in which segments of leuV were replaced by segments of the his operon showed that only when the discriminator of leuV is replaced by the his discriminator was GDR-disturbed. All upstream sequences which were replaced by his sequences had little effect on GDR. Overall, there appeared to be little correlation between promoter efficiency and GDR.

Molecular characterization of mutations affecting expression level and growth rate-dependent regulation of the Escherichia coli zwf gene

We characterized three cis dominant mutations which elevate glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase level. Growth rate-dependent regulation and oxidative stress control of enzyme level were altered by the mutations. DNA sequencing and transcript mapping showed that the "up" mutations created new promoters whose hyperactive expression overrides the normal regulation of the native promoter.

Genetic and physical analyses of the growth rate-dependent regulation of Escherichia coli zwf expression

Growth rate-dependent regulation of the level of Escherichia coli glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase, encoded by zwf, and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, encoded by gnd, is similar during steady-state growth and after nutritional upshifts. To determine whether the mechanism regulating zwf expression is like that of gnd, which involves a site of posttranscriptional control located within the structural gene, we prepared and analyzed a set of zwf-lacZ protein fusions in which the fusion joints are distributed across the glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase coding sequence. Expression of beta-galactosidase from the protein fusions was as growth rate dependent as that of glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase itself, indicating that regulation does not involve an internal regulatory region. The level of beta-galactosidase in zwf-lac operon fusion strains and the level of zwf mRNA from a wild-type strain increased with increasing growth rate, which suggests that growth rate control is exerted on the mRNA level. The half-life of the zwf mRNA mass was 3.0 min during growth on glucose and 3.4 min during growth on acetate. Thus, zwf transcription appears to be the target for growth rate control of the glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase level.

The trmA promoter has regulatory features and sequence elements in common with the rRNA P1 promoter family of Escherichia coli

The tRNA(m5U54)methyltransferase, whose structural gene is designated trmA, catalyzes the formation of 5-methyluridine in position 54 of all tRNA species in Escherichia coli. The synthesis of this enzyme has previously been shown to be both growth rate dependent and stringently regulated, suggesting regulatory features similar to those of rRNA. We have determined the complete nucleotide sequence of the trmA operon in E. coli and the sequence of the trmA promoter region in Salmonella typhimurium and also analyzed the transcriptional regulation of the gene. The trmA and the btuB (encoding the vitamin B12 outer membrane receptor protein) promoters are divergent promoters separated by 102 bp between the transcriptional start sites. The trmA promoters of both E. coli and S. typhimurium share promoter elements with the rRNA P1 promoter. The sequence downstream from the -10 region of the trmA promoter is homologous to the discriminatory region found in stringently regulated promoters. Next to and upstream from the -10 region is a sequence, TCCC, in the trmA promoter that is present in all of the seven rRNA P1 promoters and in some tRNA promoters but not in any other sigma 70 promoter. However, a similar motif is also found in promoters transcribed by the heat shock sigma factor sigma 32. The trmA gene is transcribed as a monocistronic operon, and the 3' end of the transcript is shown to be located downstream from a dyad symmetry region not followed by a poly(U) stretch. Using a trmA-cat operon fusion, we show that the growth rate-dependent regulation of trmA resembles that of rRNA and operates at the level of transcription.

Guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate is not required for growth rate-dependent control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli.

rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli is subject to at least two regulation systems, growth rate-dependent control and stringent control. The inverse correlation between rRNA synthesis rates and guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate (ppGpp) levels under various physiological conditions has led to the supposition that ppGpp is the mediator of both control mechanisms by inhibiting transcription from rrn P1 promoters. Recently, relA- spoT- strains have been constructed in which both ppGpp synthesis pathways most likely have been removed (M. Cashel, personal communication). We have confirmed that such strains produce no detectable ppGpp and therefore offer a direct means for testing the involvement of ppGpp in the regulation of rRNA synthesis in vivo. Stringent control was determined by measurement of rRNA synthesis after amino acid starvation, while growth rate control was determined by measurement of rRNA synthesis under different nutritional conditions. As expected, the relA- spoT- strain is relaxed for stringent control. However, growth rate-dependent regulation is unimpaired. These results indicate that growth rate regulation can occur in the absence of ppGpp and imply that ppGpp is not the mediator, or at least is not the sole mediator, of growth rate-dependent control. Therefore, growth rate-dependent control and stringent control may utilize different mechanisms for regulating stable RNA synthesis.

