Full Configuration Interaction Wave Research Articles

Reasons Why Most Single-Reference Coupled Cluster Methods Fail to Provide the Correct Adiabatic Potentials of a Diatomic Carbon Molecule: UCCSDecCCSD Potential Study.

Many single-reference coupled cluster (CC) methods offer adiabatically incorrect potentials when calculating the diatomic carbon molecule, so this problem has been studied extensively. Analysis of the full configuration interaction (FCI) wave function indicates that the main cause of the adiabatic collapse of potentials calculated by the CC method with singles, doubles, and triples (CCSDT) is the strongly increasing bonding character of the T4FCI cluster contribution. In turn, comparative analysis of the CCSDTQ adiabats X1Σg+ and B'1Σg+ demonstrates that the gap between them near the avoided crossing geometry is significantly reduced by quantitatively differentiating the character of the T4 and cluster contributions. These observations clearly indicate the need to take into account the T4 cluster contribution in the standard CC wave function to obtain the correct adiabatic potential. Further analysis of this issue shows that the T4 contribution must be additionally bonding to ensure the adiabatic correctness of the potential. What also seems very interesting is that when the UCCSDecCCSD method [Toboła, Chem. Phys. Lett. 2014, 614, 82-88] is used for the potential calculation, the shape of the potential is entirely determined by a subset of unrestricted Hartree-Fock (UHF) configurations, which are structurally identical to the ground-state configuration in the UHF-based CCSD wave function.

Geometric interpretation for coupled-cluster theory. A comparison of accuracy with the corresponding configuration interaction model.

Although coupled-cluster theory is well-known for its accuracy, the geometry associated with the manifold of wave functions reached by the coupled-cluster Ansatz has not been deeply explored. In this article, we look for an interpretation for the high accuracy of coupled-cluster theory based on how the manifold of coupled-cluster wave functions is embedded within the space of n-electron wave functions. We define the coupled-cluster and configuration interaction manifolds and measure the distances from the full-configuration interaction (FCI) wave function to these manifolds. We clearly observe that the FCI wave function is closer to the coupled-cluster manifold that is curved than to the configuration interaction manifold that is flat for the selected systems studied in this work. Furthermore, the decomposition of the distances among these manifolds and wave functions into excitation ranks gives insights into the failure of the coupled-cluster approach for multireference systems. The present results show a new interpretation for the quality of the coupled-cluster method, as contrasted to the truncated configuration interaction approach, besides the well-established argument based on size extensivity. Furthermore, we show how a geometric description of wave function methods can be used in electronic structure theory.

Quantum Proton Effects from Density Matrix Renormalization Group Calculations.

We recently introduced [J. Chem. Phys. 2020, 152, 204103] the nuclear-electronic all-particle density matrix renormalization group (NEAP-DMRG) method to solve the molecular Schrödinger equation, based on a stochastically optimized orbital basis, without invoking the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. In this work, we combine the DMRG method with the nuclear-electronic Hartree-Fock (NEHF-DMRG) approach, treating nuclei and electrons on the same footing. Inter- and intraspecies correlations are described within the DMRG method without truncating the excitation degree of the full configuration interaction wave function. We extend the concept of orbital entanglement and mutual information to nuclear-electronic wave functions and demonstrate that they are reliable metrics to detect strong correlation effects. We apply the NEHF-DMRG method to the HeHHe+ molecular ion, to obtain accurate proton densities, ground-state total energies, and vibrational transition frequencies by comparison with state-of-the-art data obtained with grid-based approaches and modern configuration interaction methods. For HCN, we improve on the accuracy of the latter approaches with respect to both the ground-state absolute energy and proton density, which is a major challenge for multireference nuclear-electronic state-of-the-art methods.

Quantifying Delocalization and Static Correlation Errors by Imposing (Spin)Population Redistributions through Constraints on Atomic Domains.

The failure of many density functional approximations can be traced to their behavior under fractional (spin)population redistributions in the asymptotic limit toward infinite bonding distances, which should obey the flat-plane conditions. However, such errors can only be characterized sufficiently in terms of those redistributions if exact energies are available for many possible (spin)population redistributions at different bonding distances. In this study, we propose to model such redistributions by imposing (spin)populations on atomic domains by constraining full configuration interaction wave functions. The resulting N-representable descriptions of small hydrogen chains at different bonding distances allow us to computationally illustrate the effects of the flat-plane conditions in the limit to infinite bond distances, leading to more chemical insight into those flat-plane conditions. As the proposed methodology is able to capture the effects of the flat plane conditions, it could be used to generate the reference data that is required to measure the extent to which approximate methods violate the requirements of the exact functional, leading to a quantification of the delocalization and static correlation error of such methods.

