Galaxy Spin Research Articles

Asymmetry in Galaxy Spin Directions: A Fully Reproducible Experiment Using HSC Data

The asymmetry in the large-scale distribution of the directions in which spiral galaxies rotate has been observed by multiple telescopes, all showing a consistent asymmetry in the distribution of galaxy spin directions as observed from Earth. Here, galaxies with a redshift from HSC DR3 are annotated by their direction of rotation, and their distribution is analyzed. The results show that galaxies that rotate in the opposite direction relative to the Milky Way as observed from Earth are significantly more prevalent compared to galaxies that rotate in the same direction relative to the Milky Way. The asymmetry also forms a dipole axis that becomes stronger when the redshift gets higher. These results are aligned with observations from virtually all premier digital sky surveys, as well as space telescopes such as the HST and the JWST. This shows that the distribution of galaxy spin directions as observed from Earth is not symmetrical, and has a possible link to the rotational velocity of the Milky Way. This experiment provides data, code, and a full protocol that allows the results to be easily reproduced in a transparent manner. This practice is used to overcome the “reproducibility crisis” in science.

No evidence for anisotropy in galaxy spin directions

ABSTRACT Modern cosmology rests on the cosmological principle, that on large enough scales the Universe is both homogeneous and isotropic. A corollary is that galaxies’ spin vectors should be isotropically distributed on the sky. This has been challenged by multiple authors for over a decade, with claims to have detected a statistically significant dipole pattern of spins. We collect all publicly available data sets with spin classifications (binary Z-wise/S-wise), and analyse them for large-angle anisotropies ($\ell \le 2$). We perform each inference in both a Bayesian and frequentist fashion, the former establishing posterior probabilities on the multipole parameters and the latter calculating p-values for rejection of the null hypothesis of isotropy (i.e. no power at $\ell \gt 0$). All analysis indicate consistency with isotropy to within $3\sigma$. We similarly identify no evidence for a ‘hemisphere anisotropy’ that neglects the angular dependence of the dipole. We isolate the differences with contrary claims in the ad hoc or biased statistics that they employ. Our code is publicly available .

Galaxy Spin Transition Driven by the Misalignments between the Protogalaxy Inertia and Initial Tidal Tensors

Abstract A numerical detection of the τ-driven transition of galaxy spins is presented, where τ is the degree of misalignment between the initial tidal field and protogalaxy inertia tensors. Analyzing the data from the IllustrisTNG300-1 simulations, we first measure the values of τ at the protogalactic sites found by tracing the constituents of the galactic halos in the mass range of 10.5 ≤ log M h / ( h − 1 M ⊙ ) ≤ 13 back to the initial stage, z i = 127. The probability density functions of τ are shown to be well modeled by the Γ-distributions, whose shape and scale parameters turn out to have universal values on a certain critical scale. Then, we investigate how the strength and tendency of the galaxy spin alignments with the principal axes of the local tidal fields depend on the initial condition, τ. It is found that on a scale lower than the critical one, the galaxy spin transition occurs at two different thresholds from the major to intermediate and from the intermediate to minor principal axes of the local tidal fields, respectively. Noting that the τ-dependent spin transition supersedes the strength of the previously found mass-dependent, morphology-dependent, and radius-dependent counterparts, we suggest that τ should be the key driver of all types of galaxy spin transitions and that the present galaxy spins are indeed excellent fossil records of their origin.

Cosmic evolution of black hole spin and galaxy orientations: Clues from the NewHorizon and Galactica simulations

