5009 Background: Inherited risk for prostate cancer (PCa) is potentially associated with more aggressive disease. Recent data indicate that DNA repair gene abnormalities may be much more common than previously appreciated, especially BRCA2, ATM, CHEK2, BRCA1, RAD51D, and PALB2. Herein, we investigate the efficacy of a targeted gene panel in men with PCa and evaluate clinical factors in relationship to current guidelines for genetic screening. Methods: DNA sequencing and exon-level copy number analysis were performed in 1158 PCa patients (pts) between 2013 and 2016 at a commercial diagnostic laboratory. The genes requisitioned varied but consistently included 14 genes on a hereditary PCa panel, most of which were DNA repair genes. Evaluation included Gleason scores and eligibility for genetic screening based on any NCCN testing criteria in pts with positive findings (pathogenic, likely pathogenic, and risk allele). Results: Pathogenic findings were identified in 199 of 1158 (17.2%) pts, 13 pts (1.0%) had two variants. Roughly 75% of detected variants were in genes on the hereditary PCa panel, of which 34.4% were BRCA1/2. Positive variants in HOXB13, a gene associated only with PCa risk, were identified in eight (3.8%) pts. DNA mismatch repair variants, alterations with substantial known therapeutic implications, were detected in 1.7% of samples. A total of 12.4% of pts with Gleason scores of ≤6, compared with 15.4% of those with scores of ≥7 had a pathogenic variant. Within this cohort, 126 (63%) patients with positive results were eligible for genetic testing based on currently available NCCN guidelines, whereas 73 (37%) would not have qualified. Conclusions: Current NCCN guidelines and Gleason scores cannot be used to reliably stratify PCa pts for the presence/absence of pathogenic germline variants. Most positive results identified in this study have important management implications for pts and their families. The percentage of pts with germline variants who did not meet current genetic screening criteria underscores the need for revisiting current guidelines which cannot, at this time, reliably be used to predict pathologic findings on genetic testing.