Genetic Compensation Research Articles

TML1 AND TML2 SYNERGISTICALLY REGULATE NODULATION AND AFFECT ARBUSCULAR MYCORRHIZA IN MEDICAGO TRUNCATULA.

Two symbiotic processes, nodulation and arbuscular mycorrhiza, are primarily controlled by the plant's need for nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P), respectively. Autoregulation of Nodulation (AON) and Autoregulation of Mycorrhization (AOM) both negatively regulate their respective processes and share multiple components - plants that make too many nodules usually have higher AM fungal root colonization. The protein TML (TOO MUCH LOVE) was shown to function in roots to maintain susceptibly to rhizobial infection under low N conditions and control nodule number through AON in Lotus japonicus . M. truncatula has two sequence homologs: Mt TML1 and Mt TML2. We report the generation of stable single and double mutants harboring multiple allelic variations in MtTML1 and MtTML2 using CRISPR-Cas9 targeted mutagenesis and screening of a transposon mutagenesis library. Plants containing single mutations in Mt TML1 or Mt TML2 produced 2-3 times the nodules of wild-type plants whereas plants containing mutations in both genes displayed a synergistic effect, forming 20x more nodules compared to wild type plants. Examination of expression and heterozygote effects suggest genetic compensation may play a role in the observed synergy. Plants with mutations in both TMLs only showed mild increases in AM fungal root colonization at later timepoints in our experiments, suggesting these genes may also play a minor role in AM symbiosis regulation. The mutants created will be useful tools to dissect the mechanism of synergistic action of Mt TML1 and Mt TML2 in M. truncatula symbiosis with beneficial microbes.

The evolution of gene expression plasticity during adaptation to salt in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.

When environmental change is rapid or unpredictable, phenotypic plasticity can facilitate adaptation to new or stressful environments to promote population persistence long enough for adaptive evolution to occur. However, the underlying genetic mechanisms that contribute to plasticity and its role in adaptive evolution are generally unknown. Two main opposing hypotheses dominate - genetic compensation and genetic assimilation. Here we predominantly find evidence for genetic compensation over assimilation in adapting the freshwater algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii to 36g/L salt environments over 500 generations. More canalized genes in the high-salt (HS) lines displayed a pattern of genetic compensation (63%) fixing near or at the ancestral native expression level, rather than genetic assimilation of the salt-induced level, suggesting that compensation was more common during adaptation to salt. Network analysis revealed an enrichment of genes involved in energy production and salt-resistance processes in HS lines, while an increase in DNA repair mechanisms was seen in ancestral strains. In addition, whole-transcriptome similarity amongst ancestral and HS lines displayed the evolution of a similar plastic response to salt conditions in independently reared HS lines. We also found more cis-acting regions in the HS lines; however, the expression patterns of most genes did not mimic that of their inherited sequence. Thus, the expression changes induced via plasticity offer temporary relief, but downstream changes are required for a sustainable solution during the evolutionary process.

An arms race between 5’ppp-RNA virus and its alternative recognition receptor MDA5 in RIG-I-lost teleost fish

The incessant arms race between viruses and hosts has led to numerous evolutionary innovations that shape life’s evolution. During this process, the interactions between viral receptors and viruses have garnered significant interest since viral receptors are cell surface proteins exploited by viruses to initiate infection. Our study sheds light on the arms race between the MDA5 receptor and 5’ppp-RNA virus in a lower vertebrate fish, Miichthys miiuy. Firstly, the frequent and independent loss events of RIG-I in vertebrates prompted us to search for alternative immune substitutes, with homology-dependent genetic compensation response (HDGCR) being the main pathway. Our further analysis suggested that MDA5 of M. miiuy and Gallus gallus, the homolog of RIG-I, can replace RIG-I in recognizing 5’ppp-RNA virus, which may lead to redundancy of RIG-I and loss from the species genome during evolution. Secondly, as an adversarial strategy, 5’ppp-RNA SCRV can utilize the m6A methylation mechanism to degrade MDA5 and weaken its antiviral immune ability, thus promoting its own replication and immune evasion. In summary, our study provides a snapshot into the interaction and coevolution between vertebrate and virus, offering valuable perspectives on the ecological and evolutionary factors that contribute to the diversity of the immune system.

