Forward Masking Research Articles

Prediction of speech recognition in background noise and competing speech from suprathreshold auditory and cognitive measures

Previous studies have struggled to identify measures beyond the audiogram to reliably predict speech-in-noise scores. This may owe to: (i) different mechanisms mediate performance depending on materials and task; and (ii) effects are not reproducible. Here, 38 listeners with normal/near-normal audiograms completed batteries of temporal auditory and cognitive tests, and speech recognition (“Theo-Victor-Michael” test) in speech-shaped noise (SSN), speech-envelope modulated noise (envSSN), one (1T) and two (2T) competing talkers. A two-stage Bayesian modeling approach was employed. In Stage 1, speech scores were corrected for target-word frequency/neighborhood density, psychometric function parameters were extracted from temporal tests, and cognitive measures were reduced to three composite variables. Stage 2 then applied Gaussian process models to predict speech scores from temporal and cognitive measures. Leave-one-out cross-validation and model stacking determined the best combination of predictive models. Performance in SSN/envSSN was best predicted by temporal envelope measures (forward masking, gap duration discrimination), while performance in 1T was best predicted by cognitive measures (executive function, processing speed). Temporal fine structure measures (frequency-modulation, interaural-phase-difference detection) predicted the number of 1T distractor responses. All models failed on 2T. These results show that prediction of speech-in-noise scores from suprathreshold “process” measures is highly task dependent.

Forward masking of amplitude modulation detection includes a large perceptual effect

Forward masking of amplitude modulation (AM) detection is tuned: target sinusoidal AM (SAM) is masked more easily by masker SAM with a similar, rather than dissimilar, rate. This finding has been interpreted either as a sensory effect related to adapting neural units tuned to the target’s AM rate, or as a perceptual effect related to the perceived similarity of the acoustically similar AM. This study investigated these two alternative possibilities. The minimum modulation depth required to detect 96-Hz target SAM was measured following exposure to suprathreshold masker AM applied to the same broadband-noise carrier. Three forward masker modulators were tested: (1) 32-Hz SAM; (2) a 32-Hz square wave; (3) and 96-Hz SAM with a modulation index equivalent to that of the third harmonic of the square wave. The 96-Hz masker SAM produced substantial amounts of forward masking; the 32-Hz sine- and square-waves, however, did not. These findings were inconsistent with the hypothesis that detection of the target SAM was mediated by adapting neural units tuned to the target’s AM rate, suggesting, instead, that forward masking of AM detection includes a large perceptual effect.

The effect of broadband elicitor laterality on psychoacoustic gain reduction across signal frequency.

There are psychoacoustic methods thought to measure gain reduction, which may be from the medial olivocochlear reflex (MOCR), a bilateral feedback loop that adjusts cochlear gain. Although studies have used ipsilateral and contralateral elicitors and have examined strength at different signal frequencies, these factors have not been examined within a single study. Therefore, basic questions about gain reduction, such as the relative strength of ipsilateral vs contralateral elicitation and the relative strength across signal frequency, are not known. In the current study, gain reduction from ipsilateral, contralateral, and bilateral elicitors was measured at 1-, 2-, and 4-kHz signal frequencies using forward masking paradigms at a range of elicitor levels in a repeated measures design. Ipsilateral and bilateral strengths were similar and significantly larger than contralateral strength across signal frequencies. Growth of gain reduction with precursor level tended to differ with signal frequency, although not significantly. Data from previous studies are considered in light of the results of this study. Behavioral results are also considered relative to anatomical and physiological data on the MOCR. These results indicate that, in humans, cochlear gain reduction is broad across frequencies and is robust for ipsilateral and bilateral elicitation but small for contralateral elicitation.

The increase in the degree of neural forward masking of cochlea following salicylate application

BackgroundHigh doses of salicylate are known to reduce cochlear response amplitude and raise threshold. However, its effect on the cochlear forward masking, reflecting temporal resolution, is still unclear. MethodsThe neural forward masking of cochlea was evaluated using double-tone stimulation. The first tone burst (5ms) was named the “masker” and the second tone burst (5 ms) was named the “probe”. The frequency and intensity of the masker and probe were equal, and the masker-probe interval varied from 2 to 32 ms. The reduction (%) of the probe-evoked cochlear compound action potential caused by the addition of the masker tone was used to represent cochlear forward masking. The data obtained before and 2 h following the injection of sodium salicylate (250 mg/kg) were compared. ResultsThe neural forward masking of cochlea in the normal rats increased as the masker-probe interval decreased. At 16 kHz, for example, it increased from ~5% to 32ms masker-probe interval to ~85% at 2ms masker-probe interval. Two hours post salicylate injection, the neural forward masking was significantly enhanced except at 32 ms masker-probe interval. Interestingly, this enhancement was only observed in the limited frequency range of 16–30 kHz. DiscussionThe enhancement of forward masking of cochlea following salicylate administration may reflect defective neurotransmitter release. This frequency-dependent injury in the cochlea may lead to the development of central plasticity observed after salicylate administration, likely through the increase in central gain, leading to perceptual consequences.

