Co-varying disturbance and environmental gradients can shape vegetation dynamics and increase the diversity of plant communities and their features. Pinyon–juniper woodlands are widespread in semi-arid climates of western North America, encompassing extensive environmental gradients, and a knowledge gap is how the diversity in features of these communities changes across co-varying gradients in fire history and soil. In pinyon–juniper communities spanning soil parent materials (basalt, limestone) and recent fire histories (0–4 prescribed fires or managed wildfires and 5–43 years since fire) in Grand Canyon-Parashant National Monument (Arizona, USA), we examined variation at 25 sites in three categories of plant community features including fuels, tree structure, and understory vegetation. Based on ordinations, canonical correlation analysis, and permutation tests, plant community features varied primarily with the number of fires, soil coarseness and chemistry, and additionally with tree structure for understory vegetation. Fire and soil variables accounted for 33% of the variance in fuels and tree structure, and together with tree structure, 56% of the variance in understories. The cover of the non-native annual Bromus tectorum was higher where fires had occurred more recently. In turn, B. tectorum was positively associated with the percentage of dead trees and negatively associated with native forb species richness. Based on a dendroecological analysis of 127 Pinus monophylla and Juniperus osteosperma trees, only 18% of trees presently around our study sites originated before the 1870s (Euro-American settlement) and <2% originated before the 1820s. Increasing contemporary fire activity facilitated by the National Park Service since the 1980s corresponded with increasing tree mortality and open-structured stands, apparently more closely resembling pre-settlement conditions. Using physical geography, such as soil parent material, as a landscape template shows promise for (i) incorporating diversity in long-term community change serving as a baseline for vegetation management, (ii) customizing applying treatments to unique conditions on different soil types, and (iii) benchmarking monitoring metrics of vegetation management effectiveness to levels scaled to biophysical variation across the landscape.
Read full abstract