Gabor Patches Research Articles

Perceptual learning leads to long lasting visual improvement in patients with central vision loss.

Macular Degeneration (MD), a visual disease that produces central vision loss, is one of the main causes of visual disability in western countries. Patients with MD are forced to use a peripheral retinal locus (PRL) as a substitute of the fovea. However, the poor sensitivity of this region renders basic everyday tasks very hard for MD patients. We investigated whether perceptual learning (PL) with lateral masking in the PRL of MD patients, improved their residual visual functions. Observers were trained with two distinct contrast detection tasks: (i) a Yes/No task with no feedback (MD: N = 3; controls: N = 3), and (ii) a temporal two-alternative forced choice task with feedback on incorrect trials (i.e., temporal-2AFC; MD: N = 4; controls: N = 3). Observers had to detect a Gabor patch (target) flanked above and below by two high contrast patches (i.e., lateral masking). Stimulus presentation was monocular with durations varying between 133 and 250 ms. Participants underwent 24- 27 training sessions in total. Both PL procedures produced significant improvements in the trained task and learning transferred to visual acuity. Besides, the amount of transfer was greater for the temporal-2AFC task that induced a significant improvement of the contrast sensitivity for untrained spatial frequencies. Most importantly, follow-up tests on MD patients trained with the temporal-2AFC task showed that PL effects were retained between four and six months, suggesting long-term neural plasticity changes in the visual cortex. The results show for the first time that PL with a lateral masking configuration has strong, non-invasive and long lasting rehabilitative potential to improve residual vision in the PRL of patients with central vision loss.

Gamma-band activity reflects attentional guidance by facial expression

Facial expressions attract attention due to their motivational significance. Previous work focused on attentional biases towards threat-related, fearful faces, although healthy participants tend to avoid mild threat. Growing evidence suggests that neuronal gamma (>30Hz) and alpha-band activity (8–12Hz) play an important role in attentional selection, but it is unknown if such oscillatory activity is involved in the guidance of attention through facial expressions. Thus, in this magnetoencephalography (MEG) study we investigated whether attention is shifted towards or away from fearful faces and characterized the underlying neuronal activity in these frequency ranges in forty-four healthy volunteers. We employed a covert spatial attention task using neutral and fearful faces as task-irrelevant distractors and emotionally neutral Gabor patches as targets. Participants had to indicate the tilt direction of the target. Analysis of the neuronal data was restricted to the responses to target Gabor patches. We performed statistical analysis at the sensor level and used subsequent source reconstruction to localize the observed effects. Spatially selective attention effects in the alpha and gamma band were revealed in parieto-occipital regions. We observed an attentional cost of processing the face distractors, as reflected in lower task performance on targets with short stimulus onset asynchrony (SOA <150ms) between faces and targets. On the neuronal level, attentional orienting to face distractors led to enhanced gamma band activity in bilateral occipital and parietal regions, when fearful faces were presented in the same hemifield as targets, but only in short SOA trials. Our findings provide evidence that both top-down and bottom-up attentional biases are reflected in parieto-occipital gamma-band activity.

Was that a threat? A cueing study on attentional guidance by threat signals

Research indicates that stimuli signaling threat may capture and hold attention. However, whether threat signals have a true effect on perception and attention or if this effect results merely from arousal and response activation is still a matter of debate. 34 volunteers completed a modified spatial-emotional cueing paradigm to examine how perceptual sensitivity (d') and response times (RT) were affected by a threatening stimulus. The color of one cue was paired with a chance to receive an electric shock, the others were neutral. Two colored circles were presented as cues at each side of fixation, one of which could be associated with a shock. Following the cues, two Gabor patches were presented; one of which was tilted and served as target. The target Gabor patch could be presented at the location of the threat-associated cue (Cued) or on the opposite side (Uncued). Stimulus onset asynchrony (SOA) between cue and target was either 100ms or 1000ms. The results showed, relative to the neutral condition, an increased perceptual sensitivity (d') and faster RTs for targets appearing at the location where the threat associated cue was presented and lower d' and slower RTs for targets appearing at opposite side of the threatening cue. This indicates that, immediately after cue presentation, attention is captured by the threat-associated cue, evidenced by the higher d' for detecting targets at the cued versus the uncued locations at the short SOA. Crucially, this enhanced perceptual sensitivity remained present for the long SOA, suggesting that attention remains focused at the location of the threatening stimulus even 1000 ms after it was extinguished. RT measures followed a similar pattern. The current results show an effect of threatening stimuli on perceptual selectivity (d'), providing unequivocal evidence that threatening stimuli can modulate the efficacy of sensory processing. Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2016