Discrimination of 2D wall textures by passive echolocation for different reflected-to-direct level difference configurations.

In this work, we study people’s ability to discriminate between different 2D textures of walls by passive listening to a pre-recorded tongue click in an auralized echolocation scenario. In addition, the impact of artificially enhancing the early reflection magnitude by 6dB and of removing the direct component while equalizing the loudness was investigated. Listening test results for different textures, ranging from a flat wall to a staircase, were assessed using a 2 Alternative-Forced-Choice (2AFC) method, in which 14 sighted, untrained participants were indicating 2 equally perceived stimuli out of 3 presented stimuli. The average performance of the listening subjects to discriminate between different textures was found to be significantly higher for walls at 5m distance, without overlap between the reflected and direct sound, compared to the same walls at 0.8m distance. Enhancing the reflections as well as removing the direct sound were found to be beneficial to differentiate textures. This finding highlights the importance of forward masking in the discrimination process. The overall texture discriminability was found to be larger for the walls reflecting with a higher spectral coloration.

Auditory streaming emerges from fast excitation and slow delayed inhibition

In the auditory streaming paradigm, alternating sequences of pure tones can be perceived as a single galloping rhythm (integration) or as two sequences with separated low and high tones (segregation). Although studied for decades, the neural mechanisms underlining this perceptual grouping of sound remains a mystery. With the aim of identifying a plausible minimal neural circuit that captures this phenomenon, we propose a firing rate model with two periodically forced neural populations coupled by fast direct excitation and slow delayed inhibition. By analyzing the model in a non-smooth, slow-fast regime we analytically prove the existence of a rich repertoire of dynamical states and of their parameter dependent transitions. We impose plausible parameter restrictions and link all states with perceptual interpretations. Regions of stimulus parameters occupied by states linked with each percept match those found in behavioural experiments. Our model suggests that slow inhibition masks the perception of subsequent tones during segregation (forward masking), whereas fast excitation enables integration for large pitch differences between the two tones.

The relationship between ipsilateral cochlear gain reduction and speech-in-noise recognition at positive and negative signal-to-noise ratios.

Active mechanisms that regulate cochlear gain are hypothesized to influence speech-in-noise perception. However, evidence of a relationship between the amount of cochlear gain reduction and speech-in-noise recognition is mixed. Findings may conflict across studies because different signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) were used to evaluate speech-in-noise recognition. Also, there is evidence that ipsilateral elicitation of cochlear gain reduction may be stronger than contralateral elicitation, yet, most studies have investigated the contralateral descending pathway. The hypothesis that the relationship between ipsilateral cochlear gain reduction and speech-in-noise recognition depends on the SNR was tested. A forward masking technique was used to quantify the ipsilateral cochlear gain reduction in 24 young adult listeners with normal hearing. Speech-in-noise recognition was measured with the PRESTO-R sentence test using speech-shaped noise presented at -3, 0, and +3 dB SNR. Interestingly, greater cochlear gain reduction was associated with lower speech-in-noise recognition, and the strength of this correlation increased as the SNR became more adverse. These findings support the hypothesis that the SNR influences the relationship between ipsilateral cochlear gain reduction and speech-in-noise recognition. Future studies investigating the relationship between cochlear gain reduction and speech-in-noise recognition should consider the SNR and both descending pathways.

The role of the medial olivocochlear reflex in psychophysical masking and intensity resolution in humans: a review.

This review addresses the putative role of the medial olivocochlear (MOC) reflex in psychophysical masking and intensity resolution in humans. A framework for interpreting psychophysical results in terms of the expected influence of the MOC reflex is introduced. This framework is used to review the effects of a precursor or contralateral acoustic stimulation on 1) simultaneous masking of brief tones, 2) behavioral estimates of cochlear gain and frequency resolution in forward masking, 3) the buildup and decay of forward masking, and 4) measures of intensity resolution. Support, or lack thereof, for a role of the MOC reflex in psychophysical perception is discussed in terms of studies on estimates of MOC strength from otoacoustic emissions and the effects of resection of the olivocochlear bundle in patients with vestibular neurectomy. Novel, innovative approaches are needed to resolve the dissatisfying conclusion that current results are unable to definitively confirm or refute the role of the MOC reflex in masking and intensity resolution.