Reinforcement Learning Configuration Interaction.

Selected configuration interaction (sCI) methods exploit the sparsity of the full configuration interaction (FCI) wave function, yielding significant computational savings and wave function compression without sacrificing the accuracy. Despite recent advances in sCI methods, the selection of important determinants remains an open problem. We explore the possibility of utilizing reinforcement learning approaches to solve the sCI problem. By mapping the configuration interaction problem onto a sequential decision-making process, the agent learns on-the-fly which determinants to include and which to ignore, yielding a compressed wave function at near-FCI accuracy. This method, which we call reinforcement-learned configuration interaction, adds another weapon to the sCI arsenal and highlights how reinforcement learning approaches can potentially help solve challenging problems in electronic structure theory.

Ab initio molecular dynamics on quantum computers.

Ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) is a valuable technique for studying molecules and materials at finite temperatures where the nuclei evolve on potential energy surfaces obtained from accurate electronic structure calculations. In this work, we present an approach to running AIMD simulations on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ)-era quantum computers. The electronic energies are calculated on a quantum computer using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) method. Algorithms for computation of analytical gradients entirely on a quantum computer require quantum fault-tolerant hardware, which is beyond NISQ-era. Therefore, we compute the energy gradients numerically using finite differences, the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, and a correlated sampling technique. This method only requires additional classical calculations of electron integrals for each degree of freedom without any additional computations on a quantum computer beyond the initial VQE run. As a proof of concept, AIMD simulations are demonstrated for the H2 molecule on IBM quantum devices. In addition, we demonstrate the validity of the method for larger molecules using full configuration interaction wave functions. As quantum hardware and noise mitigation techniques continue to improve, the method can be utilized for studying larger molecular systems.

Tailored coupled cluster theory in varying correlation regimes.

The tailored coupled cluster (TCC) approach is a promising ansatz that preserves the simplicity of single-reference coupled cluster theory while incorporating a multi-reference wave function through amplitudes obtained from a preceding multi-configurational calculation. Here, we present a detailed analysis of the TCC wave function based on model systems, which require an accurate description of both static and dynamic correlation. We investigate the reliability of the TCC approach with respect to the exact wave function. In addition to the error in the electronic energy and standard coupled cluster diagnostics, we exploit the overlap of TCC and full configuration interaction wave functions as a quality measure. We critically review issues, such as the required size of the active space, size-consistency, symmetry breaking in the wave function, and the dependence of TCC on the reference wave function. We observe that possible errors caused by symmetry breaking can be mitigated by employing the determinant with the largest weight in the active space as reference for the TCC calculation. We find the TCC model to be promising in calculations with active orbital spaces which include all orbitals with a large single-orbital entropy, even if the active spaces become very large and then may require modern active-space approaches that are not restricted to comparatively small numbers of orbitals. Furthermore, utilizing large active spaces can improve on the TCC wave function approximation and reduce the size-consistency error because the presence of highly excited determinants affects the accuracy of the coefficients of low-excited determinants in the active space.

Exploring Hilbert space on a budget: Novel benchmark set and performance metric for testing electronic structure methods in the regime of strong correlation.

This work explores the ability of classical electronic structure methods to efficiently represent (compress) the information content of full configuration interaction (FCI) wave functions. We introduce a benchmark set of four hydrogen model systems of different dimensionalities and distinctive electronic structures: a 1D chain, a 1D ring, a 2D triangular lattice, and a 3D close-packed pyramid. To assess the ability of a computational method to produce accurate and compact wave functions, we introduce the accuracy volume, a metric that measures the number of variational parameters necessary to achieve a target energy error. Using this metric and the hydrogen models, we examine the performance of three classical deterministic methods: (i) selected configuration interaction (sCI) realized both via an a posteriori (ap-sCI) and variational selection of the most important determinants, (ii) an a posteriori singular value decomposition (SVD) of the FCI tensor (SVD-FCI), and (iii) the matrix product state representation obtained via the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG). We find that the DMRG generally gives the most efficient wave function representation for all systems, particularly in the 1D chain with a localized basis. For the 2D and 3D systems, all methods (except DMRG) perform best with a delocalized basis, and the efficiency of sCI and SVD-FCI is closer to that of DMRG. For larger analogs of the models, the DMRG consistently requires the fewest parameters but still scales exponentially in 2D and 3D systems, and the performance of SVD-FCI is essentially equivalent to that of ap-sCI.

