Globular Cluster System Research Articles

Globular Cluster Systems in Massive Low Surface Brightness Galaxies

Do LSB galaxies have globular clusters? If they do, how do the main features of these systems compare to the ones observed in other galaxies? What are the implications of these findings on the formation of the halo and the star formation history of LSB galaxies? These are the questions we are looking to address with this study.We present preliminary results of an ACS/HST survey for globular clusters on massive LSB galaxies.

The Globular Cluster System of NGC 5128

We present preliminary results from a new wide-field photometric investigation of the globular cluster system of NGC 5128. NGC 5128 is the nearest giant elliptical and thus its globular cluster system serves as prototype for those of this important galaxy type. We have obtained images from IMACS at the Magellan telescope in excellent seeing that allow us to not only resolve globular clusters but derive their structural parameters. This extensive database provides a wealth of data to study the globular clusters in unprecedented detail. We discuss here the resolution of the clusters and their preliminary structural parameters.

Extragalactic globular clusters: unraveling galaxy formation and constraining stellar evolution theories

Understanding the stellar populations of extragalactic globular cluster (GC) systems and, in particular, determining their ages, provide essential clues to constrain the star formation histories of their host galaxies. We here summarize the most relevant results derived from a detailed, spectroscopic study of 20 GCs in the E0 NGC1407. We find most GCs are old (∼ 11Gyr), follow a tight metallicity sequence reaching values slightly above solar, and exhibit mean [α/Fe] ratios of ∼ 0.3 dex. Blue horizontal branch effects are detected for 3 GCs. We also report the existence of two families of metal-rich (MR) GCs, as some of them exhibit significantly larger [Mg/Fe] and [C/Fe] ratios, what might be interpreted in terms of different star formation time-scales. Striking CN overabundances are found over the entire GC metallicity range. In particular, for MR GCs, N increases dramatically while C essentially saturates. This may be interpreted as a consequence of the increasing importance of the CNO cycle with increasing metallicity.

A photometric and spectroscopic study of the stellar populations in the Large Magellanic Cloud

In the last years we started a long-term project devoted to obtain a complete photometric and spectroscopic screening of the stellar populations of the LMC globular cluster system and surrounding fields. The ultimate goals of this project are as follows: • The definition of reliable and homogeneous cluster metallicity and age scales from high quality, high resolution spectra and color-magnitude diagrams. • The detailed study of the chemical abundance patterns of iron-peak, alpha-, s- and r-process elements, in order to constrain the star formation and chemical enrichment timescales of both the cluster and field populations and check for possible self-enrichment in the clusters.

The age structure of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies and its dependence on host galaxy properties

Aims. We present the results of an optical – near-infrared photometric survey of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies. Our project aims to study correlations between the age structure of the globular cluster systems and environmental as well as structural parameters of their host galaxies. Methods. To derive the age structure in globular cluster systems we use combined optical and near-infrared photometry. This combination facilitates the detection of young globular cluster sub-populations if their age differs significantly from the old (∼13 Gyr) population, i.e. if their age is <7 Gyr. We investigate globular cluster systems in galaxies located in the central regions of galaxy clusters (NGC 1399, M 87, NGC 4478), galaxies which are members of (sub-) groups (NGC 4365, NGC 5846) and isolated galaxies (NGC 3115 and NGC 7192). Further, we look for correlations between globular cluster system properties and structural parameters of the galaxies (velocity dispersion σ, color ((V − K), (B − V)), and luminosity MV ). For a quantitative analysis we define the “Methuselah” parameter, Mth – based on the fraction of young and old metal-rich globular clusters weighted by age, characterizing the age structure of a globular cluster system. Results. We find that, within our galaxy sample, group galaxies appear to host an intermediate-age globular cluster population, whereas the globular cluster systems in cluster galaxies and in rather isolated galaxies are dominated by an old globular cluster population. A weak correlation of Mth with the Hβ index of the integrated light of the host galaxies is the only trend found with respect to internal galaxy parameters.

