Forster Resonance Energy Transfer Experiments Research Articles

Lanthanide Complexes and Quantum Dots: A Bright Wedding for Resonance Energy Transfer

AbstractIn this microreview we describe the principle of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) occurring between closely spaced energy‐donor and ‐acceptor molecules. The theoretical treatment is depicted in relation with the data extractable from spectroscopic measurements. We present the specific case of semiconductor nanocrystals (or quantum dots – QDs) as energy donors in FRET experiments and a particular emphasis is put on the specific advantages of these fluorophores with regard to both their exceptional photophysical properties and their nanoscopic morphology. In a following section, the special attributes of luminescent lanthanide complexes (LLCs) are outlined with illustrations of properties such as their characteristic emission spectra, long‐lived luminescence, and large “Stokes shift”. Finally, the successful combination of LLCs and QDs in FRET experiments is demonstrated, showing the unrivaled benefits of this singular marriage, opening doors for energy transfer at very large distances and excellent sensitivity of detection within the frame of time‐resolved fluoroimmunoassays.(© Wiley‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, 69451 Weinheim, Germany, 2008)

Characterizing Multiple Molecular States in Single-Molecule Multiparameter Fluorescence Detection by Probability Distribution Analysis

Probability distribution analysis (PDA) [M. Antonik et al., J. Phys. Chem. B 2006, 110, 6970] allows one to quantitatively analyze single-molecule (SM) data obtained in Forster resonance energy transfer (FRET) or fluorescence polarization experiments. By taking explicitly background and shot noise contributions into account, PDA accurately predicts the shape of one-dimensional histograms of various parameters, such as FRET efficiency or fluorescence anisotropy. In order to describe complex experimental SM-FRET or polarization data obtained for systems consisting of multiple non-interconverting fluorescent states, several extensions to the PDA theory are presented. Effects of brightness variations and multiple-molecule events are considered independently of the detection volume parameters by using only the overall experimental signal intensity distribution. The extended PDA theory can now be applied to analyze any mixture, by using any a priori model or a model-free deconvolution approach based on the maximum entropy method (MEM). The accuracy of the analysis and the number of free parameters are limited only by data quality. Correction of the PDA model function for the presence of multiple-molecule events allows one to measure at high SM concentrations to avoid artifacts due to a very long measurement time. Tools such as MEM and combined mean donor fluorescence lifetime analysis have been developed to distinguish whether extra broadening of PDA histograms could be attributed to structural heterogeneities or dye artifacts. In this way, an ultimate resolution in FRET experiments in the range of a few Angstrom is achieved which allows for molecular Angstrom optics distinguishing between a set of fixed distances and a distribution of distances. The extended theory is verified by analyzing simulations and experimental data.

A simple “proximity” correction for Förster resonance energy transfer efficiency determination in membranes using lifetime measurements

Accurate measurements of oligomerization in membranes by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) are always compromised by a substantial contribution from random chance colocalization of donors and acceptors. Recently, Li and coworkers demonstrated the use of computer simulation in estimating the contribution of this “proximity” component to correct the FRET efficiency and estimate the free energy of dimer formation of the G380R mutants of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) transmembrane domain immersed into lipid bilayer. Because tight dimerization will result in complete energy transfer from donor to acceptor, we have used the same experimental system of fluorescein- and rhodamine-labeled G380R mutants of FGFR3 for the experimental assessment of the proximity FRET corrections using fluorescence lifetime measurements. The experimental proximity FRET correction, based on time-resolved fluorescence measurements, is expected to have general advantages over theoretical correction, especially in the case of nonrandomly distributed monomers.

Nuclear delivery of NFκB-assisted DNA/polymer complexes: plasmid DNA quantitation by confocal laser scanning microscopy and evidence of nuclear polyplexes by FRET imaging

Quantification of a plasmid DNA (pDNA) and investigation of its polymer-associated state in the nucleus are crucial to evaluate the effectiveness of a gene-delivery system. This study was conducted with p3NF-luc-3NF, a pDNA-bearing optimized κB motif to favour NFκB-driven nuclear import. Here, a quantification of pDNA copies in the nucleus was performed by real-time confocal laser scanning microscopy in HeLa and C2C12 cells transfected with linear polyethylenimine or histidylated polylysine. Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) from the fluorescein-p3NF-luc-3NF donor to the co-localized rhodamine-polymer acceptor was carried out to investigate whether the pDNA was still condensed with the polymer in the nucleus. Upon 5 h of transfection, the nuclear amount of p3NF-luc3NF was ∼1500 copies in both cell lines whereas that of pTAL-luc, a 3NF-free counterpart pDNA, was less than 250. This quantity of p3NF-luc-3NF dropped dramatically to that of pTAL-luc in the presence of the BAY 11-7085, an inhibitor of NFκB activation. These data strongly support a nuclear import of p3NF-luc3NF mediated by NFκB. Moreover, FRET experiments clearly revealed that most of nuclear pDNA were still condensed with the polymer raising the question of their passage through the nuclear pore complex and their impact on the gene-expression efficiency.