Black holes (BHs) are ubiquitous components of the center of most galaxies. In addition to their mass, the BH spin, through its amplitude and orientation, is a key factor in the galaxy formation process, as it controls the radiative efficiency of the accretion disk and relativistic jets. Using the recent cosmological high-resolution zoom-in simulations and in which the evolution of the BH spin is followed on the fly, we have tracked the cosmic history of a hundred BHs with a mass greater than $2 For each of them, we have studied the variations of the three-dimensional angle (Psi ) subtended between the BH spins and the angular momentum vectors of their host galaxies (estimated from the stellar component). The analysis of the individual evolution of the most massive BHs suggests that they are generally passing by three different regimes. First, for a short period after their birth, low-mass BHs BH <$3times 10$^4$M$_ are rapidly spun up by gas accretion and their spin tends to be aligned with their host galaxy spin. Then follows a second phase in which the accretion of gas onto low-mass BHs BH is quite chaotic and inefficient, reflecting the complex and disturbed morphologies of forming proto-galaxies at high redshifts. The variations of Psi are rather erratic during this phase and are mainly driven by the rapid changes of the direction of the galaxy angular momentum. Then in a third and long phase, BHs are generally well settled in the center of galaxies around which the gas accretion becomes much more coherent BH >$10$^5$ M$_ In this case, the BH spins tend to be well aligned with the angular momentum of their host galaxy and this configuration is generally stable even though BH merger episodes can temporally induce misalignment. We even find a few cases of BH-galaxy spin anti-alignment that lasts for a long time in which the gas component is counter-rotating with respect to the stellar component. We have also derived the distributions of cos(Psi ) at different redshifts and found that BHs and galaxy spins are generally aligned. Our analysis suggests that the fraction of BH-galaxy pairs with low Psi values reaches maximum at zsim 4-3 and then decreases until zsim 1.5 due to the high BH-merger rate. Afterward, it remains almost constant probably due to the fact that BH mergers becomes rare, except for a slight increase at late times. Finally, based on a Monte Carlo method, we also predict statistics for the 2-d projected spin-orbit angles lambda . In particular, the distribution of lambda traces the alignment tendency well in the three-dimensional analysis. Such predictions provide an interesting background for future observational analyses.

The SAMI galaxy survey: impact of black hole activity on galaxy spin–filament alignments

ABSTRACT The activity of central supermassive black holes might affect the alignment of galaxy spin axes with respect to the closest cosmic filaments. We exploit the Sydney–AAO Multi-object Integral-field Galaxy Survey to study possible relations between black hole activity and the spin–filament alignments of stars and ionized gas separately. To explore the impact of instantaneous black hole activity, active galaxies are selected according to emission-line diagnostics. Central stellar velocity dispersion (σc) is used as a proxy for black hole mass and its integrated activity. We find evidence for the gas spin–filament alignments to be influenced by AGN, with Seyfert galaxies showing a stronger perpendicular alignment at fixed bulge mass with respect to galaxies, where ionization is consequence of low-ionization nuclear emission-line regions (LINERs) or old stellar populations (retired galaxies). On the other hand, the greater perpendicular tendency for the stellar spin–filament alignments of high-bulge mass galaxies is dominated by retired galaxies. Stellar alignments show a stronger correlation with σc compared to the gas alignments. We confirm that bulge mass (Mbulge) is the primary parameter of correlation for both stellar and gas spin–filament alignments (with no residual dependency left for σc), while σc is the most important property for secular star formation quenching (with no residual dependency left for Mbulge). These findings indicate that Mbulge and σc are the most predictive parameters of two different galaxy evolution processes, suggesting mergers trigger spin–filament alignment flips and integrated black hole activity drives star formation quenching.

Large-Scale Asymmetry in the Distribution of Galaxy Spin Directions—Analysis and Reproduction

Recent independent observations using several different telescope systems and analysis methods have provided evidence of parity violation between the numbers of galaxies that spin in opposite directions. On the other hand, other studies argue that no parity violation can be identified. This paper provides detailed analysis, statistical inference, and reproduction of previous reports that show no preferred spin direction. Code and data used for the reproduction are publicly available. The results show that the data used in all of these studies agree with the observation of a preferred direction as observed from Earth. In some of these studies, the datasets were too small, or the statistical analysis was incomplete. In other papers, the results were impacted by experimental design decisions that led directly to showing nonpreferred direction. In some of these cases, these decisions were not stated in the papers but were revealed after further investigation in cases where the reproduction of the work did not match the results reported in the papers. These results show that the data used in all of these previous studies, in fact, agree with the contention that galaxies as observed from Earth have a preferred spin direction, and the distribution of galaxy spin directions as observed from Earth forms a cosmological-scale dipole axis. This study also shows that the reason for the observations is not necessarily an anomaly in the large-scale structure, and can also be related to internal structure of galaxies.