The globular cluster kinematics and galaxy dark matter content of NGC 4649 (M60)

From observations with the GMOS multislit spectrograph on the Gemini North telescope, we have obtained spectra for 39 globular cluster (GC) candidates in the Virgo giant elliptical galaxy NGC 4649 (M60), of which 38 are confirmed GCs. The clusters extend out to a radius of 260 arcsec (3.5 effective radii). We find no rotation of the GC system, with an upper limit of v/σ < 0.6 at a confidence level of 95 per cent. The GC velocity dispersion is constant with radius, within the uncertainties. We fit isotropic models to the GC and stellar kinematics; these models yield an (M/L)V around 16 at 200 arcsec radius (16 kpc), an increase of a factor of 2 from the central M/L. We also use the mass profile as derived from X-rays to determine the orbital structure. Using axisymmetric orbit-based models and the X-ray mass profile, we find the orbital distribution is close to isotropic within 100 arcsec, and becomes tangentially biased beyond. Furthermore, when using the X-ray profile, we find a better fit to the kinematics compared to using a constant M/L model. Thus, both isotropic and axisymmetric orbit-based models give support for the presence of a dark matter halo in NGC 4649.

Measuring the fading of S0 galaxies using globular clusters

Aims. We test the hypothesis that S0 galaxies are the descendants of fading spirals whose star formation has been shut down, by using the properties of their globular cluster systems. Methods. We estimate the amount by which the globular cluster specific frequency (number of globular clusters per unit V -band luminosity) is enhanced in S0s relative to spirals. If the transformation hypothesis is correct, and no clusters are created or destroyed in the process, then this difference provides a measure of the degree to which the S0's V -band luminosity has faded relative to that of its spiral progenitor, which we can compare with the independent values estimated from stellar population synthesis and the S0 Tully–Fisher relation. We also explore whether the degree to which the globular cluster specific frequency is enhanced in S0s correlates with the colour of the stellar population, as also predicted by this hypothesis in which galaxies become redder as they fade. Results. We find that, on average, the globular cluster specific frequency is a factor ∼ 3 larger for S0s than for spirals, which can be interpreted as meaning that passively-evolving S0s have faded on average by about a factor of three from their spiral progenitors. This value fits remarkably well with the predictions of stellar population synthesis calculations, and the offset between the S0 and spiral Tully–Fisher relations, where the S0 V -band relation lies ∼ 1.2 mag, or a factor of three, below the spiral relation. We also find that the global colours of S0 galaxies are strongly correlated with their globular cluster specific frequencies: the redder the stellar population of an S0, the larger its specific frequency, as we might expect if we are catching different S0s at different stages of passively fading and reddening. Comparison to the predictions of stellar population synthesis models show that this explanation works quantitatively as well as qualitatively. Conclusions. These tests strongly support the hypothesis that S0 galaxies were once normal spirals, whose star formation was cut off, presumably due to a change of environment. We are now in a position to start to make quantitative measurements of when this life-changing event occurred in different galaxies.

Globular cluster systems of six shell galaxies

Context. Shells in Elliptical Galaxies are faint, sharp-edged features, believed to provide evidence of a recent (similar to 0.5-2 x 10(9) years ago) merger event. We analyse the Globular Cluster (GC) systems of six shell elliptical galaxies, to examine the effects of mergers upon the GC formation history. Aims. We examine the colour distributions, and investigate differences between red and blue globular cluster populations. We present luminosity functions, spatial distributions and specific frequencies (S-N) at 50 kpc radius for our sample. Methods. We present V and I magnitudes for cluster candidates measured with the HST Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS). Galaxy background light is modelled and removed, and magnitudes are measured in 8 pixel (0.4 arcsec) diameter apertures. Background contamination is removed using counts from Hubble Deep Field South. Results. We find that the colour distributions for NGC 3923 and NGC 5982 have a bimodal form typical of bright ellipticals, with peaks near V - I = 0.92 +/- 0.04 and V - I = 1.18 +/- 0.06. In NGC 7626, we find in addition a population of abnormally luminous clusters at M-I = -12.5. In NGC 2865 we find an unusually blue population, which may also be young. In NGC 1344 and NGC 474 the red cluster population is marginally detected. The radial surface density profiles are more flattened than the galaxy light in the cores. As already known, in NGC 3923, which has a high S-N of 5.6, the radial density distribution is more shallower than the diffuse galaxy light. Conclusions. The clusters in NGC 2865 and NGC 7626 provide evidence for formation of a population associated with a recent merger. In the other galaxies, the properties of the clusters are similar to those observed in other, non-shell, elliptical galaxies.