Distribution of oscillator strengths and correlated electron dynamics in artificial atoms

The electronic structure of the quasi-two-dimensional disk-like artificial atom involving holes inside has been studied by the full configuration interaction (FCI) wave function employing mixed basis sets consisting of standard atomic orbitals and anisotropic Gaussian-type functions. The one-particle confinement potential for electrons has been modeled by a sum of an anisotropic harmonic-oscillator potential and attractive Coulomb potentials, the latter being responsible for the hole positive charges. The oscillator strengths from the ground state to a number of low-lying excited states have been calculated by the FCI energies and wave functions for different strength of the harmonic confinement ω. The results for two electrons with a hole at the center, namely, the He-like system, have shown accumulation of the oscillator strengths distributed among different dipole-allowed transitions in the excitation into the center-of-mass modes or the plasmon modes for increasing confinement strength ω. The system of two electrons with two impurity holes, namely, the H2-like system, has been also studied, which has shown a far more complicated trend of the oscillator strengths with respect to ω owing to the additional degree of freedom of the internuclear distance r. The observed trend has been rationalized on the basis of the nodal patterns in the molecular orbitals and in the electron density distributions.

Large-Scale Electron Correlation Calculations: Rank-Reduced Full Configuration Interaction.

We present the rank-reduced full configuration interaction (RR-FCI) method, a variational approach for the calculation of extremely large full configuration interaction (FCI) wave functions. In this report, we show that RR-FCI can provide ground state singlet and triplet energies within kcal/mol accuracy of full CI (FCI) with computational effort scaling as the square root of the number of determinants in the CI space (compared to conventional FCI methods which scale linearly with the number of determinants). Fast graphical processing unit (GPU) accelerated projected σ = Hc matrix-vector product formation enables calculations with configuration spaces as large as 30 electrons in 30 orbitals, corresponding to an FCI calculation with over 2.4 × 1016 configurations. We apply this method in the context of complete active space configuration interaction calculations to acenes with 2-5 aromatic rings, comparing absolute energies against FCI when possible and singlet/triplet excitation energies against both density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) and experimental results. The dissociation of molecular nitrogen was also examined using both FCI and RR-FCI. In each case, we found that RR-FCI provides a low cost alternative to FCI, with particular advantages when relative energies are desired.

Cluster decomposition of full configuration interaction wave functions: A tool for chemical interpretation of systems with strong correlation.

Approximate full configuration interaction (FCI) calculations have recently become tractable for systems of unforeseen size, thanks to stochastic and adaptive approximations to the exponentially scaling FCI problem. The result of an FCI calculation is a weighted set of electronic configurations, which can also be expressed in terms of excitations from a reference configuration. The excitation amplitudes contain information on the complexity of the electronic wave function, but this information is contaminated by contributions from disconnected excitations, i.e., those excitations that are just products of independent lower-level excitations. The unwanted contributions can be removed via a cluster decomposition procedure, making it possible to examine the importance of connected excitations in complicated multireference molecules which are outside the reach of conventional algorithms. We present an implementation of the cluster decomposition analysis and apply it to both true FCI wave functions, as well as wave functions generated from the adaptive sampling CI algorithm. The cluster decomposition is useful for interpreting calculations in chemical studies, as a diagnostic for the convergence of various excitation manifolds, as well as as a guidepost for polynomially scaling electronic structure models. Applications are presented for (i) the double dissociation of water, (ii) the carbon dimer, (iii) the π space of polyacenes, and (iv) the chromium dimer. While the cluster amplitudes exhibit rapid decay with an increasing rank for the first three systems, even connected octuple excitations still appear important in Cr2, suggesting that spin-restricted single-reference coupled-cluster approaches may not be tractable for some problems in transition metal chemistry.

Analytic Energy Gradients for Variational Two-Electron Reduced-Density-Matrix-Driven Complete Active Space Self-Consistent Field Theory.