An arms race between 5'ppp-RNA virus and its alternative recognition receptor MDA5 in RIG-I-lost teleost fish.

The incessant arms race between viruses and hosts has led to numerous evolutionary innovations that shape life's evolution. During this process, the interactions between viral receptors and viruses have garnered significant interest since viral receptors are cell surface proteins exploited by viruses to initiate infection. Our study sheds light on the arms race between the MDA5 receptor and 5'ppp-RNA virus in a lower vertebrate fish, Miichthys miiuy. Firstly, the frequent and independent loss events of RIG-I in vertebrates prompted us to search for alternative immune substitutes, with homology-dependent genetic compensation response (HDGCR) being the main pathway. Our further analysis suggested that MDA5 of M. miiuy and Gallus gallus, the homolog of RIG-I, can replace RIG-I in recognizing 5'ppp-RNA virus, which may lead to redundancy of RIG-I and loss from the species genome during evolution. Secondly, as an adversarial strategy, 5'ppp-RNA SCRV can utilize the m6A methylation mechanism to degrade MDA5 and weaken its antiviral immune ability, thus promoting its own replication and immune evasion. In summary, our study provides a snapshot into the interaction and coevolution between vertebrate and virus, offering valuable perspectives on the ecological and evolutionary factors that contribute to the diversity of the immune system.

Intelligent vehicle lateral control strategy research based on feedforward + predictive LQR algorithm with GA optimisation and PID compensation

Targeting the lateral motion control problem in the intelligent vehicle autopilot structural system, this paper proposes a feedforward + predictive LQR algorithm for lateral motion control based on Genetic Algorithm (GA) parameter optimisation and PID steering angle compensation. Firstly, based on the vehicle dynamics tracking error model, the intelligent vehicle LQR lateral motion controller as well as the feedforward controller are designed, and upon which the predictive controller is added to eliminate the system lag.Subsequently, exploiting the advantage that the PID algorithm is not model-based, a PID steering angle compensation controller that can directly control and correct the lateral error is designed. Second, a LQR controller based on path tracking deviation is designed by using the parameter rectification method of genetic algorithm (GA), which optimizes the control parameters of the lateral motion controller and improves the adaptivity of the control accuracy. Finally, Based on the Carsim-Simulink co-simulation platform, the simulation validation and analysis of double lane change (DLC) test and circular condition test (CCT) are carried out, and the results indicate that compared with the other two LQR controllers, the optimised controllers improved more than 50% in lateral error and heading error control, and the vehicle sideslip angle and vehicle yaw rate are in the range of −0.05° to 0.05° and − 0.15 rad/s to 0.10 rad/s, and it showed improved performance in tracking accuracy and satisfied vehicle stability constrains.

Knockout, Knockdown, and the Schrödinger Paradox: Genetic Immunity to Phenotypic Recapitulation in Zebrafish.

Previous research has highlighted significant phenotypic discrepancies between knockout and knockdown approaches in zebrafish, raising concerns about the reliability of these methods. However, our study suggests that these differences are not as pronounced as was once believed. By carefully examining the roles of maternal and zygotic gene contributions, we demonstrate that these factors significantly influence phenotypic outcomes, often accounting for the observed discrepancies. Our findings emphasize that morpholinos, despite their potential off-target effects, can be effective tools when used with rigorous controls. We introduce the concept of graded maternal contribution, which explains how the uneven distribution of maternal mRNA and proteins during gametogenesis impacts phenotypic variability. Our research categorizes genes into three types-susceptible, immune, and "Schrödinger" (conditional)-based on their phenotypic expression and interaction with genetic compensation mechanisms. This distinction provides new insights into the paradoxical outcomes observed in genetic studies. Ultimately, our work underscores the importance of considering both maternal and zygotic contributions, alongside rigorous experimental controls, to accurately interpret gene function and the mechanisms underlying disease. This study advocates for the continued use of morpholinos in conjunction with advanced genetic tools like CRISPR/Cas9, stressing the need for a meticulous experimental design to optimize the utility of zebrafish in genetic research and therapeutic development.