New age estimates of M31 globular clusters from multicolour photometry

The large majority of extragalactic star cluster studies performed to date essentially use multi-colour photometry, combined with theoretical stellar synthesis models, to derive ages, masses, extinction estimates, and metallicities. M31 offers a unique laboratory for studies of globular cluster (GC) systems. In this paper, we obtain new age estimates for 91 M31 globular clusters, based on improved photometric data, updated theoretical stellar synthesis models and sophisticated new fitting methods. In particular, we used photometric measurements from the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS), which, in combination with optical photometry, can partially break the well-known age-metallicity degeneracy operating at ages in excess of a few Gyr. We show robustly that previous age determinations based on photometric data were affected significantly by this age-metallicity degeneracy. Except for one cluster, the ages of our other sample GCs are all older than 1 Gyr. Their age distribution shows populations of young and intermediate-age GCs, peaking at $\sim3$ and 8 Gyr respectively, as well as the usual complement of well-known old GCs, i.e., GCs of similar age as the majority of the Galactic GCs. Our results also show that although there is significant scatter in metallicity at any age, there is a noticeable lack of young metal-poor and old metal-rich GCs, which might be indicative of an underlying age-metallicity relationship among the M31 GC population.

Hubble Space TelescopeACS Wide-Field Photometry of the Sombrero Galaxy Globular Cluster System

A detailed imaging analysis of the globular cluster (GC) system of the Sombrero galaxy (NGC 4594) has been accomplished using a six-image mosaic from the Hubble Space Telescope Advanced Camera for Surveys. The quality of the data is such that contamination by foreground stars and background galaxies is negligible for all but the faintest 5% of the GC luminosity function. This enables the study of an effectively pure sample of 659 GCs until ∼2 mag fainter than the turnover magnitude, which occurs at M = -7.60 ± 0.06 for an assumed m - M = 29.77. Two GC metallicity subpopulations are easily distinguishable, with the metal-poor subpopulation exhibiting a smaller intrinsic dispersion in color compared to the metal-rich subpopulation. There are three new discoveries. (1) A metal-poor GC color-magnitude trend has been observed. (2) The fact that the metal-rich GCs are ∼17% smaller than the metal-poor ones for small projected galactocentric radii (less than ∼2') has been confirmed. However, the median half-light radii of the two subpopulations become identical at ∼3' from the center. This is most easily explained if the size difference is the result of projection effects. (3) The brightest (MV < -9.0) members of the GC system show a size-magnitude upturn, where the average GC size increases with increasing luminosity. Evidence is presented that supports an intrinsic origin for this feature rather than being a result of accreted dwarf elliptical nuclei. In addition, the metal-rich GCs show a shallower positive size-magnitude trend, similar to what is found in previous studies of young star clusters.

Dynamics of the NGC 4636 globular cluster system

Dynamics of the NGC 4636 globular cluster system

The globular cluster system of NGC 5846 revisited: colours, sizes and X-ray counterparts

Context. NGC 5846 is a giant elliptical galaxy with a previously well studied globular cluster system (GCS), known to have a bimodal colour distribution with a remarkably high red fraction. Aims. Here we revisit the central galaxy regions searching for new globular cluster (GC) candidates, and measure magnitudes, colours and sizes for them. We also search for their X-ray counterparts. Methods. We use archival Hubble Space Telescope WFPC2 images, from which we modelled and subtracted the host light distribution to increase the available sample of GCs. We performed photometry on the central objects, and measured sizes and coordinates for the entire GC system known in this galaxy. Results. We detect two dozen previously unknown GC candidates in the central regions. Reliable sizes are obtained for about 60 GCs; their typical effective radii are in the range 3-5 pc. The largest clusters are located in the central regions. We find 7 X-ray counterparts to GCs, most of them in the central region. They are among the most luminous X-ray sources in NGC 5846. They are also optically luminous, compact and belong to the red subpopulation. Conclusions. The GCS of NGC 5846 is composed of relatively luminous X-ray sources.

Dynamical Evolution of the Mass Function of the Globular Cluster System from Fokker-Planck Calculations: Preliminary Results

AbstractUsing anisotropic Fokker-Planck models, we calculate the evolution of mass and luminosity functions of the Galactic globular cluster system. Our models include two-body relaxation, binary heating, tidal shocks, dynamical friction, and stellar evolution. We perform Fokker-Planck simulations for a large number of virtual globular clusters and synthesize these results to study the relation between the initial and present GCMFs.

