We use two-dimensional numerical models to identify controls on groundwater recharge, water table dynamics, and the sink-source function of fine-textured hummocks in water-limited environments. A silty clay loam hummock with aspen forest cover in the sub-humid Boreal Plains region of Canada is used to develop a conceptual model and calibrate a variably-saturated flow model to better investigate the dynamics of recharge, water table position, and lateral flow between the forested hummock and adjacent peatland. Scenario testing (achieved by raising and lowering the hydraulic conductivity by an order of magnitude and altering the hummock height and length) provides further understanding of the controls that hydraulic conductivity and hummock morphometry exert on recharge and forestland-peatland interactions. We find that the hydraulic conductivity of the glacial till has the largest control over recharge, followed by the hummock height and length and, lastly, annual atmospheric fluxes. Hummocks with higher hydraulic conductivity or long morphometric profiles are most often sinks of water as they promote increased root-water uptake, while taller hummocks with lower hydraulic conductivity tend to act as hydrologic sources for adjacent wetlands. The magnitude of annual recharge and water table elevation are poorly correlated with annual atmospheric fluxes due to the strong effects of multi-year storage deficits or surpluses; however, they are appreciably affected by decadal wet-dry cycles typical of the Boreal Plains climate. Additionally, we show that both distance along a hummock and elevation are key factors in controlling the spatial distribution of recharge at a single hummock. It is common to conceptualize the water table as a shallow and subdued replica of surface topography, where water flows from topographic highs (i.e., forestlands) to topographic lows (i.e., peatlands) in humid environments; however, as we show here, recharge rates, water table elevation, and the sink-source function of a forested hummock in water-limited environments is highly variable in time and space, and strongly dependent on both the hydrogeological and morphometric properties of the hummock.