Ccdc141 is required for left-right axis development by regulating cilia formation in the Kupffer's vesicle of zebrafish

Laterality is a crucial physiological process intricately linked to the cilium-centrosome complex during embryo development. Defects in the process can result in severe organ mispositioning. Coiled-coil domain containing 141 (CCDC141) has been previously known as a centrosome-related gene, but its role in left-right (LR) asymmetry has not been characterized. In this study, we utilize the zebrafish model and human exome analysis to elucidate the function of ccdc141 in laterality defects. The knockdown of ccdc141 in zebrafish disrupts early LR signaling pathways, cilia function, and Kupffer's vesicle formation. Unlike ccdc141-knockdown embryos exhibiting aberrant LR patterns, ccdc141-null mutants show no apparent abnormality, suggesting a genetic compensation response effect. In parallel, we observe a marked reduction in α-tubulin acetylation levels in the ccdc141 crispants. The treatment with histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors, particularly the HDAC6 inhibitor, rescues the ccdc141 crispant phenotypes. Furthermore, exome analysis of 70 patients with laterality defects reveals an increased burden of CCDC141 mutations, with in-vivo studies verifying the pathogenicity of the patient mutation CCDC141-R123G. Our findings highlight the critical role of ccdc141 in ciliogenesis and demonstrate that CCDC141 mutations lead to abnormal LR patterns, identifying it as a candidate gene for laterality defects.

CRIMP: a CRISPR/Cas9 insertional mutagenesis protocol and toolkit

Site-directed insertion is a powerful approach for generating mutant alleles, but low efficiency and the need for customisation for each target has limited its application. To overcome this, we developed a highly efficient targeted insertional mutagenesis system, CRIMP, and an associated plasmid toolkit, CRIMPkit, that disrupts native gene expression by inducing complete transcriptional termination, generating null mutant alleles without inducing genetic compensation. The protocol results in a high frequency of integration events and can generate very early targeted insertions, during the first cell division, producing embryos with expression in one or both halves of the body plan. Fluorescent readout of integration events facilitates selection of successfully mutagenized fish and, subsequently, visual identification of heterozygous and mutant animals. Together, these advances greatly improve the efficacy of generating and studying mutant lines. The CRIMPkit contains 24 ready-to-use plasmid vectors to allow easy and complete mutagenesis of any gene in any reading frame without requiring custom sequences, modification, or subcloning.

CYP4A22 loss-of-function causes a new type of vitamin D-dependent rickets (VDDR1C).

Vitamin D-dependent rickets (VDDR) is a group of genetic disorders characterized by early-onset rickets due to deficiency of active vitamin D or a failure to respond to activated vitamin D. VDDR is divided into several subtypes according to the corresponding causative genes. Here we described a new type of autosomal dominant VDDR in a Chinese pedigree. The proband and his mother had severe bone malformations, dentin abnormalities, and lower serum 25 hydroxyvitamin D3 (25[OH]D3) and phosphate levels. The proband slightly responded to a high dose of vitamin D3 instead of a daily low dose of vitamin D3. Whole-exome sequencing, bioinformatic analysis, PCR, and Sanger sequencing identified a nonsense mutation in CYP4A22 (c.900delG). The overexpressed wild-type CYP4A22 mainly localized in endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi apparatus, and synthesized 25(OH)D3 in HepG2 cells. The overexpressed CYP4A22 mutant increased the expression of CYP2R1 and produced little 25(OH)D3 with vitamin D3 supplementation, which was reduced by CYP2R1 siRNA treatment. We concluded that CYP4A22 functions as a new kind of 25-hydroxylases for vitamin D3. Loss-of-function mutations in CYP4A22 lead to a new type of VDDR type 1 (VDDR1C). CYP2R1 and CYP4A22 may have some genetic compensation responding to nonsense-mediated mRNA decay effect of each other.