Structural Kinetics of Cardiac Troponin C Mutants Linked to Familial Hypertrophic and Dilated Cardiomyopathy in Troponin Complexes

The key events in regulating cardiac muscle contraction involve Ca(2+) binding to and release from cTnC (troponin C) and structural changes in cTnC and other thin filament proteins triggered by Ca(2+) movement. Single mutations L29Q and G159D in human cTnC have been reported to associate with familial hypertrophic and dilated cardiomyopathy, respectively. We have examined the effects of these individual mutations on structural transitions in the regulatory N-domain of cTnC triggered by Ca(2+) binding and dissociation. This study was carried out with a double mutant or triple mutants of cTnC, reconstituted into troponin with tryptophanless cTnI and cTnT. The double mutant, cTnC(L12W/N51C) labeled with 1,5-IAEDANS at Cys-51, served as a control to monitor Ca(2+)-induced opening and closing of the N-domain by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). The triple mutants contained both L12W and N51C labeled with 1,5-IAEDANS, and either L29Q or G159D. Both mutations had minimal effects on the equilibrium distance between Trp-12 and Cys-51-AEDANS in the absence or presence of bound Ca(2+). L29Q had no effect on the closing rate of the N-domain triggered by release of Ca(2+), but reduced the Ca(2+)-induced opening rate. G159D reduced both the closing and opening rates. Previous results showed that the closing rate of cTnC N-domain triggered by Ca(2+) dissociation was substantially enhanced by PKA phosphorylation of cTnI. This rate enhancement was abolished by L29Q or G159D. These mutations alter the kinetics of structural transitions in the regulatory N-domain of cTnC that are involved in either activation (L29Q) or deactivation (G159D). Both mutations appear to be antagonistic toward phosphorylation signaling between cTnI and cTnC.

Stern-Volmer modeling of steady-state Förster energy transfer between dilute, freely diffusing membrane-bound fluorophores

Two different metrics are used to assess Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) between fluorophores in the steady state: (i) acceptor-quenching of donor fluorescence E (also known as transfer efficiency) and (ii) donor-excited acceptor fluorescence FADex. While E is still more widely used, FADex has been gaining in popularity for practical reasons among experimentalists who study biomembranes. Here, for the special case of membrane-bound fluorophores, we present a substantial body of experimental evidence that justifies the use of simple Stern-Volmer expressions when modeling either FRET metric under dilute-probe conditions. We have also discovered a dilute-regime correspondence between our Stern-Volmer expression for E and Wolber and Hudson’s series approximation for steady-state Förster quenching in two dimensions (2D). This novel correspondence allows us to interpret each of our 2D quenching constants in terms of both (i) an effective Förster distance and (ii) two maximum acceptor-concentration limits, each of which defines its own useful experimental regime. Taken together, our results suggest a three-step strategy toward designing more effective steady-state FRET experiments for the study of biomembranes.

CD4 Interacts Constitutively with Multiple CCR5 at the Plasma Membrane of Living Cells

The entry of human immunodeficiency virus into target cells requires successive interactions of the viral envelope glycoprotein gp120 with CD4 and the chemokine receptors CCR5 or CXCR4. We previously demonstrated, by Förster resonance energy transfer experiments, the constitutive association of CD4 and CCR5 at the surface of living cells. We therefore speculated that this interaction may correlate with compartmentalization of CD4 and CCR5 within the plasma membrane. Here, we characterize the lateral distribution, the dynamics, and the stoichiometry of these receptors in living cells stably expressing CD4 and/or CCR5 by means of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching at variable radii experiments. We found that (i) these receptors expressed alone are confined into 1-microm-sized domains, (ii) CD4-CCR5 associations occur outside and inside smaller domains, and (iii) these interactions involve multiple CCR5 molecules per CD4.