Saccades inevitably protect visual memory traces

With each visual fixation, a vast amount of information enters the visual system, only part of which will be stored durably in visual short-term memory (VSTM). We present four experiments testing the hypothesis that saccadic eye movements decide upon the content of VSTM, and determine naturally what we remember and what we forget. We studied whether saccades, planned and executed after the disappearance of a visual stimulus array, influence memory performance even if the saccade is irrelevant to the memory task. We flashed briefly (100 ms) an array of oriented Gabor patches and—after a variable delay—prompted saccades to a random (now empty) location in the array. Subsequently, a response cue instructed observers to report the orientation of one randomly selected stimulus in the array, probing memory either at the same (congruent) or at a different location than the saccade target (incongruent). In all experiments, memory performance was markedly better when the probed location and the saccade target coincided. This effect of saccades on visual memory was time-dependent; it was strongest right after array offset, still present after 800 ms, and no longer significant after 1600 ms (Experiment 1). In contrast, the performance difference between congruent and incongruent trials remained constant across a large range of intervals between saccade cue and the onset of the response cue (Experiment 2). Masking the memory array up to 800 ms after its offset—but simultaneously with the onset of the saccade cue—reduced performance, yet a congruency effect remained (Experiment 3). Finally, we show that this impact of saccades on VSTM is inevitable even when congruent trials are far less likely than incongruent ones (Experiment 4). These results demonstrate that saccades inadvertently determine the content of VSTM, imposing a natural bottleneck on the transition of fragile sensory traces to durable memories. Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2016

Asymmetric visual interactions across the boundary of awareness.

A salient visual object can disappear from conscious perception when surrounded by a moving texture, a phenomenon known as MIB, Motion-Induced Blindness (Bonneh, Cooperman, & Sagi, 2001). Here we tested the information available in the brain from such stimuli that do not access awareness by examining interactions across the boundary of awareness between stimuli that reach awareness and those that do not. Observers performed the MIB task in which a "Cue" was presented next to the "Target" after observers reported the perceptual disappearance of the target (Kawabe, Yamada, & Miura, 2007). Oriented Gabor patches were used as targets and cues; observers reported the target's reappearance. The results indicated an interaction between the target and the cue, depending on the orientation difference (∼30° bandwidth) and distance (∼1° range), indicating preserved properties of features in the absence of awareness. Object-based representation (binding) of unseen stimuli was tested by examining the interaction between a compound stimulus and its composing features. Here we used vertical and horizontal Gabor patches and their combinations (plaids) as targets and cues. Results indicated asymmetric relations between aware and unaware object representations; a plaid cue was not effective with a component target, but a plaid target efficiently reappeared by its component cues. This result suggests that the unseen, but not the seen plaid, is decomposed into its features. Plaid targets also reappeared with plaid cues, supporting binding without awareness. Our findings suggest preconscious representations of objects and their features, with conscious perception confined to object representations.

A model of selective masking in chromatic detection.

Narrowly tuned, selective noise masking of chromatic detection has been taken as evidence for the existence of a large number of color mechanisms (i.e., higher order color mechanisms). Here we replicate earlier observations of selective masking of tests in the (L,M) plane of cone space when the noise is placed near the corners of the detection contour. We used unipolar Gaussian blob tests with three different noise color directions, and we show that there are substantial asymmetries in the detection contours-asymmetries that would have been missed with bipolar tests such as Gabor patches. We develop a new chromatic detection model, which is based on probability summation of linear cone combinations, and incorporates a linear contrast energy versus noise power relationship that predicts how the sensitivity of these mechanisms changes with noise contrast and chromaticity. With only six unipolar color mechanisms (the same number as the cardinal model), the new model accounts for the threshold contours across the different noise conditions, including the asymmetries and the selective effects of the noises. The key for producing selective noise masking in the (L,M) plane is having more than two mechanisms with opposed L- and M-cone inputs, in which case selective masking can be produced without large numbers of color mechanisms.

