Human papillomavirus (HPV)-associated squamous cell carcinomas of the oropharynx are increasingly seen as a separate disease entity from smoking-associated oropharyngeal cancers, with a much higher likelihood of cure. The current American Joint Commission on Cancer (AJCC) staging system for HPV-positive oropharyngeal cancer is not prognostic for outcome. We evaluated a variety of potential prognostic factors in order to propose potential new components for a staging system. After gaining institutional review board approval, we queried an institutional database for patients with HPV or p16-positive nonmetastatic oropharyngeal cancers treated with definitive radiation therapy (RT), and 245 cases were identified. Patient, tumor, and treatment factors were abstracted from the charts. In addition, pretreatment imaging was reviewed, including computed tomography (CT) in 99.6%, positron emission tomography/CT in 94.3%, and magnetic resonance imaging in 7.3% to obtain precise size, location, number, and extent of primary and nodes. Outcomes, including local control (LC), regional control (RC), locoregional control (LRC), and freedom from distant metastases (FFDM) were calculated from the end of RT and estimated via Kaplan-Meier method. Comparisons were made via log-rank test. Median follow-up of patients alive at last contact was 36 months. All patients were treated with definitive RT alone (n=38, 15.4%) or concurrent systemic therapy and RT (n=209, 84.6%). LC was seen in 239 of 245 patients, for a 3-year LC rate of 97.8%. There were no statistically significant prognostic factors for local control, including tumor size or invasion of adjacent structures. RC was achieved in 235 of 245 patients (95.3% at 3 years). RC was less likely if there were 5 or more nodes (1-4 vs ≥5, P=.05), or if a lymph node was present in level 4 (level 3 or above vs level 4, P=.005). Distant metastases occurred in 21 patients, for a 3-year FFDM rate of 91.4%. Lower rates of FFDM were associated with a lymph node greater than 6 cm (P=.02), bilateral lymphadenopathy (unilateral vs bilateral, P=.034), 5 or more nodes (1-4 vs ≥5, P<.001), or if a lymph node was present in level 4 (level 3 or above vs level 4, P<.001). Outcomes for patients with HPV-associated oropharyngeal cancer treated with definitive RT are excellent. The increasing burden of adenopathy, either by size, number, or bilateral involvement, or location in level 4 portended a higher risk of regional failure or metastasis. These factors may provide a basis for altering staging.