Frequency selectivity in the modulation domain estimated using forward masking: Effects of masker modulation depth and masker-signal delay

The threshold for detecting amplitude modulation (AM) of a sinusoidal or noise carrier is elevated when the signal AM is preceded by masker AM applied to the same carrier. This effect, called AM forward masking, shows selectivity in the AM domain, consistent with the existence of a modulation filter bank (MFB). In this paper we explore the effect of two factors that can influence AM forward masking, using an 8-kHz sinusoidal carrier and a range of masker AM frequencies, fm, both below and above the signal AM frequency, fs, of 40 Hz. The first factor was the time delay, td, between the end of the masker AM and the start of the signal AM. The second was the AM depth, m, of the masker, which was either 1 or 0.25. The AM forward masking patterns in all conditions showed tuning in the AM domain; signal thresholds were highest when fm was close to fs. The amount of AM forward masking decreased with increasing td in a similar way for all fm, so the shapes of the masking patterns did not change markedly with td. Remarkably, the amount of AM forward masking decreased by only about 3 dB (a non-significant effect) when the masker m was decreased from 1 to 0.25. This result appears to be inconsistent with an explanation of AM forward masking in terms of adaptation in a MFB or in terms of a sliding temporal integrator.

Forward masking of spectrotemporal modulation suggests modulation-frequency-selective channels

Physiological data from several species suggest that the auditory system detects complex patterns of spectrotemporal modulation via spectrotemporal modulation-frequency-selective channels, a subset of which may be directionally selective (i.e., prefer upward sweeping versus downward sweeping modulation). Psychophysical data suggesting the same, however, are scarce. In this study, we sought evidence of such channels using a psychophysical forward masking paradigm. The detectability of target spectrotemporal modulation (i–25-Hz/0.5-cyc/oct) applied to the final 55-ms of a 590-ms broadband-noise-like carrier was measured following exposure to masker spectrotemporal modulation applied to the initial 505-ms of the same carrier. Four maskers were tested: one with the same spectral modulation frequency as the target but a flat temporal envelope (0-Hz/0.5-cyc/oct), another with the same temporal modulation frequency as the target but a flat spectral envelope (–25-Hz/0-cyc/oct), and two with the same spectral and temporal modulation frequencies as the target and either the same (–25-Hz/0.5-cyc/oct) or opposite ( + 25-Hz/0.5-cyc/oct) sweep direction. Forward masking was greatest for the masker fully matched to the target, intermediate for the masker with the opposite sweep direction, and negligible for the other two. Taken together, these findings suggest that detection of the target may have involved a spectrotemporal modulation-frequency-selective channel with directional selectivity.

Forward masking of amplitude modulation across ears and its tuning in the modulation domain.

Frequency selectivity in the amplitude modulation (AM) domain has been demonstrated using both simultaneous AM masking and forward AM masking. This has been explained using the concept of a modulation filter bank (MFB). Here, we assessed whether the MFB occurs before or after the point of binaural interaction in the auditory pathway by using forward masking in the AM domain in an ipsilateral condition (masker AM and signal AM applied to the left ear with an unmodulated carrier in the right ear) and a contralateral condition (masker AM applied to the right ear and signal AM applied to the left ear). The carrier frequency was 8 kHz, the signal AM frequency, fs, was 40 or 80 Hz, and the masker AM frequency ranged from 0.25 to 4 times fs. Contralateral forward AM masking did occur, but it was smaller than ipsilateral AM masking. Tuning in the AM domain was slightly sharper for ipsilateral than for contralateral masking, perhaps reflecting confusion of the signal and masker AM in the ipsilateral condition when their AM frequencies were the same. The results suggest that there might be an MFB both before and after the point in the auditory pathway where binaural interaction occurs.

Recovery from forward masking in cochlear implant listeners: Effects of age and the electrode-neuron interface.

Older adults exhibit deficits in auditory temporal processing relative to younger listeners. These age-related temporal processing difficulties may be further exacerbated in older adults with cochlear implant (CIs) when CI electrodes poorly interface with their target auditory neurons. The aim of this study was to evaluate the potential interaction between chronological age and the estimated quality of the electrode-neuron interface (ENI) on psychophysical forward masking recovery, a measure that reflects single-channel temporal processing abilities. Fourteen CI listeners (age 15 to 88 years) with Advanced Bionics devices participated. Forward masking recovery was assessed on two channels in each ear (i.e., the channels with the lowest and highest signal detection thresholds). Results indicated that the rate of forward masking recovery declined with advancing age, and that the effect of age was more pronounced on channels estimated to interface poorly with the auditory nerve. These findings indicate that the quality of the ENI can influence the time course of forward masking recovery for older CI listeners. Channel-to-channel variability in the ENI likely interacts with central temporal processing deficits secondary to auditory aging, warranting further study of programming and rehabilitative approaches tailored to older listeners.