A family of genes encode the multiple forms of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribosomal proteins equivalent to the Escherichia coli L12 protein and a single form of the L10-equivalent ribosomal protein

The budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains a family of genes that encodes four different but related small acidic ribosomal proteins designated L12eIA, L12eIB, L12eIIA, and L12eIIB and a single larger protein designated L10e. These proteins are equivalent (e) to the L12 and L10 proteins of Escherichia coli that assemble as a 4:1 complex onto the large ribosomal subunit. The five yeast genes (or their cDNAs) have been cloned and sequenced (M. Remacha, M. T. Saenz-Robles, M. D. Vilella, and J. P. G. Ballesta, J. Biol. Chem. 263:9044-9101, 1988; K. Mitsui and K. Tsurugi, Nucleic Acids Res. 16:3573, 3574, and 3575, 1988; this work). Here, the transcripts of these genes were characterized and quantitated and the proteins they encode were compared and aligned. Four of the genes, L12eIA, -IB, -IIA, and L10e, are uninterrupted, whereas the L12eIIB gene contains a 301-nucleotide-long intron between codons 38 and 39. The transcripts derived from each of these genes were analyzed by Northern (RNA) hybridization, primer extension, and S1 nuclease protection. All five genes are expressed, albeit at different levels. The transcript levels are coordinate and exhibit growth rate-dependent regulation in rich (glucose) and poor (ethanol) media. The five yeast proteins each contain a highly conserved acidic carboxy terminus of about 20 residues in length. This domain of unknown function is also present in archaebacterial but absent from eubacterial L10e and L12e proteins. Comparisons of the factor-binding domains in the yeast and other eucaryotic and archaebacterial L12e proteins indicate that the original duplication to produce the type I and II genes was a very ancient event. The evolutionary relationships between the eucaryotic, archaebacterial, and eubacterial L10e and L12e genes (and proteins) are discussed. Images

A family of genes encode the multiple forms of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribosomal proteins equivalent to the Escherichia coli L12 protein and a single form of the L10-equivalent ribosomal protein

The budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains a family of genes that encodes four different but related small acidic ribosomal proteins designated L12eIA, L12eIB, L12eIIA, and L12eIIB and a single larger protein designated L10e. These proteins are equivalent (e) to the L12 and L10 proteins of Escherichia coli that assemble as a 4:1 complex onto the large ribosomal subunit. The five yeast genes (or their cDNAs) have been cloned and sequenced (M. Remacha, M. T. Saenz-Robles, M. D. Vilella, and J. P. G. Ballesta, J. Biol. Chem. 263:9044-9101, 1988; K. Mitsui and K. Tsurugi, Nucleic Acids Res. 16:3573, 3574, and 3575, 1988; this work). Here, the transcripts of these genes were characterized and quantitated and the proteins they encode were compared and aligned. Four of the genes, L12eIA, -IB, -IIA, and L10e, are uninterrupted, whereas the L12eIIB gene contains a 301-nucleotide-long intron between codons 38 and 39. The transcripts derived from each of these genes were analyzed by Northern (RNA) hybridization, primer extension, and S1 nuclease protection. All five genes are expressed, albeit at different levels. The transcript levels are coordinate and exhibit growth rate-dependent regulation in rich (glucose) and poor (ethanol) media. The five yeast proteins each contain a highly conserved acidic carboxy terminus of about 20 residues in length. This domain of unknown function is also present in archaebacterial but absent from eubacterial L10e and L12e proteins. Comparisons of the factor-binding domains in the yeast and other eucaryotic and archaebacterial L12e proteins indicate that the original duplication to produce the type I and II genes was a very ancient event. The evolutionary relationships between the eucaryotic, archaebacterial, and eubacterial L10e and L12e genes (and proteins) are discussed.

Autogenous control is not sufficient to ensure steady-state growth rate-dependent regulation of the S10 ribosomal protein operon of Escherichia coli

The regulation of the S10 ribosomal protein operon of Escherichia coli was studied by using a lambda prophage containing the beginning of the S10 operon (including the promoter, leader, and first one and one-half structural genes) fused to lacZ. The synthesis of the lacZ fusion protein encoded by the phage showed the expected inhibition during oversynthesis of ribosomal protein L4, the autogenous regulatory protein of the S10 operon. Moreover, the fusion gene responded to a nutritional shift-up in the same way that genuine ribosomal protein genes did. However, the gene did not exhibit the expected growth rate-dependent regulation during steady-state growth. Thus, the genetic information carried on the prophage is sufficient for L4-mediated autogenous control and a normal nutritional shift-up response but is not sufficient for steady-state growth rate-dependent control. These results suggest that, at least for the 11-gene S10 ribosomal protein operon, additional regulatory processes are required to coordinate the synthesis of ribosomal proteins with cell growth rate and, furthermore, that sequences downstream of the proximal one and one-half genes of the operon are involved in this control.