Fine-Tuning Amyloid Precursor Protein Expression through Nonsense-Mediated mRNA Decay.

Studies on genetic robustness recently revealed transcriptional adaptation (TA) as a mechanism by which an organism can compensate for genetic mutations through activation of homologous genes. Here, we discovered that genetic mutations, introducing a premature termination codon (PTC) in the amyloid precursor protein-b (appb) gene, activated TA of two other app family members, appa and amyloid precursor-like protein-2 (aplp2), in zebrafish. The observed transcriptional response of appa and aplp2 required degradation of mutant mRNA and did not depend on Appb protein level. Furthermore, TA between amyloid precursor protein (APP) family members was observed in human neuronal progenitor cells; however, compensation was only present during early neuronal differentiation and could not be detected in a more differentiated neuronal stage or adult zebrafish brain. Using knockdown and chemical inhibition, we showed that nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is involved in degradation of mutant mRNA and that Upf1 and Upf2, key proteins in the NMD pathway, regulate the endogenous transcript levels of appa, appb, aplp1, and aplp2 In conclusion, our results suggest that the expression level of App family members is regulated by the NMD pathway and that mutations destabilizing app/APP mRNA can induce genetic compensation by other family members through TA in both zebrafish and human neuronal progenitors.

Upf2-Mediated Nonsense-Mediated Degradation Pathway Involved in Genetic Compensation of TrpA1 Knockout Mutant Silkworm (Bombyx mori).

Genetic mutations leading to premature termination codons are known to have detrimental effects. Using the Lepidoptera model insect, the silkworm (Bombyx mori), we explored the genetic compensatory response triggered by mutations with premature termination codons. Additionally, we delved into the molecular mechanisms associated with the nonsense-mediated mRNA degradation pathway. CRISPR/Cas9 technology was utilized to generate a homozygous bivoltine silkworm line BmTrpA1-/- with a premature termination. Transcript levels were assessed for the BmTrpA paralogs, BmPyrexia and BmPainless as well as for the essential factors Upf1, Upf2, and Upf3a involved in the nonsense-mediated mRNA degradation (NMD) pathway. Upf2 was specifically knocked down via RNA interference at the embryonic stage. The results comfirmed that the BmTrpA1 transcripts with a 2-base deletion generating a premature termination codon in the BmTrpA1-/- line. From day 6 of embryonic development, the mRNA levels of BmPyrexia, BmPainless, Upf1, and Upf2 were significantly elevated in the gene-edited line. Embryonic knockdown of Upf2 resulted in the suppression of the genetic compensation response in the mutant. As a result, the offspring silkworm eggs were able to hatch normally after 10 days of incubation, displaying a non-diapause phenotype. It was observed that a genetic compensation response does exist in BmTrpA1-/-B. mori. This study presents a novel discovery of the NMD-mediated genetic compensation response in B. mori. The findings offer new insights into understanding the genetic compensation response and exploring the gene functions in lepidopteran insects, such as silkworms.