Eccentricity effects in vision and attention

Stimulus eccentricity affects visual processing in multiple ways. Performance on a visual task is often better when target stimuli are presented near or at the fovea compared to the retinal periphery. For instance, reaction times and error rates are often reported to increase with increasing eccentricity. Such findings have been interpreted as purely visual, reflecting neurophysiological differences in central and peripheral vision, as well as attentional, reflecting a central bias in the allocation of attentional resources. Other findings indicate that in some cases, information from the periphery is preferentially processed. Specifically, it has been suggested that visual processing speed increases with increasing stimulus eccentricity, and that this positive correlation is reduced, but not eliminated, when the amount of cortex activated by a stimulus is kept constant by magnifying peripheral stimuli (Carrasco et al., 2003). In this study, we investigated effects of eccentricity on visual attentional capacity with and without magnification, using computational modeling based on Bundesen's (1990) theory of visual attention. Our results suggest a general decrease in attentional capacity with increasing stimulus eccentricity, irrespective of magnification. We discuss these results in relation to the physiology of the visual system, the use of different paradigms for investigating visual perception across the visual field, and the use of different stimulus materials (e.g. Gabor patches vs. letters).

The time course of pattern discrimination in the human brain

In electrophysiological experiments on visual pattern discrimination, decision difficulty was manipulated either via the physical characteristics of the test stimuli, or by changing the instruction given to the observer. Visual stimuli were rectangular matrices each composed of 100 Gabor patches having different orientations. Matrices differed in the number of Gabor patches with vertical, or horizontal, orientation. The observers’ task was either to discriminate the dominant orientation or to detect collinear elements in the matrix. Relating task difficulty to performance, in the first experimental paradigm (detection of orientation) we obtained the conventional S-like psychometric function but in the second (detection of collinearity) the psychometric function showed a complicated U-curve. Matching between electrophysiological and psychophysical data and image statistical functions allowed us to establish the relative timing of the cortical processes underlying perception and decision making in relation to textural features. In the first 170ms after stimulus onset coding of the low-level properties of the image takes place. In the time interval 170–400ms, ERP amplitude correlated only with complex image properties, but not with task difficulty. The first effects arising from decision difficulty were observable at 400ms after stimulus onset, and therefore this is probably the earliest electrophysiological signature of the decision making processes, in the given experimental paradigm.

An Image-Based Model for Early Visual Processing

Figure 2: Contrast discrimination. Increment threshold vs. pedestal contrast for gratigs of 8.37 cyc/deg and 1497ms presentation time. Early spatial vision was explored extensively over several decades in many psychophysical detection and discrimination experiments. Thus a large body of such data is available. Goris et al. (2013) integrated this psychophysical literature and proposed a model based on maximumlikelihood decoding of a neurophysiologically inspired population of model neurons. Their neural population model (NPM) is unique in its ability to predict several data sets simultaneously, using a single set of parameters. However, the NPM is only one-dimensional, operating on the activity of abstract spatial frequency channels. Thus it cannot be applied to arbitrary images as a generic front-end to explore the influence of early visual processing on midor high-level vision. Bradley et al. (2014), on the other hand, recently presented an early vision model operating on images. Their model is thus able to make predictions for arbitrary images. However, compared to the NPM, their model lacks in nonlinear processing, which is replaced by an effective masking contrast depending on the detection target. Thus while Bradley et al. fit a range of detection data they do not fit nonlinear aspects of early vision like the dipper function. Here we combine both approaches into a model which includes nonlinear processing and statistically efficient decoding and operates on images explicitly calculating channel activities over the image. The model applies optical degradation and retinal processing to the image before the image is passed to a spatial frequency and orientation decomposition followed by divisive inhibition. We tested the predictions of our model against a broad range of early psychophysical experiments and found it predicts some hallmarks of early visual processing like the contrast sensitivity function (Figure 1), the dipper function for contrast discrimination (Figure 2) and oblique masking data (Figure 3). The measured data we plot against stems from standard 2AFC contrast detection and discrimination experiments run for Wichmann’s DPhil thesis (1999). Early vision was extensively explored empirically and there are plenty of models which explain different parts of the empirical findings. These results provide detailed information about the first processing steps in visual perception thought to happen in the retina, LGN and V1, which stimuli can be differentiated or detected using their output and in what format the output is available to any higher visual processing. However, research on higher visual processing rarely employs the information available from early vision psychophysics. The main reasons may be that the models described in the early spatial vision literature typically do not predict behaviour on arbitrary images, because they often do not process images, but only predict the (putative) responses of the early visual system to Gabor patches or simple grating stimuli. We try to overcome these limitations by explaining many psychophysical observations within a model taking images as input.

