Probing Attachment Gain Research Articles

Evaluation of gingival suppuration and supragingival plaque following 4 modalities of periodontal therapy

Abstract This study evaluated the effect of coronal scaling (CS), root planing (RP), modified Widman surgery (MW) and flap with osseous resectional surgery (FO) upon the presence of gingival suppuration and supragingival plaque. 75 patients completed split-mouth therapy and 2 years of maintenance care. Data were collected prior to the initiation of therapy, following initial therapy, following surgical therapy and yearly during 2 years of maintenance care. All 4 types of therapy reduced the prevalence of suppuration with RP, MW and FO producing a greater reduction than CS in sites 5 mm. Sites were grouped according to presence of suppuration at 2 consecutive examinations. The mean changes in probing depth and probing attachment level for each time period were compared. Sites that began to suppurate between 2 exams or were suppurating at both exams had a less favorable response in mean probing depth reduction and mean probing attachment gain when compared to sites that stopped suppurating between exams or did not suppurate at either exam. The prevalence of supragingival plaque decreased during active therapy and 2 years of maintenance. There was no difference in the prevalence between the therapy groups except for FO-treated sites showing more plaque accumulation after surgical therapy. The presence or absence of supragingival plaque at specific sites was dynamic, frequently converting to a new status between 2 examinations.

Human suprabony healing responses following root demineralization and coronal flap anchorage

6 suprabony pockets in 2 adult patients were treated with debridement and citric acid root demineralization. Following these procedures, coronal positioning of the marginal flaps was performed at 2 sites. At 4 sites, the marginal flaps were sutured coronally using orthodontic brackets as anchors. At 1 additional site, root debridement only was performed and the margin was placed at about crestal level. Prior to root planing, all roots were notched both at the level of the gingival margin and the most apically positioned calculus. Blocks were harvested 7 and 18 weeks postsurgery and prepared for histologic analysis. Clinical results showed a gain in probing attachment in both coronally positioned sites (average = 1.8 mm) and coronally anchored sites (average = 4.5 mm). The additional debrided-only site showed a gain in probing attachment of 0.1 mm. Histologically, new cementum with functionally inserted fibers was seen within the calculus notch in all coronally anchored sites. This new attachment was associated with crestal osteogenesis. In the 2 coronally positioned and root demineralized sites, new attachment was seen within the calculus notch in 1 out of the 2 specimens evaluated. Within the limits of the evidence presented, coronal anchorage of flaps enhanced probing attachment and new attachment when used in conjunction with root demineralization.

Therapeutic effects of combined treatment using tetracycline‐immobilized collagen film and root planing in periodontal furcation pockets

46 upper and lower molars with furcation grade II involvement were selected from 16 patients with periodontal disease. The teeth were randomly allocated to the following groups according to treatment; (1) 4 consecutive administrations of tetracycline-immobilized cross-linked collagen film (TC film) at intervals of 1 week (TC group); (2) 1 root planing treatment (RP group); (3) combination treatment (TC + RP group); (4) no treatment (control group). The therapeutic effects of each treatment were compared both clinically and microbiologically. Records of plaque index, gingival index, bleeding on probing, probing depth, probing attachment level and microscopic counts were obtained at 0, 4, 6 and 8 weeks. The results showed marked decreases in probing depth and density of micro-organisms in both the RP and TC + RP groups. In particular, the TC + RP group was characterized by a decreased rate of bleeding on pocket probing and an increased probing attachment gain. The above findings demonstrated that root planning is effective in the treatment of furcation involvement and that the effects are enhanced by the local administration of TC films.

Clinical Evaluation of a Biodegradable Collagen Membrane in Guided Tissue Regeneration

A bio-resorbable type I collagen membrane was investigated as a barrier for guided tissue regeneration. Ten human subjects with at least one pair of contralateral periodontal lesions with probing pocket depths of greater than or equal to 5 mm and radiographic evidence of greater than or equal to 40% bone loss were included. Each patient underwent contralateral surgical flap procedures. A collagen barrier was adapted to the tooth in the experimental defect and the flap replaced and sutured. The controls consisted of the same procedure without the placement of the barrier. Standardized measurements of change in probing attachment levels and fill of intrabony defects were obtained at the time of surgery and 1 year later at the time of surgical re-entry. The differences in change of probing attachment levels and amount of bone fill between individual test and control sites were compared utilizing the student's t-test for paired samples. The mean probing attachment gain in the test sites was 0.56 +/- 0.57 mm, and there was a mean probing attachment loss of 0.71 +/- 0.91 mm in the control sites (P less than 0.01). The gain of bone in test lesions was 1.16 +/- 0.95 mm, while no gain was observed in the control lesions (P less than 0.01). The results of this study demonstrated that sites treated with a collagen barrier comprised of cross-linked bovine Type I collagen exhibited significantly better healing as compared to control sites over the 1-year period of the study.

