Trypanosome infections containing multiple morphologies have been described from all classes of vertebrates, including mammals, birds, non-avian reptiles, amphibians, and fish. These mixed infections make it challenging to evaluate trypanosome diversity, as it is not immediately clear whether the forms present in the bloodstream represent different species or a single pleomorphic species. Amphibians are common hosts for trypanosomes and are often infected by multiple trypanosome morphologies in the bloodstream. Based on morphological observations and life cycle studies, many authors have considered multiple trypanosome morphotypes found infecting the same frogs to be a single pleomorphic species. However, molecular evidence supporting pleomorphic trypanosome species in amphibians is lacking, primarily because linking sequence data to bloodstream trypanosome morphology in mixed infections is extremely challenging. Here we present methods to isolate individual trypanosome cells of 6 morphotypes from frog blood for nested PCR of the 18S rRNA and gGAPDH genes. Single trypanosome cells were isolated by dilution and 3 DNA extraction methods, and 5 nested PCR primer regimes were utilized to optimize amplification from very low starting concentrations. The success rates of extraction methods ranged from 29 to 50% with the use of a Direct PCR kit having the highest success rate. Although the success rate varied in the different combinations of extraction methods and primer regimes, multiple individuals of all 6 trypanosome morphotypes were sequenced for both genes in a novel way that links sequence data to cell morphology by observing isolated cells with a microscope before PCR amplification. All 6 morphologically distinguishable morphotypes coinfecting a frog were genetically distinct. The only other recent molecular study on amphibian trypanosomes also found genetic differences between morphotypes in multiple infections. Together these studies suggest that the occurrence of pleomorphism may be overestimated in amphibian trypanosomes. The methods presented here offer a promising solution to characterize trypanosome diversity within multiple morphotype infections.