Retrospective triggering of conscious perception by an interstimulus interaction.

Attention facilitates conscious perception of a visual stimulus at an attended location. Interestingly, a recent study (using the Posner spatial-cueing task) reported that attention facilitated conscious perception even when it was cued after a stimulus was gone (postcued-attention or retroperception effect). Here, we show that this effect can be induced without any contribution of attention. Contrary to previous situations, we fixed a position of a target (Gabor patch) and cue (luminance change of a circle encompassing the target) across trials so that subjects always could allocate their full attention to the target position. The cue (luminance change) improved objective and subjective visibility of the nearby target even when it was given ∼200 ms after the target's offset. This retrospective improvement was diminished when a shape of the cue was changed from a circle to a dot pattern, suggesting that the improvement emerged from a visual interaction (combinations of shapes) between the circular cue and target. Those results indicated that a local visual interaction between the target and cue is sufficient to trigger consciousness of the target, revealing a new type of retroperception effect mediated by sensory (nonattentional) mechanisms.

Contrast sensitivity revealed by spontaneous eyeblinks: Evidence for a common mechanism of oculomotor inhibition.

Spontaneous eyeblinks are known to serve important physiological functions, and recent evidence shows that they are also linked to cognitive processes. It is yet unclear whether this link reflects a crude rate modulation or, alternatively, an automatic and precise process, tightly linked to the low-level properties of sensory stimuli. We have recently reported (Y. S. Bonneh, Adini, & Polat, 2015) that, for microsaccades, the onset and release from inhibition in response to transient stimuli depend systematically on the low-level stimulus parameters. Here we reanalyzed our previous data for both microsaccades and eyeblinks for observers with sufficient blinking (>10% of trials, 18 of 23 observers tested) who watched and silently counted sequences of Gabor patches at 1 Hz with varied contrast and spatial frequency. We found that spontaneous eyeblinks, although less frequent, were similar to microsaccades in their modulation pattern in response to transient stimuli, demonstrating inhibition and rebound, which were dependent on the contrast and spatial frequency of the stimuli. The average blink response time, measured as the latency of the first blink following its release from inhibition, was longer for lower contrast and higher spatial frequency. Importantly, it was highly correlated with a similar measure for microsaccades as well as with psychophysical measures of contrast sensitivity. These results suggest that both eyeblinks and microsaccades are linked to the same inhibitory mechanism that presumably turns off oculomotor events while processing previous events and generates a rebound effect upon its release. The onset of both eyeblinks and microsaccades may thus reflect the time course of this mechanism and the associated cognitive process.

Impairing the useful field of view in natural scenes: Tunnel vision versus general interference.

A fundamental issue in visual attention is the relationship between the useful field of view (UFOV), the region of visual space where information is encoded within a single fixation, and eccentricity. A common assumption is that impairing attentional resources reduces the size of the UFOV (i.e., tunnel vision). However, most research has not accounted for eccentricity-dependent changes in spatial resolution, potentially conflating fixed visual properties with flexible changes in visual attention. Williams (1988, 1989) argued that foveal loads are necessary to reduce the size of the UFOV, producing tunnel vision. Without a foveal load, it is argued that the attentional decrement is constant across the visual field (i.e., general interference). However, other research asserts that auditory working memory (WM) loads produce tunnel vision. To date, foveal versus auditory WM loads have not been compared to determine if they differentially change the size of the UFOV. In two experiments, we tested the effects of a foveal (rotated L vs. T discrimination) task and an auditory WM (N-back) task on an extrafoveal (Gabor) discrimination task. Gabor patches were scaled for size and processing time to produce equal performance across the visual field under single-task conditions, thus removing the confound of eccentricity-dependent differences in visual sensitivity. The results showed that although both foveal and auditory loads reduced Gabor orientation sensitivity, only the foveal load interacted with retinal eccentricity to produce tunnel vision, clearly demonstrating task-specific changes to the form of the UFOV. This has theoretical implications for understanding the UFOV.

Contrast Affects fMRI Activity in Middle Temporal Cortex Related to Center-Surround Interaction in Motion Perception.

