Objective: To analyse the results of total resection of middle turbinate and partial resection of middle turbinate on nasal headache Design: Prospective study of chronic rhinogenic headache in 40 patients between January 2011 and December 2011, 25females and 15males,their age range was 18-55years,with a mean age of 32.4 years and their range of duration of headache was 1-20 years, with a mean duration of headache 6.125 years.The operation of total resection of middle turbinate has been performed in 40 ethmoidectomies & a control group of partial resection of middle turbinate has been performed by the same author in 40 ethmoidectomies. All the patients underwent pre-operative & post-operative assessment with a questionnaire of headache, using the visual analogue scale (VAS). Results: Total resection of middle turbinate showed complete cure of headache in 40 ethmoidectomies (100 percent) by questionnaire (subjective analysis). A control group of partial resection of middle turbinate showed complete cure in 20 ethmoidectomies (50 percent ), improvement (by 70%) in 4 ethmoidectomies (10 percent) & unchanged or worsened headache in 16 ethmoidectomies (40 percent) by subjective analysis at the last follow- up.The difference was statistically highly significant(P<0.01). Conclusion: Total resection of nasal middle turbinate in ESS is a good choice in chronic rhinogenic headache, not responding to usual medical anti-headache treatment & not septic. I. Introduction Each patient completed a questionnaire to elicit information on medications, medical history and the patient's subjective assessment of pre-operative & post-operative rhinogenic headache using standarized symptoms questionnaire quality of life score by Lund and Macky, the visual analogue scale (VAS). The scoring is range from 0 to 10 in which 0 represents no symptom & 10 represents greatest severity . 1 Local anesthetic test is done during the attack of headache. The nose is decongested then a piece of cotton soaked in xylocaine 2%, adrenaline 1:200.000 is put in the nose at any suspected contact area in the nose. The cotton is left for 5 minutes. Positive test is considered if the patient shows improvement of headache severity more than 50%. The simple presence of an intranasal pathology does not prove its role in headache causation.The etiologic role of this pathology should be confirmed by diagnostic local anesthetic testing as the source of pain. 2 The appropriate management of the middle turbinate remains controversial and arguments for its resection and for its preservation have been proposed. 3-5 Davis et al. reported that middle turbinectomy was the most important variable in predicting patency of the middle meatus antrostomy .6 A standard ESS Technique is done, the uncinate process is incised and removed & the middle turbinate is medialized with a freer elevator, the ethmoid bulla is entered & removed. A posterior ethmoidectomy is performed. The frontal sinus ostium is identified with a blunt curved suction .The natural ostium of the maxillary sinus is identified .The sphenoid sinus is entered medially and inferiorly as indicated. At this point, the procedure is essentially completed except for planning in regard to prevention of post-operative complications . 7 the present author has performed these procedures, as previously described, 7 on 40 patients with chronic rhinogenic headache. At a mean follow-up of 6 months. The patients were seen in the office 1 week post-operatively, any crusts are suctioned from the middle meatus & ethmoid, saline nasal irrigations were administrated. All the patients were followed up by endoscope and questionnaire of headache. The aim of this report was to review the cases of total resection of middle turbinate performed on nasal headache and compare the results with those of partial resection of middle turbinate performed by the same author at the same institution & period.
Read full abstract