Abstract Disclosure: M.S. Campana: None. Introduction: Medullary thyroid Cancer (MTC) is a rare neuroendocrine tumor that originates from thyroid parafollicular C-cells and represents 5 % of all thyroid cancers. MTC can be sporadic (75%) or hereditary (25%) associated with multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2 syndrome (MEN2). Serum calcitonin (Ctn) and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) are its tumor markers. We report a case of persistently elevated CEA levels despite an undetectable Ctn in a patient with MTC after initial thyroid lobectomy. Description of the case: A 42-year-old woman self-identified a neck lump after intentional weight loss. A neck US showed a right lobe thyroid nodule which resulted as suspicious for malignancy (Bethesda V) with subsequent right lobectomy. Pathology reported a 2.6 cm unexpected MTC with negative surgical margins, extrathyroidal extension, angioinvasion, and lymphatic invasion. No cervical lymph nodes (LNs) were removed. Immunohistochemistry was positive for CEA, chromogranin A, synaptophysin, and Ctn. T2 Nx. One month after lobectomy, the Ctn was 10.5 (0-3.0 pg/mL) and CEA 205.2 (0-3.0 ng/mL Non-smoker; 0-5.0 ng/mL smoker). The patient was then referred to our clinic for further management. Laboratories showed normal serum calcium, PTH, and fractionated plasma metanephrine/normetanephrine. A 2-month post-operative Ctn was undetectable, but CEA was elevated at 24.5. Subsequently, we broaden imaging studies to include neck US, CT neck /chest with contrast, and MRI abdomen pelvis with contrast. The only remarkable finding was a 6.7 cm pelvic mass with normal Ca-125. Genetic testing was negative for germline RET, ruling out MEN2. Patient underwent completion left lobectomy with prophylactic bilateral central neck dissection. Pathology showed benign thyroid parenchyma with multinodular hyperplasia and 0/12 LNs. Because of concerning pelvic mass, the patient was referred to OB/GYN. She underwent a laparoscopic bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy. Pathology showed a follicular ovarian cyst, negative for malignancy. A year post-completion total thyroidectomy Ctn remains undetectable, and a CEA is normal at 1.3. Discussion: Because Ctn was already undetectable 1 month after lobectomy with persistent elevated CEA a complete total thyroidectomy with prophylactic bilateral central neck dissection was indicated to achieve operative cure. Ctn is specific to MTC but variable. CEA is more reproducible with less variability; however, it is not specific to MTC and can also be elevated in smokers, benign breast and genitourinary disease, emphysema, cirrhosis, and cancer of colon, rectum, liver, genitourinary, and lung. If residual disease is present, Ctn tends to be proportionally more elevated than CEA. When the opposite occurs, poorly differentiated MTC with possibility of distant metastases vs. a second primary malignancy vs. a distant benign neoplasm known to elevate CEA need to be ruled out. Presentation: 6/2/2024