Reoriented Memory of Galaxy Spins for the Early Universe

Galaxy spins are believed to retain the initially acquired tendency of being aligned with the intermediate principal axis of the linear tidal field, which disseminates the prospect of using them as a probe of early universe physics. This roseate prospect, however, is contingent upon the key assumption that the observable stellar spins of present galaxies measured at inner radii have the same alignment tendency toward the initial tidal field as their dark matter counterparts measured at virial limits. We test this assumption directly against a high-resolution hydrodynamical simulation by tracing the galaxy component particles back to the protogalactic stage. It is discovered that the galaxy stellar spins at z = 0 have strong but reoriented memory for the early universe, exhibiting a significant signal of cross-correlation with the major principal axis of the initial tidal field at z = 127. An analytic single-parameter model for this reorientation of the present galaxy stellar spins relative to the initial tidal field is devised and shown to be in good accord with the numerical results.

Supermassive black holes in merger-free galaxies have higher spins which are preferentially aligned with their host galaxy

ABSTRACT Here, we use the Horizon–active galactic nucleus (AGN) simulation to test whether the spins of supermassive black hole (SMBH) in merger-free galaxies are higher. We select samples using an observationally motivated bulge-to-total mass ratio of <0.1, along with two simulation-motivated thresholds selecting galaxies which have not undergone a galaxy merger since z = 2, and those SMBHs with $\lt 10~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ of their mass due to SMBH mergers. We find higher spins (>5σ) in all three sample compared to the rest of the population. In addition, we find that SMBHs with their growth dominated by BH mergers following galaxy mergers are less likely to be aligned with their galaxy spin than those that have grown through accretion in the absence of galaxy mergers (3.4σ). We discuss the implications this has for the impact of active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback, finding that merger-free SMBHs spend on average 91 per cent of their lifetimes since z = 2 in a radio mode of feedback (88 per cent for merger-dominated galaxies). Given that previous observational and theoretical works have concluded that merger-free processes dominate SMBH-galaxy co-evolution, our results suggest that this co-evolution could be regulated by radio mode AGN feedback.

Galaxy cluster rotation revealed in the MACSIS simulations with the kinetic Sunyaev–Zeldovich effect

ABSTRACT The kinetic Sunyaev–Zeldovich (kSZ) effect has now become a clear target for ongoing and future studies of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and cosmology. Aside from the bulk cluster motion, internal motions also lead to a kSZ signal. In this work, we study the rotational kSZ effect caused by coherent large-scale motions of the cluster medium using cluster hydrodynamic cosmological simulations. To utilize the rotational kSZ as a cosmological probe, simulations offer some of the most comprehensive data sets that can inform the modelling of this signal. In this work, we use the MACSIS data set to investigate the rotational kSZ effect in massive clusters specifically. Based on these models, we test stacking approaches and estimate the amplitude of the combined signal with varying mass, dynamical state, redshift, and map-alignment geometry. We find that the dark matter, galaxy and gas spins are generally misaligned, an effect that can cause a suboptimal estimation of the rotational kSZ effect when based on galaxy motions. Furthermore, we provide halo-spin–mass scaling relations that can be used to build a statistical model of the rotational kSZ. The rotational kSZ contribution, which is largest in massive unrelaxed clusters (≳100 $\mu$K), could be relevant to studies of higher order CMB temperature signals, such as the moving lens effect. The limited mass range of the MACSIS sample strongly motivates an extended investigation of the rotational kSZ effect in large-volume simulations to refine the modelling, particularly towards lower mass and higher redshift, and provide forecasts for upcoming cosmological CMB experiments (e.g. Simons Observatory, SKA-2) and X-ray observations (e.g. Athena/X-IFU).