Use of E-64 cysteine protease inhibitor for the recombinant protein production in Tetrahymena thermophila

Tetrahymena thermophila is an alternative organism for recombinant protein production. However, the production efficiency in T. thermophila is quite low mainly due to the rich cysteine proteases. In this study, we studied whether supplementation of the E-64 inhibitor to T. thermophila cultures increases the recombinant protein production efficiency without any toxic side effects. Our study showed that supplementation of E-64 had no lethal effects on T. thermophila cells in flask culture at 30 °C and 38 °C. In vitro protease activity analysis using secretome as protease enzyme source from E-64-supplemented cell cultures showed a reduced protein substrate degradation using bovine serum albumin, rituximab, and milk lactoglobulin proteins. E-64 also prevented proteolysis of the recombinantly produced and secreted TtmCherry2-sfGFP fusion protein at some level. This reduced inhibitory effect of E-64 could be due to genetic compensation of the inhibited proteases. As a result, the 5 µM concentration of E-64 was found to be a non-toxic protease inhibitory supplement to improve extracellular recombinant protein production efficiency in T. thermophila. This study suggests that the use of E-64 may increase the efficiency of extracellular recombinant protein production by continuously reducing extracellular cysteine protease activity during cultivation.

Emerging roles for ABC transporters as virulence factors in uropathogenic Escherichia coli

Urinary tract infections (UTI) account for a substantial financial burden globally. Over 75% of UTIs are caused by uropathogenic Escherichia coli (UPEC), which have demonstrated an extraordinarily rapid growth rate in vivo. This rapid growth rate appears paradoxical given that urine and the human urinary tract are relatively nutrient-restricted. Thus, we lack a fundamental understanding of how uropathogens propel growth in the host to fuel pathogenesis. Here, we used large in silico, in vivo, and in vitro screens to better understand the role of UPEC transport mechanisms and their contributions to uropathogenesis. In silico analysis of annotated transport systems indicated that the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) family of transporters was most conserved among uropathogenic bacterial species, suggesting their importance. Consistent with in silico predictions, we determined that the ABC family contributed significantly to fitness and virulence in the urinary tract: these were overrepresented as fitness factors in vivo (37.2%), liquid media (52.3%), and organ agar (66.2%). We characterized 12 transport systems that were most frequently defective in screening experiments by generating in-frame deletions. These mutant constructs were tested in urovirulence phenotypic assays and produced differences in motility and growth rate. However, deletion of multiple transport systems was required to achieve substantial fitness defects in the cochallenge murine model. This is likely due to genetic compensation among transport systems, highlighting the centrality of ABC transporters in these organisms. Therefore, these nutrient uptake systems play a concerted, critical role in pathogenesis and are broadly applicable candidate targets for therapeutic intervention.

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated editing of ACTB in induced pluripotent stem cells: A model for investigating human ACTB loss-of-function and genetic adaptive responses

Heterozygous beta-actin (ACTB) indel and nonsense mutations are linked to developmental disorders. We generated two CRISPR/Cas9 human induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) lines, WTSIi018-B-19 and WTSIi018-B-20, carrying heterozygous and homozygous indel mutations in ACTB exon 4. Both iPSCs exhibited normal cell morphology, expression of pluripotency markers, and the ability to differentiate into the three primary germ layers. While iPSCs with a heterozygous ACTB mutation maintain genome integrity, homozygous mutants showed a loss of heterozygosity in chromosome three. These mutants provide a powerful model to study the onset, progression, and complex interplay of genetic compensation and phenotypic variation of ACTB-related diseases.

Abstract C081: The lysine demethylase KDM4C is an oncogenic driver in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma

Abstract Deregulation of proteins involved in chromatin regulation is common in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC), occurring via both genomic and non-genomic mechanisms. Lysine demethylase 4C (KDM4C) is one of the chromatin-modifying proteins frequently overexpressed across multiple solid cancers. We observed upregulation of Kdm4c protein in a panel of human and murine PDAC cell lines, as well as in PDAC patient samples compared to non-neoplastic controls. CRISPR/Cas9-mediated deletion of KDM4C in human and murine PDAC cells resulted in reduced proliferation and clonogenicity, and increased survival of orthotopically implanted murine PDAC allografts. Notably, in multiple KDM4C-null PDAC clones analyzed by reverse phase protein arrays (RPPA), we observed downregulation of activated mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAP kinase) pathway components (including phospho-MEK and phospho-ERK), which are key effector pathways downstream of mutant KRAS. In vitro propagation of KDM4C-null PDAC lines eventually led to adaptation and restitution of MAP kinase signaling via compensatory upregulation of other KDM4 family members (KDM4A and KDM4B). In order to bypass genetic compensation by KDM4 family members, we utilized a preclinical grade pan-KDM4 inhibitor (TACH107, Tachyon Therapeutics) in PDAC cell lines, which confirmed profound reduction in proliferation and colony formation; in vivo xenograft and allograft studies with TACH107 are now ongoing. To characterize signaling pathways perturbed by KDM4C deregulation, we investigated the transcriptional changes in PDAC cells with and without KDM4C deletion by RNA-seq and integrated these with alterations in H3K9me3 and H3K36me3 marks using histone ChIP-Seq. Regulatory network analysis identified ATF4 as one of the top downregulated transcription factor networks, validating a previously published observation linking KDM4C to amino acid biosynthesis and cell proliferation. Gene set enrichment analysis showed downregulation of RAS signatures, consistent with the RPPA data on attenuation of MAP Kinase pathway. DUSP2, a member of the dual specificity protein phosphatase subfamily that inactivates ERK, is transcriptionally upregulated and has increased H3K36me3 marks near the promoter region in KDM4C-depleted cells, nominating it as a candidate of KDM4C-mediated epigenetic regulation. To further delineate the essential binding partners of KDM4C in chromatin regulation, we have created HA-tagged catalytic domain and reader domain deletion constructs that will be used for immunoprecipitation followed by mass spectrometry analysis. Overall, our data suggests that KDM4C - and other KDM4 family members – regulate MAPK signaling in KRAS-mutant cells, at least partially via attenuation of transcripts encoding specific protein phosphatases. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration linking the requirement of sustained activity of the KDM4 family of lysine demethylases to MAPK signaling in cancer and presents an opportunity to leverage this oncogenic pathway for therapeutic purposes. Citation Format: Menna-t-Allah Shaheen, Laila Barkoudeh, Sarah Dhebat, Kimal I. Rajapakshe, Bidyut Ghosh, Anirban Maitra. The lysine demethylase KDM4C is an oncogenic driver in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference in Cancer Research: Pancreatic Cancer; 2023 Sep 27-30; Boston, Massachusetts. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2024;84(2 Suppl):Abstract nr C081.

Prime-Editing of human ACTB in induced pluripotent stem cells to model human ACTB Loss-of-Function diseases and compensatory mechanisms

Beta-actin (ACTB) heterozygous loss-of-function mutations are associated with pleiotropic developmental disorders entailing intellectual disability and frequent organ malformations in affected individuals. We generated two CRISPR/Cas9 prime-edited human induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) lines, IUFi004-A-1 and IUFi004-A-2, carrying a heterozygous missense mutation in exon 4 of ACTB. Mutant iPSCs exhibited normal cell morphology and genomic integrity, maintained expression of pluripotency markers, and differentiated into the three primary germ layers. The mutants offer a valuable platform for examining the molecular and functional consequences of ACTB haploinsufficiency, developing effective treatments, and exploring mechanisms underlying phenotypic variability and genetic compensation observed in monogenic diseases.

Special Breeding Techniques for Use in Mouse Mutation Analysis.

Certain specialized breeding techniques may come in handy during the analysis of a mutation in order to further understanding of the mutation and its interactions with other genes. Different mutant alleles of the gene in question might be available from other sources or mutations with similar phenotypes could potentially be alleles. This could be determined by complementation testing. In the production of a conditional allele, retention of exogenous DNA in the allele could fortuitously disrupt a regulatory element and thus result in a hypomorphic allele, which can be simply tested by breeding. Mutations in different genes frequently affect the same organ, tissue, or cell type through genetic interactions. Common approaches to investigate and interpret genetic interactions are detailed here for gene families, in which there may be redundancy or genetic compensation of different genes, for genes that constitute different components of a biochemical pathway, for genes with overlapping expression patterns, and for unrelated genes that produce similar mutant phenotypes.