Identification of promoter mutants defective in growth-rate-dependent regulation of rRNA transcription in Escherichia coli.

We measured the activities of 50 operon fusions from a collection of mutant and wild-type rrnB P1 (rrnB1p in the nomenclature of B. J. Bachmann and K. B. Low [Microbiol. Rev. 44:1-56, 1980]) promoters under different nutritional conditions in order to analyze the DNA sequence determinants of growth rate-dependent regulation of rRNA transcription in Escherichia coli. Mutants which deviated from the wild-type -10 or -35 hexamers or from the wild-type 16-base-pair spacer length between the hexamers were unregulated, regardless of whether the mutations brought the promoters closer to the E. coli promoter consensus sequence and increased activity or whether the changes took the promoters further away from the consensus and reduced activity. These data suggest that rRNA promoters have evolved to maintain their regulatory abilities rather than to maximize promoter strength. Some double substitutions outside the consensus hexamers were almost completely unregulated, while single substitutions at several positions outside the -10 and -35 consensus hexamers exerted smaller but significant effects on regulation. These studies suggest roles for specific promoter sequences and/or structures in interactions with regulatory molecules and suggest experimental tests for models of rRNA regulation.

Saturation mutagenesis of an Escherichia coli rRNA promoter and initial characterization of promoter variants

Using oligonucleotide synthesis techniques, we generated Escherichia coli rrnB P1 (rrnB1p according to the nomenclature of B. J. Bachmann and K. B. Low [Microbiol. Rev. 44:1-56, 1980]) promoter fragments containing single base substitutions, insertions, deletions, and multiple mutations, covering the whole length of the promoter including the upstream activation sequence (UAS). The activities of 112 mutant promoters were assayed as operon fusions to lacZ in lambda lysogens. The activities of most mutants with changes in the core promoter recognition region (i.e., substitutions, insertions, or deletions in the region of the promoter spanning the -10 and -35 E. coli consensus hexamers) correlated with changes toward or away from the consensus in the hexamer sequences or in the spacing between them. However, changes at some positions in the core promoter region not normally associated with transcriptional activity in other systems also had significant effects on rrnB P1. Since rRNA promoter activity varies with cellular growth rate, changes in activity can be the result of changes in promoter strength or of alterations in the regulation of the promoter. The accompanying paper (R. R. Dickson, T. Gaal, H. A. deBoer, P. L. deHaseth, and R. L. Gourse, J. Bacteriol. 171:4862-4870, 1989) distinguishes between these two alternatives. Several mutations in the UAS resulted in two- to fivefold reductions in activity. However, two mutants with changes just upstream of the -35 hexamer in constructs containing the UAS had activities 20- to 100-fold lower than the wild-type level. This collection of mutant rRNA promoters should serve as an important resource in the characterization of the mechanisms responsible for upstream activation and growth rate-dependent regulation of rRNA transcription.

DNA determinants of rRNA synthesis in E. coli: Growth rate dependent regulation, feedback inhibition, upstream activation, antitermination

We have examined the DNA regions required for rRNA synthesis in E. coli using promoter- lacZ and λP L- rrnB operon fusions. Sequences between −51 and −20 with respect to the P1 promoter transcription initiation site contain the critical information for growth rate dependent control. The region essential for growth rate regulation is the same as that necessary for feedback inhibition. A separate upstream region, between −51 and −88, increases rRNA transcription at least 15-fold and appears to have an abnormal conformation. The box A sequence downstream of promoter P2, but not DNA between P2 and box A, is required for efficient rRNA chain elongation. These results indicate that neither upstream activation nor antitermination determines growth rate dependence. Rather, growth rate regulation takes place at the target site for the negative feedback system, the P1 promoter itself. We propose that negative feedback regulation is responsible for the growth rate dependence of rRNA synthesis in E. coli.