An Optical Search for Dwarf Novae in M22

AbstractWe report on the results of our 2004 monitoring program of M22, designed to search for CVs undergoing dwarf nova (DN) eruptions. We wish to compare these globular cluster systems to similar ones in the field and determine if their different formation mechanisms result in different properties. We present a light curve for a CV candidate that went into outburst during May. Data were reduced with the ISIS image subtraction routine. Our ground-based results are consistent with previous HST measurements, and confirm the DN nature of the outburst. We also report on further attempts to apply the ISIS software to look for additional outbursts of this object during 2004 as well as to identify other variable candidates in the core of M22.

Luminosity Function of Faint Globular Clusters in M87

We present the luminosity function to very faint magnitudes for the globular clusters in M87, based on a 30 orbit \textit{Hubble Space Telescope (HST)} WFPC2 imaging program. The very deep images and corresponding improved false source rejection allow us to probe the mass function further beyond the turnover than has been done before. We compare our luminosity function to those that have been observed in the past, and confirm the similarity of the turnover luminosity between M87 and the Milky Way. We also find with high statistical significance that the M87 luminosity function is broader than that of the Milky Way. We discuss how determining the mass function of the cluster system to low masses can constrain theoretical models of the dynamical evolution of globular cluster systems. Our mass function is consistent with the dependence of mass loss on the initial cluster mass given by classical evaporation, and somewhat inconsistent with newer proposals that have a shallower mass dependence. In addition, the rate of mass loss is consistent with standard evaporation models, and not with the much higher rates proposed by some recent studies of very young cluster systems. We also find that the mass-size relation has very little slope, indicating that there is almost no increase in the size of a cluster with increasing mass.

An extensive study of dynamical friction in dwarf galaxies: the role of stars, dark matter, halo profiles and MOND

We investigate the in-spiralling time-scales of globular clusters (GCs) in dwarf spheroidal (dSph) and dwarf elliptical (dE) galaxies, due to dynamical friction (DF). We address the problem of these time-scales having been variously estimated in the literature as much shorter than a Hubble time. Using self-consistent two-component (dark matter and stars) models, we explore mechanisms which may yield extended DF time-scales in such systems in order to explain why dwarf galaxies often show GC systems. As a general rule, dark matter and stars both give a comparable contribution to the dynamical drag. By exploring various possibilities for their gravitational make-up, it is shown that these studies help to constrain the parameters of the dark matter haloes in these galaxies, as well as to test alternatives to dark matter. Under the assumption of a dark halo having a central density core with a typical King core radius somewhat larger than the observed stellar core radius, DF time-scales are naturally extended upwards of a Hubble time. Cuspy dark haloes yield time-scales ≲4.5 Gyr, for any dark halo parameters in accordance with observations of stellar line-of-sight velocity dispersion in dSph galaxies. We confirm, after a detailed formulation of the DF problem under the alternative hypothesis of modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) and in the lack of any dark matter, that due to the enhanced dynamical drag of the stars, the DF time-scales in MOND would be extremely short. Taking the well-measured structural parameters of the Fornax dSph and its GC system as a case study, we conclude that requiring DF time-scales comparable to the Hubble time strongly favours dark haloes with a central core.

The U-shaped Distribution of Globular Cluster-specific Frequencies in a Biased Globular Cluster Formation Scenario

Using high-resolution numerical simulations, we investigate mass- and luminosity-normalized specific frequencies (T_N and S_N, respectively) of globular cluster systems (GCSs) in order to understand the origin of the observed U-shaped relation between S_N and V-band magnitude (M_V) of their host galaxies. We adopt a biased GC formation scenario in which GC formation is truncated in galaxy halos that are virialized at a later redshift, z_trun. T_N is derived for galaxies with GCs today and converted into S_N for reasonable galaxy mass-to-light-ratios (M/L). We find that T_N depends on halo mass (M_h) in the sense that T_N can be larger in more massive halos with M_h > 10^9 M_sun, if z_trun is as high as 15. We however find that the dependence is too weak to explain the observed S_N-M_V relation and the wide range of S_N in low-mass early-type galaxies with -20.5 < M_V < -16.0 mag for a reasonable constant M/L. The M_V-dependence of S_N for the low-mass galaxies can be well reproduced, if the mass-to-light-ratio M_h/L_V \propto M_h^{\alpha}, where \alpha is as steep as -1. Based on these results, we propose that the origin of the observed U-shaped S_N-M_V relation of GCSs can be understood in terms of the bimodality in the dependence of M_h/L_V on M_h of their host galaxies. We also suggest that the observed large dispersionin S_N in low-mass galaxies is due partly to the large dispersion in T_N.