Elevated Id2 expression causes defective meiosis and spermatogenesis in mice.

Inhibitors of DNA binding (ID) proteins mainly inhibit gene expression and regulate cell fate decisions by interacting with E-proteins. All four ID proteins (ID1-4) are present in the testis, and ID4 has a particularly important role in spermatogonial stem cell fate determination. Several lines of evidence indicate that ID proteins are involved in meiosis; however, functional experiments have not been conducted to validate this observation. In this study, we report that ID2 is enriched in spermatocytes and that forced ID2 expression in germ cells causes defects in spermatogenesis. A detailed analysis demonstrated that Id2 overexpression (Id2 OE) decreased the total number of spermatogonia and changed the dynamics of meiosis progression. Specifically, spermatocytes were enriched in the zygotene stage, and the proportion of pachytene spermatocytes was significantly decreased, indicating defects in the zygotene-pachytene transition. The number of MLH1-positive foci per cell was decreased in pachytene spermatocytes from Id2 OE testes, suggesting abnormalities in recombination. Transcriptome analysis revealed that forced Id2 expression changed the expression of a list of genes mainly associated with meiosis and spermatid development. ID2 protein is expressed in spermatocytes, and its genetic ablation in the germline does not affect spermatogenesis, likely due to genetic compensation of its family members. However, forced Id2 expression changes meiosis progression and causes defects in spermiogenesis. These data provide important evidence that ID proteins play pivotal roles in male meiosis and spermatid development.

Mechanistic toxicology in light of genetic compensation.

Mechanistic toxicology seeks to identify the molecular and cellular mechanisms by which toxicants exert their deleterious effects. One powerful approach is to generate mutations in genes that respond to a particular toxicant, and then test how such mutations change the effects of the toxicant. CRISPR is a rapid and versatile approach to generate mutations in cultured cells and in animal models. Many studies use CRISPR to generate short insertions or deletions in a target gene and then assume that the resulting mutation, such as a premature termination codon, causes a loss of functional protein. However, recent studies demonstrate that this assumption is flawed. Cells can compensate for short insertion and deletion mutations, leading toxicologists to draw erroneous conclusions from mutant studies. In this review, we will discuss mechanisms by which a mutation in one gene may be rescued by compensatory activity. We will discuss how CRISPR insertion and deletion mutations are susceptible to compensation by transcriptional adaptation, alternative splicing, and rescue by maternally derived gene products. We will review evidence that measuring levels of messenger RNA transcribed from a mutated gene is an unreliable indicator of the severity of the mutation. Finally, we provide guidelines for using CRISPR to generate mutations that avoid compensation.

Generation and validation of a myoglobin knockout zebrafish model

Previous studies using myoglobin (Mb) knockout mice and knockdown zebrafish have presented conflicting results about in vivo phenotypes resulting from the loss of this conserved and highly expressed protein, and therefore a new well-characterized knockout model is warranted. We here describe the generation of three distinct zebrafish mb knockout lines using the CRISPR/Cas system. None of the three lines exhibited any morphological phenotypes, changes in length, or lethality during embryonic and larval development. The adult homozygous knockout mb(Auzf13.2) zebrafish line were absent of Mb protein, had an almost complete degradation of mb mRNA, and showed no changes in viability, length, or heart size. Furthermore, transcriptomic analysis of adult heart tissue showed that mb knockout did not cause altered expression of other genes. Lastly, no off-targeting was observed in 36 screened loci. In conclusion, we have generated three mb knockout lines with indistinguishable phenotypes during embryonic and larval development and validated one of these lines, mb(Auzf13.2), to have no signs of genetic compensation or off-target effects in the adult heart. These findings suggests that the mb(Auzf13.2) shows promise as a candidate for investigating the biological role of Mb in zebrafish.