Behavior of Trichoderma reesei Hydrophobins in Solution: Interactions, Dynamics, and Multimer Formation

Filamentous fungi utilize small amphiphilic proteins called hydrophobins in their adaptation to the environment. The hydrophobins are used to form coatings on various fungal structures, lower the surface tension of water, and to mediate surface attachment. Hydrophobins function through self-assembly at interfaces, for example, at the air-water interface, and at fungal cellular structures. Despite their high tendency to self assemble at interfaces, hydrophobins can be very soluble in water. To understand the mechanism of hydrophobin self-assembly, in this work, we have studied the behavior of two Trichoderma reesei hydrophobins, HFBI and HFBII in aqueous solution. The main methods used were Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) and size exclusion chromatography. A genetically engineered HFBI variant, NCys-HFBI, was utilized for the site-specific labeling of dyes for the FRET experiments. We observed the multimerization of HFBI in a concentration-dependent manner. A change from monomers to tetramers was seen when the hydrophobin concentration was increased. Interaction studies between HFBI and HFBII suggested that at low concentrations homodimers are preferred, and at higher concentrations, the heterotetramers of HFBI and HFBII are formed. In conclusion, the results support the model where hydrophobins in aqueous solutions form multimers by hydrophobic interactions. In contrast to micelles formed by detergents, the hydrophobin multimers are defined in size and involve specific protein-protein interactions.

Direct observation of protein folding in nanoenvironments using a molecular ruler

We observe folding of horse heart cytochrome c in various environments including nano-compartments (micelles and reverse micelles). Using picosecond-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) dynamics of an extrinsic covalently attached probe dansyl (donor) at the surface of the protein to a heme group (acceptor) embedded inside the protein, we measured angstrom-resolved donor–acceptor distances in the environments. The overall structural perturbations of the protein revealed from the FRET experiments are in close agreement with our circular dichroism (CD) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) studies on the protein in a variety of solution conditions. The change of segmental motion of the protein due to imposed restriction in the nano-compartments compared to that in bulk buffer is also revealed by temporal fluorescence anisotropy of the dansyl probe.

Fanciful FRET

The validity of experiments based on Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), an imaging technique widely used to measure protein-protein interactions in living cells, critically depends on the accurate and precise measurement of FRET efficiency. The use of FRET standards to determine FRET efficiency, and a consideration of such factors as how the abundance of FRET acceptors and the stoichiometry of donors and acceptors in a molecular complex can affect measured FRET efficiency, will enhance the usefulness with which FRET experiments can be interpreted.

Analysis of Photobleaching in Single-Molecule Multicolor Excitation and Förster Resonance Energy Transfer Measurements

Dye photobleaching is a major constraint of fluorescence readout within a range of applications. In this study, we investigated the influence of photobleaching in fluorescence experiments applying multicolor laser as well as Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) mediated excitation using several red-emitting dyes frequently used in multicolor experiments or as FRET acceptors. The chosen dyes (cyanine 5 (Cy5), MR121, Alexa660, Alexa680, Atto647N, Atto655) have chemically distinct chromophore systems and can be excited at 650 nm. Several fluorescence analysis techniques have been applied to detect photobleaching and to disclose the underlying photophysics, all of which are based on single-molecule detection: (1) fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) of bulk solutions, (2) fluorescence cross-correlation of single-molecule trajectories, and (3) multiparameter fluorescence detection (MFD) of single-molecule events. The maximum achievable fluorescence signals as well as the survival times of the red dyes were markedly reduced under additional laser irradiation in the range of 500 nm. Particularly at excitation levels at or close to saturation, the 500 nm irradiation effectively induced transitions to higher excited electronic states on already excited dye molecules, leading to a pronounced bleaching reactivity. A theoretical model for the observed laser irradiance dependence of the fluorescence brightness of a Cy5 FRET acceptor dye has been developed introducing the full description of the underlying photophysics. The model takes into account acceptor as well as donor photobleaching from higher excited electronic states, population of triplet states, and energy transfer to both the ground and excited states of the acceptor dye. Also, photoinduced reverse intersystem crossing via higher excited triplet states is included, which was found to be very efficient for Cy5 attached to DNA. Comparing continuous wave (cw) and pulsed donor excitation, a strong enhancement of acceptor photobleaching by a factor of 5 was observed for the latter. Thus, in the case of fluorescence experiments utilizing multicolor pulsed laser excitation, the application of the appropriate timing of synchronized green and red laser pulses in an alternating excitation mode can circumvent excessive photobleaching. Moreover, important new single-molecule analysis diagnosis tools are presented: (1) For the case of excessive acceptor photobleaching, cross-correlation analysis of single-molecule trajectories of the fluorescence signal detected in the donor and acceptor detection channels and vice versa shows an anticorrelated exponential decay and growth, respectively. (2) The time difference, Tg - Tr, of the mean observation times of all photons detected for the donor and acceptor detection channels within a single-molecule fluorescence burst allows one to identify and exclude molecules with an event of acceptor photobleaching. The presented single-molecule analysis methods can be constrained to, for example, FRET-active subpopulations, reducing bias from FRET-inactive molecules. The observations made are of strong relevance for and demand a careful choice of laser action in multicolor and FRET experiments, in particular when performed at or close to saturation.

