We study the self-trapped vortex-ring eigenstates of the two-dimensional Schrödinger equation with focusing Poisson and cubic nonlinearities. For each value of the topological charge l, there is a family of solutions depending on a parameter that can be understood as the relative importance of the cubic term. We analyze the perturbative stability of the solutions and simulate the fate of the unstable ones. For l=1 and l=2, there is an interval of the family of eigenstates for which the initial profile breaks apart but subsequently reconstructs itself, a process that can be interpreted as a nontrivial nonlinear oscillation between the vortex and an azimuthon. This revival provides a compelling realization of a recurrence of the Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou type. Outside this interval, the vortices can be stable (for small cubic terms) or unstable and nonrecurrent (for large cubic terms). We argue that there is a crossover between these regimes that resembles a strong stochasticity threshold. For l≥3, all solutions are unstable and nonrecurrent. Finally, we comment on the possible experimental implementation of this phenomenon in the context of nonlinear laser beam propagation in thermo-optical media.