Genus Microbotryum Research Articles

No Evidence of Reproductive Character Displacement between Two Sister Fungal Species Causing Anther Smut Disease in Silene

Reproductive isolating mechanisms that are stronger for sympatric populations than for allopatric populations of a given species pair are indicative of reproductive character displacement, that is, selection for increased barriers to avoid the costly production of hybrid offspring. Evidence of reproductive character displacement in nature remains equivocal and requires further experimental studies. The genus Microbotryum includes species of anther‐smut fungi, which castrate pathogens specialized on different plants in the Caryophyllaceae and which serve as excellent models for studying mechanisms of speciation. Microbotryum lychnidis‐dioicae and Microbotryum silenes‐dioicae are sister species that show no assortative mating and relatively high hybrid viability and, yet, display a lack of gene flow in natural populations. We wanted to test whether these apparently contradictory results could be explained by reproductive character displacement. We first confirmed the absence of detectable gene flow between the two species in two sympatric populations. Then, using experimental crosses and inoculations of host plants (Silene latifolia and Silene dioica), we compared intrinsic reproductive barriers between M. lychnidis‐dioicae and M. silenes‐dioicae for sympatric versus allopatric populations. We found no evidence for strong reproductive character displacement at any of the following stages: selfing propensity, assortative mating, or hybrid infectivity. Altogether, our results suggest that ecological differences and a tendency for high selfing rates constitute barriers that are strong enough to effectively prevent interspecific gene flow.

Using phylogenies of pheromone receptor genes in the Microbotryum violaceum species complex to investigate possible speciation by hybridization

Several cases of speciation by hybridization have been reported in fungi, mostly involving recent hybridization between closely related species. In the basidiomycete genus Microbotryum by contrast some species were suspected to have arisen by hybridization between moderately distant species. In particular two species, M. lagerheimii and M. silenes-acaulis, had different placements in phylogenetic trees depending on the genes considered. Microbotryum species exhibit bipolar heterothallism, and here we analyzed sequences of the two alternate pheromone receptors to obtain further insights on the occurrence of hybridization. Indeed because mating-type loci are always heterozygous homoploid hybrid speciation should leave a permanent footprint at the mating-type locus by retaining the alternate alleles from their respective parental species. The trees obtained with each of the two pheromone receptors were well resolved, and the species relationships were in agreement with published phylogenies. Fungal pheromone receptor genes of basidiomycetes thus appear useful for phylogenetic studies, although it may not be true for the homobasidiomycetes where duplications of these genes have occurred. Furthermore an incongruence between the phylogenies of the two pheromone receptors was found for one species, M. lagerheimii, as previously observed between other nuclear genes. However additional species analyzed here revealed that the incongruence involved the whole clade including both M. lagerheimii and the Microbotryum species parasitizing Lychnis flos-cucucli. The ancestor of these species thus possibly arose via hybridization between distant ancestral lineages, although further studies should address alternative hypotheses, such as chance events during lineage sorting.

Hidden diversity in the non‐caryophyllaceous plant‐parasitic members of Microbotryum (Pucciniomycotina: Microbotryales)

Members of the fungal genus Microbotryum are well‐known parasites on eudicotyledonous plant hosts. However, recent studies focused exclusively on Microbotryum species being parasites in the anthers of Caryophyllaceae in which strong host‐specificity was confirmed by molecular analyses. Consequently, species numbers have risen considerably as multi‐host parasites were split up in so‐called cryptic species. We subjected three non‐caryophyllaceous Microbotryum groups to molecular phylogenetic analyses to see whether we would confirm multi‐host morphospecies or if host‐specific cryptic species in these selected groups could be revealed as well (i.e. a group of non‐caryophyllaceous anther smuts, parasites on different Fallopia species, and parasites on Polygonum bistorta and Polygonum vi‐viparum). We applied a multiple analysis strategy to correct for varying alignment effects on a two‐locus dataset (ITS and LSU rDNA). The results obtained by the different approaches are uniform; high host‐specificity exists in the non‐ caryophyllaceous anther smuts, but overlapping host ranges occur in the parasites of Fallopia species. Results for the parasites of Polygonum are similar, with Microbotryum bistortarum being separated into three lineages and M. marginale forming a lineage on P. bistorta which apparently is conspecific with M. bistortarum p.p. Our study shows that phylogenetic patterns within Microbotryum are much more complicated than deduced from morphological observations alone. Even though Microbotryum species are highly host‐specific, it is impossible to identify species based solely on host taxa affiliation. Species status is reinstated for the anther smut on Salvia pratensis.