Giant low surface brightness galaxies in TNG100

ABSTRACT Giant low surface brightness (GLSB) galaxies, such as Malin 1 and UGC 1382, contain the largest stellar discs known. GLSB galaxies also often contain large masses of neutral hydrogen (H i). However, these extreme galaxies’ origin and properties remain poorly understood. Using the cosmological simulation IllustrisTNG 100, we identify and select a sample of ∼200 galaxies with extended ($R_{\rm {\rm H\,{\small I}}}\,\gt\, 50$ kpc) and well-defined H i discs, ∼6 per cent of the total galaxies in the same stellar mass range (10.2 < log (M*/M⊙) < 11.6). This GLSB sample is heterogeneous, with mixed galaxy morphologies ranging from the most disc-dominated systems to massive ellipticals. These simulated GLSB galaxies are located in massive haloes ($V_{\max }\, \gt \, 150\ \rm {km\ s^{-1}}$) and their properties, such as total H i content, stellar disc parameters, star formation rate, and rotation curves, agree with observed GLSB galaxies. We construct a paired control sample to contrast with the GLSB galaxies. The GLSB galaxies tend to have large galaxy spin parameters ($40{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ larger) and larger ex situ stellar mass fractions than the paired control. We find evidence that aligned mergers promote the formation of extended discs and that isolated environments help the survival of those discs across cosmic time.

Orientation of the spins of galaxies in the local volume

ABSTRACT We estimated the angular momentum, J, of 720 galaxies in the Local Volume with distances r < 12 Mpc. The distribution of the average angular momentum along the Hubble sequence has a maximum at the morphological type T = 4 (Sbc), while the dispersion of the J-values for galaxies is minimal. Among the Local Volume population, 27 elite spiral galaxies stand out, with an angular momentum > 0.15 of the Milky Way, J > 0.15JMW, making the main contribution ($\gt 90~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ ) to the total angular momentum of galaxies in the considered volume. Using observational data on the kinematics and structure of these galaxies, we determined the direction of their spins. We present the first map of the distribution of the spins of 27 nearby massive spiral galaxies in the sky and note that their pattern does not exhibit significant alignment with respect to the Local Sheet plane. The relationship between the magnitude of the angular momentum and stellar mass of the local galaxies is well represented by a power law with an exponent of (5/3) over an interval of six orders of magnitude of the mass of galaxies.

Is the observable Universe consistent with the cosmological principle?

The cosmological principle (CP)—the notion that the Universe is spatially isotropic and homogeneous on large scales—underlies a century of progress in cosmology. It is conventionally formulated through the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies as the spacetime metric, and culminates in the successful and highly predictive Λ-Cold-Dark-Matter (ΛCDM) model. Yet, tensions have emerged within the ΛCDM model, most notably a statistically significant discrepancy in the value of the Hubble constant, H 0. Since the notion of cosmic expansion determined by a single parameter is intimately tied to the CP, implications of the H 0 tension may extend beyond ΛCDM to the CP itself. This review surveys current observational hints for deviations from the expectations of the CP, highlighting synergies and disagreements that warrant further study. Setting aside the debate about individual large structures, potential deviations from the CP include variations of cosmological parameters on the sky, discrepancies in the cosmic dipoles, and mysterious alignments in quasar polarizations and galaxy spins. While it is possible that a host of observational systematics are impacting results, it is equally plausible that precision cosmology may have outgrown the FLRW paradigm, an extremely pragmatic but non-fundamental symmetry assumption.

Reanalysis of the Spin Direction Distribution of Galaxy Zoo SDSS Spiral Galaxies

The distribution of the spin directions of spiral galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey has been a topic of debate in the past two decades, with conflicting conclusions reported even in cases where the same data were used. Here, we follow one of the previous experiments by applying the SpArcFiRe algorithm to annotate the spin directions in an original dataset of Galaxy Zoo 1. The annotation of the galaxy spin directions is carried out after the first step of selecting the spiral galaxies in three different manners: manual analysis by Galaxy Zoo classifications, by a model-driven computer analysis, and with no selection of spiral galaxies. The results show that when spiral galaxies are selected by Galaxy Zoo volunteers, the distribution of their spin directions as determined by SpArcFiRe is not random, which agrees with previous reports. When selecting the spiral galaxies using a model-driven computer analysis or without selecting the spiral galaxies at all, the distribution is also not random. Simple binomial distribution analysis shows that the probability of the parity violation to occur by chance is lower than 0.01. Fitting the spin directions as observed from the Earth to cosine dependence exhibits a dipole axis with statistical strength of 2.33 σ to 3.97 σ . These experiments show that regardless of the selection mechanism and the analysis method, all experiments show similar conclusions. These results are aligned with previous reports using other methods and telescopes, suggesting that the spin directions of spiral galaxies as observed from the Earth exhibit a dipole axis formed by their spin directions. Possible explanations can be related to the large-scale structure of the universe or to the internal structure of galaxies. The catalogs of annotated galaxies generated as part of this study are available.