As the size of a high contrast drifting Gabor patch increases, perceiving its direction of motion becomes harder. However, the same behavioral effect is not observed for a low contrast Gabor patch. Neuronal mechanisms underlying this size–contrast interaction are not well understood. Here using psychophysical methods and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), we investigated the neural correlates of this behavioral effect. In the behavioral experiments, motion direction discrimination thresholds were assessed for drifting Gabor patches with different sizes and contrasts. Thresholds increased significantly as the size of the stimulus increased for high contrast (65%) but did not change for low contrast (2%) stimuli. In the fMRI experiment, cortical activity was recorded while observers viewed drifting Gabor patches with different contrasts and sizes. We found that the activity in middle temporal (MT) area increased with size at low contrast, but did not change at high contrast. Taken together, our results show that MT activity reflects the size–contrast interaction in motion perception.

Contrast sensitivity function in stereoscopic viewing of Gabor patches on a medical polarized three-dimensional stereoscopic display

While three-dimensional (3-D) imaging systems are entering hospitals, no study to date has explored the luminance calibration needs of 3-D stereoscopic diagnostic displays and if they differ from two-dimensional (2-D) displays. Since medical display calibration incorporates the human contrast sensitivity function (CSF), we first assessed the 2-D CSF for benchmarking and then examined the impact of two image parameters on the 3-D stereoscopic CSF: (1) five depth plane (DP) positions (between DP: −171 and DP: 2853 mm), and (2) three 3-D inclinations (0 deg, 45 deg, and 60 deg around the horizontal axis of a DP). Stimuli were stereoscopic images of a vertically oriented 2-D Gabor patch at one of seven frequencies ranging from 0.4 to 10 cycles/deg. CSFs were measured for seven to nine human observers with a staircase procedure. The results indicate that the 2-D CSF model remains valid for a 3-D stereoscopic display regardless of the amount of disparity between the stereo images. We also found that the 3-D CSF at DP≠0 does not differ from the 3-D CSF at DP=0 for DPs and disparities which allow effortless binocular fusion. Therefore, the existing 2-D medical luminance calibration algorithm remains an appropriate tool for calibrating polarized stereoscopic medical displays.

106. Parietal cortex involvement in visual perceptual learning: A rTMS investigation

Practice-induced visual perceptual learning is thought to reflect the plasticity of sensory brain regions. The hypothesis that changes in early visual areas may depend on top-down modulation from higher level brain regions by attentional mechanisms is still debated. We used a causal approach by repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) to evaluate the role of primary visual cortex (V1) and posterior parietal cortex (PPC) in visual perceptual learning. Twelve healthy volunteers performed a forced-choice orientation discrimination task of gabor patches (consisting of 500 trials in five blocks) without any intervention or immediately after a conditioning inhibitory 1-Hz rTMS protocol delivered over the V1, the right PPC, and the vertex (control area), in four different days. Conditioning inhibition by 1-Hz rTMS over the V1 produced an overall worsening of the performance accuracy but no effect in the learning rate, as measured by the slope of the learning curve. The learning rate was lower after right PPC inhibition compared to the other conditions, when evaluated during the first two blocks (200 trials) where occurred most of the learning. These preliminary findings suggest that higher level brain regions may be involved in the mechanisms underlying perceptual learning.

Testing the idea of privileged awareness of self-relevant information.

Self-relevant information is prioritized in processing. Some have suggested the mechanism driving this advantage is akin to the automatic prioritization of physically salient stimuli in information processing (Humphreys & Sui, 2015). Here we investigate whether self-relevant information is prioritized for awareness under continuous flash suppression (CFS), as has been found for physical salience. Gabor patches with different orientations were first associated with the labels You or Other. Participants were more accurate in matching the self-relevant association, replicating previous findings of self-prioritization. However, breakthrough into awareness from CFS did not differ between self- and other-associated Gabors. These findings demonstrate that self-relevant information has no privileged access to awareness. Rather than modulating the initial visual processes that precede and lead to awareness, the advantage of self-relevant information may better be characterized as prioritization at later processing stages.

Undetectable Changes in Image Resolution of Luminance-Contrast Gradients Affect Depth Perception.