Within-host competitive exclusion among species of the anther smut pathogen

BackgroundHost individuals represent an arena in which pathogens compete for resources and transmission opportunities, with major implications for the evolution of virulence and the structure of populations. Studies to date have focused on competitive interactions within pathogen species, and the level of antagonism tends to increase with the genetic distance between competitors. Anther-smut fungi, in the genus Microbotryum, have emerged as a tractable model for within-host competition. Here, using two pathogen species that are frequently found in sympatry, we investigated whether the antagonism seen among genotypes of the same species cascades up to influence competition among pathogen species.ResultsSequential inoculation of hosts showed that a resident infection most often excludes a challenging pathogen genotype, which is consistent with prior studies. However, the challenging pathogen was significantly more likely to invade the already-infected host if the resident infection was a conspecific genotype compared to challenges involving a closely related species. Moreover, when inter-specific co-infection occurred, the pathogens were highly segregated within the host, in contrast to intra-specific co-infection.ConclusionWe show evidence that competitive exclusion during infection can be greater among closely related pathogen species than among genotypes within species. This pattern follows from prior studies demonstrating that genetic distance and antagonistic interactions are positively correlated in Microbotryum. Fungal vegetative incompatibility is a likely mechanism of direct competitive interference, and has been shown in some fungi to be effective both within and across species boundaries. For systems where related pathogen species frequently co-occur in the same host populations, these competitive dynamics may substantially impact the spatial segregation of pathogen species.

Maximized virulence in a sterilizing pathogen: the anther‐smut fungus and its co‐evolved hosts

Host sterilization is a common feature of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). Because host reproductive failure may free up resources for pathogen reproduction and transmission, theory predicts that selection on sterilizing pathogens will favour maximum virulence (i.e. complete sterilization). We examined patterns of infection in sexually transmitted anther-smut fungi (Microbotryum) on four of their host species in the Caryophyllaceae. Using controlled fungal matings and experimental inoculations, we compared disease expression in inoculations ranging from host-specific pathogens to hybrids and cross-species treatments. Our data support the existence of host-specific sibling species within the genus Microbotryum based on a low infection rate from cross-inoculations and reduced fitness for hybrid pathogens. These patterns of host specificity and reproductive isolation, however, were not absolute. We did observe some successful cross-species and hybrid infections, but the expression of disease was frequently incomplete, including only partial host sterilization and the failed dehiscence of pathogen spores. The prevalence of these maladapted disease phenotypes may greatly inhibit the emergence of novel host pathogen combinations. Infections by hybrid pathogen genotypes were intermediate, in terms of both infection rate and the normality of disease symptoms, between host-specific and cross-inoculated pathogens. In addition, the frequency with which hybrid and cross-inoculated anther-smut pathogens were able to infect but not sterilize new hosts supports the prediction that sterilizing STDs are under selection to maximize virulence in natural populations.

Implications of molecular characters for the phylogeny of the Microbotryaceae (Basidiomycota: Urediniomycetes).

BackgroundAnther smuts of the basidiomycetous genus Microbotryum on Caryophyllaceae are important model organisms for many biological disciplines. Members of Microbotryum are most commonly found parasitizing the anthers of host plants in the family Caryophyllaceae, however they can also be found on the anthers of members of the Dipsacaceae, Lamiaceae, Lentibulariaceae, and Portulacaceae. Additionally, some members of Microbotryum can be found infecting other organs of mainly Polygonaceae hosts. Based on ITS nrDNA sequences of members of almost all genera in Microbotryaceae, this study aims to resolve the phylogeny of the anther smuts and their relationship to the other members of the family of plant parasites. A multiple analysis strategy was used to correct for the effects of different equally possible ITS sequence alignments on the phylogenetic outcome, which appears to have been neglected in previous studies.ResultsThe genera of Microbotryaceae were not clearly resolved, but alignment-independent moderate bootstrap support was achieved for a clade containing the majority of the Microbotryum species. The anther parasites appeared in two different well-supported lineages whose interrelationship remained unresolved. Whereas bootstrap support values for some clades were highly vulnerable to alignment conditions, other clades were more robustly supported. The differences in support between the different alignments were much larger than between the phylogenetic optimality criteria applied (maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood).ConclusionThe study confirmed, based on a larger dataset than previous work, that the anther smuts on Caryophyllaceae are monophyletic and that there exists a native North American group that diverged from the European clade before the radiation of the European species. Also a second group of anther smuts was revealed, containing parasites on Dipsacaceae, Lamiaceae, and Lentibulariaceae. At least the majority of the parasites of Asteraceae appeared as a monophylum, but delimitations of some species in this group should be reconsidered. Parasitism on Polygonaceae is likely to be the ancestral state for the Microbotryaceae on Eudicot hosts.