Temporal characteristics of the cochlear response after noise exposure

The effect of intense noise on cochlear sensitivity has been extensively studied, but its influence on the temporal characteristics of the cochlear response is still unclear. This study investigated the effects of noise exposure on the latency of cochlear response and cochlear forward masking. Rats were exposed to an octave band noise (8–16 kHz) at 90 dB SPL for 5 days. Cochlear compound action potentials (CAPs) induced by single- and double-tone stimuli and distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) were recorded 1 day or 2 months after the noise exposure. The latency of the CAP and its forward masking were compared between the noise-exposed rats and normal control rats. The noise exposure significantly reduced DPOAE and elevated CAP threshold in the noise band region, but not in the other areas. Even in the noise band area, the noise did not reduce CAP-amplitude at the high stimulation level (80 dB SPL). Correspondingly, about one-third of the outer hair cells (OHC) in the noise band area disappeared, while the inner hair cells (IHC) did not. However, the noise exposure in the frequency range of 4–24 kHz significantly prolonged CAP latency and increased its variability, while the CAP forward masking effect was significantly enhanced in the frequency range of 16–30 kHz. The frequency-dependent changes in CAP latency and forward masking after noise exposure may reflect different types of synaptic subinjury in the cochlea, which may lead to psychophysical consequences of sound localization and speech recognition.

Conductive hearing loss during development does not appreciably alter the sharpness of cochlear tuning

An increasing number of studies show that listeners often have difficulty hearing in situations with background noise, despite normal tuning curves in quiet. One potential source of this difficulty could be sensorineural changes in the auditory periphery (the ear). Signal in noise detection deficits also arise in animals raised with developmental conductive hearing loss (CHL), a manipulation that induces acoustic attenuation to model how sound deprivation changes the central auditory system. This model attributes perceptual deficits to central changes by assuming that CHL does not affect sensorineural elements in the periphery that could raise masked thresholds. However, because of efferent feedback, altering the auditory system could affect cochlear elements. Indeed, recent studies show that adult-onset CHL can cause cochlear synapse loss, potentially calling into question the assumption of an intact periphery in early-onset CHL. To resolve this issue, we tested the long-term peripheral effects of CHL via developmental bilateral malleus displacement. Using forward masking tuning curves, we compared peripheral tuning in animals raised with CHL vs age-matched controls. Using compound action potential measurements from the round window, we assessed inner hair cell synapse integrity. Results indicate that developmental CHL can cause minor synaptopathy. However, developmental CHL does not appreciably alter peripheral frequency tuning.

Channel Interaction During Infrared Light Stimulation in the Cochlea.

The number of perceptually independent channels to encode acoustic information is limited in contemporary cochlear implants (CIs) because of the current spread in the tissue. It has been suggested that neighboring electrodes have to be separated in humans by a distance of more than 2 mm to eliminate significant overlap of the electric current fields and subsequent interaction between the channels. It has also been argued that an increase in the number of independent channels could improve CI user performance in challenging listening environments, such as speech in noise, tonal languages, or music perception. Optical stimulation has been suggested as an alternative modality for neural stimulation because it is spatially selective. This study reports the results of experiments designed to quantify the interaction between neighboring optical sources in the cochlea during stimulation with infrared radiation. In seven adult albino guinea pigs, a forward masking method was used to quantify the interaction between two neighboring optical sources during stimulation. Two optical fibers were placed through cochleostomies into the scala tympani of the basal cochlear turn. The radiation beams were directed towards different neuron populations along the spiral ganglion. Optically evoked compound action potentials were recorded for different radiant energies and distances between the optical fibers. The outcome measure was the radiant energy of a masker pulse delivered 3 milliseconds before a probe pulse to reduce the response evoked by the probe pulse by 3 dB. Results were compared for different distances between the fibers placed along the cochlea. The energy required to reduce the probe's response by 3 dB increased by 20.4 dB/mm and by 26.0 dB/octave. The inhibition was symmetrical for the masker placed basal to the probe (base-to-apex) and the masker placed apical to the probe (apex-to-base). The interaction between neighboring optical sources during infrared laser stimulation is less than the interaction between neighboring electrical contacts during electrical stimulation. Previously published data for electrical stimulation reported an average current spread in human and cat cochleae of 2.8 dB/mm. With the increased number of independent channels for optical stimulation, it is anticipated that speech and music performance will improve. Lasers Surg. Med. © 2020 Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Forward masking and cognitive-language skills in children as a function of literacy stage