A great number of studies have suggested a variety of ways to get depth information from two dimensional images such as binocular disparity, shape-from-shading, size gradient/foreshortening, aerial perspective, and so on. Are there any other new factors affecting depth perception? A recent psychophysical study has investigated the correlation between image resolution and depth sensation of Cylinder images (A rectangle contains gradual luminance-contrast changes.). It was reported that higher resolution images facilitate depth perception. However, it is still not clear whether or not the finding generalizes to other kinds of visual stimuli, because there are more appropriate visual stimuli for exploration of depth perception of luminance-contrast changes, such as Gabor patch. Here, we further examined the relationship between image resolution and depth perception by conducting a series of psychophysical experiments with not only Cylinders but also Gabor patches having smoother luminance-contrast gradients. As a result, higher resolution images produced stronger depth sensation with both images. This finding suggests that image resolution affects depth perception of simple luminance-contrast differences (Gabor patch) as well as shape-from-shading (Cylinder). In addition, this phenomenon was found even when the resolution difference was undetectable. This indicates the existence of consciously available and unavailable information in our visual system. These findings further support the view that image resolution is a cue for depth perception that was previously ignored. It partially explains the unparalleled viewing experience of novel high resolution displays.

Perceptual similarity of visual patterns predicts dynamic neural activation patterns measured with MEG

Perceptual similarity is a cognitive judgment that represents the end-stage of a complex cascade of hierarchical processing throughout visual cortex. Previous studies have shown a correspondence between the similarity of coarse-scale fMRI activation patterns and the perceived similarity of visual stimuli, suggesting that visual objects that appear similar also share similar underlying patterns of neural activation. Here we explore the temporal relationship between the human brain's time-varying representation of visual patterns and behavioral judgments of perceptual similarity. The visual stimuli were abstract patterns constructed from identical perceptual units (oriented Gabor patches) so that each pattern had a unique global form or perceptual ‘Gestalt’. The visual stimuli were decodable from evoked neural activation patterns measured with magnetoencephalography (MEG), however, stimuli differed in the similarity of their neural representation as estimated by differences in decodability. Early after stimulus onset (from 50ms), a model based on retinotopic organization predicted the representational similarity of the visual stimuli. Following the peak correlation between the retinotopic model and neural data at 80ms, the neural representations quickly evolved so that retinotopy no longer provided a sufficient account of the brain's time-varying representation of the stimuli. Overall the strongest predictor of the brain's representation was a model based on human judgments of perceptual similarity, which reached the limits of the maximum correlation with the neural data defined by the ‘noise ceiling’. Our results show that large-scale brain activation patterns contain a neural signature for the perceptual Gestalt of composite visual features, and demonstrate a strong correspondence between perception and complex patterns of brain activity.

Retrospective Attention Gates Discrete Conscious Access to Past Sensory Stimuli.

Cueing attention after the disappearance of visual stimuli biases which items will be remembered best. This observation has historically been attributed to the influence of attention on memory as opposed to subjective visual experience. We recently challenged this view by showing that cueing attention after the stimulus can improve the perception of a single Gabor patch at threshold levels of contrast. Here, we test whether this retro-perception actually increases the frequency of consciously perceiving the stimulus, or simply allows for a more precise recall of its features. We used retro-cues in an orientation-matching task and performed mixture-model analysis to independently estimate the proportion of guesses and the precision of non-guess responses. We find that the improvements in performance conferred by retrospective attention are overwhelmingly determined by a reduction in the proportion of guesses, providing strong evidence that attracting attention to the target’s location after its disappearance increases the likelihood of perceiving it consciously.

Role of form information in motion pooling and segmentation.

Traditional theories of visual perception have focused on either form or motion processing, implying a functional separation. However, increasing evidence indicates that these features interact at early stages of visual processing. The current study examined a well-known form-motion interaction, where a shape translates along a circular path behind opaque apertures, giving the impression of either independently translating lines (segmentation) or a globally coherent, translating shape. The purpose was to systemically examine how low-level motion information and form information interact to determine which percept is reported. To this end, we used a stimulus with boundaries comprising multiple, spatially-separated Gabor patches with three to eight sides. Results showed that shapes with four or fewer sides appeared to move in a segmented manner, whereas those with more sides were integrated as a solid shape. The separation between directions, rather than the total number of sides, causes this switch between integrated or segmented percepts. We conclude that the change between integration and segmentation depends on whether local motion directions can be independently resolved. We also reconcile previous results on the influence of shape closure on motion integration: Shapes that form open contours cause segmentation, but with no corresponding enhanced sensitivity for shapes forming closed contours. Overall, our results suggest that the resolution of the local motion signal determines whether motion segmentation or integration is perceived with only a small overall influence of form.