Analytic energy gradients are presented for a variational two-electron reduced-density-matrix (2-RDM)-driven complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) method. The active-space 2-RDM is determined using a semidefinite programing (SDP) algorithm built upon an augmented Lagrangian formalism. Expressions for analytic gradients are simplified by the fact that the Lagrangian is stationary with respect to variations in both the primal and the dual solutions to the SDP problem. Orbital response contributions to the gradient are identical to those that arise in conventional CASSCF methods in which the electronic structure of the active space is described by a full configuration interaction (CI) wave function. We explore the relative performance of variational 2-RDM (v2RDM)- and CI-driven CASSCF for the equilibrium geometries of 20 small molecules. When enforcing two-particle N-representability conditions, full-valence v2RDM-CASSCF-optimized bond lengths display a mean unsigned error of 0.0060 Å and a maximum unsigned error of 0.0265 Å, relative to those obtained from full-valence CI-CASSCF. When enforcing partial three-particle N-representability conditions, the mean and maximum unsigned errors are reduced to only 0.0006 and 0.0054 Å, respectively. For these same molecules, full-valence v2RDM-CASSCF bond lengths computed in the cc-pVQZ basis set deviate from experimentally determined ones on average by 0.017 and 0.011 Å when enforcing two- and three-particle conditions, respectively, whereas CI-CASSCF displays an average deviation of 0.010 Å. The v2RDM-CASSCF approach with two-particle conditions is also applied to the equilibrium geometry of pentacene; optimized bond lengths deviate from those derived from experiment, on average, by 0.015 Å when using a cc-pVDZ basis set and a (22e,22o) active space.

The electron-pair density distribution of the1,3Πuexcited states of H2

The non-monotonic behavior of the electron repulsion energy and the inter-electronic distance, as a function of the internuclear separation, in the3Πuexcited state of the hydrogen molecule has been assessed by explicit calculation and analysis of the electron-pair density distribution functions from high level ab initio full configuration interaction wave functions, for both the3Πuand the1Πustates. Additionally, Hund’s rule as applied to these two states has been accounted for in terms of simple electronic shielding effects induced by wave function antisymmetrization.

Performance of Shannon-entropy compacted N-electron wave functions for configuration interaction methods

The coefficients of full configuration interaction wave functions (FCI) for N-electron systems expanded in N-electron Slater determinants depend on the orthonormal one-particle basis chosen although the total energy remains invariant . Some bases result in more compact wave functions, i.e. result in fewer determinants with significant expansion coefficients. In this work, the Shannon entropy, as a measure of information content, is evaluated for such wave functions to examine whether there is a relationship between the FCI Shannon entropy of a given basis and the performance of that basis in truncated CI approaches. The results obtained for a set of randomly picked bases are compared to those obtained using the traditional canonical molecular orbitals, natural orbitals, seniority minimising orbitals and a basis that derives from direct minimisation of the Shannon entropy. FCI calculations for selected atomic and molecular systems clearly reflect the influence of the chosen basis. However, it is found that there is no direct relationship between the entropy computed for each basis and truncated CI energies.

Application of a convergent, composite coupled cluster approach to bound state, adiabatic electron affinities in atoms and small molecules.

Benchmark quality adiabatic electron affinities for a collection of atoms and small molecules were obtained with the Feller-Peterson-Dixon composite coupled cluster theory method. Prior applications of this method demonstrated its ability to accurately predict atomization energies/heats of formation for more than 170 molecules. In the current work, the 1-particle expansion involved very large correlation consistent basis sets, ranging up to aug-cc-pV9Z (aug-cc-pV10Z for H and H2), with the goal of minimizing the residual basis set truncation error that must otherwise be approximated with extrapolation formulas. The n-particle expansion begins with coupled cluster calculations through iterative single and double excitations plus a quasiperturbative treatment of "connected" triple excitations (CCSD(T)) pushed to the complete basis set limit followed by CCSDT, CCSDTQ, or CCSDTQ5 corrections. Due to the small size of the systems examined here, it was possible in many cases to extend the n-particle expansion to the full configuration interaction wave function limit. Additional, smaller corrections associated with core/valence correlation, scalar relativity, anharmonic zero point vibrational energies, and non-adiabatic effects were also included. The overall root mean square (RMS) deviation was 0.005 eV (0.12 kcal/mol). This level of agreement was comparable to what was found with molecular heats of formation. A 95% confidence level corresponds to roughly twice the RMS value or 0.01 eV. While the atomic electron affinities are known experimentally to high accuracy, the molecular values are less certain. This contributes to the difficulty of gauging the accuracy of the theoretical results. A limited number of electron affinities were determined with the explicitly correlated CCSD(T)-F12b method. After extending the VnZ-F12 orbital basis sets with additional diffuse functions, the F12b method was found to accurately reproduce the best F/F(-) value obtained with standard methods, but it underestimated the CH3/CH3 (-) value by 0.01 eV.