Growth rate-dependent regulation of RNA polymerase synthesis in Escherichia coli

The rate of synthesis of the beta and beta' subunits of RNA polymerase relative to the rate of synthesis of total protein was found to remain constant with increasing steady state growth rate. This is in contrast to the relative synthesis rates of ribosomal proteins which are known to increase with growth rate. Yet the ratio of the rate of transcription of the ribosomal protein (rplJL) and RNA polymerase (rpoBC) domains of the rplKAJLrpoBC gene cluster was found to be invariant. Fusions to lacZ were used to relate the rate of transcription of the rplKAJL genes to the rate of synthesis of total protein. No change was seen at growth rates above 0.8 doublings per hour. This indicates that the growth rate-dependent expression of these ribosomal proteins is regulated at the post-transcriptional level. However because both the relative rate of transcription of rpoBC and rate of synthesis of beta and beta' were found to remain invariant over this growth range it suggests the expression of these RNA polymerase subunits is regulated at the transcriptional level.

Multiple promoters for the transcription of the ribosomal RNA gene cluster in Halobacterium cutirubrum

The archaebacterium Halobacterium cutirubrum has a single ribosomal RNA transcription unit in its genomic DNA. The 5′-flanking sequence preceding the proximal 16 S gene contains two imperfect and three perfect copies of a bipartate direct repeat sequence and the first half of a long nearly perfect inverted repeat sequence that surrounds the 16 S gene. Initiation of transcription occurs within a preserved eight base segment present in each of the five direct repeat sequences. The most upstream and least conserved repeat element represents the major transcription start site and this site appears to exhibit growth rate-dependent regulation. The primary transcripts are processed near a short discontinuity within the first half of the long inverted repeat sequence to produce the 5′ end of precursor 16 S rRNA.

Initiation of translation makes attenuation of ampC in E. coli dependent on growth rate.

The chromosomal beta-lactamase gene of E. coli, ampC, shows increased expression with increased growth rate of the bacteria. We have previously shown that transcription of ampC is attenuated, and that a mutation in the terminator stem of this attenuator abolishes the growth rate-dependency of ampC expression. We now present studies using mutations, made in vitro, located such that the 5'-end of ampC mRNA carries a possible recognition sequence for initiation of translation close to the attenuator stem. Alteration of the supposed initiation codon AUG to UUG resulted in a reduced and growth rate-independent expression of ampC beta-lactamase. AmpC mRNA starts with the sequence AUC, which might be a non-typical ribosome binding site, situated four bases before the AUG. Deletion of the C in this sequence caused a partial reduction of ampC expression and also a partial loss of the growth rate-dependent regulation. The phenotypes of these mutants support a model in which formation of a ribosome initiation complex at a level increasing with the growth rate inhibits termination of transcription at the ampC attenuator.

Essential site for growth rate-dependent regulation within the Escherichia coli gnd structural gene.

Expression of gnd of Escherichia coli, which encodes the hexose monophosphate shunt enzyme, 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (6PGD; EC 1.1.1.44), is subject to growth rate-dependent regulation: the level of the enzyme is directly proportional to growth rate under a variety of growth conditions. Previous results obtained with strains carrying transcriptional fusions of gnd to the structural genes of the lactose operon suggested that the growth rate-dependent regulation of gnd expression is at the post-transcriptional level. To characterize the regulation further, we prepared with phage MudII a set of eight independent gnd-lac gene (protein) fusions. We showed through genetic analysis and DNA sequencing that each fusion joint was located within the 6PGD-coding sequence between the first and second base pair of a codon, the reading frame required for production of a hybrid 6PGD-beta-galactosidase. Strains harboring the gnd-lac fusion plasmids produced proteins whose mobility in a NaDodSO4/polyacrylamide gel agreed with the molecular weights predicted from the DNA sequence for the respective hybrid proteins. The level of beta-galactosidase was high and relatively growth rate-independent in the fusion whose fusion joint was at codon 48. The level of beta-galactosidase in the other seven fusion strains whose fusion joints were located further downstream in the 6PGD-coding sequence showed the same dependence on growth rate as 6PGD in a normal strain. beta-Galactosidase levels were not affected by the presence of a gnd+ gene in trans to any of the fusions. The results suggest that all sites necessary for growth rate-dependent regulation of 6PGD level lie in gnd upstream from codon 118 and that an essential site of negative control lies within the coding sequence, between codons 48 and 118.

Role of attenuation in growth rate-dependent regulation of the S10 r-protein operon of E. coli.

