Diverse ecological factors (top-down and bottom-up) act on the richness and abundance patterns of insect galls. Host plant density is a kind of bottom-up factor and is related to “resource concentration hypothesis.” In this study, we analyzed forest patches that differ in vegetational structure and host plant abundance: homogeneous forest patches (Schinus-dominated) and more complex forest patches, to determine whether there are differences in the intensity of gall infestation among individual trees. Insect galls were sampled from 15 Schinus polygamus trees along five transects in each forest (150 trees in total). Two galler species, a psyllid leaf galler and cecidomyiid shoot galler, were recorded. We found that Psyllidae gall infestation in S. polygamus presents higher values of galls per individual tree in Schinus-dominated forest patches than forest patches that are more diverse in plant species. Cecidomyiidae galls did not differ between areas and were not related to host plant abundance. We did not observe any variation in gall infestation within individual. Our study demonstrated that density-dependence effect could be more important for some galls species than others. The results suggest that biological attributes of galling insects’ infestation could be associated with susceptibility to host plant density.