Large-scale study of the NGC 1399 globular cluster system in Fornax

We present a Washington C and Kron-Cousins R photometric study of the globular cluster system of NGC 1399, the central galaxy of the Fornax cluster. A large areal coverage of 1 square degree around NGC 1399 is achieved with three adjoining fields of the MOSAIC II Imager at the CTIO 4-m telesc ope. Working on such a large field, we can perform the first indicative determination of the total size of the NGC 1399 globular cluster system. The estimated angular extent, measured from the NGC 1399 centre and up to a limiting radius where the areal density of blue globular clusters falls to 30 per cent of the background level, is 45± 5 arcmin, which corresponds to 220 - 275 kpc at the Fornax distance. The bimodal colour distribution of this globular cluster system, as well as the different radial distribution of blue and red clusters, up to the se large distances from the parent galaxy, are confirmed. The azimuth al globular cluster distribution exhibits asymmetries tha t might be understood in terms of tidal stripping of globulars from NGC 1387, a nearby galaxy. The good agreement between the areal density profile of blue clusters and a projected dark-matter NFW density profile is emphasized.

The Effect of Substructure on Mass Estimates of Galaxies

Large galaxies are thought to form hierarchically, from the accretion and disruption of many smaller galaxies. Such a scenario should naturally lead to galactic phase-space distributions containing some degree of substructure. We examine the errors in mass estimates of galaxies and their dark halos made using the projected phase-space distribution of a tracer population (such as a globular cluster system or planetary nebulae) due to falsely assuming that the tracers are distributed randomly. The level of this uncertainty is assessed by applying a standard mass estimator to samples drawn from 11 random realizations of galaxy halos containing levels of substructure consistent with current models of structure formation. We find that substructure will distort our mass estimates by up to ~20% - a negligible error compared to statistical and measurement errors in current derivations of masses for our own and other galaxies. However, this represents a fundamental limit to the accuracy of any future mass estimates made under the assumption that the tracer population is distributed randomly, regardless of the size of the sample or the accuracy of the measurements.

Chemical Compositions of Red Giant Stars in Old Large Magellanic Cloud Globular Clusters

We have observed 10 red giant stars in four old Large Magellanic Cloud globular clusters with the high-resolution spectrograph MIKE on the Magellan Landon Clay 6.5 m telescope. The stars in our sample have up to 20 elemental abundance determinations for the α-, iron peak, and neutron-capture element groups. We have also derived abundances for the light odd-Z elements Na and Al. We find NGC 2005 and NGC 2019 to be more metal-rich than previous estimates from the Ca II triplet, and we derive [Fe/H] values closer to those obtained from the slope of the red giant branch. However, we confirm previous determinations for Hodge 11 and NGC 1898 to within 0.2 dex. The LMC cluster [Mg/Fe] and [Si/Fe] ratios are comparable to the values observed in old Galactic globular cluster stars, as are the abundances [Y/Fe], [Ba/Fe], and [Eu/Fe]. The LMC clusters do not share the low-Y behavior observed in some dwarf spheroidal galaxies. [Ca/Fe], [Ti/Fe], and [V/Fe] in the LMC, however, are significantly lower than what is seen in the Galactic globular cluster system. Neither does the behavior of [Cu/Fe] as a function of [Fe/H] in our LMC clusters match the trend seen in the Galaxy, staying instead at a constant value of roughly -0.8. Because not all [α/Fe] ratios are suppressed, these abundance ratios cannot be attributed solely to the injection of Type Ia supernova material and instead reflect the differences in star formation history of the LMC versus the Milky Way. An extensive numerical experimental study was performed, varying both input parameters and stellar atmosphere models, to verify that the unusual abundance ratios derived in this study are not the result of the adopted atomic parameters, stellar atmospheres, or stellar parameters. We conclude that many of the abundances in the LMC globular clusters we observed are distinct from those observed in the Milky Way, and these differences are intrinsic to the stars in those systems.