Evaluation of gingival suppuration and supragingival plaque following 4 modalities of periodontal therapy

This study evaluated the effect of coronal scaling (CS), root planing (RP), modified Widman surgery (MW) and flap with osseous resectional surgery (FO) upon the presence of gingival suppuration and supragingival plaque. 75 patients completed split-mouth therapy and 2 years of maintenance care. Data were collected prior to the initiation of therapy, following initial therapy, following surgical therapy and yearly during 2 years of maintenance care. All 4 types of therapy reduced the prevalence of suppuration with RP, MW and FO producing a greater reduction than CS in sites greater than or equal to 5 mm. Sites were grouped according to presence of suppuration at 2 consecutive examinations. The mean changes in probing depth and probing attachment level for each time period were compared. Sites that began to suppurate between 2 exams or were suppurating at both exams had a less favorable response in mean probing depth reduction and mean probing attachment gain when compared to sites that stopped suppurating between exams or did not suppurate at either exam. The prevalence of supragingival plaque decreased during active therapy and 2 years of maintenance. There was no difference in the prevalence between the therapy groups except for FO-treated sites showing more plaque accumulation after surgical therapy. The presence or absence of supragingival plaque at specific sites was dynamic, frequently converting to a new status between 2 examinations.

Responses of Four Tooth and Site Groupings to Periodontal Therapy

The responses of four tooth/site groupings to periodontal therapy were evaluated. Eighty-two patients with periodontitis were treated in a split mouth design with coronal scaling, root planing, modified Widman surgery, and flap with osseous resectional surgery. Patients were evaluated prior to therapy, 4 weeks post-Phase I therapy, 10 weeks post-Phase II therapy, and at yearly intervals during 2 years of maintenance therapy. The tooth/site groupings evaluated were: 1) interproximal sites of single rooted teeth (T1), 2) facial and lingual sites of single rooted teeth (T2), 3) nonfurcation sites of molar teeth (T3), and 4) furcation sites of molar teeth (T4). Following 2 years of maintenance, no clinically significant differences in probing depth reduction or probing attachment loss were present between the four tooth/site groupings in 1 mm to 4 mm sites. T2 had the greatest decrease of probing depth in 5 mm to 6 mm sites followed by T1, T3 and T4. T1 and T2 showed a greater gain of probing attachment followed by T3 and T4. T1 and T2 had the greatest decrease of probing followed by T3 which was greater than T4 in greater than or equal to 7 mm sites. T4 had significantly less probing attachment gain than the other groups. There was a trend for T1 and T2 to have less gingival bleeding post-therapy and for T2 to have less plaque accumulation than the other groups at both pre- and post-therapy examinations.

Human Freeze–Dried Dura Mater Allografts as a Periodontal Biological Bandage

Freeze-dried dura mater allografts (FDDMA) were used as a biologic bandage covering periodontal osseous defects which were grafted with autogenous bone particles. Seven consenting adult patients having multiple one-, two-, and wide three-wall periodontal osseous defects participated in the study. Four to 6 weeks following initial preparation, all defects were treated by full thickness flap surgery, debridement of defects, root planing, intramarrow penetration as needed, and autogenous bone grafts that filled the defects. Randomly selected grafted defects in each patient were then covered with FDDMA (experimental) or by the host flap (RF) (control). Periodontal dressing and systemic tetracycline (250 mg q.i.d.) were used for 7 days. Frequent maintenance was performed until reevaluation at 6 months postsurgically. Soft tissue results showed no significant differences in initial probing pocket depths, recession, or gain of probing attachment. There was a significantly greater amount of probing pocket depth reduction and significantly shallower residual pockets when FDDMA was used. Hard tissue findings indicated that there were no significant differences in initial defect depth, amount of crestal resorption, or amount or percent of defect fill with either treatment. There were significant differences in the percent of defect resolution and the depth of the residual defect in favor of the FDDMA treatment. None of the FDDMA sites were felt to need a secondary surgery to correct residual defects or residual pockets. This study suggests that FDDMA may be beneficial as a "biologic bandage" to cover periodontal osseous defects that were filled with autogenous bone grafts. The trends in this study suggest that FDDMA may be very useful in periodontal regeneration procedures.

Microbial succession in recolonizing deep periodontal pockets after a single course of supra- and subgingival debridement.

