Fifteen crude oils from the Qaiyarah, Butmah, and Ain Zala fields were investigated using organic geochemistry to infer organic matter maturity, redox conditions of the depositional environment, and lithology of the corresponding source rocks. Carbon isotope compositions and sulfur contents were measured for all samples and saturated and aromatic biomarkers were analyzed by GC-MS.Low pristane/phytane (0.68–0.82) and high C35 S/C34S (1.03–1.66) and homohopane indices (0.14–0.24) in the oil samples indicate anoxic or euxinic conditions for the corresponding source rocks. In addition, sulfur content, C30 norhopane/C30 hopane, and C31 R/C30 hopane, Ts/Tm and C27 diasteranes/regular steranes values suggest carbonate source rocks with variable amounts of clays. These source rocks contain mainly type II-S kerogen. Moretane/hopane, hopane and sterane isomerization ratios suggest generation from early mature organic matter. Hierarchical cluster analysis identified three families charged from carbonate source rocks with variable amounts of clays and maturity. Oil-source rock correlation (based on published data) and age-related biomarkers suggest that these oils were generated from Jurassic source rocks (Sargelu, Naokelekan, and/or Chia Gara formations). Jurassic rocks in Ain Zala and Butmah area have low potential for hydrocarbon generation, therefore, the Ain Zala and Butmah oils were charged from Jurassic formations outside the Ain Zala area, but within the neighboring area northeast of Butmah and Ain Zala.