Globular Cluster Subpopulations Research Articles

The globular cluster system of the young elliptical NGC 6702

We study the globular cluster (GC) system of the dust-lane elliptical galaxy NGC 6702, using B, V and I-band photometric observations carried out at the Keck telescope. This galaxy has a spectroscopic age of ~2Gyrs suggesting recent star-formation. We find strong evidence for a bimodal GC colour distribution, with the blue peak having a colour similar to that of the Galactic halo GCs. Assuming that the blue GCs are indeed old and metal-poor, we estimate an age of 2-5Gyrs and supersolar metallicity for the red GC subpopulation. Despite the large uncertainties, this is in reasonable agreement with the spectroscopic galaxy age. Additionally, we estimate a specific frequency of S_{N}=2.3\pm1.1 for NGC 6702. We predict that passive evolution of NGC 6702 will further increase its specific frequency to S_{N}~2.7 within 10Gyrs, in closer agreement to that of typical present-day ellipticals. We also discuss evidence that the merger/accretion event that took place a few Gyrs ago involved a high gas fraction.

Erratum: “The Age Difference between the Globular Cluster Subpopulations in NGC 4472” [Astron. J. [BF]118[/BF], 2734 (1999)

Erratum: “The Age Difference between the Globular Cluster Subpopulations in NGC 4472” [Astron. J. [BF]118[/BF], 2734 (1999)

The Age Difference between the Globular Cluster Subpopulations in NGC 4472

The age difference between the two main globular cluster subpopulations in the Virgo giant elliptical galaxy NGC 4472 (M49) has been determined using Hubble Space Telescope WFPC2 images in the F555W and F814W filters. Accurate photometry has been obtained for several hundred globular clusters in each of the two main subpopulations, down to more than 1 mag below the turnover of their luminosity functions. This allows precise determinations of both the mean colors and the turnover magnitudes of the two main subpopulations. By comparing the data with various population synthesis models, the age-metallicity pairs that fit both the observed colors and magnitudes have been identified. The metal-poor and the metal-rich globular clusters are found to be coeval within the errors (~3 Gyr). If one accepts the validity of our assumptions, these errors are dominated by model uncertainties. A systematic error of up to 4 Gyr could affect this result if the blue and the red clusters have significantly different mass distributions. However, that one subpopulation is half as old as the other is excluded at the 99% confidence level. The different globular cluster populations are assumed to trace the galaxy's major star formation episodes. Consequently, the vast majority of globular clusters (and by implication the majority of stars) in NGC 4472 formed at high redshifts but by two distinct mechanisms or in two episodes. The distance to NGC 4472 is determined to be 15.8 ± 0.8 Mpc, which is in excellent agreement with six of the seven Cepheid distances to Virgo Cluster spiral galaxies. This implies that the spiral and elliptical galaxies in the main body of Virgo are at the same distance.

Constraints on the merger models of elliptical galaxies from their globular cluster systems

The discovery of protoglobular cluster candidates in many present-day mergers allows us to understand better the possible effects of a merger event on the globular cluster system of a galaxy, and to foresee the properties of the end-product. By comparing these expectations with the properties of globular cluster systems of elliptical galaxies at the present time we can constrain merger models. The observational data indicate that (i) every gaseous merger induces the formation of new star clusters, and (ii) the number of new clusters formed in such a merger increases with the gas content of the progenitor galaxies. Low-luminosity (about MV > −21), discy ellipticals are generally thought to be the result of a gaseous merger. As such, new globular clusters are expected to form but have not been detected to date. We investigate various reasons for the non-detection of subpopulations in low-luminosity ellipticals, i.e. absence of an old population, absence of a new population, destruction of one of the populations and, finally, an age–metallicity conspiracy that allows old and new globular clusters to appear indistinguishable at the present epoch. All of these possibilities lead us to a similar conclusion, namely that low-luminosity ellipticals did not form recently (z < 1) in a gas-rich merger, and might not have formed in a major merger of stellar systems at all. High-luminosity ellipticals do reveal globular cluster subpopulations. However, it is difficult to account for the two populations in terms of mergers alone and, in particular, we can rule out scenarios in which the second subpopulation is the product of a recent, gas-poor merger.

Metallicity Distributions in Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems: Constraints on Globular Cluster and Galaxy Formation

The merger model for elliptical galaxy formation has received increasing attention since it was first suggested by Toomre &amp; Toomre (1972). Van den Bergh (1984) pointed out a problem with the idea that elliptical galaxies were formed by simply combining two, or more, spiral galaxies. He noted that the specific frequency (SN, number of globular clusters per unit galaxy light) is systematically lower for spirals than for ellipticals. Schweizer (1987) suggested that globular clusters (GCs) might be expected to form in the merger process, thereby alleviating or possibly eliminating the SN problem. Ashman &amp; Zepf (1992) developed this idea into a merger model for GC formation with testable predictions.We recently examined this model in the light of new HST and ground-based imaging data on the blue and red sub-populations of GCs in elliptical galaxies (Forbes, Brodie &amp; Grillmair 1997). We concluded that the merger model for GC formation has serious problems, particularly in explaining the characteristics of GCs in giant elliptical galaxies with high SN. A multi-phase collapse scenario was suggested as more consistent with the available evidence.

HST imaging of the globular clusters in the Fornax cluster: NGC 1399 and NGC 1404

The Fornax cluster galaxies NGC 1399 and NGC 1404 are ideal for studying the effects of a cluster environment on globular cluster systems. Here we present new optical imaging of these two galaxies from both the Hubble Space Telescope's Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 and the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory's 1.5m telescope. The combination of both data sets provides unique insight on the spatial and colour distribution of globular clusters. From B-I colours, we find that both galaxies have a broad globular cluster metallicity distribution that is inconsistent with a single population. Two Gaussians provide a reasonable representation of the metallicity distribution in each galaxy. The metal-rich subpopulation is more centrally concentrated than the metal-poor one. We show that the radial metallicity gradient can be explained by the changing relative mix of the two globular cluster subpopulations. We derive globular cluster surface density profiles, and find that they are flatter (i.e. more extended) than the underlying starlight. The total number of globular clusters and specific frequency are calculated to be N = 5700 +/- 500, S_N = 11.5 +/- 1.0 for NGC 1399 and N = 725 +/- 145, S_N = 2.0 +/- 0.5 for NGC 1404. Our results are compared to the expectations of globular cluster formation scenarios.