In the present study, the effect of supra and subgingival plaque debridement on the dynamics of the subgingival microflora in deep pockets was investigated. 8 adult periodontitis patients participated in the study. In each patient, 4 clinically diseased sites were investigated microbiologically by phase contrast microscopy for the determination of both the %s as well as the total numbers of spirochetes and motile rods and by anaerobic cultivation for the determination of the different black-pigmented Bacteroides species. After base-line examination, patients were treated by mechanical removal of supra- and subgingival plaque deposits. 2 and 8 weeks after treatment, clinical and microbiological parameters were re-evaluated. During the experimental period, no oral hygiene procedures were performed in order to achieve fast recolonization of the pockets. Treatment resulted in a significant reduction in probing pocket depth and gain of probing attachment. 2 weeks after treatment, no further improvements could be observed. A positive correlation was found between the reduction in probing pocket depth and decrease in Bacteroides gingivalis (P less than 0.009) and between gain in probing attachment and reduction in the % of B. gingivalis (P less than 0.009). No correlation between these clinical parameters and B. intermedius, spirochetes or motile rods was apparent. An inverse relationship between B. gingivalis and B. intermedius was observed. We found that changes in %s of spirochetes and motile rods are not correlated with changes in total numbers of these bacterial groups. It was concluded that monitoring of %s of micro-organisms may not supply rational information on the microbiological conditions of the subgingival area.

4‐year observations of basic periodontal therapy

A total of 2214 sites from incisors, cuspids, and premolars were studied in 46 adult periodontitis patients following treatment consisting of plaque control and root debridement. The periodontal status at 24 months was used as baseline for observations during the subsequent 24-48 month interval which included 4 recall visits for debridement at the 24-, 30-, 36-, and 42-month time points. The data were analyzed for pooled groups of sites of different probing depth at 24 months: less than or equal to 3.5 mm, 4.0-6.5 mm, and greater than or equal to 7.0 mm. The results showed little change during the 24-48 month interval in mean scores for bleeding on probing, probing depth, and probing attachment level for all 3 groups of sites. Individual sites with probing attachment loss during the 24-48 month period were identified. The frequency of such sites was similar, irrespective of 24-month probing depth. The sites identified with probing attachment loss during the 24-48 month interval generally differed in location from those identified as having probing attachment loss during the preceeding 0-24 month period. Often, the loss of probing attachment during the 24-48 month interval seemed to be a reversal of a prior gain in probing attachment during the 0-24 month interval. This study in non-molar teeth of subjects with generally good level of compliance failed to demonstrate that sites with deeper probing depth were more difficult to maintain than shallower sites.

Effect of nonsurgical periodontal therapy (VIII). Probing attachment changes related to clinical characteristics.

Individual sites with gain and loss of probing attachment were identified amongst 1688 proximal sites in non-molar teeth from 49 patients monitored for 24 months following oral hygiene instruction and root debridement. The distribution of sites with gain and loss of probing attachment was studied within each of the 49 subjects, for each of the 10 different tooth types treated, for teeth with and without root canal fillings, for mesial and distal surfaces, and for surfaces with and without the presence of root concavity/furcation involvement. Similarly, sites with gain and loss were related to the following measurements of the severity of the initial lesion: initial probing depth, radiographic bone score, depth of radiographic intraosseous defect, and radiographically widened periodontal ligament. The analyses indicated that subjects with a higher proportion of sites with probing attachment gain tended to have a lower proportion of sites with probing attachment loss. Sites with deep initial probing depth demonstrated a high incidence of gain and a low incidence of loss of probing attachment. All other investigated characteristics showed weak or no association with probing attachment change following therapy. This report indicates that the 24-month outcome of plaque control and root debridement in proximal surfaces of non-molar teeth is not compromised by the severity of the initial soft tissue or bony lesion.

Periodontal conditions of teeth adjacent to extraction sites.

The purpose of the present clinical study was to evaluate the effect of tooth extractions on the periodontal conditions of adjacent teeth. 40 patients were selected for the study. Prior to the extractions, baseline data of the adjacent teeth were obtained. Plaque (PII) and gingival indices (GI), pocket probing depths and probing attachment levels were scored. In addition, the alveolar bone height was determined radiographically in relation to the CEJ adjacent to the extraction sites. The contralateral side of the jaw, where no tooth had to be removed, was examined as a control. A limited hygienic phase (scaling and root planing of all surfaces examined) was performed immediately prior to the extractions. Using the same parameters, all sites were reexamined 2-4 months and 6-9 months following the extractions. After the hygienic phase, the teeth adjacent to the extraction sites indicated a decrease in the pocket probing depths by 0.5 to 1.5 mm. In shallow pockets (1-3 mm), this decrease was less pronounced than in moderate to deep pockets (4-9 mm), where it was composed of shrinkage of the gingival tissues and gain of probing attachment. The radiographic level of the bony alveolar crest in relation to the CEJ of the adjacent teeth was not altered by the extraction procedure. The oral hygiene performances of the patients were not influenced during the 9-month observation period. Therefore, neither PII nor GI scores showed relevant improvements.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of age on healing following periodontal therapy.