Förster resonance energy transfer in liposomes: Measurements of transmembrane helix dimerization in the native bilayer environment

The lipid bilayer vesicle is a model of the cellular membrane. Even in this simple system, however, measuring the thermodynamics of membrane protein association is a challenge. Here we discuss Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) in liposomes as a method to probe the dimerization of transmembrane helices in a membrane environment. Although the measurements are labor intensive, FRET in liposomes can be measured accurately provided that attention is paid to sample homogeneity and sample equilibration. One must also take into account statistical expectations and the FRET that results from random colocalization of donors and acceptors in the bilayer. Without careful attention to these details, misleading results are easy to obtain in membrane FRET experiments. The results that we obtain in model systems are reproducible and depend solely on the concentration of the protein in the bilayer (i.e., on the protein-to-lipid ratio), thereby yielding thermodynamic parameters that are directly relevant to processes in biological membranes.

Oligomeric State and Mode of Self-Association of Thermotoga maritima Ribosomal Stalk Protein L12 in Solution

The "stalk" of the prokaryotic 50S ribosomal subunit is comprised of four copies of the protein L7/L12. In Escherichia coli, L7/L12 is a dimeric protein at micromolar concentrations, which is able to undergo rapid subunit exchange. A recent structural study indicated a tetrameric arrangement of the L12 proteins isolated from Thermotoga maritima, in which the proteins engaged in two different dimerization modes. In one mode, the two monomers of L12 form a tight symmetric and parallel dimer held together by a four-helix bundle, which encompasses the hinge region between the N- and C-terminal domains. In the other mode, the two monomers bind through their N-terminal region in an antiparallel configuration, in which one monomer comprises an alpha-helical hinge and the other monomer adopts an elongated shape with an unfolded hinge region. Presently, it is unclear which dimer contact prevails in solution and on the ribosome. Using cysteine mutants of T. maritima labeled with fluorescent probes, we investigated the mode of interactions between L12 subunits. Data from Forster resonance energy transfer experiments support a dimerization of L12 in solution, in which two monomers bind through their N-terminal region in an antiparallel configuration. We also demonstrate that the rate of subunit exchange in T. maritima L12 is significantly slower at 25 degrees C than that in the E. coli system. The exchange rate increases with increasing temperature and approaches the one observed for the E. coli system at 50 degrees C. Possible factors responsible for this difference are discussed.

Can Förster Resonance Energy Transfer Measurements Uniquely Position Troponin Residues on the Actin Filament? A Case Study in Multiple-acceptor FRET

Straightforward interpretation of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) data in terms of the distance from donor-labeled troponon-tropomyosin (TnTm) to acceptor-labeled actin is complicated by the potential for energy transfer to acceptors on neighboring actin monomers (cross-transfer). Calculations indicate that cross-transfer can account for a substantial percentage of the total transfer efficiency. In some cases, this renders isolated FRET data uninterpretable. To overcome these limitations, we have developed an analysis method that incorporates cross-transfer and can, in principle, define the most probable (in the “least-squares” sense) position of a TnTm residue on the actin filament. The technique analyzes data from four or more FRET experiments using acceptors attached to different residues on actin. We have used this method to specify the coordinates of skeletal troponin I (sTnI) residue 133 relative to the actin filament under Mg 2+ and Ca 2+-saturating conditions. Ca 2+-activation causes the C terminus of the regulatory domain of TnI to move away from the actin surface by 6.3 Å, laterally along the actin surface toward actin subdomain 3 by 22.0 Å, and azimuthally toward the actin inner domain by 13.2 Å. This information is used to construct a low-resolution structural model of thin filament activation.