The human tumor suppressor p16INK4a is a small monomeric protein that can form amyloid structures. Formation of p16INK4a amyloid fibrils is induced by oxidation which creates an intermolecular disulfide bond. The conversion into amyloid is associated with a change from an all α-helical structure into β-sheet fibrils. Currently, structural insights into p16INK4a amyloid fibrils are lacking. Here, we investigate the amyloid-forming regions of this tumor suppressor using isotope-labeling limited-digestion mass spectrometry analysis. We discover two key regions that likely form the structured core of the amyloid. Further investigations using thioflavin-T fluorescence assays, electron microscopy and solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of shorter peptide regions confirm the self-assembly of the identified sequences that include methionine and leucine repeat regions. This work describes a simple approach for studying protein motifs involved in the conversion of monomeric species into aggregated fibril structures. It provides first insights into the polypeptide sequence underlying the core structure of amyloid p16INK4a formed after a unique oxidation-driven structural transition.