ABSTRACT Purpose: to investigate the relation between forward masking and cognitive-language skills in children as a function of literacy stage. Methods: twenty-seven children registered in literacy stage at public schools, aged from 6 to 9 years old, with no learning difficulties or audiological problems reported, participated in this study. Frequency Following Responses were registered in two test conditions: 1) /da/ alone; 2) /da/ presented 4 milliseconds after a speech noise. Two language protocols were applied: a cognitive-linguistic skills protocol and a phonological awareness one. Results: forward masking was evident in Frequency Following Responses of all children regardless of literacy stage. Frequency Following Responses latencies in both testing conditions showed no difference among participants’ age. Cognitive-language skills scores were below those expected for all children, with significant improvement noticed as a function of age. No correlation between language performance and forward masking was found. Conclusion: there was no relation between forward masking and cognitive-language skills in children, as a function of literacy stage.

Forward masking with frequency-following response analyses

Purpose: to analyze forward masking in normally hearing young people, by using frequency-following responses. Methods: the synthetic syllable /da/ was used for the recordings of ten individuals, in the following conditions: /da/ with no masking, and /da/ after 4, 16, 32, and 64 milliseconds of masking. F-test (ANOVA) was applied for repeated measures with the Greenhouse-Geisser correction to compare testing conditions. For significant differences, multiple comparisons (between pairs of conditions) and Bonferroni correction were used. Data normality was verified by applying the Shapiro-Wilk test, and statistical significance was used at 5%. Results: wave latencies of all masking conditions were compared with those of no masking. A latency delay was observed in the transient region of the response (PV and A) in all masking conditions, except for 64 milliseconds. Latency delay also occurred for waves PW, PX, and PY, which corresponded to the sustained region of the response. Conclusion: forward masking was observed, by using frequency-following responses with /da/ syllable in four intervals (4, 16, 32, and 64 ms) of preceding masking. Forward masking was more evident in the transient region of the response than in the sustained one. This study highlights the importance of electrophysiological testing in temporal processing assessment.

A notched-noise precursor affects both diotic and dichotic notched-noise masking

The present study investigates how diotic and dichotic masked thresholds, in a notched-noise masking paradigm, are affected by activation of the Medial OlivoCochlear (MOC) reflex. Thresholds were obtained for a 500-Hz pure tone diotic or a dichotic signal, S (S0 or Sπ respectively), in the presence of a simultaneous or forward diotic masker (bandpass noise with no notch or a 400-Hz notch). A diotic precursor sound (bandpass noise with a 400- or 800-Hz notch) was presented prior to the signal and masker to activate the MOC reflex. For simultaneous- and forward-masking conditions, the decrease in masked thresholds as a notch was introduced in the masker was larger for the diotic than for the dichotic condition. This resulted in a reduced binaural masking level difference (BMLD) for the masker with a notch. The precursor augmented these two effects. The results indicate that the effect of the precursor, eliciting the MOC reflex, is less pronounced when binaural cues are processed.

Идентификация лицевых экспрессий в условиях интрасаккадической смены стимула

Extreme temporal condition for visual identification task is held. A gaze-contingent eyetracking study was used to assess how presaccadic stimulus influences the one presented during a reactive saccade. A strong forward masking effect is found. Identification rate of second image is below chance, but still in accordance with previous studies, where no masking was present. Identification rate, erratic responses, statistical connection with alternative response (2AFC task), physical properties of saccades are similar to simple intrasaccadic identification task [3; 5]. Two aspects of transsaccadic visual perception were hypothesized, possessing common temporal structure: sensoric (geometric primitive detection) and gnostical (naturalistically valid object identification).

Precedence effect for specular and diffuse reflections

Studies on the precedence effect are typically conducted by presenting two identical sounds simulating direct sound and specular reflection. However, when a sound is reflected from irregular surface, it is redirect into many directions resulting in directional and temporal diffusion. This contribution introduces a simulation of Lambertian diffusing reflections. The perceptual influences of diffusion are studied in a listening experiment; echo thresholds and masked thresholds of specular and diffuse reflections are measured. Results show that diffusion makes the reflections more easily detectable than specular reflections of the same total energy. Indications are found that this mainly due to temporal diffusion, while the directional diffusion has little effect. Accordingly, the modeling of the echo thresholds is achieved by a temporal alignment of the experimental data based on the energy centroid of reflection responses. For the modeling of masked threshold the temporal masking pattern for forward masking is taken into account.