The present investigation was performed in order to analyze the effect of age on healing of the periodontal tissues following treatment. The patients included in the present analysis consisted of 2 different samples. One group of 62 patients (sample A) was examined and treated between 1980 and 1982. 13 of these subjects were less than 40 years of age, 26 subjects were 40-49 years of age and 23 subjects were greater than 49 years old. The patients were subjected to periodontal surgery using the modified Widman flap procedure. During the active phase of treatment and for the subsequent 6 months of healing, all 62 patients were subjected to professional tooth cleaning. Instruction in proper oral hygiene measures was repeated and scaling was carried out when indicated. Sample B consisted of 21 subjects treated for advanced periodontal disease in 1969. Six of these patients were between 26 and 29 years of age at the start of treatment and 15 were at least 60 years old. The criterion for acceptance for the study in 1969 was that the patient should have lost 50% or more of his/her periodontal tissues. Following an initial examination, all patients were subjected to scaling and root planing and surgical elimination of pathologically deepened pockets. After the termination of active treatment, the patients were placed in a maintenance care program which included recall appointments every 3-6 months. Once a year after the completion of active treatment, all patients in this sample were examined regarding probing depths and clinical attachment levels. The findings from the present retrospective analyses failed to demonstrate that the age of patients with moderately advanced or advanced forms of periodontal tissue breakdown had an influence on the results of periodontal therapy. If anything, the younger patients appeared to heal with a higher frequency of shallow pockets and more gain of probing attachment than older patients.

Significance of probing force for evaluation of healing following periodontal therapy.

The present report compares pre- and postoperative probing pocket depths and probing attachment levels in deep pockets treated non-surgically as well as surgically using probing forces at 0.25 N, 0.50 N and 0.75 N. The results demonstrated that the recorded mean pre- and postoperative probing depths were deeper with increasing probing force. In deep preoperative pockets, the difference amounted to as much as 2.0 mm comparing measurements at 0.25 N and 0.75 N. The use of 0.25 N for evaluation of therapy showed less mean pocket reduction and probing attachment gain than the use of 0.50 N or 0.75 N. Selection of a higher probing force before therapy (i.e. 0.75 N) and a lower force after therapy (i.e. 0.25 N) resulted in increased values for pocket reduction and probing attachment gain compared to use of the same probing force for both pre- and postoperative recordings. The findings emphasize the significance of using a known and standardized probing force for evaluation of results following periodontal therapy.

Microbiological and clinical effects of topical subgingival antimicrobial treatment on human periodontal disease.

This study was undertaken to evaluate the microbiological and clinical effects of a subgingivally applied mixture of H2O2-NaCl and NaHCO3 followed by subgingival irrigation with 1% Betadine in the treatment of periodontal disease. 20 adults with moderate to severe periodontal disease were included in a split mouth design study. All patients were given oral hygiene instruction and were subjected to supragingival scaling in all 4 quadrants, and subgingival scaling and root planing of half the dentition. 10 patients were instructed to use the chemical antimicrobial mixture twice a day instead of dentifrice, and also received professional application of the mixture once every 14 days for 3 months in connection with reinstruction in oral hygiene procedures. The remaining 10 patients received oral hygiene instructions combined with professional tooth cleaning without use of chemicals once every 14 days during a 3-month period. The effect of treatment was evaluated by monitoring the subgingival microflora, clinical periodontal parameters, and by computer assisted subtraction analysis of serial standardized radiographs to determine changes in mass of the supporting alveolar bone. The present study revealed that subgingival debridement combined with mechanical plaque control resulted in decreased numbers of subgingival microorganisms including spirochetes and motile rods, and arrested the progressive breakdown of the periodontal tissues. Topical antimicrobial agents used in combination with subgingival scaling further reduced the subgingival microflora and substantially improved early periodontal healing including gain of probing attachment level and gain in radiographic alveolar bone mass during the 12 months of observation. No clinical improvement but a tendency to further periodontal breakdown was found in the unscaled quadrants, even in those which were subjected to a personal application of the topical antimicrobial mixture. This study indicates that professional and personal subgingival application of a mixture of H2O2-NaCl and NaHCo3 will significantly enhance the microbiological and clinical effects of periodontal scaling and root planing. These agents, and the topical mode of antimicrobial therapy seem promising in the management of human periodontal diseases.