Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) guidelines periodically review recommended practices for diagnosing and treating chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Country-specific COPD guidelines are available; however, there are differences regarding optimum diagnostic and treatment strategies. This systematic review aimed to map and compare guidance on diagnostic criteria and recommended treatment pathways for COPD patients in Latin America (LA), using GOLD as the standard. Electronic searches for guidelines, consensus, or protocols for COPD across 20 LA countries were conducted in October 2019 across seven databases (MEDLINE via Pubmed, BVS, LILACS, ScIELO, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase), websites of medical societies, and government agencies of each country. 14 guidelines were included, 2 regional and 12 country-specific (Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, El Salvador, Mexico, and Peru). Half were from government agencies and 4 were from medical societies. For diagnosis, 8 guidelines included risk factors or signs/symptoms as diagnostic criteria. Ten guidelines recommended spirometry for COPD diagnosis, in line with GOLD recommendations. Seven guidelines had instructions for diagnosing an exacerbation, while 6 contained guidance for classifying exacerbation severity, with the main strategies including an increase in symptom occurrence and the characteristics of the required treatment. Recommended treatment for COPD was defined through disease severity in 11 guidelines, similar to GOLD guidelines. For bronchodilation strategies, 9 guidelines recommend dual therapy, whilst only 5 recommend triple therapy (long-acting β2 agonist – long-acting muscarinic antagonist – inhaled corticosteroid) for symptomatic patients. Four guidelines specifically recommend triple therapy for exacerbating patients. COPD guidelines were not available in some LA countries. Few of the available guidelines recommended triple therapy as a treatment strategy. Identifying these characteristics enable better understanding of current clinical practices and highlight an urgent need for further standardization in COPD guidelines in LA, especially for patients with symptomatic/severe disease.
Read full abstract