We have investigated the transcription of the 11 gene S10 ribosomal protein operon of Escherichia coli under various growth conditions. The differential synthesis rate of structural gene message increases 2- to 2.5-fold immediately after a shift-up from glycerol minimal medium to glucose plus amino acids. After the initial increase, the transcription rate goes through several oscillations before reaching the new steady-state rate. By comparing the rates of transcription of leader and structural genes, we conclude that these oscillations are due predominantly to changes in the level of read-through at the S10 attenuator. This regulation of attenuation can account for most of the variations in protein synthesis from the S10 operon after a shift. We also measured the level of read-through in cells growing exponentially in different growth media. Over a 2.5-fold range in growth rates, the read-through changed less than 50%. Thus, regulation of attenuation cannot explain the growth-dependent regulation of ribosomal protein synthesis during steady-state growth. Apparently, additional mechanisms are required to control the expression of the S10 operon in exponentially growing cells.

DNA sequence of the Escherichia coli gene, gnd, for 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase

Expression of gnd of Escherichia coli, which encodes 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, an enzyme of the hexose monophosphate shunt, is subject to growth rate-dependent regulation and is gene dosage-dependent: the level of the enzyme increases in direct proportion to the cellular growth rate at both low and high gene copy numbers. We have determined the nucleotide sequence of gnd and flanking control regions, the 5′-end of in vivo gnd mRNA, and the start codon of the structural gene. Analysis of the sequence indicated that: (i) the gnd promoter is typical of other E. coli promoters and the structural gene is followed by a rho-independent transcription termination signal; (ii) the 56-nucleotide leader of gnd mRNA does not contain a rho-independent transcription termination signal, so growth rate-dependent regulation of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase level is not carried out by an attenuation mechanism analogous to the one that controls expression of the E. coli ampC gene; (iii) the codon composition of the structural gene resembles that of other highly expressed E. coli genes and thus is not responsible for the regulation either; (iv) the structural gene is preceded at an optimal distance by a strong Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence, AGGAG; (v) the leader region of the mRNA contains regions of dyad symmetry that have the potential to sequester the SD sequence and the start codon. This latter feature of the gene suggests that growth rate-dependent regulation may involve regulation of translation initiation frequency.

Carbon starvation and growth rate-dependent regulation of the Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA promoters: differential control of dual promoters.

We studied the effects of carbon starvation and of varying the growth rate on the activity of each of the two tandem ribosomal RNA promoters from the rrnA operon of Escherichia coli. The cellular abundance of plasmid-encoded transcripts arising at promoters P1 and P2 and terminating at the ribosomal RNA terminator in promoter-terminator fusions, together with transcript turnover rates, was used to estimate promoter activities. The rate of synthesis of the P1-promoted transcript was found to increase exponentially with growth rate and predominate at fast growth rates. The activity of the downstream promoter (P2) changed only slightly at different growth rates. Upon carbon starvation, little or no activity of the upstream promoter was detectable, while P2 activity persisted. We interpret this to mean that the dual promoters are differentially regulated so as to have separate adaptive and maintenance functions. This model simplifies most features of rRNA regulation known in E. coli.

Growth rate-dependent regulation of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase level in Escherichia coli K-12: beta-galactosidase expression in gnd-lac operon fusion strains.

The level of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase is positively correlated with the cellular growth rate. To determine whether growth rate-dependent regulation of expression of gnd, which encodes this enzyme, is carried out by a transcriptional mechanism, the structural genes of the lactose operon were fused to and brought under the control of the gnd promoter through the use of phage Mu d1(Apr lac). Four independent gnd::Mu d1(Apr lac) operon fusion strains were isolated. After the Mu d1 prophage was replaced with lambda p1(209), Lac+ specialized transducing phages carrying the gnd-lac fusions were prepared. These phages were used to demonstrate that the lac genes were fused to the gnd promoter by crossing them with gnd promoter deletion mutants and with polar phage Mu cts-induced gnd mutants. A genetic map of the fusion joints was deduced. The level of beta-galactosidase in each fusion strain was the same in cells growing on acetate as in cells growing on glucose (with specific growth rate constants of 0.1 and 0.55 h-1, respectively) and was unaffected by the presence of a gnd+ gene in trans. Our results suggest that a post-transcriptional mechanism mediates growth rate-dependent regulation of gnd and that this regulation is not autogenous. Models for regulation are discussed with respect to these results and the physiology and DNA sequence of gnd.