Galaxy Spin Classification. I. Z-wise versus S-wise Spirals with the Chirality Equivariant Residual Network

The angular momentum of galaxies (galaxy spin) contains rich information about the initial condition of the universe, yet it is challenging to efficiently measure the spin direction for the tremendous amount of galaxies that are being mapped by ongoing and forthcoming cosmological surveys. We present a machine-learning-based classifier for the Z-wise versus S-wise spirals, which can help to break the degeneracy in the galaxy spin direction measurement. The proposed chirality equivariant residual network (CE-ResNet) is manifestly equivariant under a reflection of the input image, which guarantees that there is no inherent asymmetry between the Z-wise and S-wise probability estimators. We train the model with Sloan Digital Sky Survey images, with the training labels given by the Galaxy Zoo 1 project. A combination of data augmentation techniques is used during the training, making the model more robust to be applied to other surveys. We find an ∼30% increase in both types of spirals when Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) images are used for classification, due to the better imaging quality of DESI. We verify that the ∼7σ difference between the numbers of Z-wise and S-wise spirals is due to human bias, since the discrepancy drops to <1.8σ with our CE-ResNet classification results. We discuss the potential systematics relevant to future cosmological applications.

The unusual Milky Way-local sheet system: implications for spin strength and alignment

ABSTRACT The Milky Way and the Local Sheet form a peculiar galaxy system in terms of the unusually low velocity dispersion in our neighbourhood and the seemingly high mass of the Milky Way for such an environment. Using the TNG300 simulation, we searched for Milky Way analogues (MWA) located in the cosmological walls with velocity dispersion in their local Hubble flow similar to the one observed around our galaxy. We find that MWAs in Local-Sheet analogues are rare, with one per (160–200 Mpc)3 volume. We find that a Sheet-like cold environment preserves, amplifies, or simplifies environmental effects on the angular momentum of galaxies. In such sheets, there are particularly strong alignments between the sheet and galaxy spins; also, these galaxies have low spin parameters. These both may relate to a lack of mergers since wall formation. We hope our results will bring awareness of the atypical nature of the Milky Way-Local Sheet system. Wrongly extrapolating local observations without a full consideration of the effect of our cosmic environment can lead to a Copernican bias in understanding the formation and evolution of the Milky Way and the nearby Universe.

The SAMI Galaxy Survey: flipping of the spin–filament alignment correlates most strongly with growth of the bulge

ABSTRACT We study the alignments of galaxy spin axes with respect to cosmic web filaments as a function of various properties of the galaxies and their constituent bulges and discs. We exploit the SAMI Galaxy Survey to identify 3D spin axes from spatially resolved stellar kinematics and to decompose the galaxy into the kinematic bulge and disc components. The GAMA survey is used to reconstruct the cosmic filaments. The mass of the bulge, defined as the product of stellar mass and bulge-to-total flux ratio Mbulge = M⋆ × (B/T), is the primary parameter of correlation with spin–filament alignments: galaxies with lower bulge masses tend to have their spins parallel to the closest filament, while galaxies with higher bulge masses are more perpendicularly aligned. M⋆ and B/T separately show correlations, but they do not fully unravel spin–filament alignments. Other galaxy properties, such as visual morphology, stellar age, star formation activity, kinematic parameters, and local environment, are secondary tracers. Focussing on S0 galaxies, we find preferentially perpendicular alignments, with the signal dominated by high-mass S0 galaxies. Studying bulge and disc spin–filament alignments separately reveals additional information about the formation pathways of the corresponding galaxies: bulges tend to have more perpendicular alignments, while discs show different tendencies according to their kinematic features and the mass of the associated bulge. The observed correlation between the flipping of spin–filament alignments and the growth of the bulge can be explained by mergers, which drive both alignment flips and bulge formation.

