Derivatives are like aircraft: In the right hands, they are wonderful vehicles, but in the wrong hands, or incompetently handled, they are dangerous.Due to the increased effects of globalisation, last couple of years have seen the Indian Financial Market being increasingly exposed to global market factors and are faced by rising levels of complexity of risks. To mitigate the effect of those underlying risks, Indian markets are increasingly using highly complex hedging strategies with the help of exotic instruments. The sheer explosive growth in volume of total contracts outstanding validates the heightened interest of Indian markets for such products. To satiate this heightened interest for instruments, banks have readily agreed to structure and offer these contracts to their corporate clients by focusing more on the returns rather than stressing on the potential down-side risks. However, banks should undertake transactions, particularly with companies with a sense of responsibility and circumspection that would avoid, among other things, mis-selling. Under such circumstances, it has become imperative for Indian Financial Market to adopt and demonstrate a pro-active (but disciplined) approach towards financial risk management. Putting the right prevarication strategy in place is only half the battle won; companies need to continuously monitor and assess the effectiveness of the hedging strategies and ensure that they are in sync with the underlying risk profile. However, this is easier said than done. Some of the key challenges that Indian Markets face when confronted with such complex hedging strategies are as follows:* Lack of a clear and well thought out hedging policy with clearly defined permissible instruments, allowable hedge ratios, prudent limits and maximum tenors * Lack of technical expertise to evaluate the complexity of the hedge transactions and ability to identify, understand and quantify the risks by performing periodic Mark-to-Market calculations.* Inability to closely match the hedge transactions with the underlying exposures, thereby causing ineffectiveness.* Lack of understanding of the accounting treatment to be used for both effective as well as ineffective hedge relationships. * Limited or no access to risk measurement tools as well as market data systems to independently validate the Mark-to-Market numbers reported by counterparties.* Limited band width in terms of skilled man-power to perform Mark-to-Market calculations of the transactions on an ongoing basis.* Inability to build - in worse case scenarios in the valuation models to incorporate sudden and adverse price movements ability to quantify counterparty risk exposures in the event of defaults.* Limited ability to factor - in liquidity premiums for unwinding the hedge transactions prematurely in times of adverse market conditions.* Increased scrutiny and regulatory pressure requiring companies to evaluate and document their quantitative methodologies, supporting processes, underlying systems and adherence to strict reporting guidelinesOf course, the word derivative covers a multitude of investment vehicles and strategies. It includes relatively common put and call options, and stock and bond index futures, but also more exotic instruments such as swaps and swaptions, collateralized mortgage obligations, total-return and credit default swaps, and commodity derivatives.Protecting against loss:Most derivatives can be used to protect against loss or to enhance returns modestly with limited risk.* Buying put options for a portfolio can protect it against market declines, generally at modest cost. Selling call options on the stocks in a portfolio can enhance its return when the market is moving sideways.* Stock and bond index futures also can be used to hedge portfolios or to put to work instantly new cash flow without affecting the market prices of the stocks being acquired.But these and other instruments can be used in more dangerous ways. Futures can be used to leverage portfolios. There is no way, at present, for investors to make reasoned decisions about whether to accept the exposure to derivatives, and no easy way for their financial advisers to get the information needed to advise their clients properly. Before the fund watchers begin to gather and publish this information, many planners and advisers will have to refresh their knowledge of derivatives, a technical area the details of which are all too easy to forget when not dealt with frequently. Then they will be equipped to educate their clients and help them make appropriate choices of funds, fully cognizant of what the derivatives in their funds bring to the table in terms of risk and return.
Read full abstract