ABSTRACT Previous studies have shown that environmental, social, and governance (ESG) commitment affects the underpricing level of new issues. In this study, we argue that ESG’s impact on mutual fund performance could depend on funds’ strategy in investing in initial public offerings (IPOs). We focus on the performance and systematic risk exposure of IPO funds compared to matched non-IPO funds according to their ESG risk ratings. Using a sample of 184 U.S. funds between 2015 and 2021, we find that ESG factors negatively (positively) affect IPO (non-IPO) fund performance during the full period. However, for the pandemic crisis period, our results support the outperformance of low ESG-risk funds, regardless of whether they were focused on IPOs. It appears that investors require a much higher systematic risk premium to invest in high-ESG-risk funds compared to low-ESG-risk funds during crisis periods.
Read full abstract