Polynomial scaling approximations and dynamic correlation corrections to doubly occupied configuration interaction wave functions.

A class of polynomial scaling methods that approximate Doubly Occupied Configuration Interaction (DOCI) wave functions and improve the description of dynamic correlation is introduced. The accuracy of the resulting wave functions is analysed by comparing energies and studying the overlap between the newly developed methods and full configuration interaction wave functions, showing that a low energy does not necessarily entail a good approximation of the exact wave function. Due to the dependence of DOCI wave functions on the single-particle basis chosen, several orbital optimisation algorithms are introduced. An energy-based algorithm using the simulated annealing method is used as a benchmark. As a computationally more affordable alternative, a seniority number minimising algorithm is developed and compared to the energy based one revealing that the seniority minimising orbital set performs well. Given a well-chosen orbital basis, it is shown that the newly developed DOCI based wave functions are especially suitable for the computationally efficient description of static correlation and to lesser extent dynamic correlation.

A study of the compactness of wave functions based on Shannon entropy indices: a seniority number approach

This work reports the formulation of Shannon entropy indices in terms of seniority numbers of the Slater determinants expanding an N-electron wave function. Numerical determinations of those indices prove that they provide a suitable quantitative procedure to evaluate compactness of wave functions and to describe their configurational structures. An analysis of the results, calculated for full configuration interaction wave functions in selected atomic and molecular systems, allows one to compare and to discuss the behavior of several types of molecular orbital basis sets in order to achieve more compact wave function expansions, and to study their multiconfigurational character.

Structure of genuine and conjugate Fermi holes and the first Hund rule in He-like systems

The singly-excited states of He and He-like atomic ions in the manifold of the n = 3 principal shell have been studied replying on the full configuration interaction wave function focusing on the origin of the first Hund rule. The probability density distributions of the singlet-triplet pairs of states for the three orbital configurations of (1s)(3s), (1s)(3p), and (1s)(3d) have been examined in detail in the internal space (r1,r2,ϕ−). The structure of the genuine and conjugate Fermi holes for the (1s)(3s) and (1s)(3p) configurations has shown similar characteristics to those for the respective (1s)(2s) and (1s)(2p) configurations examined in an earlier study. A significantly smaller size of the genuine and conjugate Fermi holes for the (1s)(3d) singlet-triplet pair of states rationalizes the much smaller singlet-triplet energy gap of this pair than those for the (1s)(3s) and (1s)(3p) pairs of states.

Implementation of renormalized excitonic method at ab initio level

The renormalized excitonic method [Hajj et al., Phys Rev B 2005, 72, 224412], in which the excited state of the whole system may be described as a linear combination of local excitations, has been implemented at ab initio level. Its performance is tested on the ionization potential and the energy gap between singlet ground state and lowest triplet for linear molecular hydrogen chains and more realistic systems, such as polyenes and polysilenes, using full configuration interaction (FCI) wave functions with a minimal basis set. The influence of different block sizes and the extent of interblock interactions are investigated. It has been demonstrated that satisfactory results can be obtained if the near degeneracies between the model space and the outer space are avoided and if interactions between the next-nearest neighbor blocks are considered. The method can be used with larger basis sets and other accurate enough ab initio evaluations (instead of FCI) of local excited states, from blocks, or from dimers or trimers of blocks. It provides a new possibility to accurately and economically describe the low-lying delocalized excited states of large systems, even inhomogeneous ones.

Seniority and orbital symmetry as tools for establishing a full configuration interaction hierarchy

We explore the concept of seniority number (defined as the number of unpaired electrons in a determinant) when applied to the problem of electron correlation in atomic and molecular systems. Although seniority is a good quantum number only for certain model Hamiltonians (such as the pairing Hamiltonian), we show that it provides a useful partitioning of the electronic full configuration interaction (FCI) wave function into rapidly convergent Hilbert subspaces whose weight diminishes as its seniority number increases. The primary focus of this study is the adequate description of static correlation effects. The examples considered are the ground states of the helium, beryllium, and neon atoms, the symmetric dissociation of the N(2) and CO(2) molecules, as well as the symmetric dissociation of an H(8) hydrogen chain. It is found that the symmetry constraints that are normally placed on the spatial orbitals greatly affect the convergence rate of the FCI expansion. The energy relevance of the seniority zero sector (determinants with all paired electrons) increases dramatically if orbitals of broken spatial symmetry (as those commonly used for Hubbard Hamiltonian studies) are allowed in the wave function construction.