Asymmetry in Galaxy Spin Directions—Analysis of Data from DES and Comparison to Four Other Sky Surveys

The paper shows an analysis of the large-scale distribution of galaxy spin directions of 739,286 galaxies imaged by DES. The distribution of the spin directions of the galaxies exhibits a large-scale dipole axis. Comparison of the location of the dipole axis to a similar analysis with data from SDSS, Pan-STARRS, and DESI Legacy Survey shows that all sky surveys exhibit dipole axes within 52° or less from each other, well within 1σ error, while non-random distribution is unexpected, the findings are consistent across all sky surveys, regardless of the telescope or whether the data were annotated manually or automatically. Possible errors that can lead to the observation are discussed. The paper also discusses previous studies showing opposite conclusions and analyzes the decisions that led to these results. Although the observation is provocative, and further research will be required, the existing evidence justifies considering the contention that galaxy spin directions as observed from Earth are not necessarily randomly distributed. Possible explanations can be related to mature cosmological theories, but also to the internal structure of galaxies.

Using 3D and 2D analysis for analyzing large-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions

Abstract The nature of galaxy spin is still not fully known. Iye, Yagi, and Fukumoto (2021, AJ, 907, 123) applied a 3D analysis to a dataset of bright SDSS galaxies that was used in the past for photometric analysis. They showed that the distribution of spin directions of spiral galaxies is random, providing a dipole axis with low statistical significance of 0.29σ. However, to show random distribution, two decisions were made, each of which can lead to random distribution regardless of the real distribution of the spin direction of galaxies. The first decision was to limit the dataset arbitrarily to z &amp;lt; 0.1, which is a redshift range in which previous literature already showed that random distribution is expected. More importantly, while the 3D analysis requires the redshift of each galaxy, the analysis was done with the photometric redshift. If the asymmetry existed, its signal is expected to be an order of magnitude weaker than the error of the photometric redshift, and therefore a low statistical signal under these conditions is expected. When using the exact same data without limiting to zphot &amp;lt; 0.1 and without using the photometric redshift, the distribution of the spin directions in that dataset shows a statistical signal of &amp;gt;2σ. Code and data for reproducing the analysis are publicly available. These results are in agreement with other experiments with SDSS, Pan-STARRS, HST, and the DESI Legacy Survey. The paper also examines other previous studies that showed random distribution in galaxy spin directions. While further research will be required, the current evidence suggests that large-scale asymmetry between the number of clockwise and counterclockwise galaxies cannot be ruled out.

Analysis of ∼106 Spiral Galaxies from Four Telescopes Shows Large-Scale Patterns of Asymmetry in Galaxy Spin Directions

The ability to collect unprecedented amounts of astronomical data has enabled the nomical data has enabled the stu scientific questions that were impractical to study in the pre-information era. This study uses large datasets collected by four different robotic telescopes to profile the large-scale distribution of the spin directions of spiral galaxies. These datasets cover the Northern and Southern hemispheres, in addition to data acquired from space by the Hubble Space Telescope. The data were annotated automatically by a fully symmetric algorithm, as well as manually through a long labor-intensive process, leading to a dataset of nearly 10 6 galaxies. The data show possible patterns of asymmetric distribution of the spin directions, and the patterns agree between the different telescopes. The profiles also agree when using automatic or manual annotation of the galaxies, showing very similar large-scale patterns. Combining all data from all telescopes allows the most comprehensive analysis of its kind to date in terms of both the number of galaxies and the footprint size. The results show a statistically significant profile that is consistent across all telescopes. The instruments used in this study are DECam, HST, SDSS, and Pan-STARRS. The paper also discusses possible sources of bias and analyzes the design of previous work that showed different results. Further research will be required to understand and validate these preliminary observations.

New evidence and analysis of cosmological-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions

In the past several decades, multiple cosmological theories that are based on the contention that the Universe has a major axis have been proposed. Such theories can be based on the geometry of the Universe, or multiverse theories such as black hole cosmology. The contention of a cosmological-scale axis is supported by certain evidence such as the dipole axis formed by the CMB distribution. Here I study another form of the cosmological-scale axis, based on the distribution of the spin direction of spiral galaxies. Data from four different telescopes are analyzed, showing nearly identical axis profiles when the distribution